Teamwork Self Reflection - Organizational Behaviour

Topics: Decision theory, Decision making, Decision making software Pages: 68 (8558 words) Published: November 19, 2014
Decision Aiding

A new method for group decision support based on ELECTRE

III methodology

Juan Carlos Leyva-L�oopez, Eduardo Fern�aandez-Gonz�aalez *

Facultad de Ingenier�ııa, Universidad Aut�oonoma de Sinaloa, Ciudad Universitaria, Calzada de Las Americas S/N, Culiac�aan, Sinaloa,

Mexico, CP 80040, Mexico

Received 9 November 1999; accepted 9 January 2002


Group decision is usually understood as the reduction of different individual preferences on a given set to a single

collective preference. At present, there are few approaches which solve the group ranking problem with multiple criteria

in a widely acceptable way. Often, they rest on a poor heuristic which makes a decision about consensus ranking

difficult to support. This paper presents an extension of the ELECTRE III multicriteria outranking methodology to

assist a group of decision makers with different value systems to achieve a consensus on a set of possible alternatives.

Our proposal starts with N individual rankings and N corresponding valued preference functions, and uses the natural

heuristic provided by ELECTRE methodology for obtaining a fuzzy binary relation representing the collective pre-

ference. A comparison of this method with PROMETHEE II for group decision is carried out. We found that, in this

particular application, the proposed heuristic based on majority rules combined with concessions to significant mi-

norities, performs relatively better than a compensatory scheme based on a net flow weighted sum function.

� 2002 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.

Keywords: Multicriteria analysis; Group decision; Outranking methods; ELECTRE III; Genetic algorithms

1. Introduction

People make a group decision (intra-organiza-

tional or inter-organizational) when they face a

common problem and they are all interested in its

solution. This problem may be the purchase of a

car, the acquisition of a house by a family, the de-

sign of a new product or a production planning or

to find the best location for the wastewater treat-

ment plant in a city. An important characteristic

of group decision is that all involved individuals

belong to some organization (family, firm, gov-

ernment). They may differ in their perception of the

problem and have different interests, but they are

all responsible for the organization�s well-being and

share responsibility for the implemented decision.

When a decision situation involves multiple

actors, each with different values and informa-

tional systems, the final decision will generally be

the result of an interaction between this indivi-

dual�s preferences and those of others. This inter-

action is not free of conflict, which may be due to

*Corresponding author. Tel.: +52-667-7134281; fax: +52-


E-mail addresses: (J.C. Leyva-

L�oopez), (E. Fern�aandez-Gonz�aalez).

0377-2217/03/$ - see front matter � 2002 Elsevier Science B.V. All rights reserved.


European Journal of Operational Research 148 (2003) 14-27

any of a number of factors, e.g. different ethical or

ideological beliefs, different specific objectives, or

different roles within organization. Whatever the

origin of the conflicting value systems, they will

usually affect the evolution of the decision process

in ways that were not expected at the outset (Roy,

1996; Keeney, 1992).

Group decision is usually understood as the

reduction of different individual preferences on a

given set to a single collective preference (Jelassi

et al., 1990). We will not focus on the psycholo-

gical aspects of group interactions. The main goal

of this work is the prescription of a final group

ranking from these individual preferences...

Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Organizational Behaviour Self Reflection Essay
  • Essay on Teamwork Self Reflection
  • Organizational Behaviour Essay
  • organizational behaviour Essay
  • Essay on Teamwork Reflection and Assessment
  • Self Reflection Essay Organizational Behaviour
  • Cultural and Teamwork Map and Self Reflection Essay
  • Organizational Behaviour Essay

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free