Preview

The Men we carry in our minds

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
438 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Men we carry in our minds
The Difference between Sex and Social Class
A Summary of Scott Russell Sanders’ “The Men We Carry in Our Minds”

In Scott Russell Sanders’ essay, “The Men We Carry in Our Minds”, he indicates his perspective through discussing the issues that exist between sex and social class. Sanders’ depicts his thoughts through narration which allows him to portray his own life experiences to support his viewpoint. Sanders’ thesis is fundamentally based on the lives of men “who’ve been discredited” (Sanders 292) and how their lives have been considered easier than the lives of women.

Sanders’ first perspective of the world was on the lives of the poor, working class. In the essay he shares his memories from childhood, during which he was witness to what he believed to be the life of luxury for women, which was considered to be the typical house work of cooking, cleaning, and caring for the children. Sanders expressed the lives of men as a day in and day out job of doing the same back breaking labor so that they could support their families (293). He portrays the graphic details, recalling from his past, of the demanding jobs men endured. For example, Sanders talks about “the nails of their hands” being “black and split” (293) illustrating that they work tremendously hard and go through a lot of pain to fulfill their duties.

In Sanders’ final point the differences that exist between rich and poor, male and females becomes more vivid when he receives the opportunity to attend college by earning a scholarship where only the wealthy attend (295). This forces Sanders to experience a new world where the women he meets in the college make assumptions about him just because of his sex without knowing about his past (296).These women assumed that all men were like their fathers, having women to assist them with every need and pleasure they would have (296). These men never had to worry about making the bill at the end of every month nor did they have to ask for any

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Manrsios, Gregory. "Class in America-2003": The Social Construction of Gender." Trans. Paula S. Rothenberg. Race, Class, and Gender in the United State. 6th ed. New York: Worth Publishers, 2004. 193-207.…

    • 756 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout the essay, Saunders uses vivid contrast, and personal reflections to reveal the relationship between gender roles of men and women, and the social class they fall into. With his early use of contrast, reflection, and narration, Sanders uses memories of his personal up bringing in order to expose his initial perspective of the duties men and women are subject to. On one hand, he proclaims that the men he views throughout his childhood are ones that are “killing themselves or preparing to kill others” (295). This conveys how they vigorously strain their bodies to bring money into the family, and prepare to go to war. However, on the other hand he also emphasizes that in his mind women live freer and less confining lives than men since they work in “handsomer places than any factory” (295). Growing up within a mid century lower class, Sanders is exposed to the “toiling” (293) and strenuous lives of the many male figures surrounding him. This initially shapes his “early vision of manhood”(293) and enables him to obtain a personal perspective and prejudice of what role men should play in a typical society. Nevertheless, Sanders also details how his fathers ability to obtain an important office job within his company, allows Sanders and his family to move upwards into a higher social class. This movement permits him to attend college where he meets the daughters of high status jobholders. These women accuse Sanders that because of his male sex, he is destined to “become like their…

    • 559 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For each, she had to master new skills, learn the social environment of each job, and work laboriously for hours on end. She further analyzes and evaluates the rising problem of poverty. A single, educated woman – with the ability to rely on conveniences such as emergency cash, a car, and a credit card; a woman who was without children or a family to support – struggled to make ends meet working one or more jobs demonstrates the inadequacy of the minimum wage and its fail to sufficiently supply an individual or family with the means necessary to support the “working poor.” Companies are reluctant to raise the pay of their employees and can punish and/or fire employees who step out of line. “When you enter the low-wage workplace, you check your civil liberties at the door…We can hardly pride ourselves on being the world’s preeminent democracy if large numbers of citizens spend half of their waking hours in what amounts to a dictatorship.” (Ehrenreich 210) The calculated $30,000 “living wage” for a family of three comes to $14 an hour, and 60 percent of Americans earns less than that. The lifestyles of the poor are tainted with low self-esteem and the need to “work through” fatigue, injury, illness, etc. “They are [the lifestyles] emergency situations. And that is how we should see the poverty of so many millions of low-wage Americans – as a state of emergency.” (Ehrenreich…

    • 691 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The introduction to The Dignity of Working Men outlines the research Michele Lamont undertakes about working class individuals in America. She asserts that they are the "backbone of American society", important to understand because of their social and political power. The first part of the book analyzes working class American men and how they think and act. Lamont first states that white, middle class workers place themselves above the upper middle class because they see them as lacking in morals and relationship skills. These white men also separate themselves even further from blacks and the poor, attaching socioeconomic status with moral worth as opposed to the detachment of the two in the previous example.…

    • 594 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Scott Sanders’ The Men We Carry in Our Minds is an assessment of the oppression and common themes experienced by individuals as a result of encultured social constructs. Scott uses a series of imagery heavy narratives to isolate a repeating pattern of “destiny” observed throughout the narrator’s life. While the first series of reflections introduce the subjection of men based on the social implications of one’s skin color, the second series of reflections reflect on the ideas on gender equality by considering the destinies assigned through societal expectations.…

    • 317 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many people can agree that females have the hard life, but many people do not think about how tough the life of a male can be. In society, for many years, there has been a stereotype that females have little to no advantages, while males have many. No one really stops to think that while women deal with the phrase “like a girl”, men deal with the phrase “be a man”. Social expectations have forced men into rigid gender roles that have limited their ability to express themselves and restricted their behaviors to those only regarded as socially acceptable for men. Even though women are often looked at as the underprivileged gender, men also have struggles of their own growing up.…

    • 730 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    What does it mean to be a “man?” Unfortunately, in American culture this is all too important of a question. According to sociologist, Michael Kimmel, being a (white) man entails having much anger, violence, and entitlement, which he describes further in his book: Angry White Men. These actions are also displayed in the 2007 film, The Departed, which follows the story of two white men on their journey to take on the Irish Mob along with the Massachusetts State Police Department. But, where do these actions come from? In this paper, I will be arguing that men in today’s society act out while trying to fulfill the ideal masculine role that is shaped by American society’s social expectations and social institutions including the family,…

    • 866 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the essay, “The Men We Carry in Our Minds”, Scott Russell Sanders discusses his perspective on men in comparison to the impression that women carry in their minds. Sanders uses a unique way of writing through narration and life experiences to truly illustrate his point that the impressions of men or women are based on ones own life experiences. As a young boy knowing only of the hardships of workingmen, Sanders later experiences drastic social differences when he receives a scholarship to attend a university “meant for the children of the rich”. His use of men and women in his personal experiences depict an un-stereotypical approach to convey his message to his audience. This analysis of Sanders’ essay will observe the organization of the author’s ideas, the essays’ purpose and audience, and the effectiveness to illustrate his views of men and women.…

    • 899 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the society today, men and women are trying to make things equal between the two genders. Women are allowed to participate in what some people call men activities or jobs, such as: welding, mechanics, or even being the CEO of some companies. During Sanders’s past most of a man’s future was to work hard and to support their families and women’s jobs were to take care of the house and children. In the past, all men worked hard. Sanders grew up to believe that men were to be in charge of everything. Men were the backbone of the country. Sanders say “When I was a boy, the men I knew labored with their bodies, they were marginal farmers, just scrapping by, or welders, steelworkers, and carpenters” (Sanders, 623.) Sanders had more consideration towards men. His view on men are without a doubt shown, that men are what keeps this country up, if it was not for the hard working hands of men, nothing would be able to get function properly. He also believed that men were warriors, superior beings that would give their life for the right thing. It has always been known that men are more in control than women are. It is clearly shown that Sanders is sensitive towards men and will always be on their side no matter what the situation is, but he also has a soft side for women because he has now come to realize what they go through alot while men are at work.…

    • 701 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Banksy once said, “We were all humans until race disconnected us, religion seperated us, politics divided us, and wealth classified us.” In the novel, “Of Mice and Men”, Steinbeck portrays several men and one woman on a ranch in California during the great depression. One of these men is an old black man named Crooks, and the woman is the boss’s son’s wife referred to as “Curley’s wife”. Crooks is the stable caretaker and has a separate room from all the other workers. Curley’s wife is the only woman on the ranch and is isolated by Curley from the other men who both have big dreams. Steinbeck illustrates that Crooks’s dream of being treated like any other white man, and Curley’s wife’s dream of being a movie star are destroyed by society’s racism and setting they’re in, showing that dreams don’t come true despite best efforts.…

    • 931 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As a child, Alison, compared the way she saw men portray themselves and compared their characteristics to her father’s. “…And who answered not to the laws of society, but to those of his own craft,” (Bechdel 2006:7). She could see her father lacked the ideal masculinity that we as a society think of how men are typically considered. “I measured my father against the grimy deer hunters…

    • 197 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thelma and Louise

    • 685 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Gender and power relations continue to be at odds with each other. Critically review how we still live in a male dominated society where patriarchal power still holds the key to the doors and windows of freedom, self-identity and expression. Strongly engage with this statement drawing on key actors in the film, also religion, ethnicity and gender relations.…

    • 685 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Gender Trouble

    • 1369 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Butler suggests that the “patriarchy” is a strawman and scapegoat that other feminists use in order to foment procedures to create a new, non-oppressive society. Butler believes that, “heterosexual melancholy is culturally instituted as the price of stable gender identities” (Butler, 70). She sees the debilitating way in which genders unconsciously isolate and detach themselves categorically form one another as, not a conspiracy on the part of the patriarchy, a stumbling block that both genders have fallen into – allowing the great gender divide to be instituted without seeing that the genders do overlap in many ways, creating hybrid and variegated notions of sex and gender. Butler views gender as not being as stable as we’d like to think it is. Butler also asserts that, “Gender identification is a kind of melancholia in which the sex of the prohibited object is internalized as a prohibition” (Butler, 63). In this statement, Butler asserts that gender is traditionally defined based off of what a “man” or “female” lacks physiologically. This is confused with sex.…

    • 1369 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    We begin a more in depth look into Sanders personal beliefs and history as he recalls discussing with a colleague the traditional hardships that both genders have faced throughout history. His companion Anneke expresses her belief that men have a tougher time in life than women, and the idea that “men are the ones who have been discredited, and have to search their souls” (292) . It is this very thought that causes Sanders to reflect upon his own personal experiences. “When I think back on my childhood, on how I learned to see men and women, I have a sense of ancient, dizzying depths.” (Sanders 293) As a child, Sanders felt as though a man of his socioeconomic class, had very limited options when it came to his future. He knew would eventually face a choice of…

    • 555 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    hi the pooh

    • 387 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Throughout the 1920’s, black people and women in America have been forced to live through poor social conditions. Until recent years, these people have been excluded from society and were considered and outsider in a normal community. John Steinbeck shows the reader this in his novella, “Of Mice and Men.” Steinbeck uses the characters of Crooks and Curley’s wife to display that although one character is a black male and the other, a white woman, they still have similar traits. These factors like discrimination, loneliness and shattered dreams make Crooks and Curley’s wife parallel (equal).…

    • 387 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays