Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

the scientific method

Powerful Essays
2341 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
the scientific method
LAB EXERCISE: Scientific Investigation

Laboratory Objectives
After completing this lab topic, you should be able to:
1. Identify and characterize questions that can be answered through scientific investigation.
2. Define hypothesis and explain what characterizes a good scientific hypothesis.
3. Identify and describe the components of a scientific experiment.
4. Summarize and present results in tables and graphs.
5. Discuss results and critique experiments.
6. Design a scientific experiment.
7. Interpret and communicate results.

Introduction
Biology is the study of the phenomena of life, and biologists observe living systems and organisms, ask questions, and propose explanations for those observations. Science assumes that biological systems are understandable and can be explained by fundamental rules or laws. Scientific investigations share some common elements and procedures, which are referred to as the scientific method. Not all scientists follow these procedures in a strict fashion, but each of the elements is usually present. Science is a creative human endeavor that involves asking questions, making observations, developing explanatory hypotheses, and testing those hypotheses. Scientists closely scrutinize investigations in their field, and each scientist must present his or her work at scientific meetings or in professional publications, providing evidence from observations and experiments that supports the scientist’s explanations of biological phenomena.

EXERCISE I: PRACTICING THE SCIENTIFIC METHOD

Read the following example and answer the questions that follow.

INVESTIGATION OF THE EFFECT OF SULPHUR DIOXIDE ON
SOYBEAN REPRODUCTION

Agricultural scientists were concerned about the effect of air pollution, sulfur dioxide in particular, on soybean production in fields adjacent to coal-powered power plants. Based on initial investigations, they proposed that sulfur dioxide in high concentrations would reduce reproduction in soybeans. They designed an experiment to test this hypothesis (Figure 1). In this experiment, 48 soybean plants, just beginning to produce flowers, were divided into two groups, treatment and no treatment. The 24 treated plants were divided into four groups of 6. One group of 6 treated plants was placed in a fumigation chamber and exposed to 0.6 ppm (parts per million) of sulfur dioxide for 4 hours to simulate sulfur dioxide emissions from a power plant. The experiment was repeated on the remaining three treated groups. The no-treatment plants were placed similarly in groups of 6 in a second fumigation chamber and simultaneously exposed to filtered air for 4 hours. Following the experiment, all plants were returned to the greenhouse. When the beans matured, the number of bean pods, the number of seeds per pod, and the weight of the pods were determined for each plant. Figure 1. Experimental Design for soybean experiment. The experiment was repeated four times. Soybeans were fumigated for 4 hours.

Determining the Variables
Read the description of each category of variable; then identify the variable described in the preceding investigation. The variables in an experiment must be clearly defined and measurable. The investigator will identify and define dependent, independent, and controlled variables for a particular experiment.

a) The Dependent Variable
Within the experiment, one variable will be measured or counted or observed in response to the experimental conditions. This variable is the dependent variable. For the soybeans, several dependent variables are measured, all of which provide information about reproduction.
What are the dependent variables?

b) The Independent Variable
The scientist will choose one variable, or experimental condition, to manipulate. This variable is considered the most important variable by which to test the investigator’s hypothesis and is called the independent variable.
What was the independent variable?

Can you suggest other variables that the investigator might have changed that would have had an effect on the dependent variables?

Although other factors, such as light, temperature, time, and fertilizer, might affect the dependent variables, only one independent variable is usually chosen.
Why is it important to have only one independent variable?

Why is it acceptable to have more than one dependent variable?

c) Controlled Variables
Consider the variables that you identified as alternative independent variables. Although they are not part of the hypothesis being tested in this investigation, they would have significant effects on the outcome of this experiment. These variables must, therefore, be kept constant during the course of the experiment. They are known as the controlled variables. The underlying assumption in experimental design is that the selected independent variable is the one affecting the dependent variable. This is only true if all other variables are controlled.
What are the controlled variables in this experiment?
What variables other than those you may have already listed can you now suggest?

Choosing or Designing the Procedure
The procedure is the stepwise method, or sequence of steps, to be performed for the experiment. It should be recorded in a laboratory notebook before initiating the experiment, and any exceptions or modifications should be noted during the experiment. The procedures may be designed from research published in scientific journals, through collaboration with colleagues in the lab or other institutions, or by means of one’s own novel and creative ideas. The process of outlining the procedure includes determining control treatment(s), levels of treatments, and numbers of replications.

a) Level of Treatment
The value set for the independent variable is called the level of treatment. For this experiment, the value was determined based on previous research and preliminary measurements of sulfur dioxide emissions. The scientists may select a range of concentrations from no sulfur dioxide to an extremely high concentration. The levels should be based on knowledge of the system and the biological significance of the treatment level.
What was the level of treatment in the soybean experiment?

b) Replication
Scientific investigations are not valid if the conclusions drawn from them are based on one experiment with one or two individuals. Generally, the same procedure will be repeated several times (replication), providing consistent results. Notice that scientists do not expect exactly the same results inasmuch as individuals and their responses will vary. Results from replicated experiments are usually averaged and may be further analyzed using statistical tests.
Describe replication in the soybean experiment.

c) Control
The experiment design includes a control in which the independent variable is held at an established level or is omitted. The control or control treatment serves as a benchmark that allows the scientist to decide whether the predicted effect is really due to the independent variable.
What was the control treatment in this experiment?

What is the difference between the control and the controlled variables discussed previously?

EXERCISE II: DESIGNING AN EXPERIMENT

Introduction
In this exercise, the entire class, working together, will practice investigating a question using what you have learned so far about the scientific process.

a) Question
Cardiovascular fitness can be determined by measuring a person’s pulse rate and respiration rate before and after a given time of aerobic exercise. A person who is more fit may have a relatively slower pulse rate and a lower respiratory rate after exercise, and his or her pulse rate should return to normal more quickly than that of a person who is less fit. Your assignment is to investigate the effect of a well-defined, measurable, controllable independent variable on cardiovascular fitness.

Specific questions can be asked about an independent variable related to the broad topic of cardiovascular fitness. For example, your question might be “Does cigarette smoking have an effect on cardiovascular fitness?” List the questions in the space provided. Choose the best question and propose a testable hypothesis.

b) Hypothesis
Record the hypothesis chosen by the class.

The Experiment
A test, called the step test, that is often used for assessing cardiovascular fitness (Kusinitz and Fine, 1987). Here are the basic elements of this test:
1. The subject steps up and down on a low platform, approximately 8 in. from the ground, for 3 minutes at a rate of 30 steps per minute.
2. The subject’s pulse rate is measured before the test and immediately after the test. The subject should be sitting quietly when the pulse is counted. Use three fingers to find the pulse in the radial artery (the artery in the wrist, above the thumb). Count the number of beats per minute. (Count the beats for 30 seconds and multiply by 2.)
3. Additionally, the pulse rate is measured at 1-minute intervals after the test until the pulse rate returns to normal (recovery time). Count the pulse for 30 seconds, rest 30 seconds, count 30 seconds, and rest 30 seconds. Repeat this procedure until the pulse returns to normal. Record the number of minutes to return to the normal pulse rate. (Do not record the pulse rate.)

*As a group, design an experiment and record the components below:

Dependent variable(s):

Independent variable:

Controlled variables:

Control:

Level of treatment:

Replication:

Summarize the experimental designed by your class:

Prediction
Predict the results of the experiment based on your hypothesis (if/then).

Performing the Experiment
Following the procedures established by your investigative team, perform the experiment and record your results.

Results
Record total class results in a Table. Identify the treatment conditions at the top of the table.

Presenting and Analyzing Results

Once the data are collected, they must be organized and summarized so that the scientists can determine if the hypothesis has been supported or falsified. In this exercise, you will design tables and graphs; the latter are also called figures. Tables and figures have two primary functions. They are used (1) to help you analyze and interpret your results and (2) to enhance the clarity with which you present the work to a reader or viewer.

Tables
You have collected data from your experiment in the form of a list of numbers that may appear at first glance to have little meaning. Look at your data. How could you organize the data set to make it easier to interpret? You could average the data set for each treatment, but even averages can be rather uninformative. Could you use a summary table to convey the data (in this case, averages)?
Table 2 is an example of a table using data averages of the number of seeds per pod and number of pods per plant as the dependent variables and exposure to sulfur dioxide as the independent variable. Note that the number of replicates and the units of measurement are provided in the table and table legend.

Table 2. Effects of 4-Hour Exposure to 0.6 ppm Sulfur Dioxide on Average Seed and Pod Production in Soybeans.

Treatment Number Seeds per Pod Pods per Plant
Control 24 3.26 16
S02 24 1.96 13

Tables are used to present results that have a few too many data points. They are also useful for displaying several dependent variables. For example, average number of bean pods, average number of seeds per pod, and average weight of pods per plant for treated and untreated plants could all be presented in one table.

The following guidelines will help you construct a table: • All values of the same kind should read down the column, not across a row. Include only data that are important in presenting the results and for further discussion. • Information and results that are not essential (for example: test-tube number, simple calculations, or data with no differences) should be omitted. • The headings of each column should include units of measurement, if appropriate. • Tables are numbered consecutively throughout a lab report or scientific paper. For example” Table 4 would be the fourth table in your report. • The title, which is located at the top of the table, should be clear and concise, with enough information to allow the table to be understandable apart from the text. Capitalize the first and important words in the title. Do not capitalize articles (a, an, the), short prepositions, and conjunctions. • Refer to each table in the written text. Summarize the data and refer to the table; for example, “The plants treated with sulfur dioxide produced an average of 1.96 seeds per pod (Table 2).” Do not write, “See the results in Table 2.” • If you are using a database program, such as Excel, you should still sketch your table on paper before constructing it on the computer.

Application
1. Using the data from your experiment, design a summary table to present the results for one of your dependent variables, pulse rate. Your table need not be the same size or design as the sample. In your table, provide units of the dependent variable (pulse rate). Tell the reader how many replications (if any) were used to calculate the averages.
2. Compose a title for your table. Refer to the guidelines in the previous section.

Interpreting and Communicating Results

The last component of a scientific investigation is to interpret the results and discuss their implications in light of the hypothesis and its supporting literature. The investigator studies the tables and graphs and determines if their hypothesis has been supported or falsified. If the hypothesis has been falsified, the investigator must suggest alternate hypotheses for testing. If the hypothesis has been supported, the investigator suggests additional experiments to strengthen the hypothesis, using the same or alternate methods.
Scientists will thoroughly investigate a scientific question, testing hypotheses, collecting data, and analyzing results, until they are satisfied that they can explain the phenomenon of interest. The final phase of a scientific investigation is the communication of the results to other scientists. Preliminary results may be presented within a laboratory research group and at scientific meetings where the findings can be discussed. Ultimately, the completed project is presented in the form of a scientific paper that is reviewed by scientists within the field and published in a scientific journal. The ideas, procedures, results, analyses, and conclusions of all scientific investigations are critically scrutinized by other scientists. Because of this, science is sometimes described as self-correcting, meaning that errors that may occur are usually discovered within the scientific community.
Scientific communication, whether spoken or written, is essential to science. During this laboratory course, you often will be asked to present and interpret your results at the end of the laboratory period. Additionally, you will write components of a scientific paper for many lab topics.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Scientific Method

    • 257 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Match each example task in Column 2 with a step of the scientific method in Column 1. List out each match in order according to the scientific method steps, and explain the reasoning for your choice.…

    • 257 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    1.03 Scientific Method

    • 435 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Study at different times of the day to see if the time has an effect on how much information is retained.…

    • 435 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Now that you have read and reviewed Chapter 1, take your learning a step further by testing your critical thinking skills on this scientific reasoning exercise.…

    • 532 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    1.03 Scientific Method

    • 385 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Research: I will have to find information on the items in the cup that I want to sink and float…

    • 385 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Scientific Method

    • 372 Words
    • 2 Pages

    This document is not meant to be a substitute for a formal laboratory report. The Lab Report Assistant is simply a summary of the experiment’s questions, diagrams if needed, and data tables that should be addressed in a formal lab report. The intent is to facilitate students’ writing of lab reports by providing this information in an editable file which can be sent to an instructor.…

    • 372 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Scientific Method

    • 4542 Words
    • 130 Pages

    Learning Goal: To understand how the scientific method can be used to search for explanations of nature. The scientific method is a procedure used to search for explanations of nature. The scientific method consists of making observations, formulating hypotheses, designing and carrying out experiments, and repeating this cycle. Observations can be either quantitative or qualitative. Quantitative observations are measurements consisting of both numbers and units, such as the observation that ice melts at . In contrast, qualitative observations are observations that do not rely on numbers or units, such as the observation that water is clear. A hypothesis is a tentative explanation of the observations. The hypothesis is not necessarily correct, but it puts the scientist's understanding of the observations into a form that can be tested through experimentation. Experiments are then performed to test the validity of the hypothesis. Experiments are observations preferably made under conditions in which the variable of interest is clearly distinguishable from any others. If the experiment shows that the hypothesis is incorrect, the hypothesis can be modified, and further experiments can be carried out to test the modified hypothesis. This cycle is repeated, continually refining the hypothesis. If a large set of observations follow a reproducible pattern, this pattern can be summarized in a law—a verbal or mathematical generalization of a phenomenon. For example, over the years people observed that every morning the sun rises in the east, and every night the sun sets in the west. These observations can be described in a law stating, "The sun always rises in the east and sets in the west." After a great deal of refinement, a hypothesis can lead to a theory. A theory is an explanation of why something happens. For example, Newton's theory of gravitation explains why objects tend to fall toward the Earth (as well as explaining the interactions between the Earth and the other…

    • 4542 Words
    • 130 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Scientific Method

    • 451 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In performing this experiment, students apprehend and grasp the concept of the “scientific method” and its segments. The scientific method is analytically preceded by researchers to answer a question(s). First, the analyst states the problem based on contemplations. Next, a hypothesis is formed, which means the analyst made an educated guess (solution) to the problem. Before an experiment is performed the analyst has to make a prediction. A prediction is what the person assumes the outcome of the experiment will be, if their hypothesis is precise. When making a prediction it is stated in a manner of “if…..then…” Then the analyst tests the hypothesis. The experiment is manipulated so that changes to one variable cause another to interchange in order to fit your hypothesis. Variables are facts or conditions that are changed. There are three main variables in the scientific method; dependent variable, independent variable and controlled variable. Dependent variable is variables affected by the independent variable. Independent variable is the variables being tested. Controlled variable is variables that remain constant in the experiment. In this experiment five males and five females whose pulse rate and respiratory rate were recorded before and after exercising, to determine cardiovascular fitness with respect to gender. The controlled variables were the environment conditions, same time-span (minutes to exercise) and the same stool. The dependent variables were pulse and respiratory rate based on gender and the independent variables were male and female.…

    • 451 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Scientific Method

    • 434 Words
    • 2 Pages

    • Describe a real-life problem where you have or could have used the steps of the scientific method to solve the problem. Include the steps involved in solving the problem.…

    • 434 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Scientific Method

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Scientific method is a process that outlines a number of principles for answering questions. Many people in day-to-day situations use scientific method. For example, if I were to try to start my car and it doesn 't work, my first reaction would be to think of reason my car is not starting. This is just a brief example of scientific method. The principles in Scientific method should be used in an orderly manner to answer your questions. Scientific method lets people research true things as well as false. There is no guessing when using Scientific method it is completely natural. From my military career I can say from experience that Integrity is one of our Five Army Values. I like to think the Scientific method is having entire integrity, due to the fact that it is this method of discovery, and justification for that discovery, which must be accomplished entirely with integrity (www.scientificmethod.co.uk).…

    • 707 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    0

    • 1724 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Writing a QALMRI for any research paper (one that you are writing, or one that…

    • 1724 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Exam Review

    • 2457 Words
    • 10 Pages

    4. Write an equation in words & then in symbols for the following sentence: The change in the number of individuals in a population is equal to the difference between the number of births & deaths.…

    • 2457 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Scientific Investigation

    • 282 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Research- It seems people stay away from beaches when there is oil spill in it or the pollution level is too high…

    • 282 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    civil

    • 11074 Words
    • 72 Pages

    (d) design and conduct experiments, interpret and analyze data, synthesize the information to provide conclusion.…

    • 11074 Words
    • 72 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    INC1

    • 991 Words
    • 4 Pages

    3. What is the principle of falsifiability? It is an idea that a scitific hypothesis must be…

    • 991 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The best test of an argument is the argument's ability to convince someone with an opposing viewpoint.…

    • 591 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays