Preview

The Knowledge Argument Proposed By Frank Jackson

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
984 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Knowledge Argument Proposed By Frank Jackson
The point of this paper is to show what the Knowledge Argument is, the two premises it contains, and its conclusion. Also I will explain one objection it holds. Lastly, I will explain how the objection fails to succeed its point in contradicting the Knowledge Argument. The Knowledge Argument proposed by Frank Jackson is about Mary, a scientist that is brilliant and understands and knows everything about neural science and physics. This takes place in the future where she is held in a black and white room where all she ever sees is black and white. Mary has never seen a red apple, and one day they finally let her out of the black and white room and she gets to see a red apple. From this experiment a question arises which is whether or not …show more content…
In the future everything can be explained by science and Mary being a neurophysiologist of vision lets her understand how seeing colors can be explained by the wavelengths coming into the retina. She also knows what happens in the neural system that makes us say "red." Premise 2 states that after Mary left the room she learns a new fact and that fact has to do with her seeing the color red as a conscious state. When Mary perceives the color red there is a new sensation of seeing that color, something she didn’t know. The sensation she gains is a new fact she did not know before, therefore she learns something new. The two premises conclude that there is a fact that is not a physical fact but a conscious fact. This would lead us to believe that Physicalism is false. In order to come to this conclusion neither premise can deny Physicalism alone. If Mary knows all the relevant physical facts and after leaving the room she learns a new fact, a conscious state means that Mary did not actually know everything but instead is missing certain unexplainable facts. There is a gap that Physcialism cannot explain and in this gap is where conscious states fall. Dualism explains this gap with laws that explain brain states to conscious …show more content…
Her experiencing the color red does not increase her knowledge it is only a new experience that she receives. The argument being made here is that she does not seem to learn a new fact, but is now able to explain it a new way. The statement "knowledge by acquaintance" is the same as "knowledge by description" explains that when she was in the room she knew how red was like by the description (Fesser 2005, p.98-99). Once she was able to see the color red she just became acquainted with the facts she already knew. Mary is learning a new way to explain an old fact she had already learned in the black and white room. Since she already knew how the color red is formed she knows how red is. It is plausible because Mary knows how the color is formed and she can simply stimulate the color red. A Physicalist would choose to believe this objection because there is no way that anything she already has knowledge about can become a new fact. Also they think it is impossible for anything non-physical to explain what Mary is going

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Nt1310 Unit 1 Assignment

    • 361 Words
    • 2 Pages

    According to the standard account, true belief is not sufficient for knowledge. It states that knowledge requires, not only that our beliefs be true, but that we have good reasons for believing them to be true. In standard account, knowledge is justified true belief.…

    • 361 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    3. People have claimed that Jamie’s paintings have given them the blues. Clearly this cannot be entirely correct, since many of Jamie’s paintings contain no blue at all. The argument above is flawed because the author…

    • 697 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Scarlet Ibis

    • 368 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The first example he uses is when Doodle was born he say “Doodle was born with red skin.” If Doodle was born a normal skin color Doodle probably wouldn’t have been compared to the bird as much. The next example he uses is when Daddy say’s” It’s a Scarlet Ibis. Scarlet mean red and according to the description the bird was very red. If the bird had been a different color such as purple, there may not have been as much of a connection. The third example is when Hurst is describing the bird and Doodle after they both died, in both cases the blood. Blood is red and Doodle was covered in it. According to Hurst the whole shirt is bloody. Doodle and the bird shared the color red in different thing about them.…

    • 368 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Other philosophers, such as McGinn (1989), suggest that explanation of neural correlates and consciousness will escape our understanding. Nonetheless, the gap needs to be reduced and any advance at the empirical level is important. This is the basic point of Robert Van Gulick, who argues…

    • 1181 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    It also shows she cares about Haskins and is concerned for her family. The differences between Haskins reaction and Mary’s reactions are…

    • 144 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mommy was, by her own definition, “light-skinned” a statement which I had initially accepted as fact but at some point later decided was not true. My best friend Billy Smith’s mother was as light as Mommy and had red hair to boot, but there was no doubt in my mind that Billy’s mother was black and my mother was not. There was something inside me, an ache I had, like a constant itch that got bigger and bigger as I grew that told me. It was in my blood, you might say, and however the notion got there, it bothered me greatly. Yet Mommy refused to acknowledge her whiteness.”…

    • 736 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Firstly, Rebecca says the right temporal junction is the special brain region that helps adults understand other minds well. However, adult brains are more developed than a child’s brain. She does a great job at giving a good understanding to the audience by explaining the right temporal junction of the human mind. She goes into depth and talks about the specialized brain of an adult and compares it to the undeveloped brain of a child. She explains this precisely by comparing and contrasting test results of a study between adults and children. In the study she performs the same scenario for both trials. Allowing one to see how the adult mind verses the mind of a child sees right from wrong. This reveals a clear vision to her audience by showing the differences in the…

    • 592 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    What the knowledge argument also basically states is that if physicalism is in fact true, Mary would know everything in this world. Obviously though, Mary cannot have learned absolutely everything from this experience. Once Mary is released into the real world, with color, she is then experiencing, and learning something new: what it is to see color. Although she learns everything physical in her black and white environment, and still learns something new when she is exposed to color once she is released, it only seems reasonable that we are able to conclude that physicalism is false.…

    • 1300 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jackson, when looking for a way to prove this identity theory false, claims that his argument exposes truths about our consciousness that cannot be simply deduced by physicalism. He argues that the physical truth is not the whole truth. Many philosophers that defend the identity thesis can agree that the physical truth does determine the whole truth about the world. We are seen as having the capabilities of possessing all the knowledge there is and never leave a mystery unsolved. The world is entirely physical and we are physical beings. Jackson’s argument is seen to have two parts. One part is the fact that our physical knowledge is simply not enough to know everything, or what he calls it as phenomenal knowledge. This idea he also calls the…

    • 252 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The knowledge argument is strongly demonstrated in Jackson’s thought experiment about consciousness. The thought experiment starts with Mary who is confined black and white room her entire life, learning all physical…

    • 1083 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Then the events that make “The Girl in the Lavender Dress” different from “Resurreccion Mary” is that “The Girl in the Lavender Dress” being witnessed and told by the author’s grandma and her husband Herbert. And then, having “Resurrection Mary” being told and witnessed by only one person, Jerry Palus. After that, they also different because they both occur in different time periods, “The Girl in the Lavender Dress - 1942 to 43” being written after “Resurrection Mary - 1800s”. Furthermore into story-wise according to both texts,“The Girl in the Lavender Dress”, has a different plot that the one “Resurrection Mary”, because in “The Girl in the Lavender Dress” is having Herbert and Grandma riding in their car towards New Hampshire to do some…

    • 278 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Each student must submit for external assessment an essay on any one of the ten titles prescribed by the IBO for each examination session. The titles for the November 2009 session are included in this booklet. The titles ask generic questions about knowledge and are cross-disciplinary in nature. They may be answered with reference to any part or parts of the TOK course, to specific disciplines, or with reference to opinions gained about knowledge both inside and outside the classroom. The titles are not meant to be treated only in the abstract, or on the basis of external authorities. In all cases, essays should express the conclusions reached by students through a sustained consideration of knowledge issues; claims and counterclaims should be formulated and main ideas should be illustrated with varied and effective examples that show the approach consciously taken by the student. Essays should demonstrate the studentʼs ability to link knowledge issues to areas of knowledge and ways of knowing. The chosen title must be used exactly as given; it must not be altered in any way. Students who modify the titles may gain very few or no points, since the knowledge issues that essays treat must be relevant to the titles in their prescribed formulation. The essay must be well presented, clearly legible, and, where appropriate, include references and a bibliography.…

    • 4464 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    present his evidence. John brings Mary into the court to tell the judge that Mary owns the doll…

    • 920 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    “Compare and contrast knowledge which can be expressed in words/symbols with knowledge that cannot be expressed in this way. Consider CAS and one or more areas of knowledge.”…

    • 1388 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In life, people always encounter moments, where they cannot verify whether it is true or false. These moments are the one who triggers debate and research. Truth and falseness ranges from the rate of relative to the absolute. But can we really say that there are no absolute distinctions between what is true or false? Our own opinions and perceptions are the reason why the question exists. Our brain decides from where we can see the viewpoint of things. Maybe it’s a coincidence that you and me have the same opinion. But it doesn’t prove that there are no absolute distinctions between the two of them. That is why I’m agreeing with the statement. Explanations on why I decided to do so can be discussed in the subjects of AoK, such as the arts and social sciences. These subjects that I chose has proofs that can verify the statement.…

    • 1358 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays