Preview

Robert Nozick's Experience Machine

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1087 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Robert Nozick's Experience Machine
Good experiences are something that we spend our life constantly striving to obtain. Once we gain these good experiences, we look for the next opportunity in order to gain that same great feeling that we had in our last experience. What if someone told you that there was a way to have these good experiences all the time? You could quite literally plug yourself into a machine that would give you the great experiences that you have been searching for your whole life. The best part is that, once you have decided to plug yourself into this machine, you would feel and think that these false experiences you are having are real. Robert Nozick proposes this very scenario in his book Anarchy State, and Utopia. This scenario is known as “the experience machine”. (Nozick 1974, 165) Sounds great, doesn’t it? I would beg to differ. Is pleasure really the only thing that we spend our life searching for? I would argue that there are far many other important values other than pure pleasure; that is why I would not plug into the experience machine. While Nozick’s scenario may seem very tempting, there are several key elements to consider before making a decision to enter this experience machine. Does entering this experience machine correspond with one’s set of values? I would say that there are far more important things than just pleasure. It is fair to say that actually doing certain things, and not just simply having the experience of them is a good core value. We want to actually in our real world accomplish our own goals. Attaining these goals are what many people live their lives for. Aristotle claims, “Man is a goal seeking animal. His life only has meaning if he is reaching out and striving for his goals.” (Aristotle, 163) Perhaps this is what we desire; to live our lives striving to achieve our goals. Whether all of our experiences are 100% pleasurable does not matter. As long as we know that we are actually living our own lives. Clearly, there is opposition to my


Cited: in Introduction to Philosophy Fifth Edition. John Perry, Michael Bratman, John Martin Fischer. Oxford University Press. 2010. ) 5.) Nozick², Robert. (quoted in Lewis and Clark: Robert Nozick. The Experience Machine 2010.) http://legacy.lclark.edu/~jay/Robert%20Nozick.pdf.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    -Feelings classified as “pleasures” are unlikely to provide fulfillment. Some pleasures include: riding a roller coaster, or meeting a movie star.…

    • 654 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Check Point 1

    • 379 Words
    • 2 Pages

    I personally would not like to be hooked up to an ‘experience machine.’ I love feeling happiness along with other emotions but I feel by not having negative emotions we would never learn from things. A good example of this brings us to post traumatic growth, if we experience a traumatic event because of something we did we will not experience those negative feelings helping us grow and not make the same mistake twice, instead we would always see everything as positive and make continuous mistakes that could put ourselves or others in danger. Hedonic concepts of happiness are described as the enjoyment of life and its pleasures. Eudaimonic concepts of…

    • 379 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    “The Experience Machine” is a thought experiment by Robert Nozick that imagines a machine that could give people whatever desirable or pleasurable experiences individuals could want. It would stimulate the person’s brain to cause pleasurable experiences that the subject could not distinguish from those apart from the machine. Hedonism is the idea that pleasure or happiness is the sole or chief good in life. As a hedonist, one tries to maximize net pleasure. A consideration of the experience machine shows that hedonism is flawed. According to hedonism, pleasure is the only thing humans seek. People should not consider the experience machine because it would bring pleasure all of the time. If people were given…

    • 289 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    There have been a few arguments against the theory of hedonism. The strongest objection to hedonism is the “Experience Machine.” The Experience Machine was introduced by a philosopher named Robert Nozick. Nozick offered a thought experiment which imagines that scientists came out with a machine in which a person can enter into and experience a world where they live their most joyous, pleasurable life. The machine would allow you to experience your perfect life, even though in reality it is just merely a simulation. If you choose to step in the machine, you will have no memory of going into it, nor will you know that it is a simulation. So the question is, if this type of machine were available to give you a simulation of a life where would…

    • 346 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In “The Experience Machine,” Robert Nozick expresses his belief that most people would not want to “plug in” to an experience machine. He defines an experience machine as a machine that helps you to see and feel the experiences you want, even though they are far from reality. If I were given the opportunity to plug in to this experience machine, I would choose not to. Nozick states that “first, we want to do certain things, and not just have the experience of doing them” (28). This statement is very true to me. Why would I want to miss out on doing the things I want to experience most in life by letting a machine just make me think that I’m doing these things? It wouldn’t really mean anything to me if I couldn’t actually experience things in…

    • 306 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are many other goals apart from happiness in life that are worth pursuing. Although Jeremy Bentham (inventor of first type of utilitarianism, act utilitarianism) famously said “nature has placed humanity under the rule of two sovereign masters, pleasure and pain”, it seems pleasure is not the only goal people strive for.…

    • 323 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    He doesn’t claim that doing things gives us more pleasure; rather there is something intrinsically good that is beyond pleasure in experiencing a real reality (p. 28). Secondly, that it is intrinsically valuable for us to maintain and develop our characters and become better people (p. 28). Norzick argues that we care about the kinds of people that we are and what kind of virtues we exhibit. Therefore it is prudent that we spend regular time working on our characters and improving our flaws so as to become better than we currently are. The Experience Machine would hinder this because we’d be floating like “indeterminate blobs” (p. 28) in a tank unable to make proper contact with ourselves through reflections and personal check-ins that helps us evaluate and then make moves to bettering ourselves. He justifiably calls this a form of suicide (p.28). Finally, Norzick argues that it is intrinsically good to be in contact with things that transcend realties that are manmade (p. 28). He argues that the Experience Machine would limit us to only manmade realities causing us to miss out on others, namely nature and supernatural realities. While hooked up, one would be limited to only living manmade realities causing them to miss out on those that were here before us, like nature, and those suggested in religions. Norzick concludes that the argument for hedonism is false because it is…

    • 788 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    If the only way to obtain happiness is to leave reality, then the happiness is not genuine. In Aldous Huxley’s Brave New World, the citizens of Huxley’s society frequently consume a hallucinogen, Soma, in order to escape reality and experience happiness. Whenever a problem arises, the government requires its people to take Soma. But even when not on Soma, citizens are conditioned to enjoy everything they do have and dislike what they don’t. So, wouldn’t this mean infinite joy? One flaw is that the government removes the idea of family and prohibits its citizens from getting too close to any one person so that heartbreak and grief cannot occur. But removing family and…

    • 911 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    As a result, the degrees of enjoyment felt vary for different people. For selfless people, making a sacrifice in their lives brings about immediate pain but leaves them with lasting enjoyment through helping out those that they love. For selfish people it is quite the opposite. Their personal gain brings about enjoyment despite it being at the expense of others. One must look at whether this is shallow or deep enjoyment. By this I mean that the greedy people feel enjoyment, but since they hurt others along the way it would not be considered real enjoyment to good people. In addition, the enjoyment of the bad will be short-lived as it is purely materialistic and they pushed people away in order to attain…

    • 1017 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Robert Nozick has an experiment called the experience machine. If the people choose to stay inside the machine, they can freely experience anything that they want selectively. However, they can also choose to stay outside of the machine and experience in the real world unpredictably. The life, which I consider to worth living in, is a life I can go out and experience with my friends and family, not to stay in a machine. In addition, it does matter whether things actually happens. There are many adventures in the real world, in which not all of the people have experienced. The machine works on the knowledge of the people who want to go inside. The person, who chooses to stay inside the machine, has limited knowledge about the outside world;…

    • 771 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Edwards, Paul. The Encyclopedia of Philosophy Volume 7 & 8. 1st ed. Simon and Schuster MacMillan, 1996.…

    • 1637 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    An essay about the ultimate form of happiness. Not the brief pleasure sought by impulse. Nor is…

    • 528 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    If all pleasures differ only in quantity and duration, then the world in BNW is a dream for hedonists. One's life in BNW is conditioned to be content and happy with one's, job, class in life, and the daily schedule of life. This schedule for one's life never changes and so delivers a maximum amount of pleasure due to being happy and content. High pleasure in BNW also comes from the open sexual relations between people. Basically, it is encouraged from childhood to have as many sex partners as possible, therefore maximizing the amount…

    • 953 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When I read this part of the passage in my textbook about being hook to an “experience machine” that would guarantee a constant state of happiness and positive emotion did cross my mind. I thought about what it would be like just to feel the constant emotion of being happy. At first I thought it would be an incredible experience. Never having to worry, or to feel sad, to feel rejected or lonely would be awesome not to feel those emotions anymore. However, to be in a constant state of being happy and always positive could take away the fulfillment of actually living life. Eudaimonic is defined as self-realization, meaning the expression and fulfillment of inner potential. So from this perspective, the good life results from living in accordance with your true self. It’s a process in which our talents, needs, and deeply held values direct the way we conduct our lives. The hedonic view captures a major element of what we mean by happiness in everyday terms: we enjoy life, we are satisfied with how our…

    • 361 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    If plugging in to the experience machine provides more pleasure, then we should just follow the idea. However, that’s only applicable if pleasure is all that matters to us. Nozick’s reply to this hedonistic argument is that we should not choose to connect to the machine, and thus, pleasure is not the only thing that matters to us.…

    • 1003 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays