Preview

Similarities Between Larkin And Abse

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1095 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Similarities Between Larkin And Abse
How do Larkin and Abse present the idea of disappointment and loss?

Both Larkin and Abse write poems about disappointment and loss but both having a different idea to how it is presented
In ‘Home is so sad,’ by Philip Larkin, the idea of disappointment and loss is presented through a home. The form and structure gives off spontaneous thoughts and written in two quintains and each stanza containing 5 lines. Each line contains ten syllables with a basic iambic metre and containing internal full stops. The poem has a basic rhyme scheme of A,B,A,B,A and contains enjambermont in points throughout. The title in the poem is a bit ironic because ‘home’ is associated with a warm, safe, pleasant place and shouldn’t be associated with sadness. In
…show more content…
In ‘A Winter Visit,’ by Dannie Abse, the poet writes about his mum who has now died. The rhyme scheme in the poem goes A,B,A which creates disharmony and is made up of five tursets with three lines. In the first stanza the poet says “neighbouring lights come on before it’s dark” which is a preparation for nightime when it goes dark which would mean a preparation for his mother’s death. In the third stanza the poet starts off with “I would die” which suggests loss and possibility which is then followed by “This winter I’m half dead, son” which signals to us that she is aware death is near. The fourth stanza is then started with a modal verb ‘Yet’ which suggest certainty that the poet can’t cry at the situation and then continued with parenthesis “(although only Nothing keeps)” which shows that everything changes. These show disappointment and loss because Abse is aware of his mother’s death and understands that his mother has come to terms with it but wants to stay strong for her sake. Which then goes on to describe “white coat not a black” the poet has deliberately stated ‘not a black’ because black is the colour associated with death and would be the ideal colour under these circumstances but the poet is wearing white because he is a doctor but he isn’t behaving like he’s at a funeral. The poet then goes on to finish the fourth stanza with “even here – and am not qualified to weep” …show more content…
But to no surprise, we get the negative view as usual through his poems and his negative style of writing in his poems. The form and structure of the poem are made up of 3 stanzas; a sestet, 9 lines and 7 lines. The fact this poem has no usual symmetry creates a sense of disharmony which is unsatisfactory. The rhyme scheme is A,A,B,B which is made up of rhyming couplets and some half rhymes which brings regularity to the poem, and filled with enjambermont “you / looked so much forward to”. In the first stanza we get the repetition of the term “unsatisfactory” which is not positive as visiting his mum is becoming a bit of a chore to him and he doesn’t enjoy it. This is then followed by “Played record after record” which is almost like a routine and does this instead of communicating with his mum but does it “idly” meaning he put no effort in. The adverbial of place “Wasting my time at home” is juxtaposition and “you looked so much forward to” meaning his mum looked forward to it. This presents the idea of disappointment because Larkin isn’t entirely happy about having to go and spend time with his mum before she dies which any normal person would be happy about spending time with family and having memories whereas Larkin feels as though it is a chore and has no choice that he is ‘wasting his time.’ In the second stanza at the end,

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In both poems people reflect on relationships that have gone wrong. Write about both poems and their effect on you. Show how they are similar and how they are different.…

    • 993 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The poem itself is discussing a man's journey from birth to death and how all around him life is interpreted by material possessions. At the beginning of the first stanza, the sentences have been made very short and simple, as if to demonstrate the thoughts of a new born child. The first voice that the baby hears when he is born is Bobby Dazzler, one of Australia's first game shows. The very first thing that the baby hears is not the voice of his mother, nor the voice of his father, but the voice of materialism. This first stanza instantly creates the feeling of a home in the 1950s, where television was something new. The ellipsis that connects the first and second stanzas demonstrates a change in time, in this case, a change of a couple of years.…

    • 1438 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In my own eyes the meaning of this poem is a message of hope, mothers love, and giving. The mother of the son has no cloth or thread to make clothing for her son. She does not have any money to go out and buy such materials. The cold weather is making it hard on the boy to even show up at school because of his lack of clothing. One night as the boy lye awake, he watched his mother as she wove children's jackets, a red cloak, a pair of pants, a pair of boots, a hat, a pair of mittens, and a little blouse. As she wove all through the night, it was as if nothing could stop her. The son was thankful for his mother's affection towards him and took the pieces of clothing as he cherished it with his heart and…

    • 627 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In complete contrast with the reality of the poem’s setting, the touch of snow is equated with an image of lying under a blossom-laden tree in England. The home fires contain glowing coals described as ‘crusted dark-red jewels’, this actually signifies a dying fire, a symbol of people’s waning interest in the fate of the exposed soldiers. That the ‘doors are all closed: on us’ is also symbolic, representing the total loss of the memory of the men and that…

    • 874 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As the poem went on, it seemed to shift from youthful optimism to the realities of being an adult and crushing their youthful optimism. From line ten to the end it takes about the speaker’s home life and it seems like they aren’t aware of the reality around them. Their father had gotten out of the hospital and they didn’t seem sympathetic towards him, the speaker seemed to focus on the fact that they got to move into a new house and didn’t have to live in an apartment anymore. “We’d moved / from the apartment over the store / into a house with a front door. / I wanted people to ring the bell / and I’d answer it like on TV.” (ll 16-20). The speakers father has just been brought home and all they can focus on is opening the door like the people…

    • 604 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Figurative language and sensory imagery is used in the first stanza to create a tone of grieving, loss and nostalgia, through imagery of a dull ‘cold dusk’ and ‘frail, melancholy flowers among ashes’. The simile ‘the melting west is striped like ice-cream’ creates a sense of transition, reflecting the beginning of the persona’s introspective retreat into her thoughts. The use of an anaphora, which is the repetition of a word at the beginning of lines or sentences, in the line ‘Ambiguous light. Ambiguous sky’ also displays this transience. The symbol of ice-cream also represents childhood and a feeling of nostalgia for that time in the persona’s life. Her attempt at ‘whistling a trill’ may be an attempt to imitate her father’s whistling which is mentioned during the reflection of her memory, suggesting that she is trying to recreate her past experience but can’t properly do so. The persona’s direct speech in the line “Where’s morning gone?” is a rhetorical question that is questioning the…

    • 1701 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sunny Prestatyn Larkin

    • 1343 Words
    • 6 Pages

    With reference to three poems studied so far discuss how Larkin presents the theme of illusion and reality.…

    • 1343 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    To start off,the main symbolism in the poem was the house itself, I think it is portraying that not all homes were meant for warm smiles, love and laughter; sometimes it could be filled with abuse, tears, fights, and even deaths. In the 15th stanza it says “ The house divided against itself, which to me, represents an abusive-family relationship. Also, the significance of the home is made up of negative memories, in which it impacted a strong emotions, etc. Over all, the house symbolizes a schizophrenic's head and the fighting family represents the internal conflict that goes on inside.…

    • 591 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Compare the ways in which Blake and Larkin present the theme of corruption in their poems.…

    • 5026 Words
    • 21 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Poem Nettles

    • 1253 Words
    • 6 Pages

    These unconventional aspirations continue into the second and final stanza where he gives a more personal view on how he would like to see this child grow up. Despite the repetition of negatives that he uses such as towards the end its still clear that he cares deeply about this child 's future as it is still written with positive hopes. The oxymoron on the third line “An average of talents”, expresses that someone that is not at rock bottom but still not having many luxuries at the same time can result in the baby having a happy life, and this sums up the overall message that Larkin is getting across to the audience. This can even be seen before on the second line where it could be said…

    • 1253 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Syntax structure is a key area in which the poem uses the format of words to convey the specific meanings between the four different stanzas. Three ways he is able to do this are listing, enjambment, and transitions between the different parts of the poem. Listing is one technique applied to the poem. In the second stanza, the poet begins to list off materialistic things that the people all around him want that he does not particularly care for: things such as “cheap suits, red kitchen-ware, sharp shoes, [and] iced lollies.” This use of sentence structure can lead the reader to assume the author holds the material wants of a large town in contempt, as he is clearly showing the things that others want while using a negative, almost chiding, tone. In addition, the listing done in the third stanza continues to bring out this negative aura even of smaller towns, of which Larkin describes to have “tattoo-shops, consulates, [and] grim headed-scarf wives.” The structure of listing in this stanza too shows that the poet knows just what it is about these two certain areas that he does not like, and he is not afraid to simply list them off one by one. The poet also uses enjambment in order to distinguish between the mentioned places, though not as clearly noticeable as the listing before it. The enjambed line 24’s transition cleanly into a new stanza beginning with line 25 is one of the clearest examples of the syntax at work, as well as of the distinct shifts between the many stanzas.. The poet’s tone has already shifted a few lines before this move, yet one still is able to feel the third stanza end and the fourth begin while still reading the same sentence. This shift shows the feelings towards the…

    • 1339 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    This poem demonstrates a feeling of incongruity exceptionally well, since it thinks about and differentiate the amount of his dad yielded for him and how he didn't understand it's something he underestimated. This sonnet may be a tad bit one-sided, sticking on to the father's side since this ballad was potentially made to express blame and lament. The mind-set of the story is about how the storyteller lamented being so unappreciative toward his dad. It certainly demonstrates how he dreaded his dad and regarded him now that he understands what he once had, his dad's cherishing and minding. In any case, as of right now of the sonnet, it's showing that his dad left alongside all the easily overlooked details he'd once accomplish for the…

    • 126 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Mr Bleaney

    • 609 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Larkin’s use of punctuation is particularly effective throughout the poem this can be seen through his use of the comma in the middle of the first line of the first stanza, ‘side by side, their faces blurred’. Here Larkin introduces the two main themes of the poem: romantic love, through the physical relationship of the couple, as suggested by ‘Side by side’; and loss of identity, as suggested by ‘their faces blurred’. However, ‘Side by side’ has wider connotations than the purely physical; it also highlights the supportive, emotional closeness of the Earl and Countess. The theme of loss of identity introduced in the first stanza and emphasized by ‘blurred’, ‘vaguely’, ‘faint’ and ‘hint’ dominates, in subtly different ways, throughout the poem, and it is this that will gradually reveal the ultimate ‘meaning’ of the poem. Larkin further uses punctuation to emphasise thematic relevance in the third stanza when he repeats the verb lie, in ‘They would not think to lie so long.’ However, notice Larkin’s use of the full stop. Once again the lie the poet is referring to is the couple’s faith in the promise of immortality. The religious beliefs of the earl and countess had convinced them that after death they would be together eternally, their souls everlasting. Despite this, rather than enjoying a resurrection to eternal life, all that remains of them are their…

    • 609 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Mr Bleaney

    • 2011 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Larkin has used the landlady and to some extent Mr Bleaney, as the focus for the humour in the poem but it is the landlady who comes across as the comic if somewhat pitiful character. The ironic humour is used as the lighter side of the poem to contrast its dark overtones and highlights the contrasting duality that is inherent throughout.…

    • 2011 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    In 1859 Emily Dickinson wrote a poem about death. In 1861 she rewrote that poem with very different imagery making it a lot darker. The poem itself is rather short, only two stanzas. The first stanza is only changed by one word, though its meaning is significant. The second stanza however changes completely, from light and spring like to dark and wintery. There is also significant change in punctuation and additional dashes in the second piece. This is a classic characteristic of Emily Dickinson writing and since she never explained it to anyone before her death we can only take a guess as to what it really means.…

    • 733 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Better Essays

Related Topics