top-rated free essay

Research

By tkroening1970 Apr 18, 2013 397 Words
University of Illinois at Chicago College of Medicine

Ethics in Clerkships

Case for Discussion : Disclosing a Mistake
Nancy Shaw was an 18-year-old in the seventeenth week of her first pregnancy when she was examined by ultrasound at health department clinic. That ultrasound revealed that her fetus had extreme and symmetrical shortening of the limbs. The clinic referred Ms. Shaw to the prenatal diagnosis center of a public hospital. There, Ms. Shaw discussed possible causes of the abnormalities with a genetic counselor. Following that discussion, Ms. Shaw decided to terminate the pregnancy. At that time, amniotic fluid was drawn for analysis. A medical student, John Dutchman, who was present with the attending physician, Dr. Lowland, before and after the termination was surprised to hear the attending physician tell Ms. Shaw that the fetus had been female. Mr. Dutchman had not realized that a woman undergoing an abortion would want this kind of information. The attending physician told him that Ms. Shaw had specifically asked for this information because she wanted to name the baby and have a short memorial service for her, as if she had died naturally. Ms. Shaw chose the name Elizabeth for her child. Subsequent laboratory analysis showed that the fetal deformities were due to Roberts syndrome. That analysis also showed the fetus to have a karyotype of 46, XY, indicating that the fetus was male. Mr. Dutchman asked the physician whether he should advise Ms. Shaw that an error had been made in announcing the sex of the fetus to her. Dr. Lowland said that there was no medical benefit that would occur if Ms. Shaw were told this information. Revealing the information, he said, would not change the risk of the condition in future pregnancies or do anything to change the sense of loss already experienced by Ms. Shaw. He argued, very strongly, that disclosing this information could disrupt the woman’s grief resolution, by opening the tragedy anew. He did not want Ms. Shaw, in any case, having doubts that other errors might have occurred in managing her pregnancy or offering counsel about abortion. Mr. Dutchman did not express his thoughts aloud, but he was unconvinced by these arguments. He wondered whether he should do something himself, either contact Ms. Shaw directly or continue to confront Dr. Lowland about the matter. (Modified from An Ethics Casebook for Genetic Counselors, 1994.)

Cite This Document

Related Documents

  • Methods of Research

    ...Methods of Research Jennifer Whitehead CJ490 8/12/14 Professor Price Methods of Research Scientist conducts research on a daily basis. The purpose of this research is exploration, description, explanation, and application. In the area of criminal justice things are getting researched all of the time. Take murder for example, the polic...

    Read More
  • experimental research

    ...Experimental research Experimental research is commonly used in sciences such as sociology and psychology, physics, chemistry, biology and medicine etc. Experimental research tests a hypothesis and establishes causation by using independent and dependent variables in a controlled environment. KEY POINTS Experiments are generally the most...

    Read More
  • research proposal

    ...Importance of motivation for sales people in insurance business in Bangladesh Nazim Uddin Khan 1. Introduction The current research is undertaken as a research project in the M.Phil program at the Department of Marketing of Jahangirnagar University. The study is carried out to find out the importance of motivation for sales people i...

    Read More
  • Research

    ...Sta. Clara Parish School 2360 P. Burgos St., Pasay City Telefax: 831-8253 * Tel. No. 833-1238/832-8890 S.Y. 2013 -2014 50 Years of Clarian Legacy: Quality Catholic Education Research I I. The effect...

    Read More
  • Research

    ... Business Research EthicsBusiness Research EthicsWhen most people think of Ethics or Morals they think of rules that distinguish between right or wrong. Most people learn ethical norms at home, at school, in church, or in other social settings. Although most people acquire their sense of right and wrong during childhood, moral development occur...

    Read More
  • Research

    ...DATE: January 2013 PROFESSOR: Jowaisas EMAIL: djowaisas@okcu.edu Required Text: Cozby, P. C. and S. C. Bates (2012) Methods in Behavioral Research (11th ed.) Boston: McGraw Hill. In accord with international copy write laws, no photocopied texts will be allowed in the classroom. Turn off cell phones and pagers. If there is an emergen...

    Read More
  • research

    ...and Feasibility Paper: Week 2 As preparation for the final research paper, formulate a theory about the correlation between measurable independent variables (causes) and one measurable dependent variable (the effect). Be sure to have at least two independent variables for proposed research paper. The topic proposal should include the followin...

    Read More
  • Research

    ...Chapter 1 Introduction to Research © 2009 John Wiley & Sons Ltd. www.wileyeurope.com/college/sekaran 1 Definition of Business Research  Business research: an organized, systematic, databased, critical, objective, scientific inquiry or investigation into a specific problem, undertaken with the purpose of finding answers or solutio...

    Read More

Discover the Best Free Essays on StudyMode

Conquer writer's block once and for all.

High Quality Essays

Our library contains thousands of carefully selected free research papers and essays.

Popular Topics

No matter the topic you're researching, chances are we have it covered.