top-rated free essay

Self, Society, Relationships, and Such: Analysis of Edith Wharton's The Age of Innocence

By Leroy-Zhang Oct 13, 2013 1274 Words
The Age of Innocence: Self, Society, Relationships, and Such
Edith Wharton, in her novel The Age of Innocence, addresses the relationships between self, others, and society in Old New York. In order to fully understand the purpose of this novel, one must contextualize these fictional relations to real-life conditions. As Edith Wharton said herself, "no novel worth anything can be anything but a novel ‘with a purpose,’ and if anyone who cared for the moral issue did not see in my work that I care for it, I should have no one to blame but myself." Thus, the goal of this essay is to examine the larger implications of the societal relations present in the novel.

It is necessary for one to realize Edith Wharton's motives for composing the novel and to consider the historical context under which it was written. The Age of Innocence was published in 1920, precisely two years after the First World War ended. The novel itself, however, is set in the 1870's in Old New York, That organized society contrasted drastically from American society during the post-war era. Another experience that could have influenced Wharton's prose was her childhood. Her parents raised her in a society strikingly similar to the aristocratic culture featured in the novel. Wharton witnessed dramatic social change, especially with the tragic and perspective-transforming experience of World War I. Wharton also dealt with marriage and commitment issues in her adulterous and unfaithful husband who was older than her by 13 years. Not only did her life experiences compel the themes in the story (personal freedom, past vs. present, appearance vs. reality), but more importantly, they shaped the moral instruction embedded in the literature.

The three most prominent characters in the novel are Newland Archer, May Welland, and Ellen Olenska. Newland and May, products of New York society, are an engaged couple. Both come from high-status families. Ellen is May's cousin who lived in Europe before traveling to the United States to escape from her adulterous husband. Most of the story is framed through Newland's perspective. As a result, much of the personal conflict presented in the novel is within Newland. His internal conflicts come largely from his relationship with Ellen. Newland is captivated by her charisma and demeanor, so unlike that of the rest of the population of New York society. He ends up falling in love with Ellen, a feeling he perceives as clandestine but that is actually quite the opposite. Throughout the novel, Newland attempts, to no avail, to break free from the grasp and duties of his society. He is bound by the societal expectations around him, evident in the way he abides by social norms such as performing all the conventional duties before marrying May or fulfilling the role of a gentleman. He also feels the need, as he is trained to do, to confess to May everything he has done. A good example is the time he is compelled instinctively to send yellow roses to Ellen: he confesses to May his actions. Most importantly, Newland is unable to break the bonds of conventionality even later in his life. Unable to push himself to approach Ellen at Newport, he instead convinces himself to go back "if she doesn't turn before that sail crosses the Lime Rock" (217). Yet, even after all of these "setbacks," Newland still becomes "what people were beginning to call 'a good citizen'" (346). He reflects back on his life and finds that:

[His] long years together [with May] had shown him that it did not so much matter if marriage was a dull duty, as long as it kept the dignity of a duty: lapsing from that, it became a mere battle of ugly appetites. Looking about him, he honoured his own past, and mourned for it. After all, there was good in the old ways. (347) It is clear that fidelity to these duties is admirable with potentially beneficial social consequences.

Wharton uses Newland Archer to edify her readers on a deeper meaning in human nature. Immanuel Kant, an 18th and 19th century philosopher, came up with ideas of self comparable to what Wharton is trying to imply. Kant lays out several significant ideas. First is the ethical theory of Deontology, and of course along with it, the Categorical Imperative. Deontology deals not with the consequences of an action but primarily with the action itself and a set of absolute moral duties that one must abide by in order to be ethical. The categorical imperative states that a duty must be universal without producing any internal contradictions, must treat humans as ends in themselves rather than means to an end, and must operate from a place of absolute moral authority. This may all seem besides the point but if we examine these points closely, we can see a correlation. The categorical imperative, if it were to be obeyed and implemented, dictates that there should be an absolute set of moral codes to be complied with by everyone, similar to the strict codes by which Newland Archer's culture abides. The second substantial interpretation that Kant, Berkeley, and many other philosophers proposed was the idea of empiricism and transcendental idealism. These two philosophies essentially state that the world can only exist as a perception. In fact, the latter of these philosophies separates the world into two entities, phenomena and noumena. Phenomena are the experiences that humans can grasp and categorize through their senses. Noumena are "things" that humans cannot really understand. Kant emphasizes that humans should not waste time trying to uncategorize the phenomena and reveal the noumenal world since it is extremely difficult if not impossible to do so. Basically the idea is don't worry about ideas, objects, events, etc. outside of your experience. Bring the idea of transcendental idealism into the context of the phenomenal world itself, the noumena can be seen as the outside world that Newland and his society cannot perceive. These two philosophical ideas do not correlate strongly with Wharton's explicit message but have important ramifications for her underlying implications. Kant's idea of self promotes individualism but in a strict moral context.

Edith Wharton was disturbed by the transformation of the society she personally experienced. A prominent theme of the novel is the juxtaposition of the past, the present, and the end of New York society as Newland and the rest of the characters know it. Newland had been aware of these societal expectations and values "ever since he could remember, and accepted them as part of the structure of his universe" (102). Yet, even in Newland's youth, the society is dying off. The elderly couple of the Van der Luydens are the last of their kind. The title The Age of Innocence is not ironic in this sense. Even though the society is full of hypocrisy and hidden meanings, it is still an age of innocence because after all, as George Berkeley said, "to be is to be perceived." Furthermore, Edith Wharton shows through Newland Archer that a product of this type of society can still become a moral compass or role model for others.

The Age of Innocence is a novel in that demonstrates the progression of a character through an innocent society -- or at least one with the veneer of innocence. The deep moral real-life implications of what Wharton communicates can be theoretically represented by and related to Immanuel Kant's philosophical ideals. Through the use of relationships between self and society in the characters of the story, primarily Newland Archer, Edith Wharton mourns and perhaps even warns against, the societal changes she experiences throughout her life and the societal changes that could come in the future.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Age of Innocence Character Analysis

    ...CHARACTER ANALYSIS Newland Archer As the protagonist of the novel, Newland Archer's point of view governs its narration. He is said to be a dilettante at the beginning of the novel, someone who amateurishly enjoys the pleasurable and delicate sensations that are the luxury of the members of the ruling class. He is respectable and seems to ha...

    Read More
  • Similarities of Edith Wharton's Life and Her Books, Age of Innocence and Ethan Frome

    ...Alex Mardaga Koharchik English 1 Honors 6 March, 2013 Age of Innocence and Ethan Frome essay Edith Warthon was born in New York City into a very wealthy family. She was forced into a loveless marriage and eventually fell in love with another man. Her life closely resembles the two books she wrote--Age of Innocence and Ethan Frome. Age ...

    Read More
  • Metaphor Analysis of the Age of Innocence

    ...Metaphor Analysis Performance The novel opens at the opera, aptly introducing the recurring metaphor of performance, or keeping up an appearance of correct and moral behavior, whatever the reality might be. Julius Beaufort is an example of someone who manages to do this until the end of the novel, when he is unmasked and ostracized. Co...

    Read More
  • Edith Wharton's Ethan Frome: Analysis

    ...The novel Ethan Frome by Edith Wharton is a tragedy of a small town farmer that falls in love with his distant cousin. The story revolves mostly around the protagonist Ethan Frome, as his life becomes a living hell. He develops into a very interesting character as he faces difficult decisions to run away with the love of his life, Mattie Silver....

    Read More
  • The Age of Innocence by Edith Wharton

    ...his needs-tender and impressionable, with equal purity of mind and manners. The engagement was announced discreetly, but all of New York society was soon privy to this most perfect match, a union of families and circumstances cemented by affection. Enter Countess Olenska, a woman of quick wit sharpened by experience, not afraid to flout...

    Read More
  • The Age of Innocence

    ...fantasies The Age of Innocence by Edith Wharton is a book that gave the word "love" many other meanings, such as impossible, meaningless and incomplete. There were many unbearable obstacles that Countess Ellen Olenska, one of the main characters, had to face because of love. She was treated badly by many people and always longed for love but ne...

    Read More
  • Age of Innocence

    ...‘leave-taking from Madame Olenska’. This also foreshadows the relationship and the romantic interest of Ellen Olenska, drawing similarities between lovers parting and his own departure with Ellen. 3. From the entire passage what is being suggested about his desires and pretensions? Recurring theme of Newland’s Idealism What –...

    Read More
  • the age of innocence Wharton implies indirectly that this letter indicates that the Countess has had an illicit affair. He now feels pity for Ellen Olenska and decides that it is necessary for him to protect her from further damaging her own reputation, which would be devastated if it were revealed that she had been unfaithful to her husband. That evening,...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.