Sound localisation is the process of determining the location of a particular source of sound, and this is achieved through the use of binaural and monaural cues. To investigate what factors affect the ability to localise sound, one hundred and eighty six psychology students underwent an experiment where subjects indicated what direction they heard a set of keys coming from when the keys were shaken above the participant’s head on three different positions of the midline. The four conditions in this study included head movement, no head movement, normal pinnae and distorted pinnae. As hypothesised, sound localisation improved significantly when the head was mobilized rather than immobilised, in conjunction to the pinnae being normal rather than distorted. These findings suggest that sound localisation is most successful when the head is mobile and the pinnae is normal.
The Effects of Pinnae and Head Movement in Sound Localisation
The brain is equipped with the ability to perceive hearing, meaning it is able to recognise differences in intensity, spectrum and timing in order to correctly detect auditory stimuli. It is important to be able to locate sounds in the space surrounding us, and this is achieved through using the pinnae and head movement. Pinnae effects and head movement assist in directional auditory localisation (Muller, B.S., & Bovet, P. 1999) and spatial hearing (Denise Van Barneveld, Floor Binkhorst, A. John Van Opstal 2011). The pinnae is the outer structure of the ear which catches and guides sounds into the inner ear, and this study will assess the differences of sound localisation if the pinnae is distorted and undistorted. The use of head movement in this study is to investigate whether sound localisation improves when the head is mobilized or immobilised. The role in sound localisation is to detect the direction of the auditory stimuli coming from in front, behind, above or below the head (Martijn J H Agterberg; Myrthe K S Hol; Ad F M Snik; Marc van Wanrooij; A John Van Opstal), and this is done through the use of different cues, including binaural and monaural cues (Marc. M. Van. Wanrooij, A. John Van Opsal (2006). Binaural cues use interaural time difference (ITD) and interaural intensity difference (IID). ITD refers to the length of time that it takes for a noise to reach both ears, for example, if a noise originates from one particular side of the head, the noise will take longer to reach the opposite ear. This determines what direction sound is coming from. IID refers to the intensity of the auditory stimuli that is being heard, and this will help determine what direction the sound is coming from, similar to ITD. These compare sound on both ears through the recognition of sound pressure and time difference (Denise Van Barneveld, Floor Binkhorst, A. John Van Opstal 2011).
Monaural cues are different to binaural cues as they only use one ear rather than both to localise sound.
This study was based on Muller and Bovet’s article Role of Pinnae and Head Movements in Localising Pure Tones (1999), which investigated the role of the pinnae and head movement in sound localisation, as well as sound frequency. In their study, they discovered that head movement as well as normal pinnae and low frequency tones resulted in improved sound localisation. The study that the psychology students underwent did not include frequency tones to make matters simpler and to truly understand the function of pinnae and head movements in the role of sound localisation.
To hypothesize, the accuracy of sound localisation will be greater when the pinnae is not distorted rather when the pinnae is distorted, and it is further hypothesized that the accuracy of sound localisation will be greater when the head is mobilised rather than immobilised.
There are two independent variables in this study, and they each have two stages. These stages are normal pinnae and head immobilization, normal pinnae and head mobilization, distorted pinnae and head immobilization and distorted pinnae and head mobilization. The dependent variable in this study is the correct sound localisation.
Method
The aim of this study was to discover what factors contribute to correct sound localisation in regards to pinnae and head movement.
Participants
There was a total of 186 participants involved in this study. These participants were university students and were located at three different ACU campuses across Australia, 24.2% of which from the Brisbane campus, 34.9% from the Melbourne campus and 39.8% from the Strathfield campus. Of these students, 34.9% were male and 65.1% female.
Materials Used
Materials used in this study involved four materials; a classroom chair for the participant to sit on, a set of keys that the students supplied themselves, a sheet of paper that indicated to the person shaking the keys above the participant’s head in what order to shake the keys, and a writing utensil.
Procedure
Participants merged off into randomly selected groups of three, one then sat on a chair and closed their eyes whilst another dangled a set of keys approximately one meter above their head, and the keys were skaken for two seconds at a time. The sitting participant indicated whether they heard the keys from above, in front or behind their head. The other student documented the answers and compared these answers to the correct location the keys were dangled from. Participants completed the task within 15 minutes.
Design
The experiment involved two independent variables, and the participant was instructed for the first part of the experiment to have normal pinnae and head immobilisation to locate the sound of the keys. They were then instructed to distort their pinnae by folding the top part of the ear down and leave the head immobilised. They then indicated where they located the sound of the keys. The next part of the experiment was to have normal pinnae, but now the participant had free head movement, and the process of locating the sound of the keys repeated. The last part of the experiment was to distort the pinnae and have free head movement while locating the sound of the keys.
Results
The mean number of correct sound localisations was calculated for each of the four conditions. These means are presented in Figure 1. As can be seen in the Figure 1, the mean number of correct sound localisations in the two normal pinnae conditions were significantly higher than the number recalled in the two distorted pinnae conditions (F(1,185)=430.05.55, p<.001). Although the difference was not as large, is can be seen in Figure 1 that the mean number correct sound localisations made in the two head movement conditions were significantly greater than those of the two no head movement conditions (F(1,185)=40.61, p<.001).
Figure 1. The mean number of correct sound localisations under the normal and distorted pinnae, and the head movement and no head movement conditions.
Discussion
The purpose of this experiment was to understand sound localisation and it’s connection to the pinnae and head movement, and through the experimentation of independent variables it was discovered that the results matched up with the hypothesis, as sound localisation was at it’s greatest when the pinnae was normal rather than distorted and the head was mobile rather than immobile.
These findings were predicted because the pinnae is structured in a specific way to detect and localise sound to the best of a human’s ability and head movement is a natural reflex when a sound is detected. Using both of these simultaneously help to localise sound to the participant’s greatest ability.
According to the results, head immobilisation does not effect sound localisation dramatically, but distorted pinnae makes a significant impact on sound localisation, making it much poorer.
The limitations of this study included the fact that participants supplied their own keys, meaning each group’s keys would have a different sound. Some keys could have made a louder or quieter noise than others or a noise of a higher or lower frequency. Another thing that could have affected the results is that the length the keys were held to the participant’s were approximate, as were the amount of time the keys were shaken for.
In future research, all participants should use the same set of keys as well as having exact measurements metres and time.
Conclusion
In conclusion, this study revealed that the pinnae and head movement affects sound localisation, and distorting the pinnae and having an immobilised head results in poorer quality of sound localisation, therefore having normal pinnae and mobile head movement results in more accurate sound localisation.
References
Muller, B. S., & Bovet, P. (1999 September) Role of pinnae and head movements in localizing pure tones. 58 (3), 170-179
Denise Van Barneveld, Floor Binkhorst, A. John Van Opstal (2011 Spetember) Absence of compensation for vestibular-evoked passive head rotations in human sound localization. 34 (7), 1149-1160
Marc. M. Van. Wanrooij, A. John Van Opsal (2006) Sound Localization Under Perturbed Binaural Hearing. 97 (1), 715-726
Martijn J. H. Agterberg, Myrthe K. S. Hol, Ad F. M. Anik, Marc Van Wanrooij, A. John Van Opstal (2012) Contribution of monaural and binaural cues to sound localisation in listeners with acquired unilateral conductive hearing loss: improved directional hearing with a bone-conduction device. 286 (1-2) 9-18
References: Muller, B. S., & Bovet, P. (1999 September) Role of pinnae and head movements in localizing pure tones. 58 (3), 170-179 Denise Van Barneveld, Floor Binkhorst, A. John Van Opstal (2011 Spetember) Absence of compensation for vestibular-evoked passive head rotations in human sound localization. 34 (7), 1149-1160 Marc. M. Van. Wanrooij, A. John Van Opsal (2006) Sound Localization Under Perturbed Binaural Hearing. 97 (1), 715-726 Martijn J. H. Agterberg, Myrthe K. S. Hol, Ad F. M. Anik, Marc Van Wanrooij, A. John Van Opstal (2012) Contribution of monaural and binaural cues to sound localisation in listeners with acquired unilateral conductive hearing loss: improved directional hearing with a bone-conduction device. 286 (1-2) 9-18
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
The Acoustic Reflex Threshold (ART) were tested at 500 Hz, 1000Hz, and 2000Hz. There was no indication of inner ear problems at these frequencies.…
- 577 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
No, the sound is less easily located if the source is equidistant from both ears. Sound arriving from spots equidistant from both ears arrives at each ear at the same time and with equal loudness. This does not provide enough information to adequately locate the position of the source.…
- 1351 Words
- 6 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
There historically have been two competing theories of hearing: place theory and temporal theory. Pitch is a perceptual attribute and is related to the frequency of the sound. Place theory states that sensation of a low frequency pitch derives solely from the motion of a particular group of hair cells, while the sensation of a high pitch derives from the motion of a different group of hair cells. Each sensation is identified with the action of an anatomical location along the basilar membrane. One problem with place theory is that it cannot fully account for our ability to discriminate between two tones of similar frequency.…
- 208 Words
- 1 Page
Satisfactory Essays -
There are three factors that contribute to sound localization, sound shadow, time of arrival and phase difference. The sound shadow are created by high frequencies. Time of arrival is the difference that the sound arrives at each ear and phase difference between the ears that provides the localization of lower frequencies. (University of Phoenix, 2012).…
- 974 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Sound waves enters through your ear and travels through a narrow passage called ear canal, which then leads to your ear drums. Then the ear drums vibrate from the incoming sound waves and sends these sound vibrations to your three tiny bones called malleus, incus, and stapes. When the sound vibration hits the fluid movement in the cochlea of the inner ear. An elastic partition goes through the cochlea, which starts from the beginning of the cochlea to the end. After this, it goes into two different directions, upper part and lower part. The partition is called basilar membrane. Following that, the vibrations causes the fluid to ripple a travelling wave which forms along…
- 756 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Auditory Learners and their piece to the puzzle on one style of learning. It’s about going hands on. Remembering a picture in your head or possibly reading aloud because you feel like you are going to learn faster then reading silently. Will this type of learning style help an online college student? It would seem that an auditory learner would have to change or alter their learning style based upon this method of delivery.…
- 562 Words
- 3 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
3. What relevance does auditory deprivation have with regard to hearing aid fitting and use?…
- 1123 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
The human ear is divided into three parts: the outer ear that contains the ear canal, the middle ear comprised of the ear drum and the small auditory bones, and the inner ear containing the cochlear and associated nerves. Sound is perceived in the brain through a mechanism that transforms auditory information encoded in the vibrations of the eardrum to electronic pulses that becomes transmitted through the auditory nerves in the brain. The cells that stimulate the nerve fibers and transduce the vibrational signal to electrical signal are the hair cells in the cochlea. A cochlear implant is designed to act in place of these cells (Christiansen and Leigh 363). It is inserted into the patient’s cochlea and contains a processor that takes the…
- 1646 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Imagine a place where sight no longer matters; a place where every thought, every feeling, and every emotion depends entirely on the sounds coming from the speakers of a headphone. I sat apprehensively on the cushioned chair in my quiet living room, headphones sat snug upon my head as I experienced this world for the first time. The laptop before me betrayed nothing, remaining blank as the sound of a brush danced across my ears, the rhythmic sound strangely relaxing to the point I didn’t notice when the sounds stopped. A hand appeared on my shoulder to shake me from my trance, and I turned to look at the young woman standing behind me. Ms. Kristina Burnham was a little on the short side with a little weight to her curves. Curly brown locks framed her round face and were a stark contrast to her pale complexion. Dressed casually in a yellow shirt and jeans, she looked like a person who enjoyed reading, but not someone I expected to make audios for other to listen to. As I slide the device off my head, she began to explain what I had just experienced: The Autonomous Sensory Meridian Response, otherwise better known as “ASMR”.…
- 979 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Psychology 101 Review Outline Chapter 1: Introduction I. Basic Definitions (pg 3-5): A. Psychology - The scientific study of behavior and mental processes B. Theory - A general principle proposed to explain facts are related C. Hypothesis - A testable prediction about conditions under which particular behaviors or mental processes work D. Replication - Repetition of a study to verify research findings E. Goals of Psychology - To describe, explain, predict, and influence behavior/mental processes F. Basic (new knowledge) vs. applied (practical problems) research II. History and Types of Psychology (pg 6-13): A. Wilhelm Wundt: father of psychology, established 1st psychological lab in Leipzig in 1879, developed…
- 3805 Words
- 16 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
An audiogram is used to determine type, degree, and configuration of a hearing loss. Early signs of otosclerosis show hearing loss in low-frequency tones. As the disease progresses, an audiogram reveals loss in both high and low frequencies, showing a flat configuration. Bone conduction loss at 2,000 Hz is known as the Carhart notch. This has been considered an indicator of otosclerosis; however, recent research has found the Carhart notch cannot be used to confirm diagnosis in all patients (Batson & Rizzolo, 2017).…
- 609 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
I had no idea, for example, that they were as limited as they are. This article has also brought me to introspect about how my own views of what it is to be deaf have changed since I have become more familiar with the community that surrounds it. I feel it is the default opinion, for a hearing person who is uneducated in deaf culture, to use the medical perspective. Previous to becoming acquainted with the culture I would have assumed that any deaf person would desire the ability to hear on any level available. It is clear that this is simply not the case, and for good reason. Just as I do not with to be deaf and be forced to give up major parts of my culture, primarily music, I would not expect the inverse of a member of the deaf community. I feel that this article does a good job of distinguishing the difference between a disability and a difference. Being outside of the mainstream does not make someone less capable or accomplished as a person. Primarily I feel that this article is important, however, for the understanding it brings by helping the reader to truly understand both sides of what a cochlear implant does and by underlining that in the respect of assimilation to the deaf community and the ability to communicate through sign these implants could be seen as…
- 780 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Hearing is such a vital factor of one’s life, where without it, communication and understanding of the world around us can become very difficult. As humans, we are able to hear from within the womb before we are even born into the world. To then loose this ability at any age in life, could be very troubling to an individual. An audiologist’s responsibility is to assess and treat all types of patients who may have a hearing loss or even a balancing issue. Speech-language pathologists will also work along side with audiologists when necessary to ensure the best treatment possible.…
- 1038 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
(Miller, Carlson, & McCauley 2013) experimented on the effects auditory rhythms could have on the allocation of visual attention. The human body follows an internal clock or a circadian rhythm unconsciously and Miller, Carlson and McCauley (2013) tested if the internal clock could be entrained or synchronized with an asynchronous (single repetitive) tone while responding to stimuli on a computer screen. The first of three experiments examined how auditory entrainment or auditory synching affected visual attention (Miller et al., 2013). As tones were being played, participants made a saccade, or a quick eye movement, from a central fixation point to a test dot that would appear on a computer screen at end of an auditory rhythm sequence of…
- 1065 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
The dichotic listening test method of cerebral lateralization allows the use of healthy individuals (Pinel, 2009). During the dichotic listening test, “three pairs of spoken digits are presented through earphones: the digits of each par are presented simultaneously, one to each ear” (Pinel, 2009, p. 402-403). For example, the person taking the test may hear six, nine, four in one ear and at the same time hear the numbers three, five, two in the other ear (Pinel, 2009). Te dichotic listening test show most individuals show left-hemisphere dominance for hearing because the right ear registers slightly more (Pinel, 2009).…
- 515 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays