Preview

"Respect for Life" Ronald Dworkin

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1725 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
"Respect for Life" Ronald Dworkin
“Respect for Life”

Taking the responsibility of becoming a parent comes with many emotionally and morally challenging decisions of right and wrong. Mr. and Mrs. Ayala have been faced with one of the toughest moral dilemma's that parents could be confronted with. Their only daughter who is twenty has recently been diagnosed with a rare form of blood cancer known as leukemia. The chances of recovery are extremely slim without a rare bone marrow transplantation from a close blood match. The problem linked to this process is that the blood needs to come from a sibling, which Anissa does not have. The Ayala's have considered having another child in order to give Anissa the best chances of survival. The parents know that the best chance for her survival is to have another child which may possibly possess the matching bone marrow. Since their only daughter has lived a healthy, loving and wonderful twenty years along side them, they want to do whatever possible to save her. They know she deserves the right to live life, love, and achieve all the goals that a young lady could desire. The “respect for life” is obviously strong with these parents since they are willing to do anything in their power to save their precious only daughter. They know for a fact that their daughter should have a long life ahead of her with a lot of potential. The author of “Life's Dominions,” Robert Dworkin best describes the frustrating dilemma on hand: “If you believe that the natural investment in a human life is transcendently important, that the gift of life itself is infinitely more significant than anything the person whose life it is may do for himself, important though that may be, you will also believe that a deliberate, premature death is the greatest frustration of life possible, no matter how limited or cramped or unsuccessful the continued life may be. Clearly, the moral dilemma they are faced with is whether or not they should conceive another child solely for the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    I also feel that Sarah’s doctors should’ve suggested this option to the Health and Human Services before they suggested it to Sarah’s parents because they now gave Sarah’s parents hope in the one place hope should not be given because these doctors cannot be 100% sure that the transplant or any transplant will be successful but because they told the parents they are confident they encouraged the parents to take on Health and Human Services.…

    • 1267 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A new ethical discussion is emerging in the oncology world due to overwhelming advances in fertility preservation in all age groups. The journal article “The Ethics of Fertility Preservation for Paediatric Cancer Patients: From Offer to Rebuttable Presumption” addresses the pressing need to discuss the ethics of failing to preserve fertility as this current practice may no longer be considered ethically appropriate for populations for whom established techniques are available. The current standard practice involves merely offering the option of fertility preservation procedures to children and young adults with cancer. Previous ethical discussions of fertility preservation have focused on the question of whether it is appropriate to perform fertility preservation procedures for a particular patient. The question at the heart of this article suggests the new discussion needs to address the question, “is failing to proceed with fertility preservation ethically justifiable?’” (McDougall 2015). The article gives some…

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Had this had been me in this predicament I would choose to see the pregnancy through, however I would choose to give the child up for adoption because I don’t think it is the child’s fault that they are born with this disability so I would give them the opportunity to live for I too see life as being sacred. As a result one might say that the theory I relate too is the moral agency one. I chose to handle the decision based on my morality and I thought that it was not right to choose to terminate the pregnancy. Due to me judging the situation and deciding what was right and what was wrong, my decision was heavily influenced by the moral agency…

    • 1063 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The root of the argument stems from the lack of a decisive role that is responsible for making decisions when faced with conflicting moral issues. The doctors felt that an agreement with the mother regarding treatment should be followed until, according to their best judgment, she is no longer capable of making the decision on her own. The doctor is put in an ambiguous position to make a final decision since it would seem that his professional opinion is secondary to the choices of the mother. It was argued that a spouse or parent could make the decision at this point, rather than the doctor, especially if it were concerning the care for the as-yet unborn child. However, the rights of the unborn child are called into question if the choice may potentially cause the death of the child. At this point, the doctors looked towards legislative measures to not only protect themselves from legal action, but to establish some sort of precedent to follow. However, even the judge was hesitant to take on the role and stated that it should be judged on a case by case basis. Whether they maintain the agreement with the mother, or alter treatment to save the child, the doctors will always be in conflict when determining where the doctor/patient relationship lies and when it is appropriate to take action against the will of the…

    • 299 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    This dilemma involves a woman, Susan, who finally becomes pregnant after many years of trying. A blood test reveals that the baby she is carrying had Downs Syndrome. Both her doctor and a professor of evolutionary biology, Richard, who she consulted, suggest that she terminate the pregnancy based on the amount of suffering that both she and the child would endure as a result of the Downs Syndrome diagnosis. Richard went so far as to say that aborting the pregnancy would be the most ethical decision in the situation, given the circumstances.…

    • 1180 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The key decision makers in this case are the patient, and the medical team. The big question is whether to respect the patient's autonomy and compromise standards of care or ignore the patient's wishes in an attempt to save her life. The key decision makers in this case is the woman’s husband and herself. The husband already lost an unborn child due to the mother’s religious background, should he lose his wife as well? Many religions, if not all believe in wrongs of innocent killings. If the woman is religious shouldn’t she think about the murder of her unborn child? The decision she made without accepting the blood transfusion and surgery caused her to lose her child and is the cause of her own death.…

    • 296 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After much thought and consideration, I have come to the difficult conclusion that having an abortion would be the most humane decision, not only for the baby, but for myself (the mother) and for my theoretical spouse, children, and other family members. Trisomy 13 is an awful chromosomal abnormality that has no cure. This is not a disease such as down syndrome that a child could live with. Research has shown that most babies with Trisomy 13 do not even live to be a year old. The rare percentage of babies that live over a year have severe defects and do not live a long, sustainable life. I want my child to have the highest quality of life possible. I would never want to bring a child into the world to have it suffer. Trisomy 13 guarantees a…

    • 673 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Induced abortion is just one of the multitudes of bioethical dilemmas that a physician is charged with confronting. The act of inducing abortion is a controversial subject that involves many potentially competing factors such as an individual’s moral and religious compass, what rights an unborn fetus has and the rights that a woman has over her own body. In the case of a 16 year-old girl who is pregnant as a result of incest and seeking an abortion, my role as the practitioner would be to put the health of the patient first - above all personal bias.…

    • 401 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When a person first reads the famous quote “We must always take side. Neutrality helps the oppressor, never the victim. Silence encourages the tormentor, never the tormented.” Spoken by the notable Elie Wiesel while accepting the Nobel Peace Prize of 1986, it could cause a reaction; in this case any reaction could occur depending on a person’s morals, ethics and even values. But, what does this quote really mean?…

    • 710 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After about nine months of seasickness and cravings, women have the power to bring life into this Earth. When women are not in the position to give birth during the late stage of their pregnancy, they usually have only two possible outcomes. In these cases, the decision should depend on what the family and the mother find best. The government should not intervene and choose for the mother as they most likely will not know the best option for the two. As the female population progresses and receives additional rights that will lead to equality, they are still restrained from making a choice for their own child that does not require assistance from authority on the sensitive convoluted topic. The fact that a late term abortion is required implies…

    • 727 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    What is truth? Many believe that truth is what we are taught and the words we know, but the basic question Orwell raises in 1984 is whether there is any such thing as “truth.” Fromm further argues that the beliefs of truth explained in 1984 are “a development which is taking place in the Western industrial countries.” The three slogans discussed by Orwell are war is peace, freedom is slavery and ignorance is strength, which are, in fact, a reality in present day society.…

    • 732 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    However, she mentions that there are the “usual clients”—particularly in their teenage years—that so clearly have no parental or financial support behind them. The argument that is made here by pro-choice activists, is that the when the ability to take care of the potential child is at stake—thus providing a lifestyle that is not fit for a baby—it is of greater nobility to clear the child and the mother of such burden. In my opinion, there is only one word for a person with this attitude: selfish. Having a personal relationship with someone who is struggling with the fact that she is incapable of having children of her own, I see the inevitable sorrow that goes along with having an incomplete family despite your greatest efforts. In the essay, it is said that there are over 100 abortions a day in that particular clinic alone. In this world, if all of those people chose to let a family who is capable of providing the child a stable homelife adopt the child, they would not only be saving the child’s life, but saving a family’s life. Infertility is a growing issue in today’s society, and adoption is sometimes the only answer. Families around the world who are struggling with this issue have to pray for a miracle, as sometimes it takes up to 10 years to finally adopt a child. This is all happening, whilst girls and women alike are making it a…

    • 1062 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Abortion Outline

    • 287 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The Dilemma of Life By Nikki Lehman Dr. Trent WRI234-C 26 February 2013 The Dilemma of Life I. Introduction A. Describe two arguments for abortion. B. Introduce the solution. II.…

    • 287 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Cafs

    • 728 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Surrogate motherhood raises difficult ethical, philosophical and social issues. There is debate in the community as to the wisdom of surrogacy arrangements. There is scope for disagreement as to the morality of aspects of such reviews the arrangements. This Chapter reviews the arguments for and against surrogacy, including the moral bases for making judgements about surrogacy. In raising these issues the Commission is seeking guidance on community attitudes to assist in formulating principles on can he made.…

    • 728 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Satire Essay On Abortion

    • 599 Words
    • 3 Pages

    When I was about seven years old, I heard my aunt, a gynecologist, speaking on the phone with one of her patient’s husbands’ who wanted his wife to abort their baby. My aunt absolutely refused and commanded that he stop calling her. At the time, I didn’t really comprehend the story or what was happening, but I never forgot that moment. As I grew older, I understood why my aunt was so rigid about her decision. Abortion has been a huge issue not only in today’s society, but probably dating back to earlier times. It is the slaughtering of innocent lives with approval from the government. This is exactly why this dilemma should grab the attention of everyone, because It doesn’t just affect a specific age group it affects everyone and it is a…

    • 599 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays