The Disconnect in the Connected Era

Good Essays
NFlow

The Disconnect in the Connected Era David Goldberg, in his article “If Technology is Making Us Stupid, It’s Not Technology’s Fault” posits that the blame in the deterioration of human intelligence lies not with computers, but with the fashion of their use: “… it is not the technology, but the social conditions of their use that are the most compelling concerns here” (91). We as a society have been thrust into an age wherein there is a gadget for everyone and everything. The responsibility to bend these tools to our will or let them hinder our development is paramount to the success of generations to come and is inherently left to the individual. To place the blame on the technology itself is pure folly. Would one question the tool of a carpenter, or the carpenter’s wielding of it in the crafting of a piece? Goldberg goes so far as to imply that the user may share the blame with his environment when he cites Duke Researchers Vigdor and Ladd: “One interpretation of these findings is that home computer technology is put to more productive use in households with more effective parental monitoring, or in househoulds where parents can serve as more effective instructors in the productive use of online resources” (91). Peer into the average living room and you will see children staring into the screen of an iPad rather than a book. More often than not the content being consumed is limited to “Angry Birds” or whatever game du jour the media is bombarding our youth with. Parents must reassume responsibility for encouraging their children to apply themselves to something of consequence. The notion that technology should be used not just as a medium of entertainment but as a learning aid must be ingrained in children from the earliest possible stages of development. Furthermore, Goldberg brings to attention the fact that amidst the rampant filth available on the Internet, there is much of consequence to be found – one must simply search it out. He quotes

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    rhetoric essay

    • 898 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In his article “If Technology Is Making Us Stupid, It’s Not Technology’s Fault,” David Theo Goldberg effectively informs the reader about the effects that computers in the home and school environment could have on the future education of the coming generations. Goldberg achieves this by executing defined organization and adding unique comparisons about the potentially crippling effects technology can have on a society when put into the wrong hands.…

    • 898 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    From crimes to the amount of knowledge that one obtains, when pointing fingers there must be logic and factual evidence to support a statement. Bauerlin was not the first to point fingers at technology for younger generation shortcomings. Referring back to Begley’s article she says, “But there is no empirical evidence that being immersed in instant messaging, texting, iPods, videogames and all things online impairs thinking ability.” More clearly stating that all the connections to technology have no proof that technology has impaired the thinking ability of this generation. On the contrary, older people believe that when you write and read from books intelligence and knowledge will be more efficient. Regardless of their beliefs, there will be no argument on the topic until evidence is brought to the table. Evidence is one of the most important aspects needed when giving blame to a specific cause. Outside of the stats, there is research that shows the positive side to the use of technology which is that it improves our thinking…

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Roz Chast Argument Essay

    • 441 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Mark Bauerlein notices “intellectual habits … slipping … each year” due to technological distractions (Source A). But thanks to the digital revolution, it’s now easier than ever to gather information, which has caused a lack of enthusiasm for intense research on a topic and gathering more information. Although this may be true in most cases, one can easily pursue a subject- it’s just a matter of desire. Sharon Begley states an issue on what’s meant by the “dumbest” and how there is no “empirical evidence” that technology impairs one’s thinking ability (Source B). There is nothing that identifies what “dumb” specifies, nor is there anything that undoubtedly confirms technology as a hindrance to one’s mental development. It’s only by one’s own will to venture out for knowledge and whether it’s used in an effective way.…

    • 441 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Do not sit in front of the TV and stare, instead go read a book: a saying most children have heard from adults multiple times over the years. Goldberg in his blog post, “If technology is making us stupid, it’s not technology’s fault” describes how the introduction of technology into our daily lives, brings plenty of learning opportunities to the fingertips of many people that were otherwise unavailable. Goldberg’s purpose is to convey the idea that technology is not at fault for the decrease in intelligence. He equips himself with a matter-of-fact tone to appeal to his audience of parents and teachers that technology isn't causing the decline and that it is actually a useful tool for learning. Using the three persuasive appeals of logos, ethos…

    • 1124 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “What’s the Matter with Kids Today,” composed by Amy Goldwasser, is a strong argument against the assumption that Internet and other new found technology is worthless. Goldwasser begins her argument by giving you examples of the opposing view. For instance, within her first three paragraphs she gives many negative views against Internet use, one being a survey conducted by a research organization called Common Core. “A phone (land line!) survey of 1,200 17-year-olds… researched Feb. 26, found our young people are living in “stunning ignorance of history and literature.” (Goldwasser 666) This survey led to the acceptance speech of Doris Lessing, a British novelist and playwright, for winning a Nobel Prize in literature, where she referred too many as “a fragmenting culture,” and states that, “young men and women… have read nothing, knowing only some specialty or other, for instance, computers.” (Goldwasser 666)…

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Could you imagine living in a world where technology leads our lives? Jamais Cascio in his article “Get Smart” believes that technology is improving and enhancing our everyday lives. He argues that technology will create a natural phenomenon. However in the article “Is Google making us stupid?” Nicholas Carr argues that our reliance on technology is altering our ability to read, think, and fully be human. Along with my own experiences I agree with Cascio on his findings that the Internet has allowed everyday humans to be submerged into a whole new world.…

    • 1169 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Nicholas Carr

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The internet is changing us.Absolutely. It is changing us to become quicker, more impulsive, more distracted people who probably aren’t very skilled at deep reading. And to most first generation people, such as Carr, this seems to be a huge apocalypse that is going to destroy all of humanity. Whereas, it isnt. Not at all. This is a change, perhaps an evolutionary one. But like most changesthat occured, the wide usage of the internet is bound to bring a new, exciting era of technology. Perhaps even, artificial intelligence. This is my first argument.My second is against Carr’s liberal usage of the term ‘ stupid ‘. Through his essay, he fails to explain the relevance of this term, so it seems as if it is carelessely thrown around. Knowledge is subjective. It depends on the era one lives in, where one lives, their field of expertise and so many more. Thus, people need to look at it as and evolution of ‘ knowledge ‘ as a whole and expiring from the traditional sense of knowledge which required an ability to read deeply and analyse lengthy…

    • 1162 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Dumbest Generation

    • 955 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In today’s society, our century’s technology isn’t being taken to its advantage the way past generations would have used it for. According to “The dumbest Generation” Mark Bauerlin says “Young Americans have much more access and education than their parents did” (Source A). When our parents were our age, the use of internet or technology something they could rely on. They had to learn at school the hard way. To do research, they probably had to go through books to get their background knowledge. To do a math problem, it had to be done all on paper without the use of a calculator. To simply look up how do to a certain task, YouTube or the internet wouldn’t be available to them. Now, a child has these opportunities to their advantages, but are they being used for education purposes? No because chances are they’re busy on the…

    • 955 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The new generation of kids are being affected by technology enormously throughout the growth of technology. Ruth states in her article that a study done by the Kaiser Family Foundation found that children from the age of eight to eighteen are spending more than seven and a half hours a day on technology (Ruth 1). Which affects the children because it cause them to do less physical activity. She also states “The danger with our technology-obsessed kids, Greenfield warns, is that they are no longer accustomed to the full range of mess and meaningful human interaction” (Ruth 2). Kids no longer know how to interact with one another, because they are stuck on technology. Ruth mention in her article how social technology is molding children's brain…

    • 148 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Another setback about using too much technology is that it’s driving children away from going outside and playing with friends. Some children’s only contact with nature is through Discovery Channel or Nation Geographic Channel. You will barely ever see kids playing at the local park anymore. Not only has too much technology lead to driving kids away from nature, but also childhood obesity, laziness, and addiction to games and internet because of it. Parents need to take action and take their kids outside instead of letting them sit in front of a TV all day long (Mehta). Taking action is a must in order for kids to get away from the technological world.…

    • 494 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Big Disconnect Summary

    • 1272 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Steiner-Adair, C. (2014). The Big Disconnect: Protecting Childhood and Family Relationships in the Digital Age. Reprint. HarperCollins.…

    • 1272 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The use of technology has skyrocketed over the past few years, with a whopping ninetyfive percent of people utilizing the internet, constantly checking smartphones, and relying on other forms of media for entertainment, socializing, or work related instances. Compared with the digital satellites, MP3 players, and Palm Pilots of the 1990s, the technology today has truly advanced, causing many people to become dependent on media-related devices. More than fifty percent of today’s youth contribute to this dependency. What is not taken seriously enough is that this eagerness for technology is destroying the minds of young children by distracting them from important family values, causing various bullying issues, exposing them to violence, and inducing many health risks. Technology therefore should cease to exist in the lives of children, who should instead learn important life lessons from playing outside, utilizing talents, or spending time with the family. It is very important for a child to spend quality time with his or her family. Parents, grandparents, siblings, or extended family members help children develop positive self-esteem by communicating values, encouragement, and love. Today, children’s sense of those relationships is altered due to the fact that they are becoming less and less interested in family and instead more and more intrigued with media. The average kid ages eight to eighteen spends over seven and a half hours a day using technology, equaling seventy-five hours a week (Negative Effects Of). With all of that attention going to technology, children develop a loss of family interest. A group of four to six year olds said they would rather watch television than spend quality time with their fathers (Negative Effects Of). Story time with mother is rapidly being replaced with an old episode of Spongebob, thus creating disconnected children that do not find the value they should within their families. Every second a child is watching television or…

    • 1062 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In a world filled with interactivity and interconnectedness, how is it possible to be so disconnected from the people who live the closest you? Peter Lovenheim’s article, “Won’t you be my Neighbor,” discusses this very ideal. After a terrible murder-suicide occurred in Lovenheim’s neighbor he was forced to asked him-self do I really know who lives next me? Lovenheim realized he didn’t and decided to something about it. He decided he was going to sleepover neighbor’s homes in order to get to know them better. What Lovenheim should have taken into account is that, not everyone cares to “connect,” with his or her neighbors; others may simply just not have the time. And finally with the technology today, our “neighborhood” has grown to be more then the surrounding blocks near our home.…

    • 564 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    The 21st century is a remarkable time where everything is changing from tradition to technology. This has a profound effect on our youth and will have a greater effect on future generations. These times will shape the future generations for either a technology-reliant generation or shape and mold the future of tradition. The effect of young people having technology is overly apparent to teachers and their parents. Their kids get bored with things they loved to do as kids. The difference is they have television and many other technologies growing up that have shaped their minds into being entertained. If they are not they will ignore, throw fits or simply not learn from the experience. Neil Postman warns in his book Amusing Ourselves to Death that education presented as entertainment undermines tradition. Traditions like learning from your teacher instead of an online application. Traditions like learning from the outside world around you by exploring it instead of digitally exploring the internet. Today teachers are attempting to turn technology into learning devices but much like Postman’s “rear-view mirror thinking”, the iPad and related devices are used for entertainment. The impact technologies like the iPad and iPod and introducing video games for “educational benefit” are not helping them socially, emotionally or educationally as much as harming them.…

    • 1536 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    There is an increasing psychological dependence on technology, leading people to be hooked on it earlier in life. Being exposed to technology at an early age allows children become conditioned to a technological dependent environment. This creates a permanent presence on those who are generously participating in the new technological age. Even children in Brave New World were conditioned to accept their roles in life since “birth”. In a study conducted by the University of Michigan Health System, it was found that “children ages 2 through 5 spend 32 hours a week in front of a television and/or playing video games.” (Boyse) The most critical learning ages in a person’s life are ages 1 through 5 so, what are we exposing future generations to? Parents should be limiting the amount of time their children spend with electronics. The American family, also functioning as a support system, is deteriorating as well. Recall that a family unit ceased to exist in the society of Brave New World and that words such as “mother” were taboo. People would rather spend time watching television, or playing video games than having a conversation with the people they live with. The University of Michigan also discovered that more time spent in front of the television means less time with family (Boyse). For a family relationship to function properly there must be communication. The…

    • 2621 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Good Essays