Preview

Robert Browning's Ordinary Men

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
442 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Robert Browning's Ordinary Men
Browning depicts the men in his case study as ordinary middle aged men who choose not to commit murder of Jewish men, women, and children as compared to Ordinary Men or Ideological Soldiers, it is clearly stated that men of Police Battalion 310 not only believed Jews as subhuman enemies but as a threat to Germany. The majority of PB 310 consisted of younger men who were consistently exposed to the political and economic turmoil of Germany. These men likely joined Hitler Youth and were exposed to Nazi propaganda through their school education. As stated on pages 49-50, most of these young soldiers were active party members. It also showed figures for men born between 1905-1912 as more susceptible to Nazi ideology.
In fact, men affiliated with National Socialism were deemed desirable for police admittance. “Daluege described this measure ‘as a political necessity’. He further added ‘the politically schooled soldiers of the movement are the guarantors that the National Socialist ideology (Ideenwelt) will serve the general good of the Prussian police’” (44). Clearly, Daluege understood the significance of police men sharing and establishing National Socialist ideology. In addition, Himmler set up propaganda meetings for members of the SS and SA to further enhance their beliefs by including
…show more content…
The majority of men who participated in the killing of men, women, and children were far removed from the idea of Jews and people and sincerely believed their threat to Germany. Police battalions were not forced to commit murder, but instead choose to commit these actions in alignment with their ideology. “PB 310 was in fact only one of thirty-one police battalions operating on the Eastern Front during 1942” (60-61), indicating the numerous men who believed in their action and committed to their

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Satisfactory Essays

    The wars between the Axis Power and the Allied and the dropping of atomic bombs in Japan were usually what come into a discussion about World War II. Besides those events, the most horrific and considerably inhumane time was the Holocaust. The Holocaust was a period time during World War II, when Adolf Hitler launched a “movement” to kill all the Jews and anyone he deemed as lower than him in his territories. Most people now looked back at history around this time and believed that the SS and policemen killed the Jews because of brainwashing and forcing. But, in the book Ordinary Men, Christopher R. Browning argued that it was not the case. He argued that these police officers were ordinary men just like everybody else and they were not forced…

    • 136 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Bahr's Testimonies

    • 224 Words
    • 1 Page

    The “Testimonies of SS Men” provides further examples that the Nazi regime shaped the perpetration of the Holocaust, not simply willing individuals. For example, observe Bahr’s testimony. Bahr was an SS officer responsible for gassing victims in a concentration camp. The counsel asks Bahr how long the victims took to die, how long it took to gas them, and why he killed. Bahr simply responds that he does not know; he just obeyed orders (Testimonies, 2). When pressed further about why he gassed people, Bahr responded that he “only had orders to pour the gas in” and did not know anything else about it (Testimonies, 2). Bahr’s testimony implies that he distanced himself from the victims. This ordinary man does not appear to have such animosity…

    • 224 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Adolf Hitler, when appointed Chancellor in 1933, wanted to use his newly acquired power base to create a new Volksgemeinschaft a new German nation. However, in order to be in this new ‘master race’ having ‘Aryan’ qualities was essential, as well as being socially and politically committed to the Fuhrer. In order to create this new community the government needed to make the various groups which constituted the German public sympathetic to their cause. The most obvious place to start was youth indoctrination.…

    • 1976 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Throughout the novel Browning uses the judicial interrogations as his source, though these sources could be very biased. He follows the path that Reserve Police Battalion 101 follows all the way from their orders at Jozefow, Poland, to the Erntefest massacres. Browning depicts how these average mid-age men were transformed into cold-blooded killers that kill when ordered. Browning makes it clear that the Reserve Police Battalion 101 were part of the German internal police force called the Order Police. Their main duties included ghetto clearing and the deportation of Jews. When I read this I thought by order police they were simply there to keep order and prevent any type of uprisings, but Browning shows such isn’t the case when he describes the type of “Order” Reserve Police Battalion 101 was ordered to keep.…

    • 575 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Although our world has seen many events occur which defy explanation and simply boggle the mind, thus far none has matched the Holocaust in the intensity and sheer damage that it caused the world and more significantly the Jewish population of Europe. Yet, to this day who should be blamed for the Holocaust has still been an open question, yes it was Hitler's plan and original idea, but was he the only one behind it? All along it was the idea that the Jews had been the downfall of the German empire and something has to be done about them. A large factor in these ideas was the use of Einzatsgruppen and Police detachments behind the Army Front in clearing out and containing the Jewish populations in Ghettos or simply to eliminate them. Who these men were and what they represented is what Christopher R. Browning discusses in his book "Ordinary Men: Reserve Police Battalion 101 and the Final Solution in Poland." We are shown what kind of men comprised this unit, Party members, members of the SS, which social class did they come from, working or privileged upper higher classes, and so on. The first killings are examined and how individuals reacted to them. None of the members of Police Battalion 101 had any idea that their first shooting of unarmed Jews was to take place, thus when asked by the commander of the Battalion those who wish to step out can, and they will be assigned other jobs, at first one man stepped out and was immediately berated by his commanding officer. After Trapp (the commander of the battalion) "had taken Schmike (the man who stepped out) under his protection, some ten or twelve other men stepped forward as well. They turned in their rifles and were told to await a further assignment from the major (pg. 57)." Later on even more men would step out or at least be asked to be excused after they had shot five or six people while others simply milled about at different junctures of the area trying to avoid being asked to be part of the shooting squads.…

    • 746 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    What did the police do? Were they not fighters for the law, for justice? The Nazis not only sent troops to war, but to grab innocent people like jews, homosexuals, gypsies, political opponents, and more to concentration camps. With rants, protests, and speeches; the Nazis managed to get many of german workers to join their party. They were all upset about the treaty of Versailles, and wanted a change.…

    • 1378 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Why did Nazi soldiers in Germany during the third Reich obey orders by Adrof Hitler and commit atrocities to the Jewish communities? Why do people commit bad deeds in a situation where they are led to blindly obey an authority figure? The conscious says not to continue, but the authority figure said “It is absolutely essential that you continue” (Nevid & Rathus, p. 245). Should one resist and not obey the authority figures that made the immoral request? Stanley Milgram a Psychologist at Yale University did research study on this question.…

    • 689 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As logical as this reason sounds, it is, nonetheless, a historically inaccurate assertion. While Browning only examines one battalion from the Holocaust in his book, it seems reasonable to assume that the consequences those men received for choosing not to kill were common among other battalions as well. For Reserve Police Battalion 101, at the beginning of one of their first assignments they were given the opportunity to opt out. Their leader, Major Trapp, “made an extraordinary offer: if any of the older men among them did not feel up to the task that lay before him, he could step out” (2). Not only were they given the option to withdraw at the beginning, some men asked to opt out right before the action at Jósefów, and others withdrew after it started (61). Often, the men who chose not to participate were restationed and assigned jobs, such as driving a truck being on guard duty. The men were not killed for the decision they made, and the consequences they received for this choice were minimal. One of the most obvious “consequences” of a man’s choice not to kill was being considered less manly and more cowardly among his companions. The men might have felt embarrassed among their friends for not having gone through with the killing, it…

    • 1427 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Why Did Genocide Happen

    • 1373 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Following the conclusion of World War II in Nazi Germany, the world witnessed the Nuremburg War Criminal Trials, a set of trials against the onlookers of the Holocaust, or Germany’s mass extermination of European Jews. In most of the cases in the trials, the accused often used obedience to plead their cases, claiming that their actions had all come from higher in the Nazi’s hierarchy of government. Researcher Stanley Milgram “devised [an] experiment to answer the question ‘Could it be that Eichmann and his million accomplices in the Holocaust were just following orders? Could we call them accomplices?’ … The study revealed that two-thirds of the time, the participant was willing to deliver potentially life-threatening shocks to the ‘learner’ simply because they were receiving orders from an authority figure” (Document A and Documentary). Historians baffled the thought that Americans were not capable of killing their own peers, simply because the population was thought of as “superior” and it was claimed to be “impossible for an American to kill a fellow American.” However, Milgram’s experiments confirmed the truth that humans are willing to commit unethical or inhumane acts against other humans if given orders from an authority figure, confirming his suspicions during the Nuremberg Trials, and more specifically, Adolf Eichmann’s claim that he was only following…

    • 1373 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ralph Ellison's novel, The Invisible Man, depicts an epic of racial change and bitter race relations in America; yet, it was not meant to describe the struggle of black, white, or yellow people, but to illustrate how a man's experiences through human error shape his being and his reality. The narrator in this story, who remains unnamed, builds up to a conclusive invisibility through the knowledge that many different people he meets along his journey pass down to him. His character in the end and the reality in which he lives in had all built up with the help of the little invisible characters mentioned in the story. As the story moves along, the narrator encounters Emerson, a man mentioned as…

    • 1045 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Ordinary Men

    • 1347 Words
    • 6 Pages

    If one were to take anything from Christopher Browning’s Ordinary Men it is that even the most ordinary, normal men have the capacity to kill. The 101st Reserve Police Battalion executed at least 6,500 Jews at the Polish cities and villages of Jozefow, Lomazy, Serokomla, Lukow, Konskowola, Parczew, Radzyn, Kock, and Miedzyrzec and participated in the deportation of at least 42,000 Jews to the gas chambers in Treblinka (Browning, chapter 14, page 121). There were most likely even more killings that were never documented and much less remembered by the members of the 101st. These men had their first taste of death at Jozefow where they massacred 1,500 Polish Jews (Browning, chapter 8, page 74). It was a brutal and harrowing event where men, women, children, and the elderly were all executed, many in their own homes and even more in the forest surrounding the town. But out of this horror and chaos also came a sliver of hope for the souls of the men of the 101st when Major Trapp offered an interesting option; whoever did not have the stomach to participate in the executions could step out before the massacre was underway. Ten or twelve men accepted his offer (Browning, chapter 7, page 57). This would eventually lead to many men stepping away from executions in coming “actions”. Before the war these men were ordinary lower class workers who no doubt enjoyed many of the simple pleasures that we still enjoy today. These were ordinary men who found themselves in an extraordinary situation. They were ordinary men who became extraordinary killers.…

    • 1347 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    According to American historian Benjamin Sax, “the SS was not merely a police, surveillance and paramilitary organisation. Its main objective, from which it derived its ‘legitimate’ use of force, was to create the racially pure Volksgemeinschaft”. This description of the SS Gestapo incorporates many opinions revolving around its position in the Third Reich; he infers that its use of ‘legitimate force’ had an impact on how society behaved, which suggests that Hitler used this force as a tool of repression. However Volksgemeinschaft was an ideology respected by the masses of Germany’s ‘Aryan race’, particularly after the ‘stab in the back’ myth of 1918. Therefore, Sax may also be inferring that the SS Gestapo had little opposition due to the shared support of what they stood for: Hitler’s propaganda fuelled vision of his German Empire. This divided view is supported by the ‘alltagsgeschichte’ approach (the study of everyday life) in which the Third Reich can be seen as based partly on popular support, as well as an intrusive and arbitrary terror.…

    • 2028 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Invisible Man is a story told through the eyes of the narrator, a Black man struggling in a White culture. The narrative starts during his college days where he works hard and earns respect from the administration. Dr. Bledsoe, the prominent Black administrator of his school, becomes his mentor. Dr. Bledsoe has achieved success in the White culture which becomes the goals which the narrator seeks to achieve. The narrator's hard work culminates in him being given the privilege of taking Mr. Norton, a White benefactor to the school, on a car ride around the college area. After much persuasion and against his better judgement, the narrator takes Mr. Norton to a run down Black neighborhood. When Dr. Bledsoe found out about the trip the narrator was kicked out of school because he showed Mr. Norton anything less than the ideal Black man. The narrator is shattered, by having the person he idealizes turn on him. Immediately, he travels to New York where he starts his life anew. He joins the Brotherhood, a group striving for the betterment of the Black race, an ideal he reveres. Upon arrival in the Brotherhood, he meets Brother Tarp and Brother Tod Clifton who give him a chain link and a paper doll, respectively. I choose to write about these items because they are symbolic of his struggle in his community fighting for the black people and of his struggle within himself searching for identity.<br><br>The narrator works hard for the Brotherhood and his efforts are rewarded by being distinguished as the representative of the Harlem district. One of the first people he meets is Brother Tarp, a veteran worker in the Harlem district, who gives the narrator the chain link he broke nineteen years earlier, while freeing himself from being imprisoned. Brother Tarp's imprisonment was for standing up to a White man. He was punished for his defiance and attempt to assert his individuality. Imprisonment robbed him of his identity which he regained by escaping and establishing himself…

    • 1263 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    From the 30th of January 1933, it was only a year before the Nazis would consolidate every institution within Germany. This consolidation brought the Trade Unions, the Civil Service, the legal system, the states, the political parties and the German Army under Nazi control. Such a fundamental change begs the question of the Nazis succeeded in maintaining such immense power over Germany. Historians such as Martin Broszat (Llewellyn, 2013) have argued it was primarily the exploitation of psychological and physical force through the propaganda machine and the use of armed forces. Others such as David Irving argue that it was the colossal popular appeal for the Nazi policies that allowed them to maintain control over Germany (Llewellyn, 2013). The popular appeal of the Nazis was undeniable. However, it has become evident through hindsight that popular appeal did not always prevail, and in these circumstances the Nazis were quick to summon the propaganda machine to psychologically enforce and implement their policies, through fear and intimidation. Moreover, it was often the use of physical force and coercion that allowed for the new regime to create popular appeal which in turn kept the Nazis in power. Contrary to the statement, it is futile to divorce these perspectives, as their interdependence is primary in ascertaining how the Nazis remained in power. In order to understand this, it is vital to analyse the change in the lives of certain groups within Germany.…

    • 2324 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Nazi Germany

    • 5813 Words
    • 20 Pages

    On the surface, not many things seemed to have changed in the German government. Only three out of twelve ministers in the new cabinet belonged to the NSDAP. Several ministers had already been members of the Brüning, Papen, and Schleicher cabinets. Hitler, however, received a decisive concession from his conservative allies right before Hindenburg appointed him: the right to call new elections. The Reichstag had just been re-elected in November 1932, but Hitler hoped to win a majority in a new election campaign in which he would for the first time be able to use the power of the state in support of his party. That his party colleague Hermann Göring controlled Prussia with its strong police apparatus (which, until 1932 under SPD control, had often fought the Nazis) and that a Nazi was Interior Minister and thus head of the police all over Germany greatly helped Hitler.…

    • 5813 Words
    • 20 Pages
    Good Essays