Preview

The Ethics Of Driverless Cars Analysis

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
776 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The Ethics Of Driverless Cars Analysis
Argument
All engineers dream of creating something that is revolutionary; self-driving cars are a dream slowly becoming a reality. In Neil McBride’s (Sept 2015) article “The Ethics of Driverless Cars” published in SIGCAS Computer & Society, he declares that he believes our society is not ready for self-driving cars. In Milos N. Mladenovic’s and Tristram McPherson’s (August 2015) article “Engineering Social Justice into Traffic Control for Self-Driving Vehicles?” published in Springer Science+Business Media Dordrecht 2015, also agrees that we aren’t ready for self driving cars just yet. Although many agree that we are not ready, there are also others whom believe the opposite because of how much safer driving cars would be without humans.
…show more content…
McBride explains how self-driving cars are very smart on there own, but for them to actually be common in our society they need to work along side humans: “The technological and the human are more entangled, impossible to prise apart and must be considered as a whole (McBride, 2015, p. 184). He also states, “It is the machine that is autonomous and the human that is disempowered” (McBride, 2015, p. 181) making us below something we, humans, created. In this article the author tells us how we could lose our identities to these self-driving cars: “In societies where reputation, wealth, and role in society are represented in the car and its use, driverless cars will pose a threat” (McBride, 2015, p. 183). In this article McBride tells us how great self-driving cars can be on there own, but the possibilities vastly extend if we can use them cooperatively. In our minds us being human makes up the most powerful things on the planet Earth. McBride explains if we aren’t integrated with self-driving we will become powerless in a way; we will rely fully on a car. McBride explains in this article that in our society these days the way you drive your car and the way you represent that car defines your personal identity. Therefore, making it so that the cars and society still function together solves all the problems we, as humans, face with making self-driving cars a …show more content…
Mladenovic and McPherson both write about how we already have a system in place, although it isn’t optimized for self-driving cars: “We thus have reason to expect that that contemporary conventional traffic control (C1) will be replaced by a next-generation of traffic control that utilizes these new technologies—traffic control 2.0 (C2)” (Mladenovic&McPherson, 2015, p. 1334-1335). In the article Mladenovic and McPherson explain how the changes are needed before we can introduce them to the general public: “The convergence of computing, sensing, and communication technology will soon permit large-scale deployment of self-driving vehicles. This will in turn permit a radical transformation of traffic control technology” (Mladenovic&McPherson, 2015, p. 1334-1335). Mladenovic and McPherson both write about how we have been using the same traffic control system for decades even though technology has evolved. They also explain how creating a new technology like this will allow us to finally put to use the greatest technology ever: self-driving

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    Alex Davies, the author of the article “Congress Could Make Self-Driving Cars Happen-or Ruin Everything” has written to show how much congress really is included in the creation of these new automated cars. The new technology in development “permeates so many parts of society: public safety, privacy, the environment, liability and insurance law, employment, urban planning, and more.” The technology being engineered is so new that no one agrees on how the finished product will work or how to know when a car is equipped to fully run on its own. The article talks on how urgent it is to companies engineering the cars to have some sort of government guidelines approved quickly. This is so important because the engineers designing the cars are unable…

    • 230 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The transition itself to self driving cars could be costly and dangerous. Self driving cars would be very expensive, so not every person could afford to own one. The danger of the switch is that self driving cars have to take into account the cars that are still operated by people: “‘autonomous drive vehicles are a wonderful idea, but the transition from driver-operated to driverless is likely to be filled with accidents.’ For instance, while approaching a traffic light, a self-driving car calculates that if it speeds up a little bit, it will be able to pass through the light, but the driver in the car in front decides to stop because he thinks he won’t make it on time. What do you think the result will be?” (Ramirez). The most controversial part of self driving cars however, is how the computer inside the car will decide whose life is more important in the case of an inevitable accident. “the cars will be designed to avoid accidents, but ‘If it happens where there is a situation where a car couldn’t escape, it’ll go for the smaller thing.’ But what if the smaller thing is a child?” (Spangler). It is very difficult to determine whose life is more important, and even more difficult to program a car to…

    • 847 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In " Will your driverless car kill you so others live?" author Eric Schwitzgebel argues that driverless car may make crucial desions when in conflict, that may risk your life. He targets the audience, by putting them in this type of situation, discussing the dangers the cars would bring to its passsengers. Schwitzgebel contradicts his argument by stating that self driving car may actually be useful for young teens who can not keep their eyes on the road.…

    • 78 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    According to studies 94 percent of vehicle accidents are caused by human error,So as the evolution of vehicles continues, new technology has risen("Google Self-Driving Car). One vehicle that caught the public's eye is the Self-Driving car. The only problem is that people are very concerned with this new idea. People are afraid of malfunctions and other related issues like hacking. Also cost is a big problem. Though there are malfunctions and affordability issues, Self-Driving cars are safe because they include a 360 viewing camera with radar detection,autonomous brakes, and a high tech computer that runs the whole vehicle.…

    • 1525 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Many popular name brand car companies expect driverless cars to be on the market by 2020, and for all cars to be driverless by 2025. The idea of a car that can drive, navigate, and park itself was an idea only to be heard of in the movies, but now it is in it’s final stages of testing. The self driving car is currently in production of prototypes to be demonstrated to the public by popular name brand companies like: Tesla, Mercedes Benz, BMW, and more. With the introduction of a driverless car, the lives of many drivers will become much easier and create a positive effect.. The self driving car consists of an advanced programmed computer, as well as many sensors that help guide and calculate smart decisions for the car to make. A car that drives…

    • 1454 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Self Driving Dbq

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Some people would say that it’s sophisticated having them. Authors of document D states that self-driving cars will twenty miles per hour and have a GPS. The authors of documents A and B believed that casualties and accidents would decrease as the functions of the cars get better. Others would say that it’s the future, and we should progress with them. Some also would say that it’s cool and nice to have “safe” self-driving cars. According to document D, self-driving cars would have a “laser range finder” and a front that could decrease the severity of the injuries. Therefore, proponents of the self-driving cars, say that the self-driving cars will be the cause of potential decreasing accidents and deaths and is beneficial to society.…

    • 498 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Given that such technology is a recent development, philosophical work on the topic is in its infancy. However, due to the rate at which technology advances, this issue is timely, and Kirkpatrick gives a good overview of the ethics of self-driving…

    • 697 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Picture the streets completely filled with cars, not moving, going nowhere; an endless standstill of traffic. Driverless cars aren’t all they’re cracked up to be, they can and will cause problems. If driverless cars take over then laws will need to be rewritten, new possibile insurance matters occur, and traffic will increase causing longer commutes.…

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Self-driving cars are being built and are being experimented with everyday. Google has been building driverless cars for a while now. Features the cars will have is a GPS receiver, laser range finder, windscreen, video camera, radars, and an 160km-range engine. Although the self-driving cars already have all these features, it still has glitches that are continuously being operated on to be improved. Driverless cars technology cannot be fully trusted. A driver should have the option of driving his or her own car or have a self-driving car. Driverless cars should not be mandatory because of the dangers of the cars’ evolving technology.…

    • 767 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The subject is being researched and developed calling them autonomous vehicles exclaiming the need to ensure the passengers are safe when driving by removing the human error of being distracted. Yet, the major issues preventing it will not be easy to overcome. Unless all cars would be autonomous no amount of sensors, cameras. or computer programming will be able to cope with other driver’s instincts and actions. Concerning cost more technology will come at a larger cost, of which many will be unable to afford. (The self-driving function is stated by) Even still, an autonomous car can crash, or get cashed into just as any other would, only you'd be helplessly along for the ride. The reaction time or decisions made by a car in certain situations may not make sense. To serve as a point think of a natural disaster, flooding could prevent the car from going a certain path or leave it damaged and stuck. If the car is programmed to follow the road what will happen if its blocked, or what if a family wishes to drive through the uncharted woods? Another example is provided by Durbin as he said how “There are still some situations in which humans outperform computers. At a four-way stop, for example, a driver can crane his neck, scan for traffic in any direction and quickly determine the speed of any oncoming vehicles. So far,…

    • 1469 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Self Driving Artifact

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Firstly, autonomous vehicle control can increase the flow of traffic and make transportation far more efficient.[2] While few fully autonomous vehicles have actually been utilized and tested in the real world, it is a known fact that they have the potential to increase the safety and productivity of the road. The elimination of bottlenecking and traffic as a whole can enable cities to repurpose land previously used for multilane highways or roads. This would change the urban landscape entirely, and allow for more nature friendly parks and recreation centers to be constructed. However, self driving technology is also met with significant skepticism as moral and safety issues arise. The potential for fatal car accidents and detrimental injuries isn’t too uncommon for the self driving car because often it’s sensors aren’t precise enough to accurately identify or measure a given obstacle.[3] Of course, as one could predict, pushing 70mph on a highway and running head first into a tree doesn’t exactly have a positive outlook for those involved. Also, there is an aspect of losing blue collar jobs as computers begin to replace them. The trucking industry is worth nearly $700-billion , and one third of that money goes to paying for the drivers, meaning that replacing them using computers would be economically ideal for participating businesses.[4] Nearly 1.7 million blue collar truck drivers have the potential to lose their jobs because of the implementation of self driving…

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Essay On Driverless Autos

    • 428 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Most mischances in the United States are brought about by driver blunder and imagine a scenario in which that could be brought down if the autos that we drive, drive themselves. This another thing that is out now days, they are beginning to turn out with autos that drive themselves, Google as of now has a driverless auto out and about and I'm certain others will go with the same pattern. At the first World's Fair, there was take around a driverless auto that would be accessible to the pubic by the 60s despite the fact that that hasn't happen we are closer to having this sorts of autos out and about.…

    • 428 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Impaired Driving

    • 417 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Since the implementing the Google car on the road, Google has conducted two full monthly reports on accidents and impaired driving. In their second report, there have been a total of 11 accidents that have been involved with the self-driving car, and each of those accidents the driverless vehicle was at zero fault. The man accidents were mainly the Google car being rear ending by the distracted driver; usually minimal damage. Google has reported that in their six years on the project, there has been a total of 14 minor car accidents that involves more than 1.8 million miles of autonomous and manual driving combined. This evidence would indicated that the greatest challenge of autonomous driving is not technology systems of self driving cars, but rather the implementation for the reduction of human drivers.…

    • 417 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Self driving cars can be a negative thing because of all the human error involved. In one instance, one of Google’s self driving cars got into an accident with another vehicle after the driver panicked when the car slowed to a stop for pedestrian. When he panicked, the driver stomped on the brake and the car behind him rear ended him. There was no injures, but the two cars suffered heavy damage. (Tribune News Service)…

    • 320 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Self Driving Cars

    • 530 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Self driving cars participate in a behavior called platooning. It will improve traffic conditions, then we would be able to get around without worrying about much traffic. For Self-driving cars to function correctly and efficiently they need to communicate with each other, helping to locate traffic problems and dangers on the road early on. Sensors in the self-driving cars allow vehicles to drive on the road closer together without any accidents therefore eliminating traffic. Self driving cars are so smart, they can drive around and pick people up and just drop them off. Sebastian Thrun once said " Self-driving cars will enable car-sharing even in spread-out suburbs. A car will come to you just when you need it. And when you are done with it, the car will just drive away, so you won't even have to look for parking". Think about how much easier things would be if we had self-driving cars. All the advanced sensors on the car will avoid any traffic and if the majority of the cars on the road are self-driving cars, then we wouldn't have to worry about any kind of…

    • 530 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays