top-rated free essay

Rhetorical Analysis

By geeksterbia Apr 22, 2015 1017 Words
Rhetorical Analysis

The article “The effects of private tutoring and parenting behaviors on children’s academic achievement in Korea: Are there differences between low- and high-income groups?” is a study conducted by Bong Joo Lee, Hyun Suk Jwa, and Se Hee Lim. The article examines the differences in parenting behaviors and private tutoring between high and low income families. The authors’ make an argument against the common belief “that family income is positively related to academic achievement through the investment in private tutoring in Korea” (Bong Joo Lee, et al. 164), as well as supporting the idea that parental involvement makes a greater impact on the academic achievements of their children. They give many great examples throughout the article to support their case by the use of academic studies as well as the use of their own research, data, charts, and tables to support their overall claim.

The authors’ state that other studies done on this subject provide inconsistent results due to a lack of control on many other contributing factors. A child’s academic achievement can’t be solely based on the effect of private tutoring alone, but also on the amount of income a family receives and the amount of support the parents give their children. They then pointed out that some studies showed that private tutoring “had a statistically significant effect on academic performance of children (Chung, 2011; Hanushek, 1989; M. S. Kim & Kim, 2010; E. W. Lee, 2006),” while other reports from “Ban, Chung, and Yang (2005) report no effect of private tutoring on academic achievement.” The inconsistent results of empirical studies suggest that there is a complex relationship between a family’s socio-economic factors, expenses for private tutoring, and children’s academic achievement (Bong Joo Lee, et al. 165). These claims effectively support the overall argument against Korea’s traditional belief relating academic achievement to the amount of private tutoring a child receives.

While private tutoring is considered a material investment by parents, the behaviors of the parent’s themselves can greatly impact the educational outcome of their children. Studies have shown that positive parenting behaviors, like openness in conversation and involvement in their child’s educational progress, can greatly improve their child’s academic achievement (Bong Joo Lee, et al. 166). Neglectful parenting behaviors, “however, tend to be related to lower levels of academic performance (Chung, 2011; B. J. Lee, Kim, & Kim, 2010; Mayer, 1997).” Other studies have also supported this claim, “finding that parents with higher incomes display more positive parenting behaviors (J. H. Lee & Kim, 2007; Mayer, 1997; Shin, 2004).” The author’s citation of other studies supports the idea of parental behaviors in relation to the child’s educational outcome. Comparing the authors’ claim to the research conducted by others, the studies have received consistent results and therefore creating a base of credibility for the audience. Research has shown that parents with a higher level of education can create an environment more suitable for academic success than those with less education (Bong Joo Lee, et al. 166). They support their claim by comparing it to the same claim in similar studies, not only that, but they are able to replicate the same data in the article. This gave the reader a visual aid to help better understand the conclusion of their article. With the charts provided throughout the article the audience can see the extensive research done by the authors to prove their point. Gathering data from multiple sources, the authors’ were able to provide a trustworthy accumulation of information. Using the Korean Welfare Panel Study (KWPS), a nationwide survey of a representative sample of the Korean population, they are able to view a wide range of families’ socio-economic characteristics (The Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs & Seoul National University, 2009). Comparing the expenditures on private tutoring, middle school students’ academic achievement, and behaviors of their parents, the survey gives a great amount of information to base the study off of. But with the only collectible data being from KWPS, the data isn’t completely reliable because there was no other study to base it off of. Following the literary comparisons of the authors’ claims to other studies, the research done by Lee, Jwa, and Lim can be seen visually by the audience through a number of charts and tables. Examining the differences in key variables, the authors’ are able to perform multi-group comparisons using structural equation modeling (Bong Joo Lee, et al. 169). This then leads into an explanation of their method, from what variables they controlled and what tests they’ve used to achieve their results. The data shown in their results effectively supports their overall conclusion that a child’s academic achievement shouldn’t be solely based off of their parents’ income, but rather, that the study should include as many controlled factors in order to achieve the most accurate results. While all of the information provided has been strictly scrutinized, it’s inevitable to say that the study has its limitations. “Any analysis using observational data faces a possibility of model misspecification (Bong Joo Lee, et al. 175).” By the authors’ mentioning these limitations and accepting that their data isn’t perfect, the audience can see the overall objective is to inform the reader. They are not trying to seek approval of the audience by use of emotional appeal but they gain the reader’s attention through logic and reason.

Throughout this article the authors used a strong appeal of logos to support their claims. The lack in use of ethos and pathos gave the article more credibility by using facts and data to support their argument. The tone of the article was very formal, it created a professional image of the authors. Although the research wasn’t perfect, their acknowledgement of this gave them the upper-hand. This made the experience more believable and appealing to the audience, supporting the authors’ overall conclusion.

Works Cited

Bong Joo Lee, Hyun Suk, Jwa, Se Hee Lim.”The effects of private tutoring and parenting behaviors on children’s academic achievement in Korea: Are there differences between low- and high-income groups?” KEDI Journal of Educational Policy. 11.2 (2014): 163-178. Print.

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Rhetorical Analysis

    ...Rhetorical Analysis Prejudice is an issue that has been around for hundreds of years. It has become a part of natural human behavior. Two sides divide prejudice at the present: one fighting to eradicate prejudice and the other in defending it and claiming it can be socially productive. Most people choose the side of eradicating prejudice fr...

    Read More
  • Rhetorical Analysis Essay

    ...January 13th 2012 AP English Rhetorical Analysis Essay #3 Final Draft Every individual has traditions passed down from their ancestors. This is important because it influences how families share their historical background to preserve certain values to teach succeeding generation. N. Scott Momaday has Native American roots inspiring him ...

    Read More
  • Rhetorical Analysis Example

    ...Step-by-step Rhetorical Analysis 1. Identify the three elements of the rhetorical triangle. a. Who is the speaker? (education, ethnicity, era, political persuasion, etc.) b. Who is the audience? c. What is the subject? 2. What is the author saying about the subject? What is his/her assertion? 3. What is the author’s attitude (tone) ab...

    Read More
  • Rhetorical Analysis of "The Shadow Scholar"

    ...Bessette Laura Bessette ENG W131 Spring 2014 Rhetorical Analysis of "The Shadow Scholar" The prefix 'pseudo' seems to perfectly describe the character of Dave Tomar, known by all as Ed Dante (Dave Tomar is Dante's pseudonym). His article "The Shadow Scholar," which appeared in the chronicle review section of _The Chronicle of Higher Educati...

    Read More
  • Conducting Job Analysis

    ... Conducting a Job Analysis and writing a Job Description WHAT IS JOB ANALYSIS? Job analysis may be formally defined as the collection and collation of information regarding the tasks performed in various positions in an organization and assessments of the knowledge, skills, and abilities necessary to successfully perform those tasks. To st...

    Read More
  • Rhetorical Analysis of Ellen DeGeneres's Commencement Speech

    ... Ellen’s Commencement Speech Rhetorical Analysis Graduation caps fly into the air, cheers erupt, and diplomas are received. This is a typical graduation day. Not only did these ceremonial events take place for Tulane University's class of 2009, but Ellen DeGeneres was there to congratulate them as well! This class was dubbed the...

    Read More
  • Rhetorical Modes

    ...Associate Program Material Appendix C Rhetorical Modes Matrix Rhetorical modes are methods for effectively communicating through language and writing. Complete the following chart to identify the purpose and structure of the various rhetorical modes used in academic writing. Provide at least two tips for writing each type of rhetorical...

    Read More
  • Rhetorical modes

    ...University of Phoenix Material Rhetorical Modes Quiz Complete the following chart to identify the purpose and structure of the various rhetorical modes used in academic writing. Provide at least two tips for writing each type of rhetorical device. Rhetorical mode Purpose Explain when or why each rhetorical mode is used. Struc...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.