Preview

Roger Caillois The Ambiguity Of The Sacred

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1019 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Roger Caillois The Ambiguity Of The Sacred
In Roger Caillois’ piece, The Ambiguity of The Sacred, he states “There is scarcely any religious system, even in the broadest sense of the term, in which the categories of the pure and impure do not play a fundamental role.” Most religions are based on what a person should do and what they should not do in order to stay pure, which is what religions want you to to strive to be. So what does it mean to be pure and impure? In his writing he explains what it means to be pure, how a person becomes/remains pure, as well as how purity and impurity are intertwined with one another in reality. All of these things are going to be provided in the following paragraphs. Caillois explains that purity and impurity is not as separated as a person might …show more content…
First they must rid themselves of all of the profane things or actions. A person must no longer be “a human.” That is to say that they can no longer participate in humanly things. They must reject: sleep, speech, others company, nourishment, and all sexual relations. They must also bathe, shave, and change into his best and purified clothing. In order for a person to stay in the sacred he must stay “consecrated and detached from the profane.” A person can move from positive sacred to negative sacred and vice versa without returning to the profane, but it is impossible to stay in the positive sacredness for too long. For example, a woman during her menstrual cycle is considered to be impure and evil. The girls during this time of their life are sent off away from the village and can not even touch the ground for fear of contamination. The only way for on of the girls to return to purity and sacredness is to go through “ritual purifications.” An example of how purity and impurity go hand in hand, is a woman during her pregnancy and childbirth. Pregnancy is considered to be good and positive, all the while, childbirth is considered impure and evil. Like a girl during her menstrual cycle, a woman who is about to give birth is sent off during this time for fear that she may contaminate others with her impurity. However after a woman gives birth, the blood is stored away and eventually used to cure certain types of skin

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    But Jesus does not avoid contact with common unclean people, instead, he touch lepers, spend time with Gentiles, go to graves or corpses, heals on the sabbath (i.e. purity in the sense of profane and sanctified). Jesus defines a new halakha for his disciples. The clean and sanctified does not become contaminated by but brings cleansing into an unclean environment. He moves the focus of purity from the outer man to the inner, he violates the purity codes to bring Gods mercy to those who needs cleanliness. (deSilva, 2004,…

    • 506 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    quarrel. Their frequent Sunday morning arguments about religion are a result of Gabriel’s Saturday night drinking. María is a devout Catholic, but Gabriel’s vaquero mindset causes him to distrust priests because to him they stand for order and civilization. Antonio knows that Gabriel’s father once dragged a priest from church and beat him after the priest preached against something that Antonio’s grandfather had done. At last Antonio goes downstairs, and María scolds Antonio for not being properly formal when greeting Ultima. Ultima requests that María not scold Antonio, as the night was hard on all the men in town. María protests that Antonio is still a baby. She says that she thinks it is a sin for boys to become men. Gabriel hotly declares that it is not a sin, only the way of the world, and María argues that life corrupts the innocence and purity that God bequeaths to children. She says bitterly that if Antonio becomes a priest, he will be spard Ultima are the only grown-ups he knows who eat or drink before taking Communion on Sundays.…

    • 757 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    “Christianity demands for the restriction or even avoidance of sexual activity by believers”(Cullum 621) Before the rise of christianity sex was widely accepted whether before or after marriage. Due to the reliance of Christianity, it became more attractive for women to hold onto their virginity or take a vow for widowhood. These standards were expected of women, but in no way applied to men. This is thought to be caused by an “undeveloped state of the field of late medieval masculinity, which focused on the high status of men”(Cullum 621). Men are expected to be sexual beings, and by being non-sexual a man is seen as being not normal. Men are to produce heirs, and this cannot be done without being sexual. At this point in time the words virginity, celibacy, and chastity were directly related to women. This article is strictly about christianity and it’s affects on sexuality in the middle ages, giving historical information to the time…

    • 1024 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Shamanism In Vietnam

    • 1375 Words
    • 6 Pages

    some have converted to Christianity, most stick to traditional spiritual practices of Shamanism. Shamanism is a practice of a practitioner reaching altered states of consciousness in order to interact with the social world of benevolent and malevolent spirits. Performing rituals for sick people by connecting with the spirit world (trance) to see why they are sick. The ancient time, it was believed that humans and spirits lived with each other. The conflict between the two brought a sub-deity (a member of a pantheon of a polytheistic religious system). Blinded the worlds from interacting. Treatments include herbal remedies or offering of Joss papers (ghost money.) when the soul returns back to the body through a string tying rituals (sting-tying). Red, white, black or blue strings are tied to shield the person from evil spirits. The strings symbolize binding up and holding intact of the life souls. Animal sacrifice is another Shaman ritual to attempt illness with offerings to the spirits with the sacrifice of chickens, cows, pigs, or other animals. The soul of the sacrificed soul of animals is connected to human souls. Shamans use the animal soul to protect the sick person. Then that animal is eaten. When a Hmong person dies the soul must travel to the every place the person lived until it reaches the burial place of its placental. To be dressed in the “placenta jacket” it can travel to be reunited with ancestors and be reincarnated…

    • 1375 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Leading a sacred life. (2008, October – December). Hinduism Today, 30 (4), I12 – I15.…

    • 1821 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    One religion that to some is seen as taboo is Pagan due to the belief all Pagans practice witch craft, the true meaning of a Pagan is “a follower of a polytheistic or pantheistic nature-worshipping religion.” (What is Paganism 2014) The Pagan religion is an umbrella term for many other beliefs and practices, Pagans may be trained to follow certain traditions or their own and pursue their own visions of the divine. The Indian culture has many of the same health beliefs as Pagans do; they both take on a holistic process with many seeking remedies from nature. It is believed by Pagans that if one is ill it is due to their bodies energies becoming out of balance, they will fully except modern medicine while including alternative healing measures such as Reiki, massage, chanting, chiropractic, acupuncture, hands on healing, and community healing. Pagans see death as a fundamental process of nature and that the body is recycled so the soul can take on a new form, this is a form of re-carnation, which is also a belief of the Indian…

    • 1281 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    In regards to the definition of religion given in The Sacred Quest, we find that due to the complexity of the term religion there are many different ways to satisfy what it actually is. It can be recognized that sacred reality indicates the characteristics of being specially distinctive; beyond human control; concerned with human welfare; and determinative of aspects of human existence. In a world of diverse religious traditions, we are offered distinct perceptions of sacred reality. For example Judaism, Christianity, and Islam are usually categorized as religions of transcendence, defining sacred reality as being beyond or “standing over” ordinary existence. Meanwhile, Hinduism and Buddhism are considered religions of immanence, meaning they do not portray sacred reality with an all-powerful God who is eternal and surpassing of human understanding.…

    • 920 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women are also seen as very unclean after they reach menarche. They begin to exaggerate this idea of being unclean by not brushing their hair or showering while menstruating. Women have many restrictions while being “unclean” such as they cannot pray and any fasting doesn’t count during this period and they must make it up after menstruation ends. Women and men cannot even wash their clothes together until postmenopausal when they are not known as being unclean anymore.…

    • 800 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Devil's Playground

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages

    withdraw from normal norms of those around them. To the outside world they are in a state of…

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Sacred Space

    • 610 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Philosopher Mircea Eliade describes sacred space as “Every sacred space implies a hierophony, an irruption of the sacred that results in detaching a territory from the surrounding cosmic milieu and making it qualitatively different” (Eliade, 26). After a recent trip to Santuario de Chimayo, I was able to refer to and apply Eliade’s ideas about sacred space to my own research. I have come to the conclusion that Mircea Eliade’s Theological Approach on sacred sites is very logical and truthful. Sacred sites are indeed created for encounters with the sacred as Eliade explains, but only for the believers. Those individuals whom are tourists or scholars may not necessarily experience an encountering with the sacred on their visit, however all of the visitors are respectful of the site and the other pilgrims visiting. Sacred sites like Chimayo are heterogeneous places filled with people of all different beliefs, so no it is not possible to say that every single individual visiting Chimayo experiences hierophony, but all give a mutual respect for one another and the site itself. Eliade’s approach is correct because sacred sites were indeed…

    • 610 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In her article, Doe notes that female purity is often seen as holy, whilst female sexuality is viewed as sinful (pg. 77). In her example of the devout Italian girl, Maria Goretti, Doe notes that women are basically taught that it is “better to die in a state of purity and resistance than to live defiled as a raped women” (pg. 77). She also states that this very religious point of view holds the connotation that female sexuality is problematic…

    • 679 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Sacred space and making the world sacred, is an extract from theorist Mircea Eliade’s 1987 book The Sacred and The Profane: The Nature of Religion. Mircea Eliade’s argument is that there is no such thing as a homogeneous space, even for the non-religious man. He presents this argument that all religions share something in common, by identifying the difference between the sacred and the profane it gives us a meaning of life. According to Eliade, “Where the sacred manifests it-self in space, the real unveils itself, the world comes into existence,” this manifestation can occur in the form of a hierophany or a theophany; both allow us to identify our axis mundi or absolute fixed. Hierophany being the manifestation of the holy and theophany means manifestation of God or the divine into the mundane world. To support his argument, Eliade presents us with his five key points regarding religion. To the religious man, religion differentiates between sacred and profane space through hierophany and theophany. Second, as presented in creation stories it has the ability to orients us; allowing us to identify our place in the cosmos. “Life is not possible without and opening toward the transcendent; in other words, human beings cannot live in chaos”. According Elaide, the religious man hungers after the transcendent and for that reason he needs an axis mundi; a sacred world center that permits him to communicate with the divine. His fourth key point is the consecration of sacred space, for the religious man it is the repeating of the cosmogony in the name of their God. In his final key point Eliade compares and contrasts the religious man and the modern man. According to him, “religious man can live only in a sacred world…it is there that he has real existence,” for that reason he hungers after the transcendent. According to Eliade, non-religious man on the other hand leaves us disoriented about our existence. Their idea of a sacred space differs from that of the religious man;…

    • 874 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    World Religion

    • 5930 Words
    • 24 Pages

    Define what is meant by sacred in religion and give some examples of how sacred is understood?…

    • 5930 Words
    • 24 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Romare Bearden, Prevalence of Ritual, Tidings, 1967 had a bright mind about the African American culture. Bearden took a little from his background and what he was seeing in his time or that was around him to use in his paintings. In this piece he was using an angel to send a message to the woman as letting her know that things will get better. When I look at this piece I see there is church to go and pray ,or to say that a place that people can go to get a peace of mind .I believe that in this painting that the woman or young lady felt abandon because she is looking down and ashamed. Therefore there is a rose in the painting as well I believe that is symbolizes the young lady worth. It appears someone was giving her a rose to make her feel better. The angel that appears in the painting symbolizes comfort, patience, protection, understanding, and others. Bearden painting symbolizes that the African American struggles were not a joke. In those times it symbolizes that it was still racism going on with our culture. We were losing our jobs, because we had people fighting for our rights, girls that were at the age of twelve had to quit school because they had to help out in their homes. This painting symbolizes a lot of things that was going on in the early and late 1960’s. As I said once before that the angel was there for many reasons as in comfort for the struggle, protection from the pain and destruction, understanding that there will be better times, and jobs. Romare Bearden, Rocket to the Moon, 1971 to me is my favorite painting. It is really a collage fragments build a scene of quiet despair and stoic perservance. You can see in the painting that the rocket is headed to moon; however, while urban life below remains punctuated by a red stop-light. The definition of Stoic is an ancient Greek school of philosophy that asserted that happiness can only be…

    • 690 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In churches, mosques, etc. the religion being practiced can bring people together because they have the same beliefs and similar lifestyles. Religion is also setting a boundary in some peoples lives. People might think that people should not associate with people of different religions. Religion can also put a strong boundary in some lives because they come with a set of rules to abide to and most believers of said religion will base their lives around those rules.…

    • 313 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays