Kincaid's "On Seeing England for the First Time"
In this essay titled, On Seeing England for the First Time Jamaica Kincaid subtly argues that
England's vain dominating presence, produced from the common admiration for England, played a
negative role in her life. Kincaid develops this claim of England by battling the reality of England versus
her childhood idea of England. Since this is the beginning of her work not only is the purpose to entice
the reader but to also inform them of the "reality" of England which conquered her lifestyle and inhibited
her natural growing culture. Kincaid writes in a serious, somber tone for people who also feel
dominated by England or another culture.
Questions for Discussion:
1. What is ironic about the author's words, "Seeing England for the First Time" is that in reality
neither is she really looking at England nor is this her first encounter with England. The author is
only looking at a map of England, not the people or lively culture. Also, the author describes
throughout the paragraphs the huge role of England in her life. Including the presence at her
family breakfast table and most importantly the relationship between her father and his English
hat.
2. In paragraph four Kincaid's words, "I had long ago been conquered" refers to the huge and
dominating role of England in her life. Where as the people in her life constantly regard England
Jensen 2
as the highest of the high and the source of all final judgment in her life. The large presence and
highly regarded culture of another country in her own land hinders Kincaid in a dominating way,
making her feel unimportant and small.
3. The authors talks largely about the British influence in her life, especially in regard to marketable
items. In paragraph two Kincaid talks about her family breakfast and the many foods which
come from England. The most basic parts of her, her shoes, her clothes, and her father's
clothes all contain the words, "Made in England."
Questions on Rhetoric and Style:
1. The use of parallelism in Kincaid's excerpt is prominent and helps argue her point of the
beautiful versus ugly, or more specifically, the reality versus ideal part of Europe. For example,
"England was a special jewel all right, and only special people got to wear it." This lets the
reader see England as a special place, but then author takes it back as a conceited statement.
2. The mutton simile produces an ungraceful image of England. However, when she retracts that
same simile by saying, "It could not really look like anything so familiar…" this makes the
reader question as to why she would compare England to something as brute and ungraceful as
an animal leg and then retract it saying that mutton is too familiar. This produces a confusing
image of a country that looks better than it really is.
3. The use of listing can be seen in paragraph two when talking about her breakfast and clothes.
In this listing she talks without passion or a personal opinion which makes the reader stop and
grabs their attention. The use of listing, since there is no passion, also gives it a somber tone and
sort of power of knowledge.
You May Also Find These Documents Helpful
-
A response essay to Kincaid’s article According to Jamaica Kincaid’s article, seeing things or going to new places for the first time can be exciting. But Kincaid gives us a view on personal opinions and thoughts on the reality of England. Also her purpose in writing this piece was to inform us how the people of England made them feel superior to the settlers in British colonies. Ever her tone has been criticized and angry.…
- 346 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
Now I shall talk about her childhood in particular and show how this might have had an impact on her later life. From what I have read she was a strong-minded, stubborn girl who always asked questions from her own curiosity but never had any answers for them as her aunt always said “Instead of asking these silly questions you should be focusing on what any other normal and civilised girl would wonder, what we are going to have for pudding today.” From this quote the life of a woman in those days is revealed. Obviously women in that time still weren’t treated as equals to the men. While the men worked and discussed intellectual and political debate and all the interesting and educational side of matters, women and girls were led down the path of being an obedient house wife. While the men went out and earned a living, women were meant to stay at home,…
- 2052 Words
- 9 Pages
Powerful Essays -
Elizabeth I is a one of the main known rulers of England. She brought in the “Golden Age” of Britannia. Many books that are written about Elizabeth chronologically tell about her decisions and how they affect England and the rest of Europe. Most of the books are biographies but, Christopher Haigh’s book Elizabeth I is not merely a biography but a detailed account on how Elizabeth and the people around her influenced each other and how that affected Elizabeth’s reign. In Christopher Haigh’s book Elizabeth I: Profiles in Power, his main argument and thesis is that Elizabeth had to play a dangerous game throughout her life and rule to keep England balanced with illusion.…
- 650 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
3. Kincaid regards the British influence under which she was raised through the British lifestyle her community tries to imitate and her school education. She mentions that most people at where she was raised attempt to live as British as possible, including her own parents. In paragraph 2, Kincaid says that her father really likes hats with the British style, so he wears hats that are made in England all the time, and “it was the first thing he put on in the morning as he stepped out of bed and the last thing he took off before he stepped back into bed at night”. Besides the British influence in lifestyle, Kincaid also regards the British impact on her education at school.…
- 578 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The two texts, Letters to Alice and Pride and Prejudice, mirror and contrast the central values shared and explored by evaluating them; presenting them against Jane Austen's context and that of Fay Weldon. Mirroring Austen's novel, Weldon presents the central values for women such as the social values of moral behaviour, independence, and, literary values of reading and writing, from Pride and Prejudice and adapts them to a 20th Century context. Weldon's novel's subtitle, On First Reading Jane Austen, suggests that the novel should serve as a filter to assist readers. The implication of this is that Weldon enables her readers to identify more fully the significance of Jane Austen as a writer, and, the significance of Pride and Prejudice as a piece of literature, exploring the ongoing relevance of its values concerning women.…
- 1502 Words
- 7 Pages
Powerful Essays -
The 6th document shows this by inferring that she has strong optimism in her leadership capabilities. She talked to Parliament and basically said that they cannot do anything without her approval. When she says she already found a husband she meant that her one true love is the nation of England and she will do whatever it takes to protect it. she is proving her devotion to her country. (Document 11).…
- 797 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Was the Character and Influence of Anne Boleyn the main reason for the English Reformation?…
- 756 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays -
Kincaid also talks about the way she was educated; at school the first thing that she had learned was the England map. It looked like a leg of mutton for her. Also, she used to sing hymns and recited poems about England. When she was a child, she knew so many things about England, but she had never been in England at that time.…
- 676 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
* Her literary background/parental influence encouraged her to act outside social expectations, ahead of her times, non-conservative & challenges prevailing social conservationism…
- 1117 Words
- 5 Pages
Good Essays -
Source: Chinua Achebe, "Benin Road," Collected Poems (2004; Random House for High School Teachers Web site), http://www.randomhouse.com/highschool/catalog/display.pperl?isbn=9781400076581&view=excerpt (accessed October 11, 2007).…
- 392 Words
- 2 Pages
Satisfactory Essays -
In the excerpt from the essay “On Seeing England for the first Time” the author Jamaica Kincaid describes life in Antigua when it was an English colony. Antigua was first colonized by English settlers in 1632 and achieved its independence until 1981. There was an immense British cultural influence in the island, which Kincaid shows in her essay. In the essay Kincaid reveals her defiance for England’s imposed presence in Antigua by comparing other’s conformity to England´s way of life to her own subtle defiance.…
- 936 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
The first of these section runs from lines 1-20, here the speaker sets out his thesis that if ‘Had we but world enough, and time’ (l.1) he would not rush the process of courtship and admiration. The speaker establishes a world unconfined by time and space by using the word ‘had’ to create the subjunctive tense. This passage is highly ironic however as the speaker is conscious that this is purely a theoretical state before he even speaks the words, he deviously lays out his persuasion knowing the impossibility of his proclamations. The speaker aims not only to flatter but also to impress the mistress using rich imagery. To compliment, but also to amaze with his geographical knowledge, the speaker refers to the River Humber and the Ganges River (ll.5-7) to emphasise the distance he would supposedly endure without her if time permitted. The exotic imagery of Asia is inline with British exploration and trade with the region and provides an escape from the relatively bland image of everyday life in England at the time even if the image of the East was unrealistic.…
- 1430 Words
- 6 Pages
Better Essays -
"I know I have the body but of a weak and feeble woman; but I have the heart and stomach of a king..." - Fierce words from Queen Elizabeth as she addresses her troops with an encouraging speech. As she and her soldiers await the upcoming battles, she gives a confident speech to motivate their fire. Daringly, the Queen stands in a position that delivers assurance to her troops, convincing them of a future victory against their foes. Her intonation: fierce. Her purpose: motivation. Her inspiration: England.…
- 427 Words
- 2 Pages
Good Essays -
Considering the fact that a female successor to the throne of England was ascending, there was a tremendous amount of political influence on her reign. The Act of Supremacy (Doc. 3), declared by King Henry VII, assured that Elizabeth would be the rightful heir to the throne of England; this parliamentary act stated that Elizabeth is the most superior being of the realm of her kingdom. Because Henry VIII wanted to break away from the papacy to elevate his status as head of the church and state, the motive for this parliamentary act was to increase the monarchy’s status and establish an independent kingdom of England. Moreover, John Aylmer (Doc. 2) suggests that since Elizabeth does not rule alone, but with the Parliament, there should be no reason to object her rule. Since Aylmer has connections with Elizabeth’s court and a significant influence on the population of the kingdom, he might have written this exert in his pamphlet to soothe the opinions of anti-feminists who blatantly attacked Elizabeth’s reign. Furthermore, Marcus Gheeraerts the Younger (Doc. 8) paints Elizabeth standing on a globe; this shows that her court painter was attempting to win her favor by depicting that Elizabeth had the power in her hands. Similarly, William Clowes (Doc. 10) expresses his devotion to her Majesty. Being that he is her personal surgeon, he might also want to win her favor by praising the queen and gain influence of his own.…
- 708 Words
- 3 Pages
Good Essays -
religion and she had to be careful as to how she was to implement her Protestant ideals without…
- 1239 Words
- 4 Pages
Good Essays