Preview

Superordinate Themes

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
2565 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Superordinate Themes
Analysis
After analysing the entries four superordinate themes were found, each superordinate theme having collaborating subordinate themes to support it. Extracts from the transcripts are used to give evidence for chosen themes. Themes are shown in Table 1. These themes account for experiences of eating disorder recovery, however, only the most salient (shown in bold type) are discussed in depth.
Superordinate Themes Subordinate Themes
Self vs ED • Self-Acceptance
• Internal Battles
• Personification of ED
• Masculinity
The Journey of Recovery • Choosing Recovery
• Understanding the ED & Recovery
• Struggle
• Positivity
• Turning Point
The Next Step • Moving On
• Change in Perspective
• Mental Health Issues
• Rebuilding Self
Relationships
…show more content…
He has turned the negative experience of an ED into something he has accomplished, rather than something he let take over his life.
The Next Step
This superordinate theme is based on the stages the men went though as they began to recover. During and after recovery is a different period of life and this theme encompasses what changed as the men regained a life with less impact from the disorder.
Change in Perspective
The men began expressing how they had a different outlook on life post-recovery; whether this was a change in how they felt about themselves, or how they felt about their opportunities in life.
Justin (Line 19-21): ‘I gained body weight at a gradual rate over the year and my negative thoughts and pre-conceptions about food and my body started to disappear.’
Scott (Line 142-144): ‘I feel that I have become my [more] open to listening and understanding those around me. I feel that I am more caring, compassionate, empathetic than before I was anorexic.’
Justin describes that as he went through the motions of recovery his opinions about food and him-self changed. This suggests his self-esteem increased and he was able to think in a more realistic and logical
…show more content…
Many of them struggled to keep up with any hobbies they once had, or take an interest in anything they might enjoy. During and after recovery the men began to explore their interests with more enthusiasm, creating opportunities for themselves in the process.
Carl (Line 70-72): ‘I am now an actor, I do music videos and independent films and I am even a part time model. I am also a spokesperson for depression…’
Carl appears to take pride in what he has achieved now he has recovered. He has been able to follow through with his interests and create a career out of these interests. His recovery also opened up new paths for him in the form of being a spokesperson for depression. He uses the word ‘even’ when talking about modelling as if it feels like it is something he could have never seen himself doing before or during his disorder.
Ross (Line 79): ‘…I can begin work on other areas of my life.’
Now the disorder is behind him, Ross can move on and reach the point of understanding who he is and what he wants.
Relationships and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Now, I’m not saying that Lazy Carl is a bad guy, but he is a crutch. And not the good kind of “I just broke my ankle” crutch but the bad kind of “Oh no. I just watched six straight hours of The Office” kind of crutch. He’s like junk food for the…

    • 450 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In the memoir Diary of an Exercise Addict, the first minor theme that plays into the major theme of personal struggle is love. How love makes the main character Peach move further into her personal struggle is that when Peach begins to lose weight, she felt that love came to her easier. She also finds it easier to find love when she gains barely enough weight to look like she is okay and not ill. But, she stops gaining weight and tries to maintain the weight she is at but begins to lose it again. “All these men are looking at me. They are, they are all looking at me and I know it’s because I’ve gained enough weight that my face looks normal and my body looks skinny, which means I look like a supermodel and that’s why they’re looking,” (Diary of an Exercise Addict, page 72). So when she felt that men were easily attracted to her, she believed this is because she was losing/ gaining.…

    • 1260 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    It could be for people who are dealing with depression and how other people deal with it and it could be for people studying depression symptoms or the side effects of the medicine. What the author is trying to convey is that although you may be giving up something, you may be getting something better in return. The way she proves this point is how she takes the medicine for her depression which results in her gaining weight but it is all worth it to keep herself happy for her family. The essay is about lauren Slater who was prescribed a medicine called Zyprexa. Zyprexa helps Lauren Slater deal with her depression while at the same time it makes her gain weight for which she is taking the risk to stay happy. I know this because the text explains it clearly in the header when it asks, “would you gain 80 pounds to cure a crippling depression.” In which the response was that Lauren Slater did and she learned that her vanity was the least of it. The main thesis is “My body is having a breakdown, for sure, yet instead of atomizing into pieces and parts, I'm doing just the opposite, I'm acquiring a perverse sort of solidity that…

    • 1133 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Caselli and Worley both changed their weight and life in very different ways, however the steps they both took were similar. In Caselli’s past, he tried to lose his weight by doing various diets and weight loss programs to no avail; “He would diet and lose seventy-five pounds, then put a hundred back on . . . On one diet, he got down to a hundred and ninety, but he gained it all back” (Gawande para. 10); Caselli tried to diet and found dieting never truly helped with his weight. Worley tried the same approach to her weight which resulted in no benefit to her either; “After years and years of dieting it slowly dawned on me that my body rebelled when I tried to restrict my food intake” (Worley para. 11). Worley and Caselli both found out that dieting was a waste of time and money to a problem that was more than just controlling urges; “Have this happen to you enough times and you will be apprehensive at the prospect of losing weight for fear of gaining bad more than you lose . . . All those years I figured that it was me who was failing, and then I began to realize that it was the method that was failing” (Worley para. 10-11); Worley realized that her method was failing and to help herself, she would need to take a different approach.…

    • 435 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Jacob claims he has learned how to overcome his mental health issues, meditates, and would like to work in mental health. Jacob…

    • 580 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Nancy Mairs

    • 277 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The author grabs my attention, in a positive way, knowing we are all human, with some type of disease, by way of mental or physical no matter what the problem is, we could all fall into a depression state at any given time for any given reason. But if we continue to keep positive thoughts we could all relate to Mairs.…

    • 277 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sometimes while facing adversity, there is a point in an individual where their instincts reveal the truth, that what doesn’t kill them makes them stronger. A person’s true talents are shown when faced by adversity. Bethany Hamilton had been surfing since she was a child; at age thirteen she is was injured in an almost-deadly shark attack, losing her left arm. She was back on her surf board one month later and then won first place in the Explorer Women’s Division of the NSSA National Championships, two years later. Jim Carey is another example of this; he revealed that at the age of fifteen he had to drop out of high school and support his family. His father was unemployed, poor, and they eventually had to live in a van. Carey didn’t let that stop him from becoming a comedian and is now known as one of the best comedic actors of this…

    • 481 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Eating disorders explained - Live Well - NHS Choices. 2013. Eating disorders explained - Live Well - NHS Choices. [ONLINE] Available at: http://www.nhs.uk/livewell/eatingdisorders/pages/eating-disorders-explained.aspx. [Accessed 14 June 2013].…

    • 2821 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    I felt like I was wrestling with my emotions as I tried to read on, the repetitive mention of her rape became less and less the catalyst for the book but the main focus at some parts. It felt as if her rape was the only driving force for her, that if she had not been raped she would have not felt that way towards others. I found myself thinking, “did I accidentally reread the same part?”, as I read, Gay reasserting her claims by repeating them, over and over again. I no longer felt empowered, I felt the need to question if what I believed about my self-worth and my own body issues; did my weight loss make my personal triumph less valid and if so should I regain the weight that I had so desperately lost? Gay does not blatantly state that being body positive was bad, but that the movement as a whole was flawed in that they expressed love for all but only those who would fit in anything below a size 26 at Lane Bryant would actually receive. Gay’s message is a call to action to society, for society to step up and open a conversation on fatness, that no one deserves to feel the pain she was reminded of when she saw a young girl crying as her mother told her she was too fat in order to be pretty. Gay’s book comes with its flaws but has merit, Gay speaks about issues and situations in such graphic detail that it is impossible to ignore that the issues are…

    • 1118 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Ipa Analysis Essay Example

    • 5828 Words
    • 24 Pages

    One of the subordinate themes found in this investigation was “poor health” and it’s role in each vlogger’s accounts of their experiences. This theme was common to all participants in the study as they each shared the same idea that their depreciating health was one of the main and catalytic reasons for them having the surgery to lose weight.…

    • 5828 Words
    • 24 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Free Hugs Campaign

    • 1214 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Life is full of ups and downs It may take a life time for a person to actually “settled” down with contentment that he had acquired and live life to the fullest otherwise he will endeavour and persevere the many setbacks which life can be entangled with and one person who had gone thru’ many numerous personal difficulties was Mr Juan Mann, who felt very lonely and depressed at one stage of his life when his family and friends had moved out from his hometown and decided to campaign for the free hugs…

    • 1214 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    After many years of his hardships in conducting clinical research, May was able to postulate a new way of looking at human beings. With such newly evolved point of view, May saw people as living in the world of present experiences and ultimately being responsible for who they become.…

    • 2999 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    He reaches out to the younger generations in primary and secondary schools all over Australia as a guest speaker to build confidence in listeners. His services in schools successfully decrease suicide cases that frequently happen among the youth in Australia. He has become an international speaker, he has travelled to places like India to share his experience, and his subject was disability and hope. He believes that he could give disabled people hope. He fought for what he wanted taking the example of that he couldn’t attend to a normal school but with support and his energy he and his family changed the law of Australia. He was one of the first Australian disabled Australian people to attend to a normal school. How he can still carry on with his life putting aside the rejection and loneliness he went through influenced people that if he could carry on with his life so can they. He has even made his own organisation and he is now writing a book. His family supported him from the beginning to help him believe in himself. They have helped him and guided him to make him feel stronger. The one mistake people take is that Nick tried to commit suicide at a very young age, this might encourage people and make them lose hope, because he did once as well. I disagree with this because putting aside his struggles, rejection and loneliness and the fact he tried to commit suicide he is world wide and he inspires millions of people all around the world making touching videos and messages. He has become strong in faith and he is very successful. He is grateful for every little thing he has. Without purpose, life ceases to have meaning. And when we lose meaning, we lose hope. Nick Vujicic has found his purpose in life. He encourages people all around the world to never give up. It is a frame of mind that shapes a person’s future. His videos inspire thousands of people. He is still trying out new things in his life like surfing.…

    • 2638 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Life is a Climb

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages

    For example, in the novel “Gifted Hands: The Ben Carson Story”, while Ben Carson was growing up he faced many obstacles but he decided to push through them and overcome the obstacle. One of the obstacles happened when he was in elementary school, he was considered the “dumb” student in all his classes because he would always have low grades. One day, Sonya, Ben’s mother was examining him and noticed that her son couldn’t see from a couple feet away, that’s when she figured out he needed glasses. After he had his glasses he started reading books and he became interested in science. If Sonya wouldn’t have noticed that he needed glasses he would have been making low grades on all subjects, he would not be able to read, and a slight chance of him not being a neurosurgeon............nd and give up, figure out how to climb it, go through it or work around it.” –Michael Jordan. In life everyone has obstacles but it’s your choice to either give up or push through it. If you fall, get back up, and learn from it. Obstacles can be turned into something good, Ben Carson went through many obstacles but here he is now one of the best neurosurgeons in the world,hhhhhgjjffhj jjjj cvvwnv ovnwovnwo ovnwpvnwo cnwopvnwo mononownfown…

    • 486 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    self medication

    • 1492 Words
    • 7 Pages

    their escape from the dependency and aliention brought about by medicalization. It reflects, as Bezold remarks, "a new attitude toward health, including increased self-responsibility for health" [1].…

    • 1492 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays