The Chrysanthemums by John Steinbeck and Shiloh by Bobbie Ann Mason have many similar components with slight differences. The point of view in Shiloh is told by third person limited, and in Chrysanthemums it is also third person (mostly Elisa’s view.) The Chrysanthemums is a story about a wife named Elisa Allen who is unhappy with her life and marriage. Similarly, in Shiloh the main character's name is Norma Jean Motif, and she is also unhappy with her marriage. These stories struck me as interesting because of the unique time period they are set in. Chrysanthemums was published in 1938, and Shiloh was published in 1982. Both characters show signs of wanting to become independent and gain more freedom. Also they both have masculine characteristics because of the motivation to independent. The comparison of gender roles, point of view, and setting are big factors of why these stories work together to be so similar with slight differences.…
In John Steinbeck’s story “The Chrysanthemums” the main character Elisa is in the garden wearing men’s clothing; her appearance made her seem strong. "Her face was lean and strong and her eyes were as clear as water"(Steinbeck 226). Elisa has a strong self-confident attitude in the beginning of the story before meeting the pot fixer, and by the end of the story she lacks confidence and feels like she is losing control.…
(4)Xiomara Santamarina Feminist Studies 28, no. 3 (fall 2002) In Search of Our (5)Mother’s Garden: Womanist Prose, Alice Walker…
The short stories, “The story of an hour" written by Kate Choplin and "The Chrysanthemums" by John Steinbeck have similar theme because the main character goes through similar struggle. Both character illustrates the struggle that they had to go through in the past. They did not have any rights like that the modern woman in today's era have. They both live with the inequalities. However, they both have different experience as well as ending is different. Other difference that both stories have is sex of the authors, as well as the time were written in.…
After searching for a window into her soul, he spotted the chrysanthemums. ”What’s them plants, ma’am?” Elisa was as vulnerable as her chrysanthemums and the exasperation from the man’s annoyance quickly melted away from her handsome face. He had unlocked the door to her soul and it gave up her secrets. She was proud of her chrysanthemums and knew that she grew the largest and prettiest chrysanthemums for miles around, last year they had ten-inch…
In this short story, Elisa found her true freedom. She removed the gloves that were holding her back and jumped straight into the freedom that the chrysanthemums gave her. Not only did she realize the power that the chrysanthemums gave her, but she also realized the influence that they could have on other people. By the conclusion of the story, Elisa was solidly rooted in her…
delivers to the audience her thoughts and underlying emotions of being a woman in a “man’s world.” The chrysanthemums reflects Elisa’s character and her dreams of being free to grow, make decisions, free to travel, make her own money and most of all the desire to be attractive. Elisa feels closed in and secluded from the rest of the world, just as Steinbeck describes the atmosphere at the introduction of the story, “The high grey-flannel fog of winter closed off the Salinas Valley from the sky and from all the rest of the world” (192).…
The Chrysanthemums that Elisa Allen grows represents how her and many other women were treated during this time. Currently, the Chrysanthemums are bare and dormant with no flowers. This is similar to Elisa's life because her life is bare dormant with no excitement. Furthermore, the Chrysanthemums also show the theme by how they are grown in the valley. The narrator proclaims “There was a little square sandy bed kept for rooting the Chrysanthemums(271)”. The chrysanthemums are grown in a limited space which does not allow them to grow to their fullest potential. This resembles how Elisa and many other women are being trapped by men. Women are limited to a small space and cannot perform at their…
John Steinbeck's "The Chrysanthemums" features a strong capable and unsatisfied woman, Elisa Allen, whose talent cannot be recognized in the male-dominated society.…
The 1930’s was a period of empowerment for women. The Great Depression gave women a taste of what life would be like as strong, independent people. However, when the Great Depression came to an end life returned to the way things were. In American author John Steinbeck’s short story “The Chrysanthemums” (1938), he explores the life of a woman desperate for independence from a world run by men. Steinbeck uses symbolism to illustrate a woman’s search for fulfilment in a male dominated society.…
The speaker begins by introducing the water lily as a stage for the activity that goes on around it. He describes “a green level of lily leaves” that “reefs the petal’s chamber and paves the flies’ furious arena,”--a cover for the activity below and the ground for the action above. The picture establishes the speaker’s view of nature as a complex body with layers that reach beyond its seemingly inactive surface. The language used by the speaker to describe the lily leaves, marked by alliteration and subtle imagery, also demonstrates the speaker’s appreciation of the beauty of nature’s “outer surface,” the face it shows most plainly to the casual observer. The speaker also personifies nature by describing it as a “lady” with “two minds,” clearly those that exist above and below its surface. Study these, the speaker notes to himself, and only then can one develop an accurate understanding of the heart of nature.…
www.ecofem.org/journal for patterns of domination. I aim to show that underlying these conceptions of woman and nature there are dualistic constructions that have proved…
This short story, 'The Geranium', by Patricia Grace and published 1993, is a perfect example of Battered woman syndrome and the mental effects it has on a person in this case Marney.…
I am Sandra a dear friend of Marney’s and I am writing this letter to you because I want to complain about the fact that no family member stepped in to support my friend Marney during her time of need. I recently found out that my friend Marney has been abused by her husband. I have realized that this has been happening after watching a TV programme dealing with the subject of abused wives and what they do to hide their abused lives. I suddenly understand why Marney always wears a cardigan when I visit her, which the TV programme gave an example about hiding their bruised body’s with their clothes or belongings.…
In the first paragraph, Marney is described to us as a typical house wife who cleans intensely all day long. “She did the dishes, washed the tea-towels, wiped down the table, and took the ashpan out…” It is shown that this is a routine of non-stop cleaning for Marney everyday. Her life seems rather dull and boring except for when her friends, “Sandra and Joey and their kids might call in”. Yet still Marney couldn’t enjoy all the fun with the ladies, she wouldn’t even “come for a stretch” with them. From her hesitation and excuses “I’m busy… I might do a bit more… out the back…” we can feel that there’s something preventing Marney from socializing.…