The Great Debate-School Uniforms

Topics: High school, Secondary school, Dress code Pages: 13 (4504 words) Published: April 27, 2005
Imagine that you pick your seven-year-old child up from school. He is crying and wearing a different outfit than the one he wore to school. This is naturally upsetting but not as upsetting as your next discovery. His shirt, one you have never seen before, has a large "L" written on the sleeve in permanent marker; his shorts, also not his, are too large, stained and faded. Upon questioning your child, you discover that, despite your best efforts at compliance, your child's clothing has violated the school's uniform policy. Neither you nor your husband was called to bring your child a "compliant" change of clothing; rather a loaner uniform was forced upon your child. He was made to change into these alien clothes (McBride "Student" 1-2).

The debate over mandatory uniforms in the public school system is raging across the country and in our own backyards. Proponents claim uniforms improve many areas in the educational arena while opponents vigorously challenge these claims. Opponents also cite potential civil rights violations while uniform supporters counter that the potential benefits greatly outweigh any loss of freedoms. The issue of mandatory uniforms in the public schools gained the spotlight of national attention following President Clinton's 1996 State of the Union address. During that speech the President stated, "If it means that teenagers will stop killing each other over designer jackets, then our public schools should be able to require their students to wear uniforms" (Clinton 4). The President later visited Long Beach, California, where the first, district wide, mandatory school uniform policy in the country was enjoying seemingly remarkable success. He told those attending his speech that he had signed an order instructing the Secretary of Education to send to all school districts across the nation the newly generated Manual on School Uniforms ("Clinton" 1). The manual outlines specific steps for school districts wishing to implement uniform policies. It also gives examples of a few model policies from across the nation (United 1-7). The President went on to thank and praise Long Beach for their glowingly successful uniform policy ("Clinton" 3). Thus, the Long Beach Unified School District's uniform policy became the national standard for school districts across the country.

Despite the apparent success of some uniform policies, these often highly restrictive codes are not without problems. First, the highly favorable anecdotal reports coming from some school districts with uniform policies contrast sharply with the emerging empirical studies on the efficacy of uniforms. The recent data does not support the claims made by uniform proponents. Also, if provision is not made to permit parents to opt out (exempt their children from these policies), the codes are vulnerable to legal challenge (United 3). Sadly, some districts in an attempt to have a successful uniform code are overzealous in their enforcement techniques, causing confusion and stress for school staff and parents and often humiliation for students. While requiring public school students to wear uniforms may sound like an attractive quick fix to some, actual implementation of these highly restrictive policies is often rife with difficulties.

Proponents of mandatory school uniforms claim that data and evidence support their assertions that uniforms improve discipline and reduce crime. While the positive reports emerging from some school districts with uniform policies seem to lend credence to this position, upon closer examination, flaws begin to appear. In Long Beach, California, the first district to have a widespread mandatory uniform policy in the public schools, the initial reports concerning drops in crime and discipline were astonishing. Assault dropped by sixty-seven percent, vandalism by eighty-two percent, and robbery by thirty-five percent. Overall crime was reduced by seventy-three percent the first year the policy was in place...

Cited: Anna. "Uniforms." E-mail to the author 's organization. 10 Aug. 1999.
Brunsma, David L., and Kerry A
Cimino, Karen. "Polk Schools Plan Uniform Sanctions." Ledger online [Lakeland, FL] 15 July 1999. 5 Apr. 2000

---. "Uniform Policy Isn 't Made in Shades." Ledger online [Lakeland, FL] 15 Aug. 1999. 5 Apr. 2000 < http://www.theledger.com/local/education/15unif.html>.
Clinton, William J. "State of The Union Address." U.S. Capital. 23 Jan. 1996. UDaily University of Delaware. 5 Apr. 2000 .
Ferrante, Julia
Florida. Constitution Revision Committee. Florida Constitution. Rev. No. 6, 1998. 05 May 1998. 15 Apr. 2000 .
"Guidelines and Regulations for Implementing the Mandatory Uniform Policy in Grades Kindergarten Through Eight." 12 July 1994
"In Schools with Uniforms Attendance Hits New High in LBUSD Schools." Long Beach Unified School District. 15 Apr. 2000 .
"K-8 School Crime Report Study." Long Beach Unified School District
---. "Student Branding Outrages Parents." Polk Online.com. [FL] 2 Sept. 1999. 12 Mar. 2000 .
McCall, D
Sager, Michelle. "Boy Misses FCAT in Sweater Dispute." Tampa Tribune 18 Feb. 2000. Tampa Bay Online Network. 16 Apr. 2000 .
School Board of Polk County, Florida
Shah, Nirvi. "Twelve Students in Polk Face Truancy Petitions." Ledger online.com [Lakeland, FL] 6 Apr. 2000. 15 Apr. 2000 .
Siegel, Loren
"Student Prevails in North Carolina School Uniform Dispute." American Civil Liberties Union Freedom Network. 11 Jan. 2000. American Civil Liberties Union. 15 Apr. 2000 .
Tillman, Tim
"Uniform Incidents." Polk County School Uniform Page. Aug. 1999. The Parental Action Committee of Polk County, Florida. 5 Apr. 2000 .
United States
Van Der Laan, Dick. Telephone interview. Apr. 1996.
Walters, Sabrina
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Essay about School Uniforms
  • School Uniforms Essay
  • SCHOOL UNIFORM Research Paper
  • School Uniforms Debate Essay
  • Debate on School Uniforms Essay
  • Essay about The Debate over School Uniforms
  • Debate on School Uniform Essay
  • Essay on Debate on School uniforms

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free