Cohort
Monsters Lesson 14 Judging Gawain
Answer these questions using QAR
1. Read over each question.
2. Think back (or reread) the text and create a valid, clear, and focused response.
3. Identify the relationship—where did you find your evidence?
Question
Answer
Relationship—Choose one:
Right There
Think and Search
Author and Me
Gawain is said to be Arthur’s most noble and faithful knight. Would you agree or disagree with that statement? Why? Please explain your answer in detail.
I agree, because none of the other knights would take the challenge, and were willing to let King Arthur do it himself, except Gawain, he stepped up and took his kings place.
Right There
The seduction of Gawain by Lady Bertilak was an attempt to show flaw in Arthur’s servant and the whole chivalric system. Was this attempt successful or not? Explain your answer in detail.
I would say that is was not successful, because the seduction only got a few kisses from Gawain, but what happened from that was the giving of the green girdle, and Gawain not giving his winnings to the lord as promised.
Author and Me
Discuss two choices made by Gawain throughout the course of the poem. What were the consequences of these choices? If you were Gawain, would you have made these same choices? Why or why not? Please explain your answers in detail.
The first crucial choice Sir Gawain made was taking on the challenge for his king, which took him on this journey, facing the Green Knight. Another choice that guided his fate was giving in a little to the lady of the house. Although it was not the noblest of things to do, it did gain him the green girdle, which saved his life. I agree with his choices, he was noble for risking his life for his King, and if I thought I was going to die, I might steal a few kisses from a beautiful lady too.
Think and Search
At the end of the story, Sir Gawain comments that many great men have met their demise because of a woman. What does he mean by this? How does this apply to Gawain and his search for the Green Knight?
He meant that many women have lead to the downfall of men in the medieval times and stories of them. Even though Lady Bertilak didn't cause him death, Sir Gawain did not live up to his noble reputation.
Think and Search
When Gawain returns to Camelot he recounts his journey and his reason for wearing the green girdle across his shoulder. How do King Arthur and his men react to Gawain’s story? What does this say about the relationship between Arthur and his knights?
King Arthur and his men accepted Gawain and his story and actually wore girdles the same way as a sign of nobility and respect for Sir Gawain. This shows King Arthur and his men were very close and supported every man.
Author and Me
A correlationCorrelation: Systematic connection. can be drawn between the superhuman powers of the Green Knight and those of Grendel in Beowulf. What similarities do the two "monsters" share? How are they different?
Both characters share incredible strength, and magical qualities . The Green Knight I don't see as a monster, just a superhuman character, he did not terrorize like Grendel did.
Think and Search
Do you think it is possible for man to always follow the "letter of the lawLetter of the law: A covenant or set of rules."? Why or why not?
It is possible for a person to follow the law as we have it today, people do it all the time. But to be perfect, a completely noble person, I don't think so, no body is perfect.
Think and Search
Two of the strongest symbols referenced in Sir Gawain and the Green Knight are the pentagle and the green girdle. Pick one and discuss its significance in the poem. What relevance might this symbol still hold in today’s world?
The green girdle protected Sir Gawain, but he gained it by breaking his word. I think this relates to todays world because people are always looking out for themselves and might earn good things in a bad way.
Think and Search
What would you have done differently if you were in Gawain’s position? Explain your answer in detail.
I would have give the green girdle to the lord, since he was also the green knight, he might have seen the noble act, and let me live.
Think and Search
Do you think it is important to have "rules" or "laws" in society? Why or why not? Explain your answer in detail.
I believe our conscience would stop most people from doing wrong, but of course there will aalways be those people who need the laws to keep them in check, so yes, rules and laws are necessary in society.
Think and Search
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
Christmastime in Camelot, around King Arthur’s table –this is where the story of Sir Gawain and the Green Knight begins. The Green Knight enters the court to challenge one of the men from King Arthur’s table because they are said to be the bravest of all the knights in the kingdom. The challenge that the Green Knight poses is to strike him with his own axe, and in return receive the same blow exactly one year and one day later. When not one person of the group volunteers to accept the challenge, he proceeds to call them cowards. Insulted, King Arthur volunteers. His nephew, Sir Gawain, realizes that he is of less importance than the king and volunteers to take Arthur’s place. He swings the axe and severs the head of the Green Knight. But to the surprise of everyone in the court, the Green Knight nonchalantly picks up his head. After reminding Sir Gawain of their agreement, he leaves and the court and the knights continue their festivities.…
- 1649 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The English poem Sir Gawain and the Green Knight is a significant piece in Arthurian Literature. The story approaches Gawain’s character much differently than in Sir Thomas Malory’s well-known Le Morte d’Arthur. Unlike Malory’s version of the Arthurian legend where Sir Lancelot is known as the Round Table’s finest Knight, the author of Sir Gawain and the Green Knight chose, instead, to have Sir Gawain play the role of Camelot’s most noble gentleman. In staying true to the theme of chivalry and virtue, the Gawain Poet tells a captivating story of a knights struggle to uphold the chivalric code in the face of temptation and danger.…
- 2416 Words
- 10 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The first thing that Sir Gawain does in the story that proves that he is indeed a true knight is that he takes the challenge of the beheading game that the Green Knight purposes. At first King Author took the challenge, but Sir Gawain volunteered to take the challenge so that his King, King Author is protected. The fact that Sir Gawain does…
- 526 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Do you think in the romance, “Sir Gawain and the Green Knight”, Gawain had integrity?Did the Green Knight show integrity? Do you show integrity ? Well, do you know what it means to have or show integrity? The Green Knight tested Gawain’s integrity, by giving him three major test. The three major test that determined Gawain’s integrity were seducing, listening, and persuading.…
- 359 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
The green knight then proceeds to laugh at him so he bares his neck one final time and the green knight strikes. However the knight barely cuts his neck, simply saying a strike is a strike. Gawain however shows why he is a near perfect hero, during the game with the king, he was given a magic belt that would prevent death, failing to give the belt to the king as agreed by his wager. This is a great example of a near perfect hero because he does everything right expect for one thing.…
- 1163 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
First, Beowulf is noticeably more honorable than Sir Gawain was. While staying at the Lord’s castle, Sir Gawain says to him that he “will give ye all I have earned.” This of course was a lie, breaking the covenant he had made with the lord. The Lady of the castle gave him a magical girdle to protect him and he told the lord he hadn’t received anything; this is not the works of an honorable knight. Also, Gawain “swerved aside as the axe came gliding down to slay him.” When his turn comes to be hit by the Greek Knight, he dodges the axe, which is breaking the agreement. Sir Gawain is too worried about staying alive then actually trying to be a true knight. On the contrary, Beowulf is told to complete multiple life threatening tasks and he does what he is told. He does everything asked of him and saves the town from the evil Grendel, and the Dragon. Beowulf is extremely honorable because he fought for the people of the town and died protecting a town that was not his own.…
- 427 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In 476 AD, during the medieval times, there were many knights. Most knights followed a chivalric code. By definition chivalry means the rules and customs of medieval knighthood. Chivalry can also be defined by seven knightly virtues: courage, justice, mercy, generosity, faith, nobility, and hope.…
- 373 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Sir Gawain says that he laid aside all the pointed speeches that came out of Lady Bertilak's mouth, “All the speches of specialte that sprange of her mouthe” (1778). This is because she has destroyed his masculinity with her words. She offered herself to him at first, and by rejecting her, he automatically began to walk the path towards femininity. Lady Bertilak has feminized Sir Gawain's body, and in a way is preparing him to accept the girdle which she offers to him later on (Kinney 53). The girdle in a sense repents the identity of what Sir Gawain has become after his meetings with Lady Bertilak (Heng 504). Lady Bertilak acted as a facilitator in Sir Gawain's transformation into a feminine and homoerotic character. The bedroom scene symbolizes this feminine influence that overtakes…
- 1055 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
One example from the story would be the instances where Sir Gawain politely turns down the advances of the lady of the castle while keeping the conversation’s tone as if she were granting him a favor, instead of taking advantage of the situation for his own pleasure. While there are many men today who still embrace this and will not hesitate to treat their female friends, wives, or girlfriends with the utmost respect and courtesy, today’s society as a whole tends to back away from this. There are some women who may view having a man open a car door for them as an insult to their worth, or that they might be perceived as helpless or weak because someone else opened the door for them, and this simple act of respect seems to have no value whatsoever, and it is not just acts like this one that garner such a reaction. There are some women who see any gesture of chivalry from a man, be it holding a door, pulling out a chair at a table, offering to pay for their meal, or offering any sort of favor, as degrading and refuse to take part in any of them, for fear that it may hurt their independence or that they may be perceived as a “damsel in distress” by the men around…
- 1237 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
When we hear the word knight, we imagine Arthurian-tales of glorious battles between men and dragons, fierce jousting competitions, rivalries between kingdoms, and knightly chivalry. Several of these tales center on the bravery of knights against mighty foes or on their ability to resist earthly temptations. Sir Gawain is the nephew of King Arthur and is a knight of the round table. He appears in more Arthurian-tales than any other knight and is known as the ideal that all knights should strive for. (Joe) In the Arthurian-Legend of Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, Sir Gawain faces many challenges and his decisions based on those challenges shape him into the Knight that many know now.…
- 1227 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Sexual craving and the fight to outlast overcome chivalrous code of conduct in Sir Gawain and the Green Knight. Gawain fails one test, passes another and comes out of this experience with a great lesson learned. Morals are always hardest to follow when no one is watching. Forever keep in mind that God is constantly…
- 534 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
Sir Gawain, is the only knight of King Arthur’s court to accept the challenge from the Green Knight. [quote to describe the challenge]. Sir Gawain uses the axe to cut off the head of the Green Knight, but the knight is immortal and takes his head and leaves the castle. Sir Gawain keeps his promise and a year later journeys to find the Green Knight so that the Green Knight will have the chance to return the blow with the axe. Sir Gawain believes in keeping his word, but he is not always filled with bravery. He does not completely keep his deal with the Lord he meets on the journey to find the knight. Sir Gawain hides that he is wearing…
- 501 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
In this exchange, Gawain exudes chivalry and charm. He treats both Bertilak's wife and her attendant with reverence, despite the fact that the latter is described to be a sorrowful sight to behold. A pinnacle of courtesy, Gawain is faced by a veritable moral dilemma when Bertilak's wife puts him to the test to see if he will choice between being discourteous to her or disloyal to her husband.…
- 892 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
In the poem, Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, many people believe that Sir Gawain does not abide by his principles, and he lets go of what he values most. He is so proud of his values that he depicts them on his shield, which he carries around everywhere. People do not contend about his first four sets of virtues since the book mentions,…
- 776 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
The female figures in Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, Queen Guinevere, Lady Bertilak, and Morgan le Fay, play an important role in the shaping of Sir Gawain’s destiny on his quest of his own beheading. This essay will discuss the most powerful female figure in Sir Gawain and the Green Knight, Lady Bertilak, and how her role in Sir Gawain’s quest to find the Green Knight shaped his destiny.…
- 1800 Words
- 8 Pages
Better Essays