The purpose of Paulo Freire 's essay "The Banking ' Concept of Education" is to analyze the current educational approach taken by many institutions and to provide an alternative to this approach. The essay is really criticizing the "banking" concept of education. The "banking" concept of education is the notion that the teacher is the narrator, while the student is the "container" or "receptacle" that is to be filled by the knowledge of the teacher. When the teacher is the narrator it forces the student to memorize the content that the teachers teaches. Freire believes that "Education thus becomes an act of depositing, in which the students are the depositories and the teacher is the depositor (257)." Knowledge is then considered a gift from the teacher to the student, who is assumed to know nothing. Freire 's solution to the "banking" concept of education is what he calls "problem-posing" education. "Problem-posing" education forces the student to participate with the teacher and become "critical co-investigators in dialogue with the teachers (263)." "Banking" education often resists dialogue and "problem-posing" education engages dialogue and regards it as essential to its framework. The "problem-posing" teacher is then forced to create lessons that involve the students, rather than only being in charge of the students. Freire believes that "banking" education inhibits creative power and "problem-posing" education allows creativity and promotes the thought process. He also believes that "banking education treats students as objects of assistance; problem-posing education makes them critical thinkers (265)." According to the reading, problem-posing education seems like a much more suited choice for educational institutions. Freire believes that that banking theory is not based on reality and is a fixating force. While the problem-posing theory according the Freire " . bases itself on creativity and stimulates true reflection and action upon reality; thereby responding to the vocation of persons as beings who are authentic only when engaged in inquiry and creative transformation (265)." Freire is stating that the people who are taught via the banking theory are un-human and lifeless because they are non-responsive in the teaching lessons, they are merely absorbing the information like a sponge. He also believes that if the student isn 't taught using the problem-posing method; which engages inquiry and creative transformations; then it is not an authentic representation of the student 's ability.
This essay to me seemed a little too harsh on the matter. There are subjects that are best taught via the "banking" method. I personally have taken courses that were best taught this way. For example, I just finished Cell Biology, the material for this course was so complex that unless you knew the information before hand then there was no way to really engage conversation and thought. The teacher did however allow for questions and discussions the class period following the lecture. I believe that its safe to say that my teacher took a hybridized approach that contained both the "banking" concepts and the "problem-posing" concept. I think this is acceptable, but Freire is too extreme and never makes mention of a hybridized approach. I also believe that the teaching style should also reflect the learning style of the student. There are some students that learn better from dictation, and thee are some that learn better from interaction. Works Cited
Freire, Paulo. "The Banking ' Concept of Education." Ways of Reading.
Ed. David Bartholomae and Anthony Petrosky. Boston: Bedfore, 2005. 256-269.
Cited: Freire, Paulo. "The ‘Banking ' Concept of Education." Ways of Reading. Ed. David Bartholomae and Anthony Petrosky. Boston: Bedfore, 2005. 256-269.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
He states: “instead of communicating, the teacher issues communiques and makes deposits which the students patiently receive, memorize, and repeat,” a statement that marks his first steps of hypocrisy (318). He is telling the reader that teachers in the banking concept just list what they want the students to know and understand, and the students passively receive the information. Freire, however, utilizes the banking concept with page 319 with his list of the aspects of the banking concept. Within the first two pages, he has manipulated many readers into thinking that he hates this style of education, but in order to portray the banking concept as bad, he uses it. On page 326, he uses a colon in the last paragraph, which signifies he is about to list something. By using a list, he is teaching the reader about this concept while using the same concept with which he disagrees so vehemently. He is telling the reader that this way of educating is an illness that needs healing within the education system while he uses it to manipulate, or “bank”, the…
- 1197 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
A key element that Rodriguez and Freire both speak of is banking education. Freire feels that this type of education is almost useless. Banking is no more than just listening to someone speak at you and then regurgitating the information. Both speak about education in the context of the student-teacher relationship. The banking theory of education only allows for the teacher to rule over the classroom and allows for little interaction with students. Banking turns students into "receptacle" (pg 260) bins that are crammed with information that the teacher chooses to fill…
- 853 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Freire's article the "Banking Concept of Education" depicts how education influences human beings as well as restrain peoples’ free thinking and creativity. Essentially it is an act that hinders the intellectual growth of students by turning them into. Figuratively speaking, comatose “receptors" and “collectors” of information. On a deeper level, Freire is actually talking about three kinds of relationships: between students and teacher, and between individuals and society, between self and world. Governors or dominator use this mode of education to control people’s ideology and maintain people in a certain social position. Different from this education system. Freire indicates that the "Problem-Posing" education system will develop peoples’ critical thinking. "Problem-Posing" education is a revolution and innovation education mode. It gives people authentic awareness towards themselves and the world. Freire's ideas have shaped the modern concept of and approach to education. I am going to combine my partner Wang's educational experience story with Freire points.…
- 1278 Words
- 6 Pages
Good Essays -
His idea that the students are an "empty vessel" is at the core of the banking concept where the curriculum does not take into consideration the needs of the students as libertarians, the means by which men and women deal with reality in either a critical or creative way. He makes this point because in education today the information is chosen by the educator as the "depositor" and "deposited" into the student; "the scope of action allowed the student extends only as far as receiving, filing and storing; which the students patiently receive, memorize and repeat" (319). The more a teacher does this to his students the more reality is taken away from them to learn the true meanings of life. This can be related back to Freire 's argument against the education system, because one can only memorize things for so long, after that one will lose his true purpose in the world. To go against the system of education Freire has established new methods to turn the idea of education aroundThe method of education that Freire asserts as an alternative to the banking concept is to encourage students to question and pursue the world. He calls this his "problem-posing" method on education (325). This change in focus is facilitated by a shift in the student-teacher relationship; the student learns from the teacher, and the teacher learns from the students. This is a relationship where all…
- 1260 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
Education has long been a concern among society. Studies show that different minds grasp knowledge differently; thus new techniques are always invented, while old ones are modified. In Pablo Freire's essay, "The Banking' Concept of Education," Freire simply attacks the traditional teaching style, claiming "it turns them [students] into containers,' into receptacles' to be filled' by the teacher" (Freire 213) and thus should not be used. He goes on to pose his own solution, a concept called problem-posing method. Yet it seems that these two styles must be synthesized if the learning experience is to be successful. A student cannot be expected to learn anything without the foundation gained by traditional learning, which Freire calls banking. So banking cannot be eliminated from the educational system, but should be used alongside the problem-posing method.…
- 1148 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
Have you ever thought about that time when you were empty? I mean knowledge wise. It can be referred back to the infant stage or even that time in history class when you had no idea what imperialism was or what it is about. Well according to Freire this is where “ The Banking Concept” takes place. As he mentions on page 477, the banking concept is basically saying that students are empty containters that will be filled with education by their teachers.…
- 985 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
“Banking Concept of Education” by Paulo Freire underlines the theme of miscommunication between students and the teacher. A lot of the passage is biased by the author, pointing fingers at both the student and teacher. The passage repetitively emphasizes that though teachers spout out important information, rather than learning the material, students purely memorize and then forget it instead. This fault is called the banking concept, which is contradictory to the point of education due to the give and take factor of students borrowing information but not utilizing it. Paulo Freire suggests the solution of problem-posing, meaning rather than seeing teachers as an authority who knows everything, the community should work together in striving for intellectualism.…
- 621 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Today’s education system has been reduced to teachers assume the position of holders of knowledge and who are supposed to then transfers said knowledge to students. Paul Friere (1993) in his article “the banking concept of education” has demonstrated this aspect…
- 1091 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Last week, I read an article called the banking concept of education which is written by Paulo Freire, a Brazilian author who contributed to the world greatly as an educator and influenced the field of education. What is banking concept? The banking concept is an example to describe a method that students are regarded as a container and to be filled with different kinds of information and knowledge by teachers. What the students can do is just accept the things that they learned and memorize it. Freire demonstrates that the students are regarded as a bank and teachers “deposit” the knowledge into them. The biggest problem of the banking concept of education is that the students will never think carefully and they will lose their creativity and imagination without their critical thinking. Students just acknowledged the world should be like and inhibited by too many restrictions of their study. Freire demonstrates that the banking concept of education supposes that all the students are innocent. However, learning form the teacher is the only method for the students. The problem between the educator and the students won’t disappear although there’s a new curriculum introduced. Freire thinks the most effective way to solve the problem is Problem-posing concept of education.…
- 1258 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
In The “Banking “Concept of Education Freire discusses the conventional way of teaching as a trap that creates an oppressive environment in education and cripples students in their knowledge and their ability to take action later in life. Freire discusses that the teacher and student relationship contributes heavily to this oppressive atmosphere in the classroom and encourages ignorance on behalf of the student. I challenge Friere’s thoughts of escaping from education as we know it today; and instead combine the traditional styles of the past and the new problem posing solution of the future together. Reflecting on my experiences in education and analyzing the text of Friere I have developed my own theory of education. Students need to believe they are the future and need to be prepared to act and fill the roles they are given in times of success and times of failure. A balanced education will prepare them for all the situations that they will be faced with in their future outside the classroom.…
- 3171 Words
- 13 Pages
Powerful Essays -
I agree with most of Freire’s points about the negative side to banking education, but I think that at certain times and in certain subjects it is necessary or more beneficial to learn or teach in that way. An example would be in math. In middle school, if I questioned the reality of certain principles and equations, I would not have learned as much about what was being taught as I did simply accepting the equations given to me as true, so that I could later understand how they worked and related to other concepts we learned. With that said, the banking system of education is not beneficial at all times. Some of the reason why I struggle in math is because I don’t understand the concepts of…
- 285 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Paulo Freire’s “problem-posing” teaching method is shown in “The Banking Concept of Education” through clear contradictions to the “banking method”. He makes several arguments against the banking method by attacking common teaching faux pas and explaining his method of problem-posing education, where the teacher-student relationship is of equal partnership. Freire also argues that the use of the banking method makes teachers more concerned with getting information out to the students than worrying if they understand it or not. Instead of “educating through the practice of freedom” (Freire 327), standardized tests like the Regents in New York and the MCAS in Massachusetts, “educates [students] as the practice of domination” (Freire, 327), limiting them to a strict, inanimate curriculum.…
- 1057 Words
- 5 Pages
Better Essays -
There is no relationship established in the banking concept method. I don’t like that method. I enjoy his solution to that method which was the “problem-posing” There is more communication from student to teacher. I find that an easier way to learn, and if you are struggling it is an easier way to get help. The weird thing is before I read these types of articles, I probably would of never have a complaint if a teacher was teaching me through a “banking concept” method. Correction, I probably wouldn’t have liked or enjoyed lecturing the whole time but I for sure wouldn’t of suggested another way of teaching. I enjoyed hearing about Friere’s argument and new method a lot because it makes after reading the article you are clearly convinced about which is the best method of…
- 928 Words
- 4 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Paulo Freire proposes two styles of teaching: the banking concept and problem-posing education. Through Freire’s lens, Richard Rodriguez would be seen as a banking student, but could later be seen as a problem-posing student throughout the course of his life. Both styles are still viewed today in teacher-student relationships.…
- 972 Words
- 4 Pages
Better Essays -
In The “Banking” Concept of Education Paulo Freire, takes a deeper look into the teacher – student relationship and how they interact inside of the classroom. In his essay, Freire introduces two different approaches to teaching, the “banking” concept and the “problem- posing” concept. Throughout the essay, in numerous examples that Freire gives show that he is a firm believer that the banking concept of education exists. As a student and going through any type of educational system , we have all been exposed to each type of teaching concept, and in some form it has shaped us to be who we are today.…
- 784 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays