Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

The Influence Of School On Students Perceptions And School Experience

Best Essays
1839 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Influence Of School On Students Perceptions And School Experience
Chuxuan Rao (A97085344)
March 17th 2015
EDS 117 The Influence of School on Students’ Perceptions and School Experience
Serving as the developmental intermediary for students, schools convey the values that influence children’s identities, their perceptions towards education, and their experiences in school. For the past few decades, researchers have focused on the schools’ influence on students’ academic achievement rather than on their sociological development. Despite the increasing recognition of the significant role that school plays on children’s social and cognitive growth, the impact of school education on students has not yet been fully examined. Moreover, the diversity of races in the United States generates a unique school culture. Compared to a mono-racial class, multicultural classroom creates a more complex environment for people to understand how schools influence students’ perceptions of themselves, of education, and of the world. However, recent studies have shed some light on the direction further research should take in order to explore this problem.
School plays a crucial role in enlightening students to understand their own identities, personally and culturally. Due to the diversity of cultures in the US, school has the responsibility to help the students to understand both their inherent culture and the dominant culture in America. Therefore, one important aspect to explore the school’s impact on students’ cognition of their identities relates to school’s influence on the students’ understanding on their heritage culture and on the dominant culture, and their cognitive process of discovering their own identities. Since teachers are the direct resource for students to learn about their identities, teachers’ influence can be viewed as equivalent to the school’s influence. Thus, it is necessary to examine how teachers’ perceptions on students’ identities influence students, because teachers can adopt corresponding teaching methods to help students only if they perceive the right information about their students’ identities. According to Gloria Ladson-Billings, teachers, who acquire an accurate recognition on students’ cultural identity, have a better understanding on students’ background and behaviors, and they are also more likely to help their students to understand and appreciate both their own cultural identity and the dominant culture (“The Problem with Teaching Education” 106-109). However, in the study of Native American youth, researchers critique that some schools have forced Indian students to give up their inherent culture and adapt new behaviors in order to fit into the society (McCarty et al. 662). In the video about bilingual education we watched during lecture, we also observed that the school’s “English-Only” policy seriously hinders the Spanish student’s regular study. Although schools try to help students to prepare better to fit in the dominant group, they ignore the importance of persevering students’ own inherent cultural identities. These examples show that school can also restrain students from maintaining their own natural identities. Moreover, generated as a result of cultural difference of the diverse student group, teachers’ misunderstanding on students’ identity may mislead them to recognize their individuality inaccurately, causing confusion to their own identity. Falsely interpreting students’ particular behavior as cultural tradition may mislead teachers to have a false understanding on students’ identity, thus rendering negative outcomes (“The Problem with Teaching Education” 106-109). In the article Miseducating Teachers About the Poor, the authors critique that Ruby Payne’s inaccurate and passive interpretation of the poor misleads the teacher to have a biased perception of lower class students, resulting in ineffective teaching (Bomer et al. 2504-2505). In this case, if a teacher uses Payne’s methods to deal with teaching issues, which involve lower class students, the outcome may be disappointing. Similarly, both Stacy J. Lee and Mehan also indicate that the stereotype of involuntary minority, defined by John Ogbu, incorrectly informs teachers by picturing a problematically oppressive and resistant image of the group (153-154). Likewise, the critique regarding the notion about model minority stereotype illustrates similar problem. In her article, Lee indicates that the images of model minority not only creates overwhelming pressure for students who were included in this category, but also hinders these children from directly confronting their academic problem (427-428).As a result, it is important for school to have an accurate and clear vision of students’ cultural and personal identities, since it not only helps educators to apply particular teaching techniques, and also allows students to explore their true nature.
According to Hendrickson, students’ perceptions and social behaviors are generally thought to occur as “a reaction to social reproduction manifested in schools” (38). In order to examine students’ perceptions of education and their school life, students’ experience at school becomes the key to understand the issue. Additionally, since teachers serve as the direct liaison between school and students, they are the crux of this matter. One aspect that may influence students’ school experience is teaching expectation, which can also be referred to teacher’s attitude towards students’ performance at school. Students’ academic performance, and their opinion towards schooling, have been viewed as the cause that affects teacher’s expectation; however, it is the teacher’s attitude the one that alters students’ school experience. Recent study in culturally relevant pedagogy shows that teacher’s optimistic attitude to students’ study ability helps students to build up confidence in study and gives them a positive perception towards education (“Culturally Relevant Teaching” 162-163). Moreover, the study also indicates that, when a teacher displays positive expectations towards students’ academic performance, students gain positive motivation (“Culturally Relevant Teaching” 160). If students feel confident in studying and enjoy the teaching process at school, they are more likely to have a pleasant school experience. My first investigation on student’s education background also demonstrated this point. My interviewee was a junior math student with 4.0 major GPA in college, but he was considered a typical bad student when he attended elementary school. However, his middle school teacher identified his interest in math and had faith that he would make great progress by studying math. As a result of his math teacher’s confidence in him, he showed interest in studying for the first time, and became more driven and hard-working; soon, he became one of the top students in his class. This student’s experience illustrates how a teacher’s positive attitude can alter students’ perceptions towards education. On the other hand, low expectations from teachers result in negative outcomes. Researchers, such as Randy Bomer and Laura May, indicate that as a result of low teacher expectations, poor students are inclined to be in lower track or lower ability groups hinders students’ academic progress and generates negative perceptions of schooling (2498). This phenomenon illustrates that if a teacher believes that students will not be able to succeed or if a teacher does not expect any academic success from these students, students will be influenced by the teacher, and may become passive towards education due to the lack of confidence.
Another angle to investigate the impact of school on students’ perceptions and their school experience is to explore the relationship between teacher and students. A trustworthy teacher-students rapport brings positive promotion to both students’ interests in education and their school experience, while an unfriendly or discordant relationship between teacher and students results in negative consequence on students’ school experience. Pedagogical research has discovered that if teachers “value students’ skills and abilities and channel them in academically important way”, students will become more involved in class (“Culturally Relevant Teaching” 160). It also shows that it is important for teachers to link schooling with their students’ cultural background, since incorporating students’ inherent culture into teaching process motivates students to communicate actively with teachers and their peers in classroom (“Culturally Relevant Teaching” 159-160). One student in my reading response group told us that she was treated as a linguistic deficient student, when she first came to the U.S. However, her teacher esteemed her cultural background, and asked her to share her experience about her home country. Since then, she felt more confident at class and became more interested in engaging class activities. Her experience demonstrates that how teachers’ trust and respect can bring a pleasing school experience for students. On the contrary, an intense relationship between teachers and students leads to negative outcomes. Katie A. Hendrickson points out that if students feel that their teacher does not respect or cares about them, they become less willing to participate in the class (46). Consequently, this phenomenon generates a continuing negative chain reaction that teacher will pay more attention on students who are active at class and ignore those who are less interested in study, causing students in the latter group to be more likely to have an unsatisfied school experience (Hendrickson 46). The detriments of a hostile teacher-student relation denote the importance of building up a stable and trustworthy relation between teachers and students. In conclusion, a harmonious teacher-student rapport produces positive effects on students’ perceptions of education and their school experience, but an inconsonant relationship brings opposite consequences.
In order to conduct a comprehensive analysis of school’s influence on students, we should examine how school’s teaching on cultural differences, teachers’ expectation for students, and teacher-student relationship affect students’ understanding on their identity, their perceptions of education and their school life. Although the complexity of cultural diversity in the classroom makes it difficult to investigate to what extent the school affects students’ cognitive and social development, the past researches have indicated the direction for us to decipher the puzzle. Children are the future of the country, thus it is the country’s responsibility to create a desirable school environment for children to gain useful knowledge and to chase their dreams. As a result, it is essential to understanding the significant effects that school generates on students, because it can provide crucial assistance to schools and teachers to select eclectic teaching strategies to help students to pave the way for their future success.

Work Cited
Bomer, Randy. et al. “Miseducating Teachers about the Poor: A Critical Analysis of Ruby Payne’s Claims about Poverty.” Teachers College Record, Vol. 110. No.12. 2008: 2497–2531. Print.
Hendrickson, Katie A. “Student Resistance to Schooling: Disconnections With Education in Rural Appalachia.” The High School Journal, Volume 95, Number 4, 2012:37-49. Project Muse. Web.
Ladson-Billings, Gloria. “But That's Just Good Teaching! The Case for Culturally Relevant Pedagogy.” Theory into Practice. Vol. 34. No. 3. Culturally Relevant Teaching. 1995: 159-165. JSTOR. Web.
Ladson-Billings, Gloria. “It’s Not the Culture of Poverty, It’s the Poverty of Culture: The Problem with Teacher Education.” Anthropology and Education Quarterly. Vol. 37. No. 2. 104–109. Print.
Lee, Stacy J. “Behind the Model-Minority Stereotype: Voices of High- and Low-Achieving Asian American.” Anthropology & Education Quarterl. Vol.25. No.4.1994: 413-429. JSTOR. Web.
Mehan, H. et al. “Peer Group Influences Supporting Untracking.” Constructing School Success: The Consequences of Untracking Low-Achieving Students. 134- 156. Print.
McCarty, Teresa L., Mary Eunice Romero-Little, and Ofelia Zepeda. Native American Youth Discourses on Language Shift and Retention: Ideological Cross- currents and Their Implications for Language Planning, International Journal of Bilingual Education and Bilingualism. 9:5. 2006: 659-677.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    A lot of people have things that they find more difficult than others. It is not uncommon for a person to have their downsides but when it starts affecting their daily routines that’s when it becomes a problem. In the essay “It’s Hard Enough Being Me” by Anna Lisa Raya the author discusses her cultural identity challenges after discovering she was Latina. Raya discusses how she never had to question where she came from or who she was until she attended college in New York City. When she started school in New York City she came into the realization that she no longer was a majority like she was back home in Los Angeles, California. Now that she is studying in New York City she feels like a minority because she cannot figure out where she fits…

    • 406 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Lisa Delpit says that for students to be successful in school and eventually the workplace, they have to acculturate into the culture of those in power and doing that they lose who they are, their identity(Delpit, pg 25).. She talks about children who are economically better off than students who come from lower income homes, that opportunity and acceptance is better, but children of color are left to fend for themselves. I agree with Delpit because too often teachers are constantly telling students how to speak, read, and write they forget that children have lives outside of school and what may be their norm and what they expect, is different in their student’s lives.…

    • 1557 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Biographical Essay

    • 913 Words
    • 4 Pages

    This pattern carried on throughout elementary school. I had a hard time making friends, so I decided to change myself. I conformed to society’s demands. I changed the way I dressed, talked, acted and in the process, somehow lost both my cultural and individual identity. Deep down, I knew that I acted like someone I wasn’t, but still decided to ignore it since I wanted my peers to accept me. However, when I attended ________ High School starting from seventh grade, I was forced to confront this situation. Having a predominantly Asian makeup, culture was celebrated at _______. It was not like other schools where different cultures were amalgamated. In past schools, I was the only Indian so I felt the need to avoid telling others my ethnicity. What really surprised me about ________ was that every culture was acknowledged and respected. I came…

    • 913 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Biracial Identity

    • 3026 Words
    • 13 Pages

    Multicultural education has become a very important issue in this day and age. Diversity in the United States will become increasingly reflected in our country’s schools (Banks & Banks, 2003). According to the US Department of Education (The Condition…

    • 3026 Words
    • 13 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The purpose of this paper is to examine the detrimental effects institutional racism in education has on Latino academic achievement. Consideration is given to the role of educators in perpetuating racist attitudes; the ineffective acculturation measures and the adverse effects resulting from the diminished academic expectations. Latino children exit K-12 systems deficient of the necessary skills to thrive in higher education or in the workplace; facts which foster complacency. Qualitative and quantitative data are used to support arguments and observations. Additionally, this paper is intended to promote dialog about a problem that will have long lasting implications on society at large and the growing role Latinos will play in affecting the trends in educational paradigm shifts.…

    • 2100 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Eda 577 Action Inquiry

    • 2005 Words
    • 9 Pages

    To any prospective parent, a school needs to present all the facts about itself, so as the parent may make the choice that is best for their child. Thirty years ago, when I was in school. There was no concern about scores, diversity, etc. You just went to your local elementary, middle and high school. Today parents are much more informed and curious about where their child is going to go. To some parents, it is quite important to have their children attend a culturally diverse school. “There is a richness that comes from students working side by side with others who are not of the same cookie-cutter mold,” notes Jean Snell. (Great Schools Staff, 2009, P.123) This is why it is so important for a school to annually update their school profile. Davidson Middle School is doing this on an annual basis, offering prospective parents all the facts to make an informed decision. The school profile can also be used by staff to see the changes that occur from year to year and take this information to improve in the areas that it is needed in(Educational Testing Service, 2008).…

    • 2005 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    References: Howard, T.G. (2010). Why Race and Culture Matter in Schools: Closing the Achievement Gap in…

    • 2965 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    This paper includes a reference list of literature relating to the impact socioeconomic status and race/ethnicity has on academic achievement and what can be done to combat the achievement gap. In general, the literature seems to indicate that socioeconomic status has a greater impact then race or ethnicity on achievement. However, these constructs are often intertwined. The greatest source for combatting the achievement gap are teachers high in self-efficacy, strong and well directed principal leadership, having a positive and accepting racial climate, smaller class sizes, less harsh discipline with more support to reduce bad behavior, and better communication between parents and the school. Most authors agree, making education more meaningful and purposeful to the students would increase motivation to learn, which would increase success in academics. Almost all authors agree, professional development concentrated in these areas will reduce the achievement gap due to the increased academic success. There seems to be a combination quantitative and qualitative research.…

    • 3212 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The establishment of identity is an important, complex task for all adolescents, and is considered a major developmental task for all adolescents. It is particularly complicated for adolescents belonging to ethnic and minority groups. Ethnic identity of the majority group of individuals is constantly validated and reinforced in a positive manner where as the minority group is constantly ridiculed and punished in a negative manner. What does this say for those adolescents who are the minority and not the majority? It is important to study or research ethnic identity because it provides better knowledge to help one understand striving for a sense of unity and connectivenesss in which the self provides meaning for direction and meaning of ethnic identity (Spencer, 1990). It is also important to study or research the differences between these groups due to beliefs and values.…

    • 891 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Multicultural Paper

    • 2005 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Seelye, H. Ned, & Wasilewski, Jacqueline Howell. (1996). Between Cultures: Developing Self-Identity in a World of Diversity. Lincolnwood, IL: WTC…

    • 2005 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    Nunn, L. (2011). Classrooms as racialized spaces: Dynamics of collaboration, tension, and student attitudes in urban and suburban high schools. Urban Education, 46, 1226-1255.…

    • 1653 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the first steps of finding one’s cultural identity is analyzing your family’s background. Since a majority of my family grew up or lives in Florida, and I did as well, I can say that I am a native Floridian. Also, most of my family grew up as or is Christian, and I can say that I am as well. My parents grew up in a small town, and I did as well. There are a lot of similarities between their identities and mine when one looks the surface. However, there is much more to cultural identity than what one’s family’s identity…

    • 667 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Mexican Identity Crisis

    • 1417 Words
    • 6 Pages

    I’m going to be covering issue on international students from Mexico that who are having difficulties with identity and culture while adapting within the united states. moderns countries are having an identity crisis within they’re culture The world is becoming more broad when it comes to sharing identity. In country like the united state every thing is open. To focusing on educational policies in a multicultural setting in Mexico, the study sets forth the perceptions of students on Culture, internalization and discrimination. Finally, the study analyzes the interplay between policies and perceptions of the issues concerned.…

    • 1417 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    A casual look around most neighborhoods today reveals an undeniable trend: more multicultural families exist in the United States than ever before. In fact, in the 2000 census, more than six million Americans described themselves as being of more than one race (2000 Census). Multiracial families face many struggles with regard to race identification in their daily lives as well as children at school. Many children commonly experience the social isolation of not belonging to a defined group. I will examine which factors influence these families to identify racially, the psychological effects of their well-being, and the importance of the education systems approach towards relating to multiracial children in the classroom.…

    • 1910 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jonathan Kozol

    • 996 Words
    • 3 Pages

    When I was a young child, my elementary school years were packed with fun times, learning, and promise. I was always discovering exciting new things, meeting interesting new friends, and enjoying being a generally happy child. My school, Beryl Heights Elementary, an accredited school, met or exceeded all of the standards set forth by those in power, and as an institute of learning, would teach me the skills needed to become a productive citizen. While the aforementioned sounds like a great deal, could there possibly be a sinister aspect to all of it? What about the school body? I was a happy, young Mexican boy amidst a snow White ocean of students, lightly peppered with “people of color”, as is the popular term. Jonathan Kozol believed this to be so, and although our method of observation of school systems was different, we both discovered a shockingly similar situation. As a member of an economic majority yet supposed racial minority, I feel Mr. Kozol was correct in his belief of an “educational apartheid.“.…

    • 996 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays