Presumptuously, the Sorting Hat is hailing each student as a subject of the house to which they will belong. Since the hat can see into each student's head, the hailing is more individualized than most. The Hat is never wrong about where a student belongs, as a magical object with unique abilities. The Sorting Hat is saying, in effect, "This is you. This is where you belong. You are brave, or you are loyal, or you are smart, or you are cunning."(118). However, the student wants so desperately to belong, so when the Hat makes the choice of the student for a certain house, the student chooses that house, too. "I'm brave!" she thinks. "I belong in Gryffindor! I'm going to be the best Gryffindor I can be!" The student responds by identifying him or herself as a member of that
Presumptuously, the Sorting Hat is hailing each student as a subject of the house to which they will belong. Since the hat can see into each student's head, the hailing is more individualized than most. The Hat is never wrong about where a student belongs, as a magical object with unique abilities. The Sorting Hat is saying, in effect, "This is you. This is where you belong. You are brave, or you are loyal, or you are smart, or you are cunning."(118). However, the student wants so desperately to belong, so when the Hat makes the choice of the student for a certain house, the student chooses that house, too. "I'm brave!" she thinks. "I belong in Gryffindor! I'm going to be the best Gryffindor I can be!" The student responds by identifying him or herself as a member of that