Preview

The role of destiny in "Stolen Party" by Liliana Hecker

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1708 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
The role of destiny in "Stolen Party" by Liliana Hecker
In the short story "The Stolen Party" written by Liliana Heker, a girl's dreams are shattered by the bitter reality of her destiny. Destiny plays a major role in the story. The characters in the short story demonstrate prominent differences in their values and beliefs. Each character displays unique traits. It is these unique traits, which illustrate different aspects of society. Therefore, each character represents a portion of the values and beliefs of today's society. Like society, to some extent, they possess control over their own destinies.

Rosaura is the main character of this short story. The story revolves around her from start to finish. Rosaura is an inexperienced young girl. This story opens with an argument between Rosaura and her mother. Rosaura wants to go to Luciana's birthday party. Luciana is in a wealthy family so Rosaura's mother disapproves of her daughter's attending the party. In the first few sentences the author makes it evident that Rosaura is financially challenged. Herminia, Rosaura's mother, is aware of this fact and tries to make her daughter aware of this also so that she will not mingle with others of different social status.

Rosaura sees herself as equal to all of the other children at the party and tries to better herself by seeking a way to get out of her low social class. She doesn't see her social class as a problem that prohibits her from making friends. She views herself as an educated young girl, and this education makes her equal to all of the children at the party. She is an innocent child who only sees friendship and nothing else. To some extent Rosaura controls her own destiny, although it could be argued that her social class limited her control. In fact, it could be said that she viewed her age as conferring her power of her destiny. Her age conferred her destiny because she empowered herself at a young age with education and dreams.

Rosaura became defeated by her social status at the party after answering a slew of

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Estrella’s mother, Petra, was left a long time ago by her husband. It is her circumstances that the reader is asked to relate with most. Estrella learns from her father’s disappearance that men cannot be trusted or depended on, and that women will usually always be left to take care of the family. Just as Petra has been abandoned physically by Estrella's father, and mentally by Perfecto, Estrella soon will come to be abandoned by Alejo. The fact that Perfecto has not married her mother, furthers this idea of lack of commitment made by the men in her life. “The eucalyptus trees lined the dirt road like a row of thin dancing girls fanning their feathers. Estrella knows the world of men and women through her mother Petra and Perfecto, ‘the man who was not her father’" (3). Viramontes is sympathetic to the men in some ways, but she does emphasize that when the men abandon the family, the women are left to endure for themselves and their children. Estrella and Alejo’s relationship, serves as a major basis for the author's allegation in this idea of suffering. Alejo’s death represents how once again a female is left behind. Estrella is the heart and soul of the novel and her love for Alejo, was more important than Alejo…

    • 811 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Cisneros chooses to include Rosa Vargas in this vignette. Rosa also represents the challenges faced by single mothers. She has more children than she can count and is plagued with despair after her husband leaves her without a penny to help take care of…

    • 417 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Conversing amongst friends. Shopping at the mall. Buying a cup of coffee. These are acts of freedom. Every US citizen is granted freedom the day they are born. Freedom allows people to be themselves. What if these acts were taken away from US citizens? In the story The Chosen by Chaim Potok, Reuven and Danny are both Jewish boys growing up with different lives, Reuven’s more free and Danny’s more strict, Danny dreams of one day becoming a psychologist but is restricted due to him inheriting his father’s position of being the Reb. Nevertheless, this shows that the most prevalent theme in “The Chosen” is that one must follow their dream despite society, tradition, and relationships.…

    • 1092 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Something else that is significant to this novel is Mama Elena’s struggle. Mama Elena also suffered the pangs of lost love due to her mother. Although the reactions of each woman to her predicament helps sort out the differences between Tita and Mama Elena. While Mama Elena let the loss of her love make her a controlling and menacing mother, Tita obeys her mother’s command but still has the lifelong struggle of trying to find love which she eventually gets after all the conflicts are absent from her life. “For twenty-two years she had respected the pact the two of them had made with Rosaura; now she had had enough of it. Thier pact consisted of taking into consideration the fact that it was vital to Rosaura to maintain the appearance that her marriage was going splendidly, and the most important thing for her was that her daughter grow up within that sacred institution, the family- the only way, she felt, to provide a firm moral foundation. Pedro and Tita had sworn to be absolutely discreet about their meetings and keep their love a secret. In the eyes of others, theirs must always be a perfectly normal family. For this to succeed, Tita had to give up having an illicit child. In compensation, Rosaura was prepared to share Esperanza with her, as follows: Tita would be in charge of feeding the child, Rosaura of her…

    • 868 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Valeria was in some ways a pioneer for women working in the industry, in that she excelled in every job she had. She moved across the country to a place where she knew no one to start over in life because she knew that she need a more exciting life than what she was getting in New York. While there are many faults to Valeria, she was always able to figure out how to she was going to survive and find her next…

    • 1505 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the short story, “The Stolen Party”, Rosaura, the daughter of a house-keeper for a wealthy, high-class family, is invited t9o the family’s daughter’s birthday party. Because of their low social status, Rosaura’s mother insists she does not go. Her mother states “That one’s not your friend. You know what you are to them? The maid’s daughter, that’s what.” However, Rosaura does not agree with her mother and wishes to attend the party. She wishes to be accepted among her peers. After being treated differently through-out the story, Rosaura finally realizes that her mother was right. For example,, Senora Innes treated Rosaura as a servant, as she underhandedly made Rosaura serve cake and assist the magician during his sow. She was treated differently because of her low social status, and because of this, she was not accepted by the other children at the party. A similar barrier affects Sophie, from The Chrysalids. Due to the fact that Sophie was born with an extra toe, she was considered a mutant and was not legally allowed to be living in Waknuk. For instance, because of Sophie’s deformity, her and her family had to hide her from the people of Waknuk, to avoid being killed or sent to the fringes. But after David’s father, Joseph, found out about…

    • 1012 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    From there on she continues to talk about her adolescence where she quickly learned about the threat of physical abuse and molestation towards young girls. She did not continue with school pat the age of 9 and in her small job of working in the local market she was confronted with true and absolute poverty on a daily basis. She got pregnant at age 15. At 16 she had her first fist fight with her abusive physically brother. And at 17 met the father of her other future children. While with this man, Rafael Canales, she learned first hand the hardships of poor domestic life. She also learned to assert herself even towards her own husband.…

    • 1222 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    When Rosa is given the power to do whatever she wants with Matt, she becomes corrupted. For example, “Bleating won’t save you, you good-for-nothing animal. No one can hear you… I could bury you under the floor --- and I might do it” (39). This evidence shows how Rosa abuses her power by talking to Matt like he is an unholy, filthy beast and keeping him completely isolated from the rest of humanity. Rosa’s quote is important to understand because it is where the corruption starts, but soon it escalates because no one has challenged her authority over Matt. Another piece of evidence is, “Rosa suddenly swung him up by his arms and tossed him inside. He landed with a whump and sat up coughing. ‘That’s what dirty beasts get to live in,’” (42). This citation highlights that Rosa has taken her power too far by forcing Matt to live in “deep litter” like a wild animal. The reason Rosa becomes corrupted is she was given so much power with little to no limitations. Given these points, Rosa is an example of how power corrupts the people who hold…

    • 1000 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    What one may want is not always what the heart truly desires, until the time that one realizes that he/she has lost it. Following is an analysis taken from the story "The Skating Party" in which the author Merna Summers considers the life-changing journey of one of the chosen characters during the process of self-discovery. The story in relation to self-discovery and its implications is that "self-discovery" is an intricate process that may not always reflect the best of implications. Therefore its effects have several paths, which are based upon how one comes across it.…

    • 947 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Bread and tulips

    • 1641 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The film starts off with Rosalba and her family on their yearly vacation. When seeing the family interact with each other it is quite clear that Rosalba is ignored and mistreated. When at a rest stop Rosalba drops her wedding band down the toilet which symbolizes the destruction of her marriage. Of course after fishing the wedding band out of the toilet time has passed and her uncaring family leaves Rosalba behind completely forgetting about her existence. Hurt and confused she resolves to wait for her family convinced they will realize she was missing and come back immediately. To her misfortune her family fails to realize she was missing until they are hours away from the rest stop. Her husband Mimmo then starts to blame Rosalba for being left behind, claiming that she wanders and misplaces herself. Rosalba decided to find her own way home instead of waiting for her unloving family and from there starts a journey that will forever change her life.…

    • 1641 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Maturity in 8th Grade

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In different stages of life, no matter what the setting or the ethnicity is, humanity encounters similar experiences in life. As the time goes by, all the protagonists represent identical signs of maturing and exhibits empathy through family loyalty and overcoming certain obstacles. Each story contributes to the same universal themes. There are common universal themes connecting to different stories and convey similar messages .The unlike stories portray the diverse aspects of humanity where the readers can relate to.…

    • 751 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Stolen Party

    • 1007 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Rosaura is the main character of this writing. The story revolves around her from start to finish. Rosaura is an inexperienced young girl. This story opens with an argument between Rosaura and her mother. Rosaura wants to go to Luciana's birthday party. Luciana is in a wealthy family so Rosaura's mother disapproves of her daughter's attending the party. In the first few sentences the author makes it evident that Rosaura is financially challenged. Rosaura's mother says, "I don't like you going because it is a rich peoples party." This one sentence already tells me that they are probably not very wealthy. In addition Rosaura is an inexperienced young girl. She is not tarnished by the belief that everyone should be judged according to his or her financial worth. She, unlike her mother, judges people by who they are and not by how much money they have. When Rosaura's mother states, "you should not fart higher than your own ass" she shows that she feels below those who are wealthy. Rosaura's argument shows that she does not feel bound by her financial status. Her financial state isn't even an issue to her. She says that she wants to go because she is a friend of Luciana and because she was invited. The author also demonstrates Rosaura's openness in the first few paragraphs of the story. Since Rosaura is only nine years old she has no prior experience of prejudice. She does not realize that her mother might be right about her assumption that not everyone will accept her at the party and treat her with the same respect.…

    • 1007 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Rosa Lee Story

    • 872 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Rosa and her mom never saw eye to eye and when she got pregnant at the age of thirteen it didn’t make their relationship any better. At the age of fourteen she had her first prostitution experience for five dollars, she told her customers at work that if they were going to have sex with her, they had to pay because she had eight kids at home. After Rosa third child she married into an abusive relationship with a man who was twenty one which made her sixteen she couldn’t take anymore so she moved back in with her mom.…

    • 872 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Fiction Essay

    • 1209 Words
    • 5 Pages

    In this essay, “The Rocking Horse Winner” and “The Lottery” are compared and contrasted. Their different themes and different characters have some similarities. The things the characters do and want ultimately brings them to their very own downfall. Throughout this essay, I talk about how these characters are just like every ordinary person and how our society is well represented by the different themes in each of these stories. One character is cruel and self-centered and all of that leads to her own death while the other is “unlucky” and her greed and want for wealth leads to her very own son’s death.…

    • 1209 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Rosaura is also unable to provide breast milk for Roberto, her son. This seems to be a cause of the dangerous unsupervised birthing process she endured. As a result of this lack of nutirition, Tita attempts to care for the child and grows particularly attached to this motherly role. When news comes that Pedro, Rosaura, and baby Roberto are planning a move to San Antonio in the United States, Tita’s hopes of being with Pedro and also continuing her care for Roberto are crushed. She falls into a deep depression and loses her passion and inspiration to…

    • 1587 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays