Siegel Case Summary

Good Essays
The case of Siegel, et al. v. Ford Motor Company is a class action suit brought around by older managers who indicated the company 's performance appraisal system unethically targeted them for termination due to their age. AARP assisted as co-counsel for the case which aids over four-hundred elder supervisors working with Ford Motor Company. The plaintiffs proclaim that senior administration established the system to remove older managers (US Newswire, 2002). The claim is that by constantly receiving the lowermost rating on the performance management scale, elder managers were methodically forced out of their employment.

“Organizations establish performance management systems to meet three broad purposes: strategic, administrative, and
…show more content…
Such systems often include the use of rating or ranking levels in which each employee is positioned. These systems often use quotas to place a part of top performers at the peak level and the worst performers at the bottom level. Such a system is considered to eradicate those within the organization who constantly perform below par. The system is able to work if employees are mindful of the standards for which they are graded in advance, so they can make the required modifications. It can also remove those inside the organization who are either not appropriate for precise jobs or simply lack the skills and abilities to execute their jobs efficiently (Myers, …show more content…
Managers getting a C grade lost bonuses, pay raises, and faced conceivable termination, if a C was received two consecutive years. The plaintiffs assert an unbalanced amount of older managers received a C rating (US Newswire, 2002). Disparate impact was the foundation of this particular law suit. Plaintiffs state Ford Motor Company senior management formulated a performance appraisal system in which one group of particular people were affected in a more negative manner than the others (Myers, 2003). Disparate impact is a concept brought about in 1971, in the case of Griggs v. Duke Power Company, explained in the Title VII of the Civil Rights Act 1964 (HR Guide, 2012). It disallows professional practices affecting employees that may not appear as deliberate actions of discrimination, but are discriminatory in operation.

The Siegel, et al. v. Ford Motor Company case embodies an illustration of how performance management systems can be misrepresented or abused. In many cases, large companies are simply trying to rid themselves of those not performing or those who show an unlikely ability to develop their performance over time. Employees who are not productive can significantly increase the operational expenses and can even have a damaging impact on employee morale and job gratification, if others are obligated to work with such employees for a long time

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    The general function of performance management systems in organizations is for employers to manage employees’ performance and development by providing individual feedback on their performance evaluation to identify and plan measurable areas for personal development to ensure the organization’s strategic goals are being met (DeCenzo and Robbins, 2007). For years, many organizations provided appraisal type performance reviews to their employees that ranked them against other employees. This type of ranking system is problematic, as it is unfair to compare employees from different departments who’s primary goals may be different from one another and can viewed as putting down employees who may be unable to put in as many hours or as much effort as others who have only one set project at a time and can bog down to set higher numbers. If employee development is not properly measured and managed, the organization may find it difficult to meet their strategic goals. This in turn can create complications between mainstream workers and management, as well as the company, and their customers.…

    • 1442 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In this case the city of Jackson Mississippi put into place a new pay plan for police officers and in revising its employee pay plan, the city granted raises to all police officers and police dispatchers in an attempt to bring their starting salaries up to the regional average. Officers with less than five years ' service received proportionately greater raises than those with more seniority, and most officers over 40 had more than five years of service. A group of older officers, filed suit under the Age Discrimination in Employment Act of 1967 (ADEA), claiming that they were adversely affected by the plan because of their age. The District Court granted the City summary judgment. The Fifth Circuit affirmed that judgment ruling that disparate-impact claims are categorically unavailable under the ADEA. The decision of Fifth Circuit assumed that the facts alleged by the older officers would entitle them to relief under Griggs v. Duke Power Co., 401 U.S. 424, which announced a disparate-impact theory of recovery for cases brought under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964 (Title VII).…

    • 1721 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    The year 1971 played a significant role in the shaping of American laws regarding employee discrimination in the form of disparate impact illustrated by the U.S. Supreme Court case Griggs vs. Duke Power Co (401 US 424). Up until the 1970’s, Duke Power Plant was paying their highest black employees less than the lowest paid white person in any other department. As well, right after Title VII became effective Duke Power Co. implemented certain requirements for employment along with possible department transfers for blacks only. The…

    • 1032 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the Supreme Court case, Griggs v. Duke Power Company (Duke), it was decided that Duke used a selection process which had a disparate impact on the employment opportunities of members of a race, color, religion, sex, or national origin group. Disparate impact is sometimes confusing and tricky. In the case of the Albemarle Paper Company (Albemarle) v. Moody, proved just how tricky disparate impact is. Albemarle administered tests without validating them before they were administered because it was too expensive. However, Albemarle did attempt to prove their case through a private company before their court date. Subsequently, Albemarle were not able to…

    • 315 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Many elderly Americans decide to retire at around age sixty-five, and many have chosen to say in the labor force well beyond retirement age. A reason for this many be that better health now allows people who want to work, to stay in the labor force (Macionis, 2005). Aging Americans face considerable economic discrimination, especially in the workplace (Falk & Falk, 1997). For example, older workers are sometimes fired regardless of their job performance or passed over for promotions in favor of younger employees (Falk & Falk, 1997). I have seen first hand, a man named Mo, whom I currently work with, fired from a position because the budget no longer allowed for his high salary, after 55 years experience in the particular field in which he is considered a subject matter expert, Mo was asked to leave by not being told he was leaving because the budget could no longer afford him, but by being told he was no longer able to understood today’s workforce.…

    • 1105 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Employment Law Paper

    • 820 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Age discrimination occurs when someone of a certain age or age group is denied hiring or a promotion because of their age. “The age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA) prohibits employers of 20 or more people from refusing to hire, paying less to, discharging, or otherwise discriminating, against employees because of their age” (Barnes, Dworkin, Richards, 2003, p 374). There are only 16 employees in the age range of 50-59 and 5 employees in the 60 and over category. There are also only 27 employees in the age range of 18-29 with none of these employees being executives. The other categories 30-39 and 40-49 have the most number of employees with 41 and 36 respectively. As a manager the ethical and legal obligation to the employee is to offer equal jobs for everyone in the work place who is capable of doing the job. At the same time, management should not force employees who are older to retire if the employee is not ready to retire. While employers cannot force an employee to retire if they are capable of completing the job, they can expect an employee to retire early for inability to perform the job.…

    • 820 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Business Management

    • 463 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Ineffective performance management programs can leave employers vulnerable for claims of discrimination because employees like to compare achievements and if one or more feels they've achieved more but has been praised less may feel discriminated against.…

    • 463 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Employment discrimination occurs when an employee is rebuked based on factors that have no bearing on job performance. Traits such as race, religion, gender, and national origin are all elements that can be the basis of discrimination in hiring, firing, promotion, and other employment decisions. Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act integrates the two principles of disparate treatment and disparate impact. Disparate treatment is when an employee is treated differently due to the factors mentioned above. Whereas disparate impact specifies the broader scope of employer policies that yield a negative impact on many employees with the traits mentioned above.…

    • 356 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The disparate impact theory requires a plaintiff to demonstrate that an apparently neutral employment practice affects one group more harshly than another and that the practice is not justified by business necessity. A prima face case is established when the plaintiff identifies a specific employment practice to be challenged; and through relevant statistical analysis proves that the challenged practice has an adverse impact on a protected group. When it comes to the case, discrimination was seen, but never affects more than one…

    • 1228 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Firstly, performance management mainly focus on results rather than activities and behaviors. According to employee there is a common misconception among their supervisors that behavior and activities are same as results. Due to this misconception, one employee might appear to be extremely busy, but not to be contributing at all towards the goals of the organization. For an example an employee who manually receives stock and do all the procurement work may appear to be busy compared to an employee who comes out thousands of billings everyday by system. The supervisor may conclude that the employee who does manual works are very committed to organization and thus desires a very high performance rating. But due to performance management policies these things are figured out and each employee get what they…

    • 727 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A manager rating an employee more severely than their work performance merits will create a frustrated and disgruntled employee. Workers will resent the unfair assessment of their performance. The opposite is also true, if a manager rates an employee more favourably than their performance merits “cheats them and the department of the benefits of exploring areas for improvement and the opportunities for developing and coaching” (MacKenzie, 2013)…

    • 865 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Ageism in the Workplace

    • 3527 Words
    • 15 Pages

    Ageism can happen to anyone, young or old. Many times when discussing Ageism or age discrimination, most people consider older generations as those affected, but the reality is that younger generations can be affected by Ageism as well. Ageism is growing in America today, and there are many significant issues that are being associated with this form of discrimination. The purpose of this paper is to define Ageism and who is being affected by it. Those affected are experiencing a wide array of issues that can ultimately have serious and sometimes fatal consequences. Ageism is not something that cannot be cured, and there are definitely ways to overcome it. Ways to combat this problem, include education and mentoring. This paper will outline many different opportunities within these two areas and ultimately conclude with recommendations for organizational management to combat the growing issue of Ageism.…

    • 3527 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ageism

    • 776 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The Age Discrimination in Employment Act, or the A.D.E.A., was passed to protect workers forty years of age and older form being fired because of their age and replaced with younger workers who presumably would receive lower salaries. The Supreme Court strengthened federal protection against age discrimination in 1996, saying unanimously that such lawsuits can be successful even if an older worker is replaced by one who s older than forty years old. So, even if a firm unfairly fires a sixty five year old man to make way for a forty five year old, it is still age discrimination (Schaefer, 2004). It is said that prior to the enactment of the A.D.E.A., there was evidence of hiring discrimination against…

    • 776 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Employee Performance

    • 1934 Words
    • 8 Pages

    The general function of performance management is to provide a process that delivers a fair and accurate account of individual employee performance within an organization. Appraisal systems of any type generally provide assessment that is often viewed as judgment over a particular individual’s performance for a particular period of time. Such a system, or process is best practiced with goals are set in the beginning, and then followed up with feedback regarding the outcome of the goals current status. Growth of the individual within the organization is the ultimate desire of such a system, and such growth of the individual will not end until employment with the company in question no longer exists. Provided goals may come as part of a set of different functions within a job description that the individual needs to accomplish or improve upon, or the goals might be more tailored to the…

    • 1934 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Owbpa Pros And Cons

    • 164 Words
    • 1 Page

    Congress passed the Older Workers Benefit Protection Act (OWBPA) in 1990 which revised the Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA) to defend older workers’ employee benefits from age discrimination. The OWBPA necessitates employers to follow a firm timeline to get a valid release of any age discrimination claims. The OWBPA also entails employers to deliver additional and thorough information when two or more employees are terminated at or around the same time. Increasingly, a number of companies have persuaded their older workers to retire earlier than anticipated by offering a seemingly generous retirement package. As a condition granting a generous early retirement incentive, employers have required that the employees…

    • 164 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays