Top-Rated Free Essay
Preview

Roberta Borkat "A Liberating Curriculum"

Good Essays
583 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Roberta Borkat "A Liberating Curriculum"
“A Liberating Curriculum” By Roberta F. Borkat
From a readers point-of-view
In “A Liberating Curriculum,” by Roberta Borkat, Borkat uses a sarcastic approach to get her lethargic students to realize the effect they are having on the educational system. Borkat in return offers an idea to give all her students an ‘A’ in all their classes after the second week of school. Borkat became disgusted when she had a student become livid with her because he plagiarized his paper from a well-known essay in the Literature world. She even had a few students with extenuating circumstances, not do so well on assignments and exams but still wanted a passing grade, even though, they did not put in the time or effort and did not show up for most of her sessions. Borkat hopes that in giving everyone a passing grade students will hopefully become more relaxed, and both the students and teachers will be able to do the things they love the most with their time. Borkat believes that by focusing on the negative aspects that teachers are being faced with on a daily basis, will expectantly open her students and readers eyes to the ignorance that teachers must repeatedly put up with.
Roberta Borkat utilizes ethos in several ways. Borkat tells her prospective readers about how she has been dedicated in the field of education for over twenty years. When Borkat claims, “laboring as a university professor for more than 20 years under a misguided theory of teaching,” verify that her experience as a university professor gives her the qualities to recognize when there is a problem that needs to be faced. Readers may acknowledge the fact that Borkat has been truly dedicated in this field long enough to point out several problems wrong with the educational system today. Borkat states, “I threw away numerous hours annually on trivia: . . . grading and explaining examinations; . . . holding private conferences with students; reading countless books; buying extra materials . . . endlessly worrying about how to improve my teaching,” Borkat is simply making her readers aware of all the time, effort, blood, sweat and tears, she has put into her students and profession. Some readers may praise Borkat for all of her efforts she has put into making it possible for her students to recognize the importance of the criteria she has placed before them, myriad sums of time.
When it comes to presenting pathos, Borkat does not hold back on expressing her emotions towards her students, fellow colleagues, and eventual readers. Borkat insists, “I humbly regret that during all those years I have caused distress and inconvenience to thousands of students while providing some amusement to my more practical colleagues,” this suggests that Borkat believes that in all her decades of teaching, instead of bringing her learners knowledge, understanding, and possessions they can use throughout their lives in their own fields of profession, she has brought them pain and inopportuneness, which has in turn made her fellow equals amused. Borkat reports, “One or two forlorn colleagues may even protest that . . . such authors as Chaucer, Shakespeare, Milton and Swift are intrinsically valuable. I can empathize with these misguided souls . . . After all, their bodies are dead. Why shouldn’t their ideas be dead, too,” insists that teachers are wasting their time teaching students about such satirists, when the students do not care about the topic. Instead, the teachers should just teach about things which will actually catch their students’ attention, such as “MTV and People magazine.”

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    The main message as Alexandra Robbins has said is to have, ¨… a massive change of attitudes and educational policies¨ (15). Robbins is trying to make the point that if educational policies don’t change then education will no longer be the same due to children worrying of how they will get to college and not about the actual learning experience. There needs to be a change in attitude and policies towards education because the education system has affected many students’ lives, for example, an estimate of ¨114 percent spike in suicide rates … between 1980 and 2002,¨ due to the pressure of wanting to get into the best colleges for the name (14). This quote shows that stress levels of getting into the most prestigious universities has turned kids…

    • 186 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    These teachers based their assumptions on family issues, lack of money, parent awareness, and language barriers. They assumed that parents who never went to college would not provide enough support for a first generation college student or how launage barriers put the student behind. I think it is wrong of them to make these assumptions because all students have the potential to go to college, but it is the education system and these sterotypes that are oppressing them and stopping them for pursuing their dreams. Many of these teachers assumptions were countered as many of these student’s parents fought against issues such as harsh punishments in recess when both the districts and faulty least expected them to. Aldente works to create confiaza in both the parents and teachers, but also includes the mentors.…

    • 433 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Coping with Methuselah

    • 309 Words
    • 1 Page

    In the reading selection “Coping with Methuselah”, the authors Aaron and Schwartz work well together to convey their ideas using all three principles of argument to their readers. Aaron and Schwartz literally begin with the principle of ethos in their passage titled “About the Authors” which states their professional accomplishments (articles they have written, major universities they are associated with) individually and together. Immediately this reader is convinced that their knowledge base is extensive and they are a credible source. Ifeel it was especially convincing for these two colleagues to voice the same arguments to its audience together. There is more authority when two professionals with such expertise are voicing the same concerns.…

    • 309 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    “Students will float to the mark you set,” said Mike Rose (Rose 110). Every day students are being held to a lower standard. Not only does this happen at school, but in the home life as well. Today’s generation seems to have a lot of things done for them. We just hand out A’s, and allowance that hasn’t even been earned. From these poor examples being set for us, we lose the motive and drive that it takes to succeed. People are going through life with a sense that they are owed something.…

    • 1192 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Ethos is basing arguments based on one's character through trust. The three main elements of ethos is trustworthiness/credibility, authority, and clear motives. An example would be turning to a dactor's help and advice because of their knowledge of health and medicine. People will turn to doctors because they know that doctors have experiences in the health and medical field. They would much rather listen to a doctor than a random people they do not trust. One may use this rhetorical appeal in a persuasive essay because the information given is true statements that come from experienced people or credibility. In a persuasive essay, one can give the true statements instead of giving their views and opinions. This kind of information will make…

    • 134 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    John Gatto's Cruelty

    • 303 Words
    • 2 Pages

    As a teacher of 30 years, John Gatto had a first hand experience with the cruelty of standardized testing and the curriculum derived around it. What Gatto found was that teachers and students agreed on being bored, but blamed one another for the boredom. Students claimed the teachers were not interested in the subject nor knew much about the subject. Teachers claimed the students to be rude and uninterested. Both sides are a products of the 12 year school program’s conditioning creating an endless factory of childishness. Gatto states instead of creating a prison-like environment for students and teachers alike, we should encourage the best qualities of being young by being more [flexible] with time and tests. Thus creating more competent adults.…

    • 303 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    In his essay, “I Just Wanna Be Average,” author Mike Rose says, “students will float to the mark you set” (164). From my past experiences, I completely agree that students will work harder if their teachers set the standards high. Generally, teenagers do not have high goals or standards for themselves, so it is up to the teachers to encourage and push the students towards success. Throughout his excerpt, Rose shows through numerous examples that teachers are a vital part to a student’s success in life.…

    • 605 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Every teacher likes to believe that they’re reaching out to their students, and handing down life lessons at a critical point in their students’ development. These essays lack the point of a view of the high school student that is receiving a lesson,. Most high school students simply don’t care. This is not to insult the teacher, nor is it intended to diminish the work of Mark Twain. Rather, it’s a result of the school system in general. You’re average high school student is tired husk, restlessly trudging from one class to the next. As an English teacher, it’s easy to forget that English class isn’t the only class the students have, or that all students, despite what they’re truly interested in, are forced to take all mandated classes.. Your students just came from science and are about to move on to math. After reading a few excerpts with their English teacher, they’ll move on to their next class, where they memorizes bleak formulas and forget about what they had just read, and the cycle continues. The only internalizing they do is what their tests demand be internalized, and they’ll forget the information as soon as possible. Most high schools students have no interest in learning, they only care about what…

    • 765 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    During this essay the authors tone was very direct and persuasive toward anyone whom was reading the article. All in all, you could conclude that the author, Carl Singleton thinks very poorly teachers and the schooling system in general. Within in the composition the author claims that “Illiteracy among high-school graduates is growing because those students have been passed rather than flunked; we have low- quality teachers who never should have been certified in the first place…” in other words he [the author] believes low quality teaching leads to unfair grading. I believe that teachers probably realize that when kids always get F’s after putting in a lot of effort it lowers their self-esteem and will make them want to give up. Instead of keep trying. I know for a fact that if I kept getting F’s on papers that I worked my heart out on all the time I would eventually quit because I would feel stupid and feel…

    • 481 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    letter to admin

    • 331 Words
    • 1 Page

    We are writing to you to advocate for the continuance of Miss. Degenhardt’s (Profe) teaching career at Darien High School. We write with the purpose to make you aware of Profe’s profound impact on the community and the growth of her students both in the context of academics and ethics; her notable qualities and dedication to her profession are of a role model. While Profe’s style of teaching is unorthodox at some points, this unorthodoxy provides students with a diverse and meaningful education in an otherwise, orthodox day. A quality that is central to Profe’s teaching and persona is her receptiveness to student opinion, which in our opinion should be a constant in all student-teacher relationships. For example, if a student feels that a decision in terms of either a grade or punishment she made was unjust, Profe is fully open to a one-on-one discussion, either during a mutual free or before or after school. Profe’s actions reject the notion of “my way or the highway” and epitomize the characteristic of open-mindedness: a quality that is crucial in our increasingly globally connected society. For a personal anecdote, during a student’s sophomore year he felt that he did not deserve grade X; therefore, he approached Profe and asked to meet with her before school. The student and Profe discussed the grade and while the grade remained unchanged, he had a better understanding as to why he received grade X and how he can avoid receiving grade X in the future. In another, unrelated circumstance, Profe organizes an annual in-class food drive to afford families in the Bronx a decent Thanksgiving meal, which reveals her altruism and devotion to paying it forward. Moments such as these are what define Profe’s impact and overall career to DHS and academia. As a community, we are here to support a teacher who has supported us. Thank you in advance for your time.…

    • 331 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Two Authors Two Views

    • 1299 Words
    • 6 Pages

    School is a place where the youth of America goes to become educated to achieve their potential, and to further their knowledge of life. People often criticize our school system by saying it’s a place where kids learn to be “book smart” and not “street smart.” Others say that students need to spend more time outside of the classroom to gain further knowledge about the world. These two ideas about education are the main ideas that that authors John Gatto, and Dave Eggers have. John Gatto, a teacher in the Manhattan school system for thirty years wrote, “Against School: How Public Education Cripples Our Kids, and Why.” Gatto claims to have taught in some of the worst conditions, and some of the best. Teacher of the year in New York for multiple years, Gatto claims to have seen it all. Just like Gatto, Eggers sees that the school system should be run in a different way. Eggers, the author of, “Serve or fail” developed a successful nonprofit organization that helps teach kids necessary writing skills. He sees that volunteer work plays an important role in growing up. He argues that it should be mandatory to do volunteer work while in college and that it will make students become better people. Both authors have their own different view on how they think the school systems should work. Both have strong views about why the school systems need to change. From students having too much spare time on their hands to boring classrooms, it’s the way we incorporate different learning environments that will make us be successful in our everyday life.…

    • 1299 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Learning Outcome 3

    • 905 Words
    • 3 Pages

    People often talk about the ethos of school. It is difficult to sum up what this means. It is something which is often apparent when entering school building. There is a feeling that everyone in the school matters and all play their part. Children and young…

    • 905 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    I believe that greatness is within all of us; we just need a little help finding it sometimes. I have come to understand that one caring person can make all the difference in someone else’s life. As I venture further into my teaching career, I hope to help my students to Education is a journey of seeking answers and experiencing. Every human being has the ability to learn and apply meaning to education. Learners should not be encouraged to surrender to the ideals and beliefs of a set curriculum. Rather than settling for the minimum learning requirements written out based on the expectations of the state, students should encounter knowledge, build a solid structured foundation, and then branch out to master the skills and ideas that they wish to develop and pursue. Learning then becomes a map of the sea. Students may be influenced by the way the wind blows and the tossing of the waves, but they have the knowledge and ability to adjust their sails to follow the path of the desired horizon. As educators we should not be neutral in our teaching, but radical and dynamic so that our students can learn beyond what is normal, static, and unchanging. I believe that the historical foundations of knowledge and the truths revealed by the past are vital to the knowledge of the future, but I also believe that we are agents of change and that we should teach our students to not only build upon and consecrate the truths of our past, but to challenge them and use them to think critically and make new history.…

    • 3691 Words
    • 15 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Literacy Narrative

    • 1098 Words
    • 5 Pages

    From the time when I was a little boy, growing up in Graves County, Kentucky, I have had problems with my reading and writing. Things never seemed to click for me, a trait that the teachers attributed to a mild case of dyslexia mixed with a healthy dose of attention deficit disorder. I knew, however, that no disorder was the cause of my distaste of reading and writing. Rather, there was nothing really interesting surrounding me that would grab my interest in the classroom. The teachers I encountered never took any interest in what their students wanted to read or write; they developed assignments based on what the curriculum, a course of study developed by some politicians at the Board of Education, told them to do. This work was so far removed from what we, as students were experiencing in our own lives, and the assignments were so boring that they could have put an insomniac to sleep. However, my life changed the day I met my Junior English teacher, Mr. Clark Duncan.…

    • 1098 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Opposing Viewpoints Essay

    • 1550 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Dana Stevens uses ethos very well when trying to make her argument in “Thinking outside the idiot box.” Stevens starts off with informing the audience that she has a Ph.D in comparative literature from the University of California at Berkeley. If the author has earned her a Ph.D in comparative literature that gives her credibility because she has had to go through a lot of years of schooling and she has a lot of writing experience by now after getting a job in the field. “Dana Stevens is Slate’s movie critic and has also written for the New York Times, Bookforum, and the Atlantic” (Stevens, 2012, p. 295) is…

    • 1550 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays

Related Topics