Preview

Research Devices in Hanging Katherine Garret

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
848 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Research Devices in Hanging Katherine Garret
Abigail Davis’ Hanging Katherine Garret provides its readers with perspicacious inquiries into a number of different historical topics. It provides a way of introducing history (such as the Pequot history, the religious history of the Great Awakening, interaction between the natives and the early settlers in the colonies, the Indian removal process) to the masses. As someone who has been largely unfamiliar with early American history I can certainly testify that Davis’ novel does a good job in shedding some light on these significant topics. However, the important question that arises at this conjecture is whether or not this rendition of history by Davis is, in fact, accurate. Yes, her work does shed some light on these important topics. But does it shed the right light? Is it authentic? Is it verifiable? More often than not, Davis presents us with minute details of the hanging of Kate Garret with a profound sense of convenience. The “I have stumbled onto this great mystery” device makes the actual information in the book and the research gone into acquiring that information seems unrealistic at the very least. If we can’t trust the research process, we certainly can’t trust the history. The important thing to consider at this point then becomes the relationship between fact and fiction: is Hanging Katherine Garret – A novel based on the 1737 trial of a Pequot woman actually a work of fiction? While this may not be true, Davis’ use of important information in her book suggests that it is actually so. While Karla (the protagonist) does use a lot of information from research which can be verified, the bulk or majority of her work comes from a ‘hunch’. Time and again, we see Kate’s voice occur telling Karla minute details about Pequot Indian history, the times in which she lived, her relationship with her owners and finally everything that occurred on the night of the infanticide. How can we, the readers, simply trust a dead person’s voice? No, while the

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Better Essays

    The Unredeemed Captive

    • 1617 Words
    • 7 Pages

    From the perspective of a twenty-one year old college student in the twenty first century, it is hard to relate to the colonist's of the 16 and 1700's. Crossing the frontier was a necessary task for these colonists to begin new lives in New England. The only way to tap into this same theme is through placing one's self in the wilderness, both physically and mentally, and peering out to the other side. As a class we were able to accomplish this by visiting the Buttolph-Williams House of Old Wethersfield and look upon this house through the cover of trees, just as these earlier settlers and Native Americans had done. The story of Eunice Williams is a wonderful example of the reciprocal theme of embracing the wilderness, by personal choice alone. In The Unredeemed Captive by John Demos, we hear the story of the raid upon Deerfield in 1704 and the significance of not only the torturous trek these captives endured, but the willingness for one child, Eunice Williams, to attach herself to these Native Americans captures and to embrace life in the wilderness.…

    • 1617 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The chapter demonstrates the aspects of comparative historical research. In the first part of the chapter, After the Fact, Serving Time in Virginia, various research methods used to verify what happened in the early Virginia colony by evaluation of Captain John Smith’s original narrative written to his published narrative, the research to seek historical evidence to verify names, dates and people, interpretation of anthropological facts about Algonquin Indians, and evaluation his writing style. As the chapter continues, it delves into historical analysis of economic and cultural growth of the Virginia colony reverting to what the author calls “most basic tactics of sociology” (After the Fact 6). The early colony failures were identified by historian’s research of documents from Colonial Virginia such as Smith’s writings; land company charters, written policies, and letters all reveal details about the colonies economics; trade company involvement, survival rate for new colonists, and identify innuendo’s of slavery and indentured servants. Historic research of these documents allows the author to make inferences about economic growth and how it relates to the cultural growth of the Virginia colony.…

    • 717 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Katherine Watkins was raped by John Long as she claimed under oath. Her story is confirmed by Humphrey Smith, whose deposition is in agreement with Katherine’s accusation. Humphrey had nothing to gain from defending Katherine’s story, which would warrant his story as true. In contrast, the other witnesses probably hated the white Quakers and would have delighted to see Katherine convicted and shame brought on the Quaker community. These other witness accounts from John Aust, William Harding, Mary Winter, and Lambert Tye are all part of a made up story to protect John Long and attack the Quakers. Each of these people, being black slaves, probably hated the white quakers and wanted to destroy and embarrass Katherine. The risks Katherine…

    • 191 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    John Brown: Hero? Villain?

    • 1793 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Students of history and those merely interested in casual inquiry will often explore a topic, find a legitimate opinion, accept it at face value, and move on. Too often with young or inexperienced historians this is the case. It does, in a way, make sense. Many topics an individual will study have been researched and written on countless times. It is easy to accept an opinion as is and forget about it. John Brown is one of these subjects. Merrill D. Peterson’s John Brown explores the complicated nature of the legacy of this militant abolitionist. Brown has been, in the time since his departure, construed as a hero, a villain, an antihero, a well-meaning lunatic, and so on. The nature of his actions and the divisive context they are found in gives way to many different opinions. Peterson’s book explores these many definitions of John Brown. The opinions of historians, students, politicians, and the like are weighed against the validity of their status as historical interpreters, their knowledge of the subject, their biases, and Peterson’s own interpretations. John Brown’s legacy is an ambiguous and complicated one and Peterson’s book explores the warring opinions of observers on whether John Brown is hero, villain, or both.…

    • 1793 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    [ 3 ]. Brewer, Holly. "Women in Colonial America." North Carolina State University, n.d. Web. 16 Oct. 2012. .…

    • 1806 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    Crucible-Into

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages

    In 1692 nineteen men and women and two dogs were convicted and hanged for witchcraft in a small village in eastern Massachusetts. By the standards of our own time, if not of that, it was a minor event, a spasm of judicial violence that was concluded within a matter of months. The bodies were buried in shallow graves or not at all, as a further indication that the convicted had not only forfeited participation in the community of man in this life, but in the community of saints in the next. Just how shallow those graves were, however, is evident from the fact that the people buried there were not eradicated from history: their names remain with us to this day, not least because of Arthur Miller, for whom past events and present realities have always been pressed together by a moral logic. In his hands the ghosts of those who died have proved real enough even if the witches they were presumed to be were little more than fantasies conjured by a mixture of fear, ambition, frustration, jealousy, and perverted pride.…

    • 885 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    War between the Indians and the Colonists was unavoidable from the very moment the Pilgrims first set foot on what was to eventually become Massachusetts in 1620. As more and more settlers began arriving over the years, tension between the two began to steadily rise. The settler 's insatiable hunger for land and their increasing mistreatment of the Indians began to break down an already somewhat fragile alliance between the two. The Indians were quickly losing land and their way of life as well to these new settlers and some of them believed the only way to stop this was to go on the offensive and push back them back. The result of this was a short fought war known as King Philip 's War. Though it only lasted a little over a year, it was an exceptionally brutal war that took a huge toll life wise and had a lasting impact on both the English and the Indians for many years to come.…

    • 2168 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Better Essays

    Metyard, Sarah. "The last dying speech (and last farewell to the world) of Sarah Metyard, and her own Daughter Sarah Morgan Metyard, who were executed July the 19th 1762, at Tyburn, for the barbarous Murder, of two Apprentice Girls." (1762): 1. Eighteenth Century Collections Online: Range 7219. Database. 20 Apr 2013.…

    • 2969 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    Puritan Essay

    • 844 Words
    • 3 Pages

    In 1676, Mary Rowlandson, an American woman, was captured by Native Americans and held against her will for 11 weeks. When she was returned unharmed, she wrote of her experience with the Wampanoags in A Narrative of the Captivity and Restoration of Mrs. Mary Rowlandson. In this excerpt from her narrative, Rowlandson clearly demonstrates her Puritan beliefs. This essay will identify elements of Puritanism found in Rowlandson’s writing, compare the role of God in her work to that of other Puritan writers, and finally compare Rowlandson’s focus with other Puritan writers. As an example of Puritan writing, Rowlandson’s narrative is one of the most famous works of early American literature.…

    • 844 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Better Essays

    The Unredeemed Captive

    • 1818 Words
    • 5 Pages

    The Unredeemed Captive- A Family Story From Early America, John Demos, Vintage Books, April 1995, New York…

    • 1818 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Salem Possessed Analysis

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Salem Possessed redefined the standard for the possibilities social history offers to understand the events and people of early America. Through a painstaking look at local records such as legal records, the Salem Village record book, the minister's book, and tax records Boyer and Nissenbaum discovered a long-standing pattern of contentious behavior of which the witchcraft accusations in 1692 was just one episode. Their analysis provides an invaluable insight into the social history of New England generally, and the factions of Salem Village that led to the tragic events of 1692, in particular.…

    • 774 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    In the story "John Adams and the Coming of the Revolution”, author David McCullough discusses how John Adams was asked to defend the British soldiers in court of the soldier’s accusation of man slaughter, following the Boston Massacre. Being such a problematic case that could ruin his reputation, John Adams accepted to defend the soldiers because of his experience in difficult cases, and his strong principles and beliefs. John Adam’s reputation did not even tarnish because of how skillfully he handled the case gaining the respect of the people of Boston.…

    • 610 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Throughout history, historians have spun events in order to alter and adjust others’ views on the event. This is especially true during Colonial times and the time leading up the American Revolution. During this time, information about the colonist’s events was passed on through word of mouth. One such man that was notorious for this was George Robert Twelves Hewes. Hewes was a Boston shoemaker, who at the age of twenty-eight witnessed four of his closest friends shot to death by The British red coats; he also participated in many of the key events of the Revolutionary crisis.1 Hewes recollections of the events that took place were passed along in the monograph The Shoemaker and the Tea Party: Memory and the American Revolution by Alfred F. Young. His recollections of the dumping of the tea into the harbor lead the reemergence of how significant the dumping of the tea was for the United States of America. However, stories of Hewes were also spun in order to alter the views of others.…

    • 1777 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Us History Began in 1607

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Sage, Associate Professor Henry J. U.S. History I: United States History 1607-1865. Lorton, Virginia, June 2010.…

    • 683 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Love and Hate in Jamestown

    • 1653 Words
    • 7 Pages

    As a young child many of us are raised to be familiar with the Pocahontas and John Smith story. Whether it was in a Disney movie or at a school play that one first learned of Jamestown, students want to believe that this romantic relationship really did occur. As one ages, one becomes aware of the dichotomy between fact and fiction. This is brilliantly explained in David A. Price's, Love and Hate in Jamestown. Price describes a more robust account of events that really did take place in the poorly run, miserable, yet evolving settlement of Jamestown, Virginia; and engulfs and edifies the story marketed by Disney and others for young audiences. Price reveals countless facts from original documents about the history of Jamestown and other fledgling colonies, John Smith, and Smith's relationship with Pocahontas. He develops a more compelling read than does the typical high school text book and writes intriguingly which propels the reader, to continue on to the successive chapters in the early history of Virginia.…

    • 1653 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays