Real Women Have Curves Analysis

Good Essays
The play Real Women Have Curves by Josephina Lopez, and the film by director Patricia Cardoso, portray Mexican culture differently but both manage to perpetuate stereotypes. They do this by showing how Mexicans can be very family oriented, are paranoid immigrants, and put work before schooling. These factors shown by the play and film are crucial because they help the audience fabricate stereotypes about Mexican culture. The play and film do a great job in distributing the idea that Mexicans are paranoid immigrants based on the exaggeration of reaction from the characters. In the play it is evident that the characters are terrified because in a conversation by some characters it states,
[“CARMEN I saw a van!
ROSALI What van?
CARMEN ¡La migra!
…show more content…
Women are foreseen as very supportive and in the play one offers to help another financially. This determines that women are always there for each other and support one another without thinking twice. Even though it is evident by the type of job they have, that they do not have money, these women do not hesitate to help. This right here is the kind of vision people use to make stereotypes that women in Mexican culture are very supportive however, in the film some scenes might confuse the reader because it is shown that men are more supportive than women. Patricia Cardosa uses men as the supporter in the film to show that not all women are supportive and that men can be as supportive as women. In the film, Ana’s tetchier played a big role in her life because he is the one that supported her and even encouraged her to apply and attend college. Her teacher talked to Ana’s parents to convince them that she should attain a higher education. Also Ana’s father is the one that wants her to attend college and he even takes her to the airport. Her grandfather though he was present in most of the film supported Ana when she had a boyfriend. He helped Ana go on dates with Jimmy, her boyfriend so that her parents will not notice. The play and film contradict each other because one shows how women are supportive and the other shows that men are actually supportive. Either way, both the play and the film help with the creation of stereotypes …show more content…
In the film there are scenes where Carmen, Ana’s mother treats her very harsh and hinders her from attending college. Carmen exaggerates based on her actions like when she did not say goodbye to Ana when she was leaving for college. This can be interpreted by thinking that it is hard fro parents to let their children go but its not always true. In the film the fact that the mom does not let her go might just be because Ana and her mother are not very close and do not have that mother daughter love and bond and the financial situation they are in. The fact that Ana did not mind that her college was on the other side of the nation, signifies that she is not very close to her family because she is willing to go far and does not hesitate by the fact that she will be away from home and her

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Real Women Have Curves

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages

    April 2012 Women in Unfair Work Conditions: The Fight Over Independence or Family! The play Real Women Have Curves was written by Josefina Lopez, it depicted the hard ships of immigrant female workers and the power and strength of women working together as one. About a decade later a movie was made. However the movie Real Women Have Curves still shows the same struggles these women in the play face and also shows how strong women working together…

    • 1038 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Real Women Have Curves

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Connection To Real Women Have Curves In the movie Real Women Have Curves multiple obstacles that may impact a student’s possibility of continuing with his or her education are clearly pointed out. In the movie Real Women Have Curves there is Ana, a character in the movie that has the opportunity to continue her education after high school by attending a university but, has to work as a seamstress with her mother and sister. The one issue that I can relate to is that like Ana I have had to go to work…

    • 719 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Real Women Have Curves

    • 2056 Words
    • 9 Pages

    Veronica Alvarado Alvarado 1 Scot Butwell Period 4 English 12 Mexican-American Women: Bound by Tradition The plot of the 2002 movie Real Women Have Curves revolves around a young Mexican-American woman named Ana, who has graduated high school and in hopes of pursuing a college education. Ana is the youngest daughter of her traditional, first-generation, Mexican-American parents. Although Ana is a bright young female, she is enslaved by Mexican tradition; she has the potential to…

    • 2056 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Real women have curves

    • 800 Words
    • 3 Pages

    The title of the movie Real Women Have Curves has a double meaning. Not only does it refer to body shape, but it also refer to the person who has the guts to do something and always is able to reach her goal. The director of this movie is Patricia Cardoso, who launched this funny and dramatic film. Basically, this movie is about the battle between a woman's desire to better her life through education and the traditional expectations of her family. Ana is the character throughout the movie, who has…

    • 800 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    For a long time women and men have had self image issues due to what society depicts is beautiful. If you don’t look like a certain kind of model or a certain actor/ actress then you are considered ugly. This has been going on for the longest time. Women are judged by the size of their waist, butt, thighs and how pretty their face looks. Men are judged as well. They are judged on how muscular or tall they are or if they are capable of being a Hollister model. People shouldn’t be judged on how they…

    • 571 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    One of the central messages of the movie Real Women Have Curves deals with the insecurities, constant struggles and challenges of being overweight. Ana, the main protagonist of the movie, cannot go a day without her mom addressing her as “fatty.” She constantly struggles with an overbearing mom who just doesn’t understand. Although Ana’s mom means well, she doesn’t know the implications of her words. Instead of pushing her daughter to find a suitor, she pushes Ana away from her. By doing so, she…

    • 382 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    the audience understands both languages, it allows them to connect and perceive the intend of the meaning at a deeper level. Such as in Real Women Have Curves, by Josefina Lopez, the playwright focuses on five characters, Ana, Estela, Carmen, Pancha, and Rosali, who work together in a tiny sewing factory in East Los Angeles. Using Spanish and English, the five women not only sow dresses, but sow their concepts and perception of cultural expectations, feminism, social status, and self-identity together…

    • 1537 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Unfortunately, we can have obstacles that prevent us from reaching the highest image we have created for ourselves. Fear, monetary funds, and time act as obstacles to that image. However, there is one holds more power than all the aforementioned barriers; our parents. The film, Real Women Have Curves, focuses primarily on the hardships an under advantaged, impoverished, and latina teenager encounters. Her greatest…

    • 992 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Women Have Curves

    • 180 Words
    • 1 Page

    plays presented in lecture. The stereotypes that come with gender, body image, ideals, and family in both Real Women Have Curves by Josefina Lopez and The House of Bernarda Alba by Federico Lorca are concepts that I have firsthand struggled with. Like the ambitious Ana, in Lopez’s play I was told women are better daughters when they stay close to home before coming to UT, and like Adela, I have made decisions that are too modern for some of my family members. Overall, it was interesting learning more…

    • 180 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Family is a powerful word that applies to everyone’s life, in this case Ana García from the movie “Real Women Have Curves”, battles to satisfy her fantasy of setting off for college while considering family obligation, and an intense financial circumstance. The possibility of Ana attending a university torments Ana's mom, Carmen, on the grounds that she needs to keep her family together. Carmen likewise needs Ana to help work in the family-claimed material production line, keep running by Ana's sister…

    • 398 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays