Preview

Salad Bowl vs Melting Pot

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
332 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Salad Bowl vs Melting Pot
Salad Bowl vs. Melting Pot There have been many to question and many so called answers to the merging of America and its different citizens. One cannot choose which term is better than the other; they both serve the same cause just in a different example. Along with this perspective, however, there is another expression that describes the diversity of people in America. It tends to be interpreted in the same way as the “melting pot,” but actually has a slightly different meaning with a different way of approaching and explaining American society. In comparison with the “melting pot” theory, there is the “salad bowl” theory. This idea demonstrates a complete separate perspective that the newcomers bring different cultures, where each of these cultures is kept as an essential part to make up the whole. Every distinctive culture or belief is considered to be one of the tastes or ingredients that contributes in forming the whole; therefore its original shape and characteristics are maintained. Whether to apply the term “melting pot” or the term “salad bowl” to the American multiethnic conditions brings about a large discussion and controversy. In a way, both serve as an effective and successful metaphor, despite their slight difference. Anyone who is accustomed to an extremely homogeneous society would be simply astonished after recognizing many faces with different physical features in America, and might praise the country by employing those two terms in topic. The ideas of the “melting pot” and the “salad bowl” in America both connote somewhat of an ideal to many people and are often admired. Having a close look at the reality of the country, such as the existing ethnic segregation, the fact of the white population fleeing away from the minority poverty, and the trend of the minority group forming an enclave, however, one can see that the “melting pot” theory is merely a myth, and despite its long fame, it is rather more suitable to label America as a

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Therefore, with confidence, I can say that America is neither a “melting pot” nor a “mosaic.” Though many different cultures have flocked to America, America’s intolerance for diversity is obvious; someone who is culturally different will never be able to walk down an American street without stares. More appalling, however, is the fact that those who are culturally different will face job discrimination if they choose to express their identity instead of cover it. Even on my own campus, diversity is seen as unimportant, as our diversity funding is stripped from underneath us. America will never be a melting pot nor a mosaic until it can learn to accept its own diversity, allowing it to flourish instead of killing it off on its arrival. In today’s political climate, it would make me incredibly happy to see America open its arms to other cultures instead of attempting to shut them out completely. Again, it seems as if history is repeating itself as we travel down a path of a non-inclusive America, disregarding the plight of cultural minorities for the majority’s “gain,” forgetting the importance of multiculturalism and marching towards…

    • 583 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One nation being universalistic, the other particularistic. Lipset’s facts regarding total melting pot versus mosaic has gotten very mixed in todays’ societies. The concept of the American Dream is one that many, including non-Americans are familiar with, as it is seen in movies, magazines and other media outlets. The idea that success and prosperity will be achieved through hard work within a functioning society with few barriers is one that immigrants quickly and willingly have adapted to. They begin to identify as an American first and put their original nationality second. This ultimately leads to a concept called assimilation, the process of immigrants integrating themselves into a new community and also losing some, if not all aspects of their own heritage as well. Ruben Rumbaut explains assimilation on different levels: “At the group level, assimilation may involve the absorption of one or many minority groups into the mainstream, or the merging of minority groups —e.g., second-generation West Indians “becoming black Americans.” At the individual level, assimilation denotes the cumulative changes that make individuals of one ethnic group more acculturated, integrated and identified with the members of another” (Smelser and Baltes, 82). This is a process…

    • 737 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The culture of the United States of America is essentially Western, yet is affected by African, Native American, Asian, Polynesian, and Latin American societies. A strand of what might be portrayed as American society began its development once again 10,000 years back with the movement of Paleo-Indians from Asia, Oceania, and Europe, into the district that is today the mainland United States. The United States of America has its own particular one of a kind social and social attributes, for example, tongue, social propensities, music, expressions, legends and food. The United States of America is an ethnically and racially various nation as an aftereffect of vast scale relocation…

    • 411 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Melting Pot

    • 6314 Words
    • 26 Pages

    The melting pot has been used metaphorically to describe the dynamics of American social life. In addition to its descriptive uses, it has also been used to describe what should or should not take place in American social life. How did the term originate? How was it used originally? How is it used in contemporary society? What are some problems with the idea of the melting pot? How is public education connected to the idea of the melting pot? How does the melting pot function in American cultural and political ideology? These are some of the questions considered in the following discussion.…

    • 6314 Words
    • 26 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Melting Pot Analysis

    • 394 Words
    • 2 Pages

    “God is making the American.” In Israel Zangwill’s The Melting Pot, America is concerned as the new world. Zangwill wrote the play in the early nineteen hundreds when immigration to the Americas was sufficiently increasing. Many Americans were against the idea of so many different people entering ‘their’ country; while immigrants saw the Americas as a place to which they had spent their whole lives coming. In The Melting Pot, immigration causes a rift in those residing in America.…

    • 394 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout history many ethnic cliques have experienced abuse and distrust from our American society. The people in America seem to be less understanding, and less willing to accept cultures different from their own, at least years ago. Groups such as the Indians, the African Americans, and the Immigrants, fall deeply into this category. The situations and struggles they have gone through are greatly explained in Ronald Takaki’s novel, “A Different Mirror, A History of a Multicultural America.” Although they have experienced a lot, particular financial and social configuration have changed, helping change our perspective of each civilization, for better or even worse.…

    • 1788 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Thomas Pain

    • 1135 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Throughout American history there have been many theories as to the makeup of this diverse nation. One of the most popular refers to America as the “great melting pot,” suggesting that America is a place where all kinds of different cultures and beliefs combine to form a uniquely American identity. Thomas Paine here, however, seems to be more in accord with the “tomato soup” analogy where it states that the essence of American culture is the tomato soup, that is, the so-called “American creed,” a combination of liberty, self-government, social mobility, and economic independence, while other cultures add ingredients and spices to the soup, but do not change its nature as being a pot of tomato soup. Paine suggests that despite the diversity of American population, “the simple operation of constructing government on the principles of society and the rights of man” brings “cordial unison" and serves as the basis of American society as the tomato taste is the basis of the soup. Although his assertion of diversity and the importance of rights of man seems to hold true today, that they continue to bring unity is no longer accurate.…

    • 1135 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Hyphenated American

    • 1082 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Many Americans identify themselves by a hyphenated title. People of these groups were almost all immigrants who moved to United States from their native country. United States of America has been founded on the basis of immigration and refugee. Throughout history, United States has welcomed immigrants from all over the world that came to America in hopes of seeking new life and freedom. Many people describe United States as a “melting pot”, which consist of different culture groups, religion, race, culture, and etc. However, many immigrants who had become American citizens had still referred themselves as Asian-Americans, German-American, Latin-American, and etc. this is because they are no the dominant group in the society stated by Associate Professor of Sociology, Minako Maykovich, “the criteria for physical characteristics are generally determined by the dominant group in society, thus racial difference is the greatest obstacle to the process of assimilation” (68). I am an Asian descendant who has been live in the States for ten years, and I have different views on some of the portrayals of Asian-American.…

    • 1082 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    American Identity Draft

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Even though American Identity cannot be well-defined, terms such as “Melting-Pot” or “Mosaic” are still used to describe this nation society. A Melting–Pot by definition is a pot where different materials are melted and mixed together. As a metaphor it is used to describe all the different people who came together to formed America and became one. A “Mosaic” is used in the same context as well, and it only differs in the broader aspect of a more multiculturalism adaptation. Both terms come close to describe the diversity that the United States is composed of; however, both fail in the idealism that assimilation of this culture take place, and since there is no set standard of an “American” or even a set culture, immigrants have nothing to assimilate to begin with.…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the main ideas of this book, commonly associated with America and the way we live, is that there are a wide range of people living in this country. America has been well known as the "melting pot" of the world. We have many ethnicities and races, and countless cultural differences. Within our melting pot people have different lifestyles and ambitions in life. Some work hard for what they get, and others try to find a quick way of getting what they want.…

    • 576 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In discussions of tossed salad and melting pot, a controversial issue is whether or not tossed salad is better than melting pot. Tossed salad represents multiculturalism. The tossed salad is colorful and it has unique and different ingredients it has the tomatoes, the lettuce, the cucumbers, the red and green and orange bell peppers and other ingredients. Each ingredient has its own unique color, texture and taste. What unites all these ingredients though is the dressing whether it is Italian, French or Ranch. They all come together to be able to form one thing. It is the same thing with a tossed salad society. Being part of a tossed salad means that one lives in a multicultural society in which one could find people of different races and ethnicities. People are of different skin colors. Each culture has there own unique language. Each culture has different ways of dressing and eating. They are able to maintain their culture and grow and become stronger but something still holds all these cultures together. The dream to be able to have a strong and united society. Melting pot on the other hand is a cultural assimilation it is like tomato soup. Many ingredients are used to be able to create the tomato soup but in the end it just has one flavor. All these ingredients are unique in their own way just like the ingredients from the tossed salad. They each have their own texture, taste and color. In the end though all these ingredients just come together and create one flavor that is unique. All the ingredients in one way or another loose their uniqueness, their color and texture and taste. The same thing happens with a melting pot society. Cultures come together to be able to form something new and unique. Each culture, in the beginning, has its own personality. They each have their own believes and languages. Slowly, they joined the melting pot and started to lose their cultural identity and form a new one. They are no longer unique…

    • 2110 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    What does Diversity and Multiculturalism mean to me? I believe that diversity has become so much more than just the basic qualities of race or gender. It now includes all qualities that make everyone unique, as individuals or as part of a larger group. It is also the acceptance, respect, and understanding of these unique qualities that makes diversity work in a given society. Multiculturalism is the system that is centered around the respect for and the promotion of ethnic and or gender diversity in the society. Multiculturalism is the status of several different ethnic, racial, religious or cultural groups co-existing in the same society. Today, in the U.S. we already live in a diverse, multicultural world, where popular culture has introduced us to others’ foods, music, histories, customs, and more. Moreover, the predictions that a multiplicity of infusions from culture to culture will continue unabated – and that we must develop a respect for others if we are to be active, engaged participants in the new world order (Green, 1998).…

    • 1374 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Diversity is the main factor in bringing America’s heritages together. America is not defined by a color, yet it is defined by numerous distant factors. Source 2 proves, how America is not defined by one detail; by saying, “Alongside the pain of immigration, then, and the possibility, there…

    • 361 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The face of America has slowly, but surely, changed over the course of sixty years. America’s schools, sixty years ago, were predominantly white and most teachers were white as well. If one thinks that America is still mostly white, they would be sadly mistaken with immigration numbers at all time highs. America has become the most culturally diverse nation in the world. With every passing year, it seems immigration numbers continue to rise. As these numbers have begun to rise over the past years it has begun to change the way Americans live their everyday life. Used to when one says an “American” individual you would think of a white person, however this is no longer the case. America is becoming the world’s melting…

    • 826 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Schlesinger repeatedly talks about America being a mixing pot, but to me that doesn’t seem true. Us Americans may interact with each other and socialize when it comes to exploring our identity, but when in reality behind close doors we stick to prejudices and people who closely identify as ourselves or people who attract our interest. America is like a smoothie, blended together with but not mixed wholly into one being.…

    • 452 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics