The efficiency and quality dilemma: What drives South African call centre management performance indicators?
Department of Industrial Psychology and People Management
University of Johannesburg
* corresponding author
Orientation: Call centres have become principal customer communication channels and companies attempt to simultaneously reduce costs and improve the quality of their customer interactions. These objectives are often conflicting and call centre managers struggle to balance the efficiency and quality imperatives of the business. Research purpose: This study explores the key performance indicators that drive management practices in the South African call centre industry within the context of the efficiency and quality dilemma. Motivation for the study: The South African government has identified call centres as a source of job creation and foreign investment. Management practices impact the centre’s performance and an understanding of these practices will aid the realization of these aims. Research design: A web based questionnaire was used in a survey that was conducted with South African call centre managers from more than forty four different organisations representing nine industry sectors. Main findings: This study indicated that the quality and quantity dilemma is prevalent in South African call centres and that quantitative key performance indicators drive the management practices. Practical/Managerial implications: The reported inconsistencies necessitate South African organisations to assess the alignment between the organisational vision, the strategic intent of the call centre and the performance measures allocated to the role of call centre manager. Contribution and value add: This study adds to the relatively small base of empirical research available on the South African call centre industry and contributes to this industry’s attempt to position itself favourably for both local and international outsourcing opportunities.
Key Words: Key performance indicators, call centre manager, qualitative measures, quantitative measures, South African call centres INTRODUCTION
The strategic role of call centres is changing and it has become the primary way of delivering service and the main source of contact for customers. Companies attempt to achieve customer satisfaction by offering their customers easy access to the services and products whilst lowering the cost to the company with a consolidated approach. This approach is not void of problems and managers struggle to balance the efficiency and quality imperatives of the business. This research focuses on these conflicting objectives and investigates the performance indicators that drive management practices in the South African call centre industry.
Efficiency is enabled by an array of easily accessible measures offered by call centre technology. Neely, Bourne and Kennerley (2003) suggested that too much measuring is happening and Radnor and McGuire (2004) found that the role of call centre managers is more administrative than managerial – managers focus on accumulating measurements, rather than managing people’s output. Call centre managers are faced with the challenge to decide on practices that will meet the company’s expectation of rationalised operations whilst still ensuring employee wellbeing and customer satisfaction. The conflicting nature of these call centre objectives has been well researched (Bain & Taylor, 2000; Batt, 1999; Houlihan, 2002; Kinnie, Hutchinson & Purcell, 2000; Taylor & Bain, 1999; Wallace, Eagleson & Waldersee, 2000) and these studies suggest that the two objectives – efficiency and quality - are fundamentally contradictory. Dean and Rainnie (2009, p. 326) captured the suggested discrepancy in their reference to the call centre as “a unique and contradictory service environment”.
There has been an increased interest in the...
References: Aksin, Z., Armony, M., & Mehrotra, V. (2007). The modern call center: A multi-disciplinary perspective on operations management research. Production and Operations Management, 16(6), 665-688.
Armistead, C., Kiely, J., Hole, L., & Prescott, J. (2002). An exploration of managerial issues in call centres. Managing Service Quality, 12(4), 246-256.
Babbie, E., & Mouton, J. (2001). The practice of social research. Oxford University Press.
Bain, P., & Taylor, P. (2000). Entrapped by the ‘electronic panopticon’? Worker resistance in the call centre. New Technology, Work and Employment, 15(1), 2-18.
Bain, P., Watson, A., Mulvey, G., Taylor, P., & Gall, G. (2002). Taylorism, targets and the pursuit of quantity and quality by call centre management. New Technology, Work and Employment, 17(3), 170-185.
Barnes, A. (2004). Diaries, dunnies and discipline: resistance and accommodation to monitoring in call centres. Labour and Industry, 14(3), 127-137.
Batt, R. (1999). Work organization, technology and performance in customer service and sales. Industrial & Labor Relations Review, 52(4), 539-564.
Batt, R., & Moynihan, L. (2002). The validity of alternative call centre production models. Human Resource Management Journal, 12(4), 14-34.
D’Cruz, P., & Noronha, E. (2007). Technical call centres: Beyond “electronic sweatshops” and “assembly lines in the head.” Global Business Review, 8(1), 53-67.
Dean, A.M., & Rainnie, A. (2009). Frontline employees views on organizational factors that affect the delivery of service quality in call centres. Journal of Services Marketing, 23 (5), 326-337.
Deery, S., & Kinnie, N. (2002). Call centres and beyond: a thematic evaluation. Human Resource Management Journal, 12(4), 3-13.
Department of Trade and Industry (2009a). Launch of Department of Trade and Industry investment call centre at Soweto. Retrieved March 17, 2010, from http://www.info.gov.za/speeches/2009/09101909051001.htm
Department of Trade and Industry (2009b)
De Waal, A.A. (2002). The human element in performance management systems. Quest for balance. New York: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.
Feinberg, R.A., Ik-Suk, K., Hokama, L., De Ruyter, K., & Keen, C. (2000). Operational determinants of caller satisfaction in the call center. International Journal of Service Industry Management, 11(2), 131-138.
Fernie, S., & Metcalf, D. (1998). (Not) hanging on the telephone: payment system in the new sweatshops. Centrepiece, 3, 7-11.
Fisher, J., Milner, K., & Chandraprakash, A. (2007). Organisational climate, job tension and job satisfaction in a South African call centre case study. Ergonomics SA, 19(2), 22-30.
Fornell, C., Mithas, S., Morgeson, F., & Krishnan, M.S. (2006). Customer satisfaction and stock prices: High returns, low risk. Journal of Marketing, 70(1), 3-14.
Foucault, M. (1997). Discipline and punish: the birth of the prison. Retrieved July 17, 2010, from http://www.esubjects.com/curric/general/world_history/unit_three/pdf
Frenkel, S.J., Tam, M., Korczynski, M., & Shire, K
Hart, M.L., Chiang, Y.-A.A., & Tupochere, M. (2009). Balancing agent performance and customer service in contact centres. Journal of Contemporary Management, 6, 151-169.
Halliden, B., & Monks, K. (2005). Employee-centred management in a call centre. Personnel Review, 34(3), 370-385.
Houlihan, M. (2001). Managing to manage? Stories from the call centre. Journal of European Industrial Training, 25(2/3/4), 208-220.
Houlihan, M. (2002). Tension and variations in call centre management strategies. Human Resource Management Journal, 12(4), 67-85.
Huysamen, G.K. (1998). Methodology for the social and behavioural sciences. South Africa: International Thomson Publishing.
Jack, E.P., Bedics, T.A., & McCary, C.E. (2006). Operational challenges in the call center industry: a case study and resource-based framework. Managing Service Quality, 16(5), 477-500.
Kaplan, R.S., & Norton, D.P. (1992). The balanced scorecard – measures that drive performance. Harvard Business Review, 70(1), 71-79.
Khuzwayo, W. (2007, April 29). SA call centres take on the world. Business Report. Retrieved March 10, 2010, from http://www.busrep.co.za/index.php?fSectionId=561&fArticleId=3803048
Kinnie, N., Hutchinson, S., & Purcell, J
Korczynski, M. (2002). Human resource management in service work. Hampshire: Palgrave.
Little, M.M., & Dean, A.M. (2006). Links between service climate, employee commitment and employees’ service quality capability. Managing Service Quality, 16(5), 460-476.
Marr, B., & Parry, S. (2004). Performance management in call centers: lessons, pitfalls and achievements in Fujitsu Services. Measuring Business Excellence, 8(4), 55-62.
Moshavi, D., & Terborg, J.R. (2002). The job satisfaction and performance of contingent and regular customer service representatives. A human capital perspective. International Journal of Service Industry Management, 13(4), 333-347.
Multimedia Group & C3Africa (2008). South African National BPO & Call Centre Report. Johannesburg: Multimedia Group.
Neely, A., Bourne, M., & Kennerley, M. (2003). Dysfunctional performance through dysfunctional measures. Cost Management, 17(5), 41-45.
Radnor, Z., & McGuire, M. (2004). Performance management in the public sector: fact or fiction? International Journal of Productivity and Performance Management, 53(3), 245-260.
Raz, A.E., & Blank, E. (2007). Ambiguous professionalism: managing efficiency and service quality in an Israeli call centre. New Technology, Work and Employment, 22(1), 83-96.
Richardson, H.J., & Howcroft, D. (2006). The contradictions of CRM – A critical lens on call centres. Information and Organization, 16, 56-81.
Robinson, G., & Morley, C. (2006). Call centre management: responsibilities and performance. International Journal of Service Industry Management, 17(3), 284-300.
Robinson, G., & Morley, C. (2007), Running the electronic sweatshop: Call centre managers’ views on call centres. Journal of Management and Organization, 13, 249-263.
Russel, B. (2008). Call centres: A decade of research. International Journal of Management Reviews, 10(3), 195-219.
Sergeant, A., & Frenkel, S. (2000). When do customer contact employees satisfy customers? Journal of Service Research, 3(1), 18-34.
Taylor, P., & Bain, P. (1999). ‘An assembly line in the head’: work and employee relations in the call centre. Industrial Relations Journal, 30(2), 101-117.
Taylor, P., & Bain, P. (2005). ‘India calling to the far away towns’: the call centre labour process and globalization. Work, Employment and Society, 19(2), 261-282.
Please join StudyMode to read the full document