Preview

The Liberal Party Had No Real Interest In Women's Suffrage Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
860 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Liberal Party Had No Real Interest In Women's Suffrage Analysis
Do you agree with the view that, between the years of 1884 and 1914, the Liberal Party had no real interest in women’s suffrage?

Lydia Becker, a leader in the early suffrage movement gave a speech in 1885 where she criticised the Liberal government as she believed they did not care ‘a straw for the interests and wishes of women’. This was on the back of the third reform act, which was passed a year before this source. The act gave working class men the right to vote but still left out 40 percent of men, and all women. Becker describes that the government ‘promises of greater freedom’ are a ‘mockery’. The weight of this source could perhaps be questioned, as taking into account the origin of it. This quote was from the secretary of the NSWS,
…show more content…
They perhaps felt that in giving the vote to upper-class women would result in a swing of support to the Conservatives. The Liberals would be wary of this and in 1914, a long 29 years after Becker’s speech, the Liberal Prime Minister, Asquith responded to demands for votes for women. As part of his response that, if women are to get the vote, it should include all women, upper and lower class. He said, ’if women were to get the vote then they should get it ’on the same terms as men,’ to make it a ’democratic measure’. This idea would in affect reduce the risk of the inclusion of women as it would be expected that the lower class women would vote Liberal, going against the upper class women’s support. Even though he did not include this hint of universal enfranchisement, Asquith makes it clear that he does not condone the violent actions of the Suffragettes. That in his view their actions had ‘put back the cause of women’. Events such as Black Friday, in 1910, seemed to have a negative impact on the Suffrage cause. The way in which the Suffragettes acted in the later reflection on the Police, which did not sit well with the government. Actions such as this and the continuous vandalism portrayed women in a bad light in the national media, which left the Liberal Party further away from giving women the vote, as they would be going against the media and …show more content…
There was Industrial unrest, which would effect many things. The government would need to deal this as a collapse of industry would have a huge impact on the country. Another problem the Liberal’s faced was a rebellious House of Lords as a result of a Conservative majority. The House of Lords could reject bills, until 1911, which would cause problems for the Liberals and the changes they wanted to make. Both of these events could be seen as a possible excuse, as to why the Liberal Government hadn’t

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    How successful were the Liberal government in years 1906-1914 in bringing about political and institutional reform (24)…

    • 1189 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The liberal’s victory in the 1906 was a very significant one due to how they won it with such an overwhelming majority; it was the biggest electoral victory since 1832. In the 1890’s the liberals were suffering from a crisis identity and they were lacking in money and morale. In the 1906 election the liberals won 49.4% of the vote and that amounted to 399 seats which was such a large margin compared to in 1900 where 45% of the vote was only 183 seats. There are four main reasons arguably why the Liberals won the1906 election and these are through Conservative faults such as the massacre in the Boer war. The education act in 1902 and Chamberlain’s tariff reform campaign also lost the conservatives a lot of support, which meant people turned to liberals just due to disliking the conservatives. The most important reason was Arthur Balfour getting involved and not making the right decisions for the conservatives and losing a lot of the voters they had before. The liberals also used a very negative campaign in order to get voters to realise the flaws in the conservative’s ideals and make them vote for the liberals just through dislike of the other parties.…

    • 1468 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although this petition was defeated, as like the Third Reform Bill of 1884, it was their strategies that first brought the need for franchise to the fore, agitating the need for the need for suffrage. In 1905, a huge meeting was held in protest of this act, and since then, the Suffragettes began employing more vicious strategies like heckling government ministers, breaking windows and initiating hunger strikes in prison amongst other terrible things. The New Book of Knowledge(Vol. 7., p 3330). Not all women from the movement believed in adopting such radical actions. Millicent Fawcett maintained that the women stick to their original concept of peaceful and respectable demeanour, and peaceful rallying , which she believed, would gradually wear government down. and were considered to be of more positive construct compared to the more militant movement of the Pankhursts. Pugh believes that the vote to support women's suffrage was inevitable, mainly because of these earlier endeavours, which had already started to challenge certain cemented male dominance ideologies. He continues to admonish, "...While hypocritically paying fulsome to their war works..." Lines 2-3). Martin Pugh considers Asquith, whose position was, "The natural distinction of sex, which admittedly differentiates the functions of men and women in many departments of human activity,…

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    While the 1924 Labour government was undoubtedly one of the most important developments in party politics, there were other factors that contributed to the change from Liberal vs Conservatives in the 1880 to Labour vs conservative with Liberal's downfall by 1951. The 1924 Labour government was arguably a significant development as it was the first time Labour won an election, proving they had progressed from a small independent party to a real opponent of the Conservatives. This was significant as it showed that Labour had finally gotten their foot in the door and how Conservatives had not fully recovered from their decline in the previous 2 decades. The win was a huge shock to the Conservatives, but they won in a weak position and only lasted 10 months.…

    • 944 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    First of all, source 18 is showing that people were giving up on the vote and the suffrage campaign because it seemed as if nothing was going to happen and that the 'dead period of the movement begun '. For a long period of time, no bills or laws had been passed on the issue of women 's suffrage and even when elected MP John Stuart Mill proposed to change the word 'man ' to 'person ' in 1867 it was rejected by parliament. This seemed to give little hope for the future of the campaign and did agree that the vote for women seemed further away than ever.…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the1870s, the Conservative Party won three out of four elections and formed the government for 17 years out of a total of 20 years. It reflected the Conservative Party was the most powerful party in England at that time; they even had an overpowering majority of seats in the House of Lords. They had support from everywhere. However, the situation changed dramatically when the Liberal party won the general election in 1906 with an overwhelming majority of 400 seats as against 157 seats for the Conservatives party. This event was marked as the well-known ‘Liberal landslide’. There are several reasons why the Conservative lost such a large amount of seats; national efficiency, the imposition of Education Act and Licensing Act, tariff campaign and Neglect of social reform.…

    • 1006 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Borden's Suffrage Campaign

    • 4595 Words
    • 19 Pages

    Under Ritchie-England’s leadership they organized a series of high-profile events, including the visits of British suffragettes and an exhibit of suffrage literature that featured a petition addressed to the Premier of Quebec, demanding the vote.16 With the help of the Toronto Council of Women, MCW successfully pushed the NCW to finally adopt suffrage as part of its national platform in 1910. They also encouraged widows and spinsters, eligible to vote because of their property, to support Reform candidates in Montreal’s municipal elections of 1910 and 1912.17 In 1913 executive members of the MCW decided to start an affiliated group, the Montreal Suffrage Association, led by Ritchie-England’s good friend Carrie Derick, an instructor of botany at McGill. Having a distinct suffrage association, one that included anglophone and francophone women, allowed for a more distinct recognition of the suffrage cause and solved the problem of the MCW directly alienating any critics. This was deemed necessary, since the boom in suffragist activity by the MCW did not transfer over to the Canadian public and had even less impact within Quebec.18 In 1912 the Montreal Daily Star published a…

    • 4595 Words
    • 19 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Liberals created many reforms which impacted the lives of British people differing between aid and attention for well being of all ages and insurance for the unemployed or sick. This essay will investigate whether they were of positive or negative on the British people.…

    • 932 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Moreover, the most significant cause of the constitutional crisis was the fact that the conservatives had the overall majority in the House of Lords. After the liberal landslide in 1906 the house of commons was dominated by liberals so any bill the liberal party put forward would almost certainly pass the commons; however conservatives still had ‘real’…

    • 423 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ww1 Unit 1 Research Paper

    • 1048 Words
    • 5 Pages

    There were many people who argued that because women had worked so relentlessly during the war, it would be impossible to deny them the vote, especially due to the fact that working class men got the vote that were on the frontlines. Source 5, a letter from Lord Selborne to Lord Salisbury argues this point, and claims that it would not only be unjust to the women; it would also be “dangerous to State”, as it would be a gross corruption of morality and standards, because of the “the steadying influence…

    • 1048 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Before the First World War, women did not have the vote because they were not seen as contributors towards shaping the country, economically or politically. This is because they were confined, practically, to their homes, as all they could do is cook, clean and look after the children. This is when groups like the Suffragists and the Suffragettes formed. Their aim was to gain the vote. However, propaganda against them made women look useless, even more so. Therefore, not much was changing for them.…

    • 1064 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the nineteenth century women’s rights were overlooked. “All men are created equal” but for women this was overlooked. Women were denied their “unalienable rights”. Some women like Catherine E. Beecher and Elizabeth Cady Stanton started to demand that women should not live in a society made for men. The NAWSA tried to get nation support to give women the right to vote. In August 26, 1920 Congress passed the amendment for women to vote.…

    • 314 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Do you agree with the view that the suffrage movement made ‘substantial progress’ during the first decade of the twentieth century?…

    • 818 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In 2005, it was the 85th anniversary of the nineteenth Amendment; the right to vote for American women, whether black, or white. While Abigail Adams quoted “Remember the ladies,” on 1776 in her letter to her husband, John Adams, it was also the same year that the Declaration of Independence was written with the words “all men are created equal.” Women’s suffrage began during the early twentieth century and it was disrupted during the American Civil War between the North and the South in 1861 to1865.…

    • 516 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many women take their freedoms for granted. When they vote, they do not think of how they are allowed to vote, when they get to speak up for anything they feel vehemently about, they do not consider why they are granted to speak ,and when they earn their incomes, they do not reflect on who gave them this privilege. The men and women who made all of these things possible established the preliminaries for coming women to pursue out a life of freedom.…

    • 638 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays