Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Silas Marner

Good Essays
3458 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Silas Marner
Monday, Jul 23, 2012 11:00 AM UTC
Kyle Pruett on Fatherhood
Fathers and mothers play very different roles in a child’s development, says the professor of child psychiatry, who recommends essential reading for both parents
By Eve Gerber

more

Topics: The Browser, Parenting, Books, Writers and Writing, Children, Entertainment News
Kyle Pruett on Fatherhood
This interview first appeared in The Browser, as part of the FiveBooks series. Previous contributors include Paul Krugman, Woody Allen and Ian McEwan. For a daily selection of new article suggestions and FiveBooks interviews, check out The Browser or follow @TheBrowser on Twitter.

How central are fathers to childhood development?

It depends on whom you ask. If you ask the child they would say, absolutely essential. You ask a mother, she’ll say, if he does it the right way he’s really important. If you ask the father he’s likely to say, I’m not sure but I think probably pretty important. If you ask the experts, the answer will depend on how much they know about families and child development. I don’t mean to be elusive in my answer.
The Browser
It is a pretty well-accepted fact that we have not supported paternal engagement to the extent that would be helpful to our children. We’re getting better at it now. We’ve come to understand that fathers don’t mother and mothers don’t father. Fathers can’t really be replaced, in full, especially by somebody who doesn’t feel like a father. We’re beginning to understand that to the extent that dads are positively involved, the children’s and the mothers’ lives are better.

When you say mothers don’t “father,” what does fathering mean to you?

I can still feel the ruler on my knuckles from my sixth grade teacher, who would say: It’s a noun not a verb! When I used the word as a verb I was talking about a pattern of nurturing behavior rooted in the role of the father in our society. There are a couple of things that we notice fathers do much more than mothers when given the opportunity. It’s a fairly short list that includes roughhousing and other physical activity; an interest in having children encounter the world outside of the mother’s enclosure, not in spite of it but in addition to it; the use of play as a form of teaching as well as entertainment; and a willingness to allow frustration to build a little bit more than a lot of mothers are comfortable with, in order to teach some life lessons. Those are just trends that depend on your culture. But if I have to use the verb, that’s what distinguishes fathering from mothering.
Image of Silas Marner: The Weaver of Raveloe (Oxford World's Classics)
Silas Marner

By George Eliot ads not by this site

Why did you choose George Eliot’s “Silas Marner” as your first choice?

Eliot’s description of what happens to Silas Marner’s soul and heart is not an overly romanticised view of what happens to a lot of men when they fall in love with a child – although generally the child they fall in love with is their own. Marner is accused of a crime that he does not commit and he’s ostracised from a community. He saves a little bit of money from his job so that he can keep a life going, but he’s pretty constricted. I think that’s the way a lot of women feel about their men. Through a series of Edwardian twists and turns, he winds up taking in a child he finds wandering in the woods whose mother has died. He takes the child in because it’s winter and it’s the human thing to do. The child begins to affect him and really humanise him. There are a lot of other twists and turns, but those aren’t the parts of the book that interest me. I think it’s an interesting message. A child can evoke nurturing behaviour from men to whom they are not biologically related as long as the needs of the child are valued by the man.

George Eliot is a hell of a writer and I’m a big fan of the way liberal arts help us sharpen our philosophies. I assign “Silas Mariner” to my psychology students at Yale and other places. They wrinkle up their noses until they read it. Then they come back and say, “Oh, I get it.” Fiction can often tell more truths than nonfiction.

The title page contains a quote from Wordsworth: “A child more than all other gifts that earth can offer to a declining man brings hope with it and forward looking thoughts.” Does research back up Wordsworth’s assertion about the impact of kids on fathers?

Yes. When men become fathers, a lot of things about them change. First of all, they live longer. I joke with men when I tell them that. It won’t feel like that when you’re doing it because being a father is pretty tough, but longevity goes up and suicide rates go down. Job changes slow and women will often report an increase the man’s emotional availability. “My child really softened him up” is something you often hear. So it’s not just the children who are changed by fathering. Fathers are changed as well. I think Wordsworth said it nicely.
Image of The Role of the Father in Child Development
The Role of the Father in Child Development

By Michael Lamb

Next, “The Role of the Father in Child Development” by Michael Lamb. Tell us about the book.

Michael Lamb has edited six volumes of this particular series. Whenever Michael would release a new edition people would say “this is what we know as of now”, because they trusted Michael’s view of the literature and the people whom he asked to write chapters for this book. It’s the Wikipedia of the field, only it’s real science, not fake science like a lot of Wikipedia. It is so trusted by so many people that you give it to graduate students who are interested in fatherhood, and have them read it cover to cover to see if their ideas still hold. Only after they’ve read the book can you decide whether they’ve got something to study.

It helps people think about what the developmentalists have to say about paternal engagement. It’s not just about father’s rights or competition with mothering. I’ve always shared with Michael the belief that the bottom line about paternal engagement is not how the father feels about it, but how well the child does as a result of it.

Michael is one of the most productive and helpful pioneers in understanding the effect that men have on child development. He has almost single-handedly elevated the field to an evidence-based science. Without him, this would be a much messier and far more incoherent field. He stuck with this work long after his own children grew up and he moved to another country. We all use “The Role of the Father in Child Development” as a Rosetta Stone.

You’re both pioneers in the field of fatherhood studies. Can you sketch for us the story of this field of study and what it has helped bring to light?

It’s kind of messy. You have father’s rights people and feminists writing about it, you have nurses, anthropologists, psychiatrists and early childhood educators writing about it. It takes perspective from a bunch of different disciplines. The literature on fathering is actually much broader in its perspective than that on mothering. There’s a hundred times as much mothering literature, but it tends to come from the same scientific silos. In the literature on fathering, we have had everybody from Margaret Mead to Bill Cosby helping us try to identify what the fathering experience is about. I put those of us who have a lot of degrees from fancy universities after our names in the middle of that spectrum. That’s why it’s a big messy field.

Some of the less discussed pioneers, the people who really brought the father into the family dynamic, are family therapists and theorists like Salvador Minuchin. I didn’t select one of his books because he doesn’t write specifically about fathering, but he was one of the first to insist on paternal presence and engagement in treatment, because he knew that what fathers were bringing to the table, both in terms of repair and damage, was quite different to what mothers were bringing. He really was wise in saying: We’re willing to give the mother all the credit because we’re also willing to give her all the blame. Why are we leaving the father out? From the child’s perspective, the father belongs in the discussion.

I got into this field by watching men bring their children in for visits in the early 1980s and late 1970s, when so many women were going back to work and men were picking up some of the childcare whether they wanted to or not. Some pediatricians and nurses wouldn’t talk to the father. They’d ask for the mother’s number. This invisible parent syndrome was the reason why I got interested in fatherhood, as well as my personal experience as a father. I had to get written permission from the head of OBGYN to be present at the birth of my first child, who is now 41, at the very hospital where I had been delivering babies six months before. That was a jaw dropper for me.
Image of Fatherneed: Why Father Care is as Essential as Mother Care for Your Child
Fatherneed

By Kyle Pruett

That’s an experience you write about in “Fatherneed,” your how-to guide for postpartum paternity. What are the main points you tried to get across?

The title often raises an eyebrow. What do you mean? Do children really need fathering? The answer is yes. By the age of six weeks, infants already respond differently to their fathers than they do to their mothers. There’s a predisposition to engage differently with men. Whether you’re Darwinian or Lamarckian, you have to ask the question: What’s that information doing in the child if it doesn’t matter? Why has it been preserved over 400,000 years? Then you watch what happens to children who don’t have fathers or fathering and you see the hunger that they feel.

James Herzog, an analyst in Cambridge, Massachusetts, wrote a wonderful book called “Father Hunger.” Jim articulated, I think beautifully, the inherent hunger that children have for the fathering experience. If children don’t have a biological father available, they look for fathering from the men in their lives, and often make a very strong bid towards someone that the mother will allow in their lives to get some fathering – that roughhousing and exposure to real world frustrations that they seem to be able to use in their lives.

“Fatherneed” was about waking up to that need in children and in families. It was about following up with families where the father was the primary caregiver over the first critical years, families I wrote about in “The Nurturing Father.” What happened to those children? What happened to those marriages? The fact that those children are doing so well and that there have been relatively few divorces raises interesting questions.

I have no question in my mind that the so-called “fathering revolution” is a secondary phenomenon to the feminist revolution of the 1970s. Men have had to adapt to change in the workplace and at home. Many of them are awakening to the idea that they would like to father much more actively than they were fathered. They would like to do it more consciously and with more support. It turns out that most women think that’s a pretty neat thing. I’m interested in where this next generation is going to go.

Do fathers have a different impact depending on the gender of the child?

Not as much as you might think. The nature of the relationship and the sensitivity the father has towards the child matters a lot more than whether the child is of the same or different gender.

What does your research show about the impact of a father’s state of mind on the development of the child?

I suffer from knowing too much about states of mind to treat it as a simple construct. But fathers who, for example, are suffering from postpartum depression – and they do to a much larger extent than most people are aware – feel useless and have a hard time engaging with the child or responding to the child’s bids for nurturing. Fathers’ rates of postpartum depression are about half of what women’s are, which is more than what most people would guess. Women have rates of postpartum depression around 8% in most international studies, and it turns out that men have rates of about 4%. Any risk factor that the father carries – psychological risks such as substance abuse or mood disorders – are also going to affect the job he is able to do.
Image of Partnership Parenting: How Men and Women Parent Differently--Why It Helps Your Kids and Can Strengthen Your Marriage
Partnership Parenting

By Kyle Pruett

You wrote a guide to this new distribution of responsibilities with fellow psychology professor, and your wife, Dr Marsha Klein Pruett. Please tell us about “Partnership Parenting.”

“Partnership Parenting” is about the next iteration of paternal involvement. There are the exceptions, single parents, but let’s stick with the majority of families where there is a father, a mother, and biological or not they are trying to do this together. We call it co-parenting but we are not supporting each other very well. That’s what Partnership Parenting is about – getting practical about what this mean to a couple. How do you support it? How do you get it going? How do you keep it going during the difficult times? What does the research have to say?

It was fun for Marsha and me to do this together as husband and wife. We love talking about the work. Her perspective is different from mine, it’s a really interesting and long-term conversation. We just recently had something interesting happen. The Chinese bought the rights to the book, although there’s not a paragraph in it targeted towards families in Asia. We asked the Chinese agent why they were interested. He said: Our middle class families are under a lot of pressure to change very rapidly economically, and that means they’re also changing culturally. They’re a little lost about how to do this as partners and we think your book goes a long way to helping them. It was an example to us of how little we know about the potential usefulness of partnership parenting.

Opponents of gay marriage have used your work to argue that children of same sex parents suffer, because they don’t have the benefit of both mothering and fathering which your research shows is beneficial.

I don’t agree. I don’t think these differences are rooted in chromosomes, I think they’re rooted in culture. There are many same sex couples that divide up tasks in the way that heterosexual couples do. You have good cops and bad cops. You have people who are playful and people who are serious. One parent wants to protect the child from frustration, while the other wants to help you learn from your failures. So a dimorphism tends to develop in couples when two people are trying to raise a child. We don’t have any really good science yet to tell us whether children who are raised in same sex marriages have any particular vulnerabilities, because most of them are not controlled studies. How can you control a study like that? It’s impossible. The work of Charlotte Patterson and others has said we don’t need to be especially worried about these children. They’re doing fine. So let’s pay attention to the children we know we have to worry about, the children of the poor or vulnerable single parent.
Image of The Myth of the Missing Black Father
The Myth of the Missing Black Father

By Roberta Coles

Let’s turn to “The Myth of the Missing Black Father.” Please tell us about this book of essays edited by Roberta Cole. What we can learn from it and what about it is applicable to all fathers?

I put this on my list because there is a huge shadow over the African American population that says black men don’t stick around to raise their children. Sociologists looking at this issue in the 1960s vastly overstated it. Anybody who works with the black inner-city population of kids will hear them say: “I know who my dad is. My mother hates him, he’s in and out of jail but he slips me $20 if he has it and he keeps me from getting my ass kicked, so I know who he is.” The census bureau and society may not count him as a father. He’s not residential but he’s not missing. That is a critical distinction for an awful lot of kids, who feel connected to their dads even thought they don’t live with them. So to keep this myth going simply perpetuates the inefficacy of black fathers and gives women another reason to have yet another generation of fatherless families.

The way that we as a society have bought into the myth of the black father is highly destructive to children, to women and to men. We need to fix it in this generation, because there are an awful lot of fathers who with a little help could find their way back into their children’s lives in constructive ways. We know, for example, that when men in prison participate in fathering programs they all say: The only reason for me to change my ways is because I’m a father, and I don’t want my kid to wind up across the cell block from me. But the fathering support stops when he gets out of prison, can’t get a job, his housing sucks and he’s back in trouble in six weeks. If we were able to seriously support the transition from prison and help these men reconnect with their kids, we could have very different outcomes.

Cole notes that in 2004 over 50 percent of African American children lived in mother-only households. A recent New York Times article pointed out, based on census data, that more than half of births to women under 30 now occur outside of marriage regardless of race. If more and more mothers decide to parent without fathers, what will they be forgoing?

Help, and the potential for a really useful lifelong partnership. Children grow up, just like puppies. Their needs change profoundly. Children have a hunger in them. If you choose to raise a child without the father in their life, some day that child is going to come to you for an explanation and you better be prepared for it. The absence of the paternal figure is going to be a powerful psychological entity in the life of that child. It could turn out to be a time bomb, or it could turn out to be a little firecracker.

Women can’t be all things to all children. It’s not that women can’t do a wonderful job, be incredibly loving, willing to make all the sacrifices necessary and have kids who turn out fine. They can. Women come to me and say: I want to have this child and I’ve never had a man in my life that I trusted, what do I do? Although I don’t give advice on how people ought to live their lives, I can say that if you want to avoid the negative outcomes of unrequited father hunger, including the idealisation of the guy whose sperm you have used, then get men in your life that you do value close to the child, keep them there, and let the child understand what the fathering experiences feels like from people you trust. But it’s a myth that one person can do it all. You can’t.

Replace with relevant Browser Q&As for each interview
More The Browser

http://thebrowser.com/interviews/lee-camp-on-political-satire Humour can be better than mainstream media at speaking truth to power, says the American comedian and activist. He discusses masters of the art, from Jon Stewart to Joseph Heller Eve Gerber May 28, 2012 Leah Price on the History of Reading

We can learn about the past not just through what was written but how it was read. The historian of books tells us about reading aloud in Roman times, Gutenberg-era marginalia, and Middle Age solutions to information overload Jane Rudloff June 4, 2012

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    Throughout history fatherhood has evolved from the hunter gather, to the Pre-Industrial, to the Industrial, to the modern 21st century (Burgess). Through each era the role of a father involved him to simply provide for his family, which meant going away and not spend time with them. Even in the 21st century fathers are required to spend a great deal of time away from their wives and kids. Being a father entitles much more than just providing for the family. It entitles a father to bond and help raise his kids. Without the presence of a father, kids grow up struggling through life. The role of a father is to provide support and positive interaction in a child’s life, without these elements a child loses the ability to fully experience life. Ashley Rhodes the author of “Fatherhood is Essential” covers these main points in her essay by providing examples of her own experiences with her father. Support in a child’s life is one of the key elements that shapes the type of person that child will become in the future.…

    • 973 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Lifetime of Violence

    • 903 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Parents are the caretakers, supporters, enforcers, role models, and authoritative figures in a child’s life. Parents are there to teach their children the difference between right and wrong, good and bad, and up from down. Yet, as much as all parents have the same general type of goal, which is to ultimately help their child to be successful, many mothers and fathers have different parenting skills, and sometimes, those skills are questioned.…

    • 903 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    parenting skills 01.10

    • 426 Words
    • 2 Pages

    -I think fathers enjoy fatherhood more today than in the past because now we have more technology like cell-phones on which you can record, take, and send pictures to his father when not with his child like when he is on a trip and that way he won’t lose the important moment of his child childhood.…

    • 426 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    John Locke's Theory

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages

    is important. It lays the groundwork for whom the child is going to grow up to be. Their long…

    • 816 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The single-motherhood statistics are indefensible if one even wanted to try. Studies show that children develop better in dual parent households, and more children are growing up without fathers, in less stable environments. The failure of 21st century fathers to take care of their children is a pervasive and serious problem, and can easily be categorized as a symptom of America's moral decline.…

    • 747 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Fatherless America

    • 429 Words
    • 2 Pages

    I grew up without knowing what it means to have a father. I am 18 years old and I do not recall going to bed with my father in the same house. I don’t think it ever happened. I have only seen my father four times in my whole life. My father was and still is “a two-second father” meaning he was never there for me. I have observed that there are more single parents than joined parents. Hardly, would an observer see a responsible father with…

    • 429 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Essay On Child Parenting

    • 499 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Mothers have always been the role model when it comes to nurturing and child rearing. However, since the last couple of years have seen Fathers play a crucial role in the upbringing of children. Take the example of celebrities like David Beckham, Will Smith and Johnny Depp who have shown deep bonding with their babies and have become role models. Melanie Mallers, professor of Pyschology at the California State University states that, “Fathers play a hugely important role in the mental health of their children much later in life.”…

    • 499 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    To be a father is not hard, but rather to act like a father needs time to demonstrate that. The father is the main source of income and dominant provider of the family. He settles on the significant family choices together with mother and with the assistance of different individuals. This is the customary part of the father. Fathers and moms have novel contrasts that make them have distinctive child rearing parts, that when joined, give the most far reaching model to help the child grow effectively. Consequently, kids require both parents to help them build up the skills to help them assemble fruitful social relations, take part in dependable conduct, build up the confidence and abilities to be effective in school and to wind up…

    • 1200 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The mafia killed JFK

    • 306 Words
    • 1 Page

    Researchers found that, overall, the love -- or rejection -- of mothers and fathers equally affects kids' behavior, self-esteem, emotional stability, and mental health. "But in some cases, the withdrawal of a father's love seems to play a bigger role in kids' problems with personality and psychological adjustment, delinquency, and substance abuse," says study coauthor Ronald P. Rohner, Ph.D.,…

    • 306 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In her book Longing for Daddy: Healing from the Pain of an Absent or Emotionally Distant Father, Monique Robinson, a pastor of women’s discipleship, explains that daughters long for something they cannot articulate— the need for a father, for his love “defines [her] femininity, shapes her character, affirms her identity, and validates her womanhood” (Robinson 120). Naturally, it is a father’s paternal obligation to nurture and care for his daughter’s emotional needs. Thus, when he neglects his paternal duty, his daughter’s emotional capacity becomes weighted down by negative thoughts that tell her she is unlovable. Therefore, she sets out in pursuit of love (Robinson 120). Consequently, without the support the daughter needs to positively influence…

    • 140 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    This style of parenting employs little warmth with a high degree of control (Kail & Cavanaugh, 2010). The rules are explicitly directed by these parents and are…

    • 1291 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Compare and Conttrast

    • 1065 Words
    • 5 Pages

    General Statement – A father is a man who teaches their child right from wrong, and also teaches them with morals and respect.…

    • 1065 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    With this in mind it is important to examine the role of fathers in the same way as we…

    • 2110 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Defense of Marriage Act

    • 924 Words
    • 4 Pages

    The Defense of Marriage Act is an act that was passed in 1996, making it illegal for the federal government to recognize same sex marriages. The sanctity of marriage between a man and woman should be protected because children need a male and female role model in their lives, children will start to be taught that homosexuality is actually a good thing, and it will keep the traditional definition of marriage in tact.…

    • 924 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The alarm clock goes off, time to get ready for school. That’s the Monday through Friday routine for most parents and children. Weekends consist of either sleeping in or running errands. A child without a mother or a child without a father struggles throughout their life. It is very important that once parents make the choice to have a child that they realize the responsibilities that they will have upon their child’s arrival. Caring for a child starts from the day it is formed in the wound and never ends. Statistics show that children with both a motherly and fatherly influence are more successful.…

    • 723 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays