Preview

Secret Sorrow Sorrowful Woman

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
754 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Secret Sorrow Sorrowful Woman
There are many differences between "A Secret Sorrow" and "A Sorrowful Woman". One difference is the problems that the two women face. In "A Secret Sorrow" Faye deals with a physical problem, the inability to produce children. In "A Sorrowful Woman" on the other hand the unnamed wife deals with a psychological problem, making it more complex and difficult to fix. Another difference is the role the men play in the stories. Kai, from "A Secret Sorrow" has a forceful role, he plays the role of the average formula fiction man, he's masculine, strong and tries to save Faye from herself. For instance when Faye told him that he didn't have to be a gentlemen and that it was okay for him to leave her it was interesting when Kai responds with the line "Shut up and stop playing the martyr". He refused to allow herself to give into her insecurities and wallow in self pity. Instead readers constantly see Kai picking Faye up and trying to snap her out of this funk she has slipped into. He spends the entire story trying to force Faye to believe that she is worthy of being loved. The unnamed husband in "A Sorrowful Woman" is the exact opposite of Kai. The unnamed husband is an enabler, always understanding he does not do anything to help his wife get over her problems. Instead he in a way avoids the issue and allows the woman to succumb to her issue eventually resulting in her downfall. It's interesting that Godwin constantly repeats that the husband always understands. It shows that he realizes his wife is having trouble and he wants to help however the way he attempts to help just perpetuates the issue instead of resolving it. He complies with his obviously unhinged wife's demands and behaviors, just understanding not fixing. He allows her to get away with things such as hitting the child, firing the nanny and not doing her household responsibilities. The battle is lost when the husband allows his wife to isolate herself from her family and move into a separate

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    The one element that Godwin really hits on in the short story to strengthen the overall theme is the use of fairy tale aspect. At the beginning of the narrative, Godwin inserts a line before the actual story starts that reads, “Once upon a time there was a wife and mother one too many times” (Meyer 36). In this line, she is trying to put the point across to the reader that this short story will challenge the notion of what women desire. Godwin tries to portray that the wife in her story is not the normal wife and mother, like in most fairy tales. The wife in A Sorrowful Woman resembles the exact opposite of what women in fairy tales were portrayed as. In most fairy tales, the woman usually finds prince charming, gets married, has children and lives happily ever after. She desires to different and hopes for a changed role in society. The reader doesn’t know about the wife and husband’s life before their child’s birth, however some passages presume that she had a…

    • 1253 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Secret Sorrow

    • 717 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Karen Van Der Zee “A Secret Sorrow uses, Characterization, Tone and Irony to show that love is powerful and will heal any hurt. Anyone can say that what you hope for always doesn’t come to past, and then you may lose hope of it ever happening. It is possible to give up and live in despair or even defeat. This is very similar to Karen Van Der Zee, the writer of “A Secret Sorrow portrays in her story. Karen uses the characterization, tone, and irony to show how love is more than a feeling.…

    • 717 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    A Sorrowful Woman

    • 381 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In Gail Godwin's short story, "A Sorrowful Woman", we are introduced to a woman who just as said in the title, is a sorrowful woman. She is described this way because she has some sort of problem mentally and quite often emotionally. She has a three year old son who, just like any other three year old, wants and needs the attention of its mother. She also has a husband, who is loving and very much devoted to her, her needs, and of course, the needs of their child. His undying loyalty towards her says a lot about marriage. When a married couple takes those vowels "Till death do us part", they should really mean it. Those are the words that people in today's society say too often without enough thought. In the story the husband makes a number of efforts to please his wife. He understands that she is sick and needs help. One evening while she was looking at her husband and child she got sick, sad and for some reason after that she didn't want to see them anymore. She told the husband that she didn't want to see them ever again and he, being the understanding spouse that he was, just asked what she wanted him to do. The author, Gail Godwin, is trying to give examples of how a good marriage should work. The wife was usually grumpy and always wanted something and the husband was always willing to help her and make her feel better. Marriage in a real life situation should be the same way. Just as a couple takes those vowels "Till death do us part", they should be willing to do anything to fulfill those words. The husband in this story probably wouldn't have married the sorrowful woman, had he known that she was going to be like that. But he did, and he kept those words because he did whatever he could to please her. The author just wants the readers to see that marriage is a big step and that no one knows what the future holds. If the marriage doesn't go as expected, you must still keep your words and do right by your spouse, even if it is a sorrowful…

    • 381 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Both of the female protagonists in the two stories experience a conflict. In "A Secret Sorrow" Faye 's conflict comes before the marriage. She is struck with misery and torment because she cannot have children and fears that this will prevent her from marrying the man she loves. Both she and her beloved, Kai, desire marriage with children, and van der Zee suggests that only with these things will they truly be happy. Faye feels that her inability to have children is a fatal flaw that cuts her off from Kai 's love. "Every time we see some pregnant woman, every time we 're with somebody else 's children I 'll feel I 've failed you!" (Zee 35). Faye 's anxiety and fear are based on the thought of losing her beloved Kai, accompanied by never having children. In "A Sorrowful Woman," however, the conflict comes after the marriage, when the woman has already secured her husband and child. Unlike Faye, who would be ecstatic in this woman 's situation, the protagonist of Godwin 's story is not. Oddly enough, her husband and son bring her such sorrow that eventually she is unable to see them at all, communicating only through notes stuck under her bedroom door. Godwin 's character has a loving husband and child, yet in spite of this,…

    • 1568 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Faye was facing the crisis of her lifetime, where she thought she would not be able to satisfy Kai nor make him happy without giving him the gift of a child and knowing that Kai desperately wanted to have a child with her. For that reason, she feared marrying him. "I can't be what you want me to be. We can't have the kind of life you want...I'm so afraid...you'll be…

    • 1492 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Lonely Woman

    • 1109 Words
    • 3 Pages

    One of your customers has just said to you, “The service here is terrible.” You should say:…

    • 1109 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gertrude “Ma” Rainey, when described in Blue Legacies and Black Feminism, was seen by Angela Davis as one of the greatest feminist blues musicians of her time. One view that Ma Rainey presented in her songs was her ideas on marriage. Specifically, Rainey feels that getting married shouldn’t be valued over “non or extramarital relationships (pg 16- 20). She feels that, while marriage isn’t a bad thing, overvaluing it to the point of presenting it as a need for women to have is a bad thing (pg 16- 20). She presents this theme in many of her works, but presents it most clearly in her work “Misery Blues”, in which, she presents a women truly oppressed by marriage to the point that she was falsely led to a man who promised her marriage, only to renege on his promise (pg 16). Another reason for her devalued…

    • 592 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In a sorrowful woman the mother isn’t comfortable with her role as a wife/mother. Gayle Godwin’s uses a fairy tale stereotype to reflect the mother’s attributes. The mother feels she will fail the family and tries detaching herself from them. Most Fairy tale don’t start or end like this story but she makes a valid point that fairy tales don’t always come true. Likewise, In Separating Richard and Joan’s marriage is ruined because neither of them wants the task of having a family. Both thought differently and neither was happy with their life at their…

    • 646 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Thousands on Bikini Island dead, injured, or infected with life changing diseases after nuclear bombing. As an Islander, learning about this event was very upsetting. Many families were forced out of their homes. President Christopher Loeak, the voice of his people demand justice. Due to the nuclear bombing many have to face the difficulties of homeliness.…

    • 347 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The First Sorrow

    • 610 Words
    • 2 Pages

    ‘The First Sorrow” is written by Franz Kafka, one of the most influential German author of the 20th century. In this story, the trapeze artist was very childlike. This behavior is evident because he is very anti-social, the manager acted like a parent to him and he burst out in tears at the end of the passage while being comforted by the manager.…

    • 610 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Nightingale and the Rose

    • 2628 Words
    • 11 Pages

    Someone has written to ask me to contribute to an anthology of stories for children. I reply that I don’t write children’s stories; and he writes back that at a recent congress/book fair/ seminar a certain novelist said every writer ought to write at least one story for children. I think of sending a postcard saying I don’t accept that I “ought” to write anything.…

    • 2628 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Readers Response

    • 403 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The Mortal Immortal was quite different than past assigned readings for several reasons. First, it was a short story rather than a long-winded, descriptive novel. This appealed to me because that, in itself, shows a turn to the modern side of literature. Gone are the days of praising the sublime and merely hinting at characters emotions. More presently, audiences want to be quickly brought into the action, and to experience a high level of energy and enjoyment throughout the entire work. The Mortal Immortal is the first story to present this emotional intensity. I believe this is correctly executed through its first person point of view. In other readings, the protagonists was often non-discript and shallow. This choice of narration allows the reader inside the protagonist's head and reveals inner thoughts and desires. In this way, it is much easier to identify and, in the case of Winzy, empathize with. I couldn't help but feel deeply sorry for Winzy and Bertha as their different circumstances caused the aging process to be so painful. In a way, this unrealistic tale does shed light on a true theme. Love is something that most people don't believe they fully understand. In Mortal Immortal, it correctly presents young love as strong infatuation where both partners will stop at nothing to obtain affection. As a married couple ages, love changes again, and in a way, this story is representing that theme. This seemed an interesting choice to me at first, but after looking at it under the gothic heading, I was able to find some gothic themes. First, and most obvious, there is a female entrapped in a castle and oppressed by some higher authority she cannot overcome. Winzy seeks out Bertha just like any hero from the typical gothic novel. Themes of supernatural are present, but seem rather unexplained. I found it interesting that up until this point, most of the assigned readings had endings that answered all previous inquires and explained any…

    • 403 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Karen Van Der Zee’s “A Secret Sorrow” is a novel that definitely knows how to play with words. Its writing is dramatic and intensely emotional, moving quickly from soft words to shouts of anger. This might be an intense and gripping moment for some, but I was put off by its generic, soap style plot. Faye does not want to tell Kai that she cannot have children, but after refusing to marry, Kai is persistent to get at the truth. The style and content of the novel’s writing definitely caught my attention. It has a great use of loud tones and catchy lines. Some will enjoy Kai telling Faye that she is “’Not a damaged piece of merchandise, you hear? You’re a living, breathing human being, a warm-blooded female, and I love you’.”(135) It’s when I'm sucked in that this novel falls apart. The plot is overly simplistic. The characters are bland and lifeless. Faye lacks female leadership, confidence, and anything else of interest, which leads to groans whenever she talks of how she “can’t live all [her] life with [Kais] regret and disappointment’” “‘every time [they’re] with somebody else’s children She’ll feel She’s failed [Kai]!” It was a good ride, but in the end, I feel unsatisfied. A Secret Sorrow will please those who don’t mind the intense soap style drama, but if a person doesn’t like romance, this won’t change her mind.…

    • 256 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sorrow of Young Werther

    • 1684 Words
    • 7 Pages

    Death has been the consequent for the main characters in each of the first four novels read for the course. The protagonist in each of the first four novels; Werther, Rafael, Ivan Ilyich, and K., respectively; met their demise on the final page of their respective novels. All four directly or indirectly were the cause of their painful demise. Werther chose suicide over conforming to the ways of adulthood, and moving further away from nature. Rafael chose to live a life of possessions, and in turn, his inner-self dwindled. Ivan Ilyich alienated himself from those around him, and hid behind the aristocratic social mask. Finally, Joseph K. causes his won demise by being a puppet of society, conforming to all rules, and to his own sense of guilt. Ivan Ilyich was the only character to somewhat remedy the situation before slipping into the darkness of death. In all cases, the actions of the lives of all four protagonists very clearly displayed their weaknesses as characters.…

    • 1684 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    tragic-comedy

    • 280 Words
    • 1 Page

    Tragic-Comedy as its name implies is half tragedy and half comedy. The harmonious blending of Tragedy and Comedy is called Tragic Comedy. It is entirely different from Tragedy and Comedy. It is a form by itself. In a Tragedy the function of comedy is to heighten the effect of tragedy. And the tragic background in a comedy will intensify comic effect in a comedy. But a Tragic-Comedy is a separate and unique genre with its own features.…

    • 280 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays