This first amendment is where the discussion on artistic freedom in the classroom begins. However, this does not directly regulate the ability to hang student artwork if the picture in question is of a religious nature. The conflict is based on the constitutional ideas of the establishment clause verses the free exercise clause. By not allowing the student to initially create the assignment using Jesus as his subject would violate his free exercise clause to express his personal religious beliefs (Haynes, Thomas 2007). The use of religion in visual arts is allowed as long as it is on topic, and not promoting a specific religion (Haynes, Thomas 2007). The Anti Defamation League adds one more stipulation saying that the display must be temporary and based in a secular lesson plan (ANTI DEFEMATION LEAGUE CITAION). Using this reasoning one can argue that if the picture of Jesus had text on it that said something like “You should be a Christian” then, the picture would not be hung for public view. However, if the picture was titled “My Hero”, then it would be appropriate. The picture is within the guidelines of free speech, the free exercise clause, and the establishment clause because it was not provoked by the teacher, does not promote one religion over another, and it gives the student the ability to express themselves freely while completing the
This first amendment is where the discussion on artistic freedom in the classroom begins. However, this does not directly regulate the ability to hang student artwork if the picture in question is of a religious nature. The conflict is based on the constitutional ideas of the establishment clause verses the free exercise clause. By not allowing the student to initially create the assignment using Jesus as his subject would violate his free exercise clause to express his personal religious beliefs (Haynes, Thomas 2007). The use of religion in visual arts is allowed as long as it is on topic, and not promoting a specific religion (Haynes, Thomas 2007). The Anti Defamation League adds one more stipulation saying that the display must be temporary and based in a secular lesson plan (ANTI DEFEMATION LEAGUE CITAION). Using this reasoning one can argue that if the picture of Jesus had text on it that said something like “You should be a Christian” then, the picture would not be hung for public view. However, if the picture was titled “My Hero”, then it would be appropriate. The picture is within the guidelines of free speech, the free exercise clause, and the establishment clause because it was not provoked by the teacher, does not promote one religion over another, and it gives the student the ability to express themselves freely while completing the