Top-Rated Free Essay

Reality Tv

Good Essays
Opinions on Reality Television: A Deterioration of Mass Entertainment, or a Positive Experience for Viewers

Reality television is an extremely popular phenomenon despite its exceptionally young age. Reality television shows are popping up every day, increasing viewer counts for the strongest television channels in the market. Their success, unlike their effect on the viewer, is in arguable. Salman Rushdie, in his article, Reality TV: A Dearth of Talent and the Death of Morality argues that reality television is a deterioration of mass entertainment, whereas in James Poniewozik's Television, Why Reality TV is Good for us, reality television is viewed in a more positive light. Although both articles deal with the issue of reality television shows, they take different positions and employ different rhetorical techniques to make their arguments.
Poniewozik argues that reality television is a good way for people to make their own deductions from what they see. He claims that when watching a reality television show, no hidden implications are imposed on the audience whereas that is not the case when it comes to fiction (Poniewozik, 2003). In response to a famous moment on American idol, Poniewozik states, "It didn't nudge us to laugh at her or prod us to cry for her. In about two minutes, it told a quintessentially American story of ambition and desperation and shrinking options, and it left the judgment to us." (Poniewozik, 2003). This is contrary to Salman Rushdie's beliefs on the effect of reality television on the consumer. According to Rushdie, reality television shows are nothing more than uneventful wastes of times. He claims that they are the epitome of mediocrity, caught on tape (Rushdie, 1996). He asserts, "Who needs images of the world's rich otherness, when you can watch these half-familiar avatars of yourself--these half-attractive half-persons--enacting ordinary life under weird conditions? Who needs talent, when the unashamed self display of the talentless is constantly on offer?" Rushdie implies that audiences no longer seek richness, new information or depth on television, rather, they would like to see shallow, mediocre interpretations of reality that reflect run of the mill, every day life. Rushdie fervently argues his one position throughout the article.
Poniewozik uses a different rhetorical approach from Rushdie's. Poniewozik uses a more balanced method of argument, acknowledging the issue on many levels and presenting the other side to his argument. Though the title of Poniewozik's article suggests that reality television is good, Poniewozik does not fail to show how people would think it is bad, "It makes us feel tawdry, dirty, cheap--if it didn't, we probably wouldn't bother tuning in. And in this, for once, the audience and critics agree." (Poniewozik, 2003). This statement, is to a large extent, parallel to the views in Rushdi's article. However, what Rushdie's article lacks is this balanced approach, he never mentions any positive aspects associated with reality television, rather concentrates on criticizing reality television on so many levels, often using strong language to prove his point.
Both articles use casual language and an informal tone to present their arguments. This may hinder the effectiveness of the article by compromising its sense of formality and legitimacy or break the ice with the reader and appeal to him or her on an every-day, logical level. Poniewozik mentions in his article, "A great reality-TV concept takes some commonplace piety of a polite society and gives it a wedgie." (Poniewozik, 2003) This is an obvious display of informal language and a casual tone. Rushdie, however, says, "And what tawdry narcissism is here revealed!" Rushdi uses exclamation marks, begins his sentences with "and", and accuses people of being narcissists. Not only is he being casual, but unlike Poniewozik, is being disrespectful and extremely emotional. This can be an obstacle when attempting to present a balanced and logical argument. In conclusion, both articles deal with the issue of reality television shows; they take different positions and employ different rhetorical techniques to make their arguments. Reality television is a reality in the entertainment industry today, whether a certain person supports it or not. Forming one's own opinion on the mass media that is experienced by the masses on a daily basis is essential for clarity.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Reality Tv

    • 1014 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Reality TV has unseen effects and is detrimental to society. Reality TV is the current trend on TV that has brought back the buzz to television, but it also has unforeseen effects on its viewers. Some examples of Reality TV shows include: American Idol, The Bachelorette, Americas next top model, fear factor, etc...These shows range from singing talents, overcome their fears, to looks and beauty. Reality TV brings drama and voyeurism to its viewers by making its viewers too involved, taking them away from more important matters, and by wasting valuable resources on pointless entertainment.…

    • 1014 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    British philosopher James Allen once said that “circumstances don 't make a man, they only reveal him.” With that being known, reality television is simply a mirror image of what our society has become; a judge mental driven society where the passion for power and money overcomes the power of love. It 's an overview of a society that is not only weak economically, but is also separated from unworldly roots. It 's also a culture that lives by hanging by a string, characterized by thrill-seekers and addictions. Knowing the popularity of reality T.V. shouldn’t be shocking considering the fact that the world we live in respects vanity, rather than value. Watching reality television has dramatically affected society by increased cases of drama, insecurity, and outlook on the world.…

    • 1358 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Since the 1990’s, when reality television first started becoming widely popular, we have been able to see into the lives of different kinds of people, often turning everyday people into celebrities. With some of the most popular reality television shows, like Big Brother, True Life, American Idol, and most recently Jersey Shore, we are led on to believe that it is all real ("The Hunger Games Theme of Versions of Reality”). The reality of this television though is that most of it is either altered or manipulated just for our own entertainment. The directors of some of these shows often script, manipulate and plan situations to make the shows more appealing to their audiences ("How Much of the Reality”). Even in popular books like The Hunger Games where reality television is a theme, it is shown that it is changed just for the entertainment of the viewers ("The Hunger Games Theme of Versions of Reality”). While it is perceived to be real, the title of “reality television” is a misnomer because most showed turn out to be fake and scripted.…

    • 964 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    In an article found on the Pro Quest database, television critic, Mary McNamara postulates, “… even if we were to mistakenly dismiss reality shows as having no intrinsic value, there is no denying their influence on television in general. And considering that television still remains the most ubiquitous, influential and powerful medium in the world… any shift in its structure or content is worth academic consideration.” (McNamara, M. 2011). The article goes on to explain that reality television is extremely predominant in our society as exemplified by a recent SAT test that included questions about reality television (Para 1).…

    • 1997 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    There are many people in today's society who in watch reality TV for various reasons. In the essay, "The Tribe Has Spoken", Rebecca Gardyn explains how age and gender can affect why people watch reality TV. She also focuses on whether or not reality TV will last. In her essay, there are many different statistics showing peoples perspective on reality TV. Gardyn draws upon different demographics that relate to her essay. Like others in the 18- to 24-year-old age group, I too enjoy watching reality TV. Although I like reality television, I am also interested in other genres as serial dramas because of the suspense.…

    • 895 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Best Essays

    Reality Tv Paper

    • 2528 Words
    • 11 Pages

    It is safe to assume that there are both negative and positive aspects of reality television. Do the cons outweigh the pros or vice versa? In our opinion there is much more negativity in reality shows in modern day entertainment than there are positive reinforcements. Reality shows give viewers false sense of reality and unrealistic expectations. The stars of these shows give off the persona of a real person where the audience develops a connection seeming they can relate to the everyday person. People seem to think, feel and act like these characters they see on these programs which could…

    • 2528 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In the article “Getting Real With Reality TV” published in the 5th edition of Perspectives on Contemporary Issues, author Cynthia M. Frisby argues that the reason that reality TV stays so popular is because of the audiences media gratification from social comparisons in the mass media.…

    • 570 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Shows like Keeping Up With the Kardashians, The Bachelor and The Real Housewives have been taking the country by storm with the unscripted, outrageously unpredictable stories of ordinary people from around the country.Americans spend 33% of their free time watching television and 67% of the shows are reality television(Reality Television:a Shocking Statistic).The average American watches five hours of television a day, that means they spend three and a half hours a day watching reality television.This shows that reality television is affecting everyone's everyday lives.Reality television is harmful to our society because it promotes stereotypes,it leaves a lasting impression on young susceptible minds,and it is false advertising.…

    • 1407 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Biltereyst, D. (2004). Reality TV, troublesome pictures and panics. Reappraising the public controversy around Reality TV in Europe in: S. Holmes & D. Jermyn (Red.). Understanding reality television (p. 91-111). London: Routledge.…

    • 15602 Words
    • 63 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The concept of reality shows has been borrowed from western media. These shows clash with our cultural ethos and are making people less tolerant and much more demanding, leading to break up of family systems and erosion of moral values.…

    • 579 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Due to the presentation of arguments for reality TV’s success, gimmicks and our need for it, the authors primary target group is the cult (those who watch reality TV). Enlightened, bright and independent persons (among who I prefer counting myself in) may also get a more varied approach towards reality TV.…

    • 1010 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Synthesis Essay

    • 1008 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Out of many TV shows, there is an extensive number of reality TV shows. For example, the most common are American Idol, The Bachelor, and Big Brother. These reality shows impact our lives both positively and negatively. According to Cynthia Frisby, “reality shows are just new shows that promise more drama, suspense, and laughter while constantly pushing the strings on what is morally and decently acceptable.” Reality TV shows craft opportunities for normal but talented people to compete against one another in an immense amount of ways. To most these reality shows can be a relaxing comfort but to others it can be an emotional rollercoaster just to view one certain show. Reality TV can affect the viewers and the contestants especially emotionally, selfishly, and physically.…

    • 1008 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    A reality TV show stars a non-celebrity or a volunteer who wants to participate in the program. The core role is to see what their reactions in certain scenarios are, and how they face given situations. The audience feels like they have a connection with the show’s stars as they feel that they are real and normal people representing them. Viewers are then entertained by the sadness, depression, frustration, and emptiness that the reality stars will express in the show. Audiences cannot seem to get enough of the drama of other regular, everyday people placed in unrealistic settings manipulated for the world to see. Overtime, exposure to these shows will subtly cultivate viewer’s perception of reality. Reality television shows have a negative influence on today’s society by portraying a false sense of communal experience, creating unrealistic standards of living, as well as affecting the productivity of growth to the younger generation.…

    • 1101 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Reality Television

    • 813 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Reality television has strong influence and damaging effects on our society. But let’s face it, we feed on the drama. We love to absorb another life other than our own. Along with it comes the misconception of reality which distorts how one believes they have to behave to gain fame or attention. Reality television is bad for culture because it only elevates money, beauty, and fame above other qualities by promoting inappropriate behavior such as bullying, casual sex, alcohol abuse and bad language. The media plays a major role in selling this trash in order to increase revenue.…

    • 813 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Reality Tv Essay

    • 435 Words
    • 2 Pages

    In our innovative and technical society, pop culture has flooded entertainment. The result is a talentless genre of television called reality TV. This exhausted genre of television has taken a new approach to attempt to show outrageous and extreme scenarios to keep a grasp on its’ viewers. Rather than providing true entertainment, there reality TV shows often display a talentless, annoying cast. As well as fill their shows with product placement; allowing the cast members to get wealthy off of endorsement products and become living advertisement. In Salman Rushdie’s essay “Reality TV: A Dearth of Talent and the Death of Morality,” he states that “people are becoming famous for doing nothing much at all, but doing it where everyone can see them” (216). By analyzing several shows, Rushdie’s statement can be proven correct.…

    • 435 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays