Questionable Immigration Myths

Good Essays
Jason
Professor
English 1020-52
14 October 2004
Questionable Immigration Myths David Cole's "Five Myths about Immigration," while not a persuasive argument, is obviously a personal issue for the author who believes Americans treat immigrants poorly. He introduces the reader to "Know Nothings," or "Native Americans," who blame every problem in America on the immigrants (Cole 189-90). In the introductory paragraph, Cole attempts to obtain the reader's sympathetic feelings as he writes with great passion when he describes the mistreatment his Irish Catholic immigrant ancestors endured (190). This in turn raises the question of how objective he could remain when presenting his arguments. Coles' attempts to disprove the five myths about immigrants are not effective as his tone is often too personal, clouding his judgment, and his statistics and some data are either lacking credibility or logic. The first myth is that "America is being overrun with immigrants" (190) and Cole uses statistics to contradict this belief, but they are not credible and cause the reader to question whether Cole looked at the whole picture (190). His statistical argument, "As of 1990, foreign born people made up only eight percent of the population, compared with […] fifteen percent from 1870 to 1920" (Cole190) appears convincing to the reader, but is misleading because eight percent of the population in the 1990's was significantly more than fifteen percent of the population in 1870 to 1920. Cole does not present accurate statistics to refute this first myth. For the myth "Immigrants take jobs from U.S. citizens" (190), Cole presents a report that states, "Immigrants actually create more jobs that they fill" (190-91). He uses data from a study to support his statement, but a common fear exists-- if the number of jobs is fixed and immigrants fill some of those jobs, fewer jobs will be available for the "natives." This fear is illogic to the reader because



Cited: Cole, David. "Five Myths about Immigration." Current Issues and Enduring Questions. Eds. Sylvan Barnet and Hugo Bedau. 7th ed. Boston: Bedford/St. Martin 's, 2005. 189- 192.

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    The Myth Of Immigration

    • 545 Words
    • 3 Pages

    century, it is plain out wrong and unfair. Immigrants come to America to make a better life for themselves and pursue happiness, which is so blantaly explained in The Constitution. There is a myth about immigrants stealing jobs from Americans, that is nothing more than a myth. Immigration actually provides a benefit to the national economy, whether the immigrants crossed the border illegally or not. It all comes down to “specialization of labor”.Which is a powerful force in an economy, benefiting…

    • 545 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Us Immigration Myth

    • 1775 Words
    • 8 Pages

    surrounding incoming immigrants, recent immigrants, and immigration in general. These attitudes were made more prevalent when the newly elected president, Donald Trump, instituted an executive order to temporarily ban entrance to the United States to seven Muslim-majority countries (Trump). This ban was eventually lifted by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals (Liptak). Although in the United States there continues to be negative stigmas around immigration and allowing immigrants into the U.S., immigrants…

    • 1775 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    A questionable Shape

    • 436 Words
    • 2 Pages

    'A Questionable Shape' by Bennet Simms Sims plays with our collective knowledge of the undead, interweaving his zombies’ penchant for the familiar with our own familiarity with the subject and his narrator’s internal struggle with those he is most familiar with, so that the novel becomes, among other things, an exploration of the very concept of familiarity. Defamiliarization: a process by which you try to remove certain associations with the faces of the people you love. FIGHT THE BITE:…

    • 436 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Enron’s Questionable Transactions 1. The special purpose entities (SPEs) got Enron into trouble. 2. It is debatable whether Enron’s directors knew how profits were being made through the SPEs. Speculation is that they did have knowledge, but did not question the questionable procedures. Evidence that indicates the directors knew how profits were being made includes the following: • Andrew Fastow’s role in establishing the SPEs and falsely creating 3% independent investors in…

    • 682 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Enron Questionable Transactions Question 1 The question which segment of its operations got Enron into difficulties is simple to answer, everything. Almost every all segments of their operation were improper. First of all, they practice unethical and dishonest practices which victimized workers, consumers, taxpayers and stockholders. Enron created partnerships within their own organization which led to them creating new financial instruments, called SPE’s (special purpose entities) which was…

    • 761 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    that immigration is more beneficial than some Americans believe it to be. In Cole’s essay titled, “Five Myths about Immigration,” he debunks the common stereotypes about immigrants and embraces the facts. These common stereotypes about immigrants are often fueled by ignorance and misinformation and can cause real-world harm to immigrants. According to Cole’s essay, “Passion, misinformation, and shortsighted fear often substitute for reason, fairness, and human dignity in today’s immigration debates”…

    • 1455 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Discuss and compare questionable motives within ‘Frankenstein’ and ‘In Cold Blood’ The extracts I have chosen are ‘Frankenstein’ (page 102-104) and ‘In Cold Blood’ (page 135-137). My first extract from 'In Cold Blood' begins with perry a criminal describing when he is arrested at Mexico city hotel, he expresses himself in a way that portrays his lack of education as well as his continuous frustration with life. The extract then goes on to present a letter written to Perry from his sister Barbara…

    • 2021 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A Questionable Drug: Depo Provera For decades, Depo Provera has been used around the world, not always for the same purpose. The drug, medroxyprogesterone acetate, more commonly known as Depo Provera, was originally made to be an injectable form of long-term birth control. When Depo was first approved in the US as an effective form of birth control this seemed liked a miracle drug for women. You would not have to remember to take a pill every morning, fewer side effects, even a shorter…

    • 1240 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Author David Cole explains in "Five Myths about Immigration" that people are misinformed about immigrants in America and blame them for all the problems in the American society. Cole comments that the "Native Americans", which have nothing to do with what we call Native Americans today, were labeled as "Know-Nothings" because they simply did not know anything about immigrants and prejudged immigrants who came into the country. The author quotes one "Know-Nothing" for saying that "more than half the…

    • 929 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Immigration

    • 1406 Words
    • 6 Pages

    Immigration is defined as “the action of coming to live permanently in a foreign country” Many years ago in our country and many others, immigration was needed to increase the population, expand the economy, and take hard working jobs. We live in a country where nearly everyone’s ancestry can be traced back to an immigration story, whether they came from Ireland during the potato famine, from Germany to settle in cities such as Cincinnati, or from Asia to become rich in the California gold rush…

    • 1406 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Better Essays