Preview

Summary Of The Article 'What Are We Teaching Our Girls'

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1134 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Summary Of The Article 'What Are We Teaching Our Girls'
March 6, 2014
English 102
Annotated Bibliography
Annotated Bibliography
Cartwright, Martha. What Are We Teaching Our Girls? New York City: Sussex Publishers, 2011. Print. In the article, What Are We Teaching Our Girls, Martha Cartwright starts by describing the history of beauty pageants. She states that the first pageants were not only about judging contestants on their outward appearance. The pageants also judged contestants on how respectable they were as a person. She says that beauty pageant winners once were viewed as positive role models for younger girls. They were models to show young girls what a well-rounded woman should be like. These role models were used to show girls that being beautiful on the outside is not everything
…show more content…
She takes a neutral opinion about beauty pageants and sheds light on some positive effects surrounding beauty pageants as well as the negative on young girls. In the article, she writes about the different types of pageants. The first pageant discussed is one that involves contestants performing a talent and participating in an interview in order to win a prize aimed toward their education, such as a scholarship for college. The second type of pageant talked about is the pageant based only on the physical appearance of the contestant. These types of pageants often do not contain an education prize to the winner. She argues that the second type of pageant objectify young girls and make them believe that only outward beauty is important. She then opposes her statement by saying there is no reason that young girls should be ashamed of flaunting their physically beauty. I think this article has potential to be useful in my paper. It gives both a positive and negative view of beauty …show more content…
In the article, he provides information about the negative outlook on child beauty pageants. He states his belief that child beauty pageants exploit young girls who are entered in them. He states that many of the girls will have a distorted view of themselves, which can eventually progress into major issues such as bulimia or anorexia. He also states that many of the young girls enrolled in the pageants wear clothes that are too mature for their ages. He believes that by dressing up children in provocative outfits and having professional hair and makeup done this will attract pedophiles. After he announced his two main points, he ends the article by saying he believes that no one under the age of eighteen should be allowed to compete in these beauty pageants. This article will be very useful for my research paper because it correlates with the argument I am

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    The author does not come right out and say, “Pageants are bad.” He draws the reader in with his descriptions of the activities of the children and their parents along with the pageant promoters. He opens by illustrating the transition of a young 6-year-old. Plenty of 6-year-olds have played dress up over the years by putting on mommy’s lipstick or high heels,…

    • 445 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Beauty pageants hit the scene back in 1921 when the owner of an Atlantic City hotel struck upon the idea to help boost tourism. It wasn’t until the 1960’s Child Beauty Pageants was introduced. Children's beauty pageants are judged by modeling sportswear and evening wear, how well they dance, and how much talent they have. The children themselves are judged by their appearance, how well they perform, and how confident they appear (Nussbaum).…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Annotated Bibliography

    • 482 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Beauty pageants made their first appearances in America during the 1920’s, where women flaunted around casinos, determined to win a crown for their physical attractiveness. The owner of the casino where these activities occurred, figured that this would attract more tourists. Throughout the years, more modern pageants were formed, like Ms. USA and Ms. America. Following in the footsteps of its adult form, child beauty pageants merged into the 1960’s. Child beauty pageants usually consist of modeling sportswear, evening wear, and showing off any special talent they may have. Judges critique the girls individually, based on their physical looks, poise, confidence, and perfection. To the judges, this is called “the complete package.” Although the objective of most child pageants is to build confidence and self-worth, beauty pageants can be considered exploitive to minors by causing them to believe in unrealistic ideas about beauty.…

    • 482 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Positives in Pageants

    • 1807 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The debate about beauty pageants is as varied as the kind of beauty pageants which are in existence today. Pageants go anywhere from the traditional late teens, early twenties, type pageant; to children’s pageants; to pageants for the disabled; and pageants for everything in between. No matter what kind of pageant it is, beauty is always a factor in determining the pageant’s outcome. That does not necessarily mean exterior beauty though; some pageants focus on inner beauty and strength.…

    • 1807 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The idea of child pageants creates much conflict and discouragement to others whom do not have children. Young girls whom participate in this activity are portrayed as sex objects just as women are as models because they are subjected to looking older and much more sensual. However, in some cases having children in child pageants creates social skills along with comfortability performing in front of others. The idea of little girls being entered into child pageants is intimidating to most people due to the fact that children are not supposed to look like adults until they are old enough. Many people frown upon the whole concept of a child being exposed to older men and women having them wear makeup and flirtatious outfits. As older women are also involved in beauty pageants, they too go through extreme acts of body changes making it harder for parents to fathom. Restricting little girls from engaging in beauty pageants or contests protects them from dangerous people along with remaining pure with their self-worth, learning to live as a child and not a woman, and retaining a healthy emotional mind.…

    • 1117 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The saying “Never judge a book by its cover” simply means don’t judge a person based only on appearance; however, in a beauty pageant it is hard to follow that phrase. In many of the glitz pageants, children are seen wearing heavy make up, spray tans, fake eyelashes, hair extensions, and flippers. Having contestants endure in all these beauty changes, demonstrates how natural beauty is not pretty. In Laura Agadoni article “How Do Child Beauty Pageants Affect a Child’s Development?” TV talk show host and psychologist Phil McGraw told pageant moms to explain to their children that a beauty pageant is a fantasy (Agadoni, 2003). McGraw said, “Children can easily believe after competing in pageants that they should concentrate too much on external…

    • 221 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    People who are against the pageants complain that they should be eliminated because they exploit children and place them in harm’s way. They claim because of major dangers; no one under the age of eighteen should be placed in a beauty pageant. The children who are in the pageants are dressed up in adult’s clothing, have piles of make up on, and are harming their bodies. They are harming their bodies by putting the make up on and tanning. By putting make up on at such young of an age, their face ages faster. By tanning, they begin to get that urge that some adults have to tan, which makes their skin age and have wrinkles early. It also puts them at the risk of having skin cancer at an early age. They say it also appeals the children to sexual predators. When a child is half naked on stage and sometimes on TV, these sexual predators see them and may even try to meet them. Sexual predators are only part of the problem. Studies show that every child who may benefit from the competition, hundreds of others suffer damage to their self-esteem and have warped self-vision of themselves and their bodies. Many times, they use JonBenet, a young child who competed in these pageants at the age of six. She was murdered in the basement of her home by a sexual predator. The suspect claimed he became aware of her by the pageants being on television.…

    • 559 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Children Pageants Should Be Banned “This can lead to eating disorders and poor self-esteem” (Overington, 13). Children in beauty pageants get judged on their outward appearance and get received or rejected. Children shouldn’t be allowed to compete in beauty pageants. Not only are pageants expensive, they make the children grow up too fast and the participants have poor self-esteem at the end of the day. Children beauty pageants are expensive.…

    • 544 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Anastasia Sidneva ENG 102b Fall 2015 Prof. Terziev October 15th Argumentative Essay Draft 1 Child beauty pageants lead to children’ serious mental and health issues According to a recent study conducted by (AACA) American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, exploitation in child beauty pageants can ruin a girl’s self-esteem forever and can be dangerous for their physiological turmoil. Despite children’s parents’ desire to focus their children’s attention on outward appearance, beauty and fashion, child beauty pageants are risk factors for severe psychological frustrations.…

    • 1311 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Young girls grow up watching movies about how the flawless princess falls in love with the handsome prince, so they wait to grow up to be the as beautiful and perfect as the princess is. Child beauty pageants allow these young girls to wear elaborate dresses along with makeup that makes their face look unrealistic for a child. Some parents of children who compete in beauty pageants say that the competition help the child’s self-esteem; however, these dysfunctional and harmful pageants give young, vulnerable girls a false impression on what true beauty really is. Child beauty pageants are exploitative, pressuring children to adopt semi-sexualized adult mannerisms that pulls them out of their innocence way too soon, while enforcing the message that physical appearance is all that is important.…

    • 1309 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The sinking feeling you get when you look at someone prettier than you are becoming too common amongst young girls. This encourages depression making young girls feel as if they are never good enough, never beautiful enough, never the prettiest girl in the room. Girls at the young age of 3 are being paraded around trying to achieve a form of perfection which should not exist at such a young age. These pageants are suggesting that beauty only come from the outside, one that is polished, poised and primed to flawlessness.…

    • 834 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Instances such as these are an outgrowth of that apotheosis of stage mother narcissism and child exploitation known as child beauty pageants. These shameless exhibitions treat small girls (and some boys) as if they were highly groomed pedigree dogs at a kennel show instead of children. Many parents enter their children in beauty pageants under the false notation that their child will be rewarded with confidence and self esteem, however, today’s pageants often foster poor body image, force children to mature at a rapid pace, and contribute to the sexualization of young girls.…

    • 1387 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Do beauty contests really serve a purpose of today’s society??? Today, there are large numbers of beauty contests bouncing from all possible corners of the society, for both men as well as women covering all age groups. The concept of beauty contests or so called “Beauty Pageants” is no more the same as it used to be earlier. “Beauty with Brains” was the golden and the most important rule of earlier time’s beauty pageants. Earlier the beauty pageants didn’t only meant to have a perfect hour glass figure but more than that. It involved each and every bit of beauty that the title of the contest stands for. Beauty Pageants earlier not only concentrated on the physical appearance of contestants but also on their overall personality from the way they walk to the way they talk, from the way they carry themselves to the way how really comfortable they are, from the way they smile to the way they really genuinely meant that smile, their etiquettes and above all the confidence and the intelligence with which they act, react, talk and answer the questions truly and honestly. If not writing in these many words then the simplest would be to say that beauty contests earlier meant that one should not only have a beautiful face and body but a true and a pure heart, mind and soul.…

    • 780 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The purposes, then, of this paper is to show that through beauty pageants, women are made to accept the concept of beauty as only physical, physical beauty is given much emphasis compared to a woman's intelligence and women are being objectified, all of which will be achieved through presentation of the pros and cons of beauty pageants.…

    • 2900 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Beauty Competitions

    • 1234 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Yet there are ‘beauty’ competitions. A group of men and women watch the parade of a group of half-naked girls and then pronounce one to be the most beautiful. These young mostly naïve girls, because they cannot show any skill or ability, have to flaunt their bodies in public. It is degrading to see these young girls with perpetual smiles pouting their lips and wiggling their bottoms just to gain some marks from some pretentious judges.…

    • 1234 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics