The Girl And The Elephant

Powerful Essays
Ayana Domingo
ENG 112
Dr. Jen McDaneld
October 28, 2014
The Girl and The Elephant
Ernest Hemingway's short story "Hills Like White Elephants" illustrates his expertise at combining dialogue, setting, and symbolism with conciseness. The intense plot portrays a point in a man (called the American) and a girl’s life where they are at crossroads with one another. They dispute and make much effort to converse and challenge their standpoints about whether or not they should keep their unborn child. The man wants the girl (called Jig) to proceed with an abortion while the wife struggles to get him to look at her point of view. We will never be aware of how or if they manage to make ends meet due to the fact that the story concludes without a straightforward solution. A close reading of the text uncovers all kinds of translation games, which both disorient the reader and comment on communication in the story. Hemingway’s work shows the theme of what it means to talk and how important it is to have a conversation and be open with one another.
An example of this is shown in this paragraph
“‘They look like white elephants,’ she said.
‘I've never seen one,’ the man drank his beer.
‘No, you wouldn't have.’
‘I might have,’ the man said. ‘Just because you say I wouldn’t doesn’t prove anything.’” (Hemmingway 475)

Jig’s criticism appears to be a little spiteful in the quotation. As we read further on into the story, she’s profoundly disheartened in her man due to the fact that he yearns her to have an abortion and doesn’t want to marry her. Nevertheless, her insult has nothing to do with that. Instead, she grasps the deceitful procedure – hitting him with an implication that he has not explored the world as much as she has, which seems like a bold move. From that conversation, you are able to see that there is tension between the couple by their replies and that there is a type of ‘Girl vs. Man’ duel going on. An example of their bickering is shown in the dialogue where the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Powerful Essays

    The “Man” is encouraging her to have an abortion and states “ I know you wouldn’t mind it, Jig. It’s really not anything. Its just to let the air in.”(401). The “Man” is implying that an abortion would be no big deal and further states, “ I’ll go with you and stay with you all the time. They just let the air in and then it’s all perfectly natural. That’s the only thing that bothers us. It’s the only thing that’s made us unhappy.” The term “natural” used by man in this statement implies the abortion is a natural thing to do. This statement gives the impression that the “Man” is attempting to lure Jig into his way of thinking using their surroundings. Jig is disenchanted from nature and what it represents in the story and sees it from his “simple” solution to a clear problem. Their unhappiness is seen in their drinking of alcoholic beverages to dull the pain and feel like nothing is wrong, and implies their inability to face reality. Gazing across the landscape the “Girl” expresses how the hills look like white elephants. This statement is used as a distraction for the so-called “white elephant in the…

    • 1289 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    From the beginning of the story it is evident that Hemingway intends to focus on Jig and the issues at hand that will directly impact her. Through the use of third person objective, Hemingway leads the reader to believe that the couple are going through a rough patch due to Jig becoming pregnant. Jig, the only character granted a name within the story, has mixed feelings about the pregnancy on whether or not she wants to keep the child. "Well the man said, 'if you don't want to you don't have to. I wouldn't have you do it if you didn't want to. But I know it's perfectly simple'. 'And you really want to?' 'I think it's the best thing to do. But I don't want you to do it if you really don't want to'. 'And if I do it you'll be happy?" This simple sentence displays how the man is manipulating Jig into something she is not entirely sure about. Jig asks if the man…

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the beginning, the girl does not seem to want to go through with the operation. The American man is doing his best not to upset her yet making sure to get his point across. He obviously wants her to go through with the operation for him and is trying to let her understand how easy it would be for her by saying “It’s really an awfully simple operation, Jig,’ the man said” (Hemingway 2). This seems to be only the beginning of persuasion that will ultimately influence the girl’s decision.…

    • 548 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The conversation between Jig and the American seemed doomed from the beginning. They each had pre-determined motives before the conversation even started. The American was determined to convince Jig that the operation was simple and that they would be happy after she had it; Jig was determined not to talk about it as though she thought he would simply forget about it and then the pregnancy could continue. Tannen…

    • 842 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Hills Like White Elephants

    • 1410 Words
    • 6 Pages

    “Hills Like White Elephants” is a short story filled with what seems to be meaningless dialogue, but beneath the surface of the text there are ample illustrations of Hemingway’s creative symbols. Ernest Hemingway is an important American fiction writer who started his career around 1920 and won a Nobel Prize for literature in 1954. Before serving in World War I he wrote articles for a newspaper in Kansas City. Hemingway published his first book after briefly returning to America from Italy where he was severely injured in the war. In his life he had four wives and three children that influenced his work. Hemingway also held residence in many different places like Paris, Spain, Cuba, England, and Key West. Subsequently, Hemingway moved back to Idaho after covering many aspects of the Cuban Revolution with his writing, and in 1961 he took his own life in the town of Ketchum. The miniature plot occurs on a hot summer day in the early 1900’s at a train station in Spain. An American who is not named and his girlfriend Jig are having a conversation, accompanied by a cool beer while they are uneasily waiting for their train to arrive. The chat appears to be light-hearted, however it takes a noticeable turn before the train comes and the dark subject of the dialogue becomes apparent to the reader. Jig is pregnant with the American’s baby and the whole conversation revolves around whether or not to have an abortion Hemingway’s vague discussion between Jig and the American leaves much of this short story open for interpretation. By utilizing symbolism and character development, Hemingway conveys the central theme of indecisiveness in “Hills Like White Elephants.”…

    • 1410 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hemingway led a difficult life full of martial affairs and misfortune. Some of these experiences have set the foundation for Hemingway's greatest works. This essay will analyze the influence that Hemingway's separation from Pauline and divorce from Hadley had on "Hills like White Elephants." Before writing "Hills like White Elephants," Hemingway had been residing in Paris with his wife Hadley and son, Bumby. During their stay in Paris, Hadley and Ernest Hemingway met a woman named Pauline Pfeiffer. Pauline was more of a friend to Hadley than Hemingway was. Pauline did not think much of Hemingway at first, she thought he was lazy and a no-doer. Later Pauline and Hemingway fell in love and had an affair. Once Hadley knew of their affair, Hemingway requested a divorce. Hadley agreed under one condition, Hemingway and Pfeiffer had to separate for 100 days. After the 100 days if they were still in love, then Hadley would grant the divorce (Baker 174). This separation period left an indelible effect on Hemingway's life and…

    • 2205 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ernest Hemingway's, "Hills Like White Elephants," is discussed by many people because of the way that Hemingway used dialogue that contained a lack of descriptions, unidentified characters, and barely any narration to convey the short story's meaning. In this case, the reader is required to read between the lines. In this short story, one can see that all of the symbols disclose the unsteady relationship between the American and Jig and the conflict in relation to their lifestyle and operation.…

    • 1828 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In the article, “Moving to the Girl’s Side of ‘Hills Like White Elephants”, Stanley Renner carefully analyzes the movements of the female character and argues the different view from the general conclusion while still pondering on the open-end question the writer, Ernest Hemmingway, has left with the readers. Renner is left unsatisfied with the unresolved ending of the story. Although the majority of critics conclude that the girl will have an abortion to keep her lover but the existing relationship between the American and the girl deteriorated, Renner gives a new twist to the majority conclusion. Renner assets that “published commentary has not looked closely enough at the development of the female character through the story.” (27). In Renner’s conclusion, “the pregnant girl as she struggles with the American’s wishes and her own feelings points, in my view, toward the conclusion that she decides not to have an abortion, and her companion, though not without strong misgivings, acquiesces in her decision.” (27). The author breaks the story into three different evidences to move to the girl’s side of “Hills Like White Elephants”; setting where in the female character’s development takes place, four movements of the girl’s feelings that the girl develops as time goes, the remaining details of the story.…

    • 1711 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Hills Like White Mountains

    • 1941 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Even though it possibility would exaggerate the issue to suggest that an individual significant agreement exists concerning to the statement of Ernest Hemingway’s “Hills Like White Elephants,” a rundown of the absolute majority popular opinion may develop somewhat on these logical arguments: in an inspiring accomplishment of dialogue-impelled storyline prose, Hemingway’s nameless American male admirer overlooks the tamer, feebler-wound up Jig the former regarding or indicated by her feminineness, her adolescence (she is the young woman as conflicting to the lady who runs bar), and her strangeness (for the reason that he has the particular national feeling of identity, we may infer that it’s intended to describe his from hers) in anticipation of, busted, she defers to his wish and follows terminating the child. Frederick Busch articulates it most compactly when he contends that Jig “entombs her path of assuring as she will sink her kid” (762). Other carpers have evoked that “the male’s spoken language [of outstrip and ascendancy] overcomes [Jig]” (O’Brien 22–23) and that “Jig [. . .] acknowledges that she will at no time in the past or future birth the kid she is having” (Abdoo 238). A nearer gaze at what Janet Burroway adverts to as the approach pattern of changing authority, nevertheless, brings out an additional revolutionary stream in the duologue one in which Jig, puts off her American nationality miss-represents together the discussion and the man at every act to assure the apportioned fate of her and the child not yet brought into existence (36). Read harmonizing to this prototype of violation, the short story comes forth as a sequence of blocks that ascertain Jig’s superiority indicated by her cognitive and co-native sharpness, in addition to her understanding, her mocking brain, and her adeptness with an ironical satire, each and every one of which climax in the unconditioned downrightness of the concluding…

    • 1941 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    In his article “Moving to the Girls Side of “Hills like White Elephants””, published in 1995, Renner discusses an alternative conclusion that can be made through analyzing “Hills”. He believes that most critics have not paid enough “attention to the development of the female character” (27). Also, he suggests that Jig has been “underestimated considerably” (27). It is clear that a decision has been made by the end of the story, but it does not plainly say what. The reader must use the minimal information provided to interpret what they think happens. Hemmingway only provides this minimal information in order for the reader to be able to come to their own conclusions. In “Hills”, the majorities of critics have interpreted this information and have decided that the girl gives in to the American and has the abortion. Through close looking of the story, it is more likely that the woman refused to have an abortion and the American “acquiesces” (27) to her desires. Renner‘s analysis is both a valid and extremely interesting way of seeing this story. He effectively relates his reasons for being on “the girl’s side” to the reader with well used examples from the primary text.…

    • 1748 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Since its creation, abortion has been an extremely controversial and sensitive topic. Regardless of how one feels, there always seems to be a subsequent reticent disposition when discussing abortion because the subject is so vexatious. The apprehensiveness to genuinely discuss an abortion is essentially the infrastructure in Hemingway’s “Hills like White Elephants”. The reticent, yet passionate conversation between the protagonists sets the stage for numerous interpretations. Nevertheless, by writing such an ambiguous piece, Hemingway demonstrates the exceedingly powerful impact literary devices can have on a piece of literature.…

    • 595 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jig observes the scenery outside of the station and compares the hills to “white elephants”(351). Later on in the story when the conflict is brought to light, the symbolism of the “white elephants” can be seen. The “white” symbolizes the purity of the unborn child Jig carries. Without any input in the decision, the life of this child lies in the hands of a couple in the midst of an unhealthy relationship. The American is undoubtedly more concerned with his own life and selfish desires as he attempts to convince Jig to have an abortion. Jig, on the other hand, is unsure as to what should be done about the pregnancy. She fills the conversation with her uncertain and pessimistic attitude about the matter. Eventually, she begs the American to “please please please please stop talking,” as her frustrations become too much for her to handle (353). Either way, the fate of the child is unknown to the reader, as Jig cannot seem to make a decision. The figurative representation of “elephant” can be likened to the common expression of “elephant in the room.” Jig and the American speak of the situation at hand without directly referring to it. They both “beat around the bush” as they contemplate the destiny of their unborn child. This approach to the conversation from both angles embodies the central theme of avoiding problems at one’s convenience. The purity of the child and the…

    • 968 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Hills Like White Elephants

    • 1023 Words
    • 5 Pages

    “Hill Like White Elephants” written by Ernest Hemingway, revolves around a couple sitting and conversing at a train station. The two have ordered a couple of beers and continue to make small talk. Their conversation seems casual at first but then turns tense when the American exposes the unspoken trouble between them. They begin to talk about whether or not Jig, the woman should have an “operation”. It never clearly says what the operation is, but from various clues the reader can conclude that the operation that they are talking about is abortion. The American begins trying to convince the Jig to have an abortion. He cunningly try’s to comfort Jig by telling her that decision is totally up to her, but then tells her that he believes that the operation would be the best thing for the both of them. Jig can’t seem to decide, but seems reluctant to go through with the operation.…

    • 1023 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    At the beginning of the story, she points out how she perceives the hills looking like white elephants. To this, the man replies saying that a specific operation is “very simple” (401) and is “completely natural” (401). Readers assume the author is speaking of an abortion even though the words “baby” or “pregnancy” are absent. It is received as though he is subtlety pushing her toward the operation, assuring her their relationship will be as it were before. It is obvious that Jig is hesitant toward the idea. Assuming that the two are a couple, Jig seems to be anxious; not knowing what the future will possess if she goes forth. Judging from the questions that she replies with, the reader may acquire the idea that the girl is young and slightly…

    • 584 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cited: Hemingway, Ernest. "Hills Like White Elephants." The Complete Short Stories of Ernest Hemingway. New York: Scribner 's, 1987. N. pag. Print.…

    • 846 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays