Why Mar’s death was second degree murder? Because there was no planning it wasn't some had hatred on him some didn't and it couldn't be by intent because he wanted to Sawyer shot him but missed and he was still alive, but Jack went in there and he was suffocating so Jack killed him so that he would not have to suffocate.
Was piggy murdered or was it an accident?It was murder why?Because there was …show more content…
So if they had to tell who was guilty or who's not it would go like this. Sawyer tried to kill Mars but he missed so that would be 2nd degree murder because it was intended to do and jack finished it of so Sawyer would be the guilty one because his intention was to killing him and Jack didn't want to see him suffer so he did what he had to do. So whoever tried killing piggy is guilty it was intention of murder so they are guilty.And Simon’s death was an accident because they were having self defense and they didn't know who was