Preview

Stone Butch Blues Book Review

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1448 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Stone Butch Blues Book Review
Gabriella Montes
Stone Butch Blues

Leslie Feinberg has done an extraordinary deed in her writing of Stone Butch Blues. She has unlocked her soul to anyone who reads and showed us the fears of being different no matter how slight it may be. At first I was reading it because I was required to for this course, but I found myself unable to put the book down. This book is not only an important historical narrative for the gay community, it is a captivating novel yet the “plot” doesn’t follow a traditional arch at all. It takes place during the 60s mostly and has helped me learn a lot about the Women’s Movement and the history of LGBTQ rights in the United States. Stone Butch Blues is modestly the story of a person who, because of the callousness of our society, does not fit into the “social norm.” In telling this story, Feinberg is a voice to the queer life in America. Although this is sold as a novel, it reads something like a biography. It stands as a straining tale of a person just trying to be accepted. The main character, protagonist, and narrator of Stone Butch Blues is Jess Goldberg. Jess never quite fits into all the different suits - butch or femme, man or woman, but eventually finds their own identity, away from labels and group conformity. Those reading would agree that Jess was a walking contradiction; she was a tough and introverted butch on the exterior, mixed with vulnerability and fear on the in the interior. Reading this novel I almost felt like I was carrying around Jess with me and never ever did I want to leave her behind. Jess Goldberg is greeted as family within the prevalent middle class bar scene in Buffalo, New York. That is the location where Jess discovers community, love and guidance. As much as Jess yearns to openly express her sexuality that is something that cannot be done in every location. In the labor world, Jess encounters much trouble searching for and sustaining jobs because of her sexuality and being a butch. She is

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    In both of their respective texts, Marjorie Garber and Roger Baker discuss the ever-increasing prevalence of “transvestism” (or what is modernly known as “drag”) in popular American culture. Although the American public typically disapproves of individuals blurring the boundaries of gender, the use of cross-dressing as entertainment has generally been embraced and met with great acclaim. In Vested Interests: Cross-Dressing and Cultural Anxiety, Garber argues that films like Tootsie (1982) is significant in that it portrays a heterosexual man living as a woman. While many enjoyed the movie believing that Tootsie was commentary on the relationship between men and women, Garber claims that the film is actually about transvestism. To ignore this…

    • 241 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Christopher Bruce based the production on the “sexual war” he witnessed growing up in the 1960’s. His intention was to celebrate the music of The Rolling Stones and use the qualities of the songs to reflect this. The production is set in the 1960’s when the rights of males and females began to equalise.…

    • 1069 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Stone Butch Blues’ opening was different from other books I’ve read because it begins as a love letter from Jess Goldberg who is a “butch” lesbian to her long-lost lover Theresa. It is sort of like an autobiography about her life and the struggles/events she went through being “different”. She always knew that she was not your typical average girl but as she progresses, she begins to feel lost and so she goes to seek out whom she is but that proved to be not a easy road for her.…

    • 487 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Springboard Unit 2

    • 267 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Finally, Jess is able to resolve the conflict with her family after many other attempts. Jess tried to reason with her parents, but to no avail. In addition, her gay friend was willing to pretend to marry her so that she could attend the university in the United States to play…

    • 267 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    This paper has focused and compared Mick to other characters: what intersecting power structures she is either privileged or restrained by, how those structures shape her experiences, and how she accepts or resists. Mick is restrained by her femininity notions based on racial, sexist, and classist notions, and that her characterization challenges them through her behavior. She is also restrained to accomplish her artistic aspirations due to her poor position in the intersection of gender and…

    • 1207 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In The Laramie Project, a character name Cathy Connolly claims that gay the people in Laramie feel the oppression from society, and are compelled to hide there identities. Cathy being gay herself tells why gay people are afraid of change which is sparked by opression from anti-homosexuals. “And so-she was-a kind of lesbian... she later told me that there were other lesbians that she knew who wouldn't been seen with me. That I would irreparably taint them, that just to be seen with me could be a problem.” (Kaufman 22) She says that being known as a homosexual in Laramie “would irreparably taint”. This gives you a great understanding of how oppressed gay people, if they are so afraid to reveal themselves to make a comment for a friend who has passed. Murdock Cooper another character said that “most of 'em that are gay or lesbian they know damn well who to talk to. If you step out of line you're asking for it.” (Kaufman 58) The gay people of Laramie feeling opressed because they are living in a society that has not been modernized to be able to accept homosexuals socially. Gay people and the prejudice people of Lamarie are afraid of change. They are both afraid of accepting each other, one opressing the other because they are arfraid of having homosexuals in the societty. These homophobic people would goto the extreme of even killing someone because they do not like…

    • 1097 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Two future revolutionaries, with similar upbringings, yet contributing on two entirely different platforms had no idea of the impact they would bring, nor had intention of making such a statement. One of these people was Marsha P. Johnson, an American drag queen and sex worker. She was best known for her role in the Stonewall riots. Her first trip to Stonewall was merely to celebrate her 25th birthday, but her influence would extend far from that day; eventually being a contribution to countless gay and transgender rights to be sanctioned in the future. Like Johnson, author James Baldwin was gay, black, and played a significant role during the time of great social upheaval. Their stories help define a phrase full of uncertainty, one that can…

    • 1242 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As well as the media, literature is vital for society’s ability to modify the construction of expectation and restraints on genders. Sue Monk Kidd’s novel The Secret life of Bees (2002) illustrates the way both white and black women in the 1960’s had to fight discrimination while living in a patriarchal society. Women in the 60’s had no power whatsoever, however, in the novel they find ways to gain their rights. The fight for women’s freedom wasn’t the predominant movement compared to the emancipation of African-Americans eligibility to vote without absurd Jim Crow laws and discrimination among sexes. The novel also delineates men masking their emotions for their children and wives. Both sexes are restrained to a specific category due to the alterations in society that is relevant in the…

    • 589 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    It is true when it is said that, "All paradises, all utopias are designed by who is not there, by the people who are not allowed in” (Online Newshour 1998). There is no perfect utopia, no place where pain doesn’t exist. The idea of paradise is just an idea because it is not reachable. No one lives in paradise and no one ever can because if they did, it wouldn’t be paradise anymore; just another world where ideas of how to make it perfect arise. The world moves forward and its inhabitants evolve; all people have their likes and their dislikes and that has somehow integrated with our feelings and preferences towards other people, even other races and genders. Surprisingly, though humanity has largely grown past the point of outwardly expressing it (most of the time), prejudice remains at the forefront of what is hidden in our minds. There were times however, when prejudice wasn’t hidden and intolerance was shared with as many as would hear. “Paradise” by Toni Morrison and “The Women of Brewster Place” are two such examples of the types of prejudice people faced. In “Paradise,” Toni Morrison writes about a town called Ruby that consisted of mainly African Americans. These folk believed that they were a strong community, but when things begin to become dire, the men turned their frustrations to a female community called, “The Convent” (Morrison 3). Another community having its own problems can be seen in “The Women of Brewster Place,” by Gloria Naylor; but these problems are somewhat diverse. Fundamentally, the perspectives on the feminine communities found in “Paradise” and “The Women of Brewster Place” show how prejudice toward gender and race affect the characters in the two novels. This paper is a comparison of these two novels and how they show similarities and differences in how prejudice affects the main characters.…

    • 4454 Words
    • 18 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    This is a divisive strategy that aims to produce a consumable queer, fit for a mainstream audience. Subsequently, this strategy risks straight culture subsuming both lesbians and the queer community (Moody 2011). To subsume lesbian and queer culture would erode the common political identity that allows for community organization against heterosexism. Like bell hooks (1992) contends, “Communities of resistance are replaced by communities of consumption” (33). Effectively, the apolitical representation of lesbianism obliterates the movement’s historical allegiance to working class culture, butches, interracial socializing and feminism (Moody 2011). Both productions exemplify this shift from queer sexuality to homonomative-domestic lesbian, although The Kids Are All Right epitomizes this because it fails to acknowledge the oppressive culture and diverse identities. Homonormative representations normalized the broader lesbian community and foster…

    • 720 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Relating back to the narrator's values, he seems to have become a very upstanding gentleman. He wants to be the successful man and only wants the best for himself and his family. To tie in with the title, you also see that his daughter Grace has died. This relates to the Blues because it shows sorrow in death and the name of the daughter signifies that there could possibly be some hopes in helping his brother get out of his addiction. He is deeply concerned when he reads an article about his brother on the front page of the paper explaining to the subscriber that someone was arrested for…

    • 856 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    In the 20th century, American societal norms and culture were beginning to change. Women were beginning to achieve higher education and a broader array of occupations that previously was unavailable to them, the government began to crack down hard on unsafe and unsanitary working conditions in industrial companies, the recent development of a new, exciting genre of music called rock and roll had swept the nation. Another prevalent occurrence during this period would be the rise of the fight for Civil Rights. Across the nation, people of colour were discriminated against and held at a lower tier than their Caucasian counterpart, and seen as inferior to them. This had continued for many years, until brave advocates decided to speak out against…

    • 1305 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sonny's Blues Symbolism

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Consciously being marginalized is an emotionally discouraging sensation that many people are faced with overcoming. Figuring out where one can achieve self-content through being socially accepted is a hardship presented in James Baldwin’s, “Sonny’s Blues” as symbolism of light and darkness reveals the saddening experience of marginalized Americans feeling that they are unfairly labeled as outsiders by the rest of society.…

    • 999 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    The Stonewall Riots

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages

    It is not about being violent or aggressive to other people, it is about defending your ideals and principles and about being courageous enough to go against other beliefs.…

    • 1152 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Brokeback Mountain” displays the difficulty two men have living double-sided lives as they hide their sexuality because of their profession, and because of the time period in which they lived. “Brokeback Mountain” is set back in the early 1960’s before it was socially acceptable to present yourself as lesbian or gay in public. It shows the struggles and challenges they face as they hide their secret relationship from friends, and family; the struggles Jack and Ennis face as they try to keep up the image of their profession. The way they are forced to live their lives is an unbelievable difference compared to today’s views on this topic. As a society we have without a doubt moved at a sluggish pace to get to where we are, but nonetheless have…

    • 1265 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics