Public Health in India: Dangerous Neglect
Public health services, which reduce a population’s exposure to disease through such measures as sanitation and vector control, are an essential part of a country’s development infrastructure. In India, policies have focused largely on medical services. Public health services, and even implementation of basic public health regulations, have been neglected. Various organisational issues also militate against the rational deployment of personnel and funds for disease control. There is strong capacity for dealing with outbreaks when they occur, but not to prevent them from occurring. Impressive capacity also exists for conducting intensive campaigns, but not for sustaining these gains on a continuing basis afterwards. This is illustrated by the near-eradication of malaria through highly-organised efforts in the 1950s, and its resurgence when attention shifted to other priorities such as family planning. This paper reviews the fundamental obstacles to effective disease control in India, which need to be dealt with on an urgent basis. MONICA DAS GUPTA
Focusing on clinical services while neglecting services that reduce exposure to disease is like mopping up the floor continuously while leaving the tap running. (paraphrased from Laurie Garrett, Betrayal of Trust). When I arrived in Berlin, I heard the words ‘sanitary’ and ‘health’ everywhere, but I really did not understand those words. What I eventually came to understand was that these words …referred to an entire administrative system that was organised to protect the public’s health…. and to improve the nation’s welfare. (Nagayo Sensai, architect of the Japanese public health system, c 1871).1
What Is Public Health, and Why Invest in It?
ublic health services are conceptually distinct from medical services. They have as a key goal reducing a population’s exposure to disease – for example through assuring food safety and other health regulations; vector control; monitoring waste disposal and water systems; and health education to improve Economic and Political Weekly
personal health behaviours and build citizen demand for better public health outcomes. Thus they involve such disparate activities as improving slaughterhouse hygiene and cattle-keeping practices, cleaning irrigation canals to discourage vector breeding, and applying public health regulations. These services are largely invisible to the public – typically, the public only becomes aware of the need for them when a problem develops (e g, an epidemic occurs).2 Yet unlike most medical services – which focus on the needs of individual patients – these services are of high priority for assuring good health for a population as a whole. When public health systems falter people pay a high price in terms of illness, debility and death, and if full-fledged outbreaks occur the economic costs can be very large. Public health services produce “public goods” of incalculable benefit for facilitating economic growth and poverty reduction. Consider, for example, the long-term growth possibilities generated by draining the malarial swamps of Washington DC. And conversely, consider the global
economic costs imposed by the avian flu and SARS epidemics, emanating from poor poultry-keeping and other public health practices in a few east Asian localities. In India, the 1994 plague epidemic following poor municipal sanitation in Surat is estimated by the WHO (1999) to have resulted in losses totalling $1.7 billion. Poor public health conditions take economic tolls in various ways, including reduced attraction for investors and tourists; continued expenditures on combating diseases which should have become history; and foregone labour productivity. The poor pay a high price in terms of debility, reduced earning capacity, health expenditures, and death. The rich suffer little mortality from communicable diseases, but nevertheless suffer repeated episodes of morbidity...
References: Arnold, David (1989): ‘Cholera Mortality in British India 1817-1947’ in Tim Dyson (ed), India’s Historical Demography, Curzon Press, London. Barclay (1954): Colonial Development and Population in Taiwan, Princeton University Press, Princeton. Beaglehole, Robert (ed) (2003): Global Public Health: A New Era, Oxford University Press, Oxford. Beaglehole, Robert and Ruth Bonita (1997): Public Health at the Crossroads: Achievements and Prospects, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge and New York. Das Gupta, Monica, Peyvand Khaleghian and Rakesh Sarwal (2003): ‘Governance of Communicable Disease Control Services: A Case Study and Lessons from India’, The World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No 3100, Washington DC. Das Gupta, Monica and Manju Rani (2005): ‘How Well Does India’s Federal Government Perform
Its Essential Public Health Functions?’ The World Bank Policy Research Working Paper No 3447 (forthcoming in Health Policy), Washington DC. Duffy, John (1990): The Sanitarians: A History of American Public Health, University of Chicago Press, Urbana and Chicago. Dyson, Tim (1989): ‘The Population History of Berar since 1881 and Its Potential Wider Significance’, Indian Economic and Social History Review, 26(2):167-201. Easterlin, Richard A (2004): ‘How Beneficent Is the Market? A Look at the Modern History of Mortality’, The Reluctant Economist: Perspectives on Economics, Economic History, and Demography, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Evans, Richard J (1987): Death in Hamburg: Society and Politics in the Cholera Years, 1830-1910, Oxford University Press, Oxford. Fee, Elizabeth and Theodore M Brown (2004): ‘Depression-Era Malaria Control in the South’, American Journal of Public Health 94(10): 1694. Garrett, Laurie (2000): Betrayal of Trust, Hyperion, New York. Government of India (1996): Report of the Expert Committee on Public Health System, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare, New Delhi. Government of India, Planning Commission: FiveYear Plans (First to Tenth). Government of India, Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (2002): National Health Policy. Government of Karnataka (2001): Karnataka: Towards Equity, Quality and Integrity in Health: Final Report of the Task Force on Health and Family Welfare, Processed. Guha, Sumit (1993): ‘Nutrition, Sanitation, Hygiene, and the Likelihood of Death: The British Army in India c 1870-1920’, Population Studies, Vol 47(3): 385-401. Harrison, Mark (1994): Public Health in British India: Anglo-Indian Preventive Medicine 1859-1914, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge. Institute of Medicine (1987): The Future of Public Health, National Academy Press, Washington DC. – (2002a): The Future of the Public’s Health in the 21st Century, National Academy Press, Washington DC. – (2002b): Leadership by Example: Coordinating Government Roles in Improving Health Care Quality, National Academy Press, Washington DC. Jannetta, Ann B (2001): ‘Public Health and the Diffusion of Vaccination in Japan’ in T’suijung Liu, James Lee, David S Reher, Osamu Saito and Wang Feng (eds), Asian Population History, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 292-305. Jeffrey, Roger (1988): The Politics of Health in India, University of California Press, Berkeley. Johansson, Sheila Ryan and Carl Mosk (1987): ‘Exposure, Resistance and Life Expectancy: Disease and Death during the Economic Development of Japan, 1900-1960’, Population Studies, 41(2): 207-35. John T Jacob and F White (2003): ‘Public Health in South Asia’ in R Beaglehole (ed), Global Public Health: A New Era, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 172-90. Khaleghian, Peyvand and Monica Das Gupta (2005): ‘Public Management and the Essential Public Health Functions’, World Development, 33 (7): 1083-99. Kwon, Tai Hwan (1977): Demography of Korea:
Population Change and Its Components, 192566, Seoul National University Press, Seoul. McGuire, James W (2001): Social Policy and Mortality Decline in East Asia and Latin America’, World Development, 29(10): 1673-97. McKeown, Thomas (1976): The Modern Rise of Population, Edward Arnold, London. Nath, Lalit (2003): ‘Public Health in India’, Development Research Group, The World Bank, Processed. Operations Research Group, Baroda (1988): An In-depth Evaluation of National Malaria Eradication Programme – A Case Study of Bihar and Haryana. Porter, Dorothy (1999): Health, Civilisation and the State: A History of Public Health from Ancient to Modern Times, Routledge, London and New York. Preston, Samuel H (1980): ‘Causes and Consequences of Mortality Declines in Less Developed Countries during the Twentieth Century’ in Richard A Easterlin (ed), Population and Economic Change in Developing Countries, The University of Chicago Press, Chicago and London, pp 289-360. Preston, Samuel H and Michael R Haines (1991): Fatal Years: Child Mortality in Late Nineteenth Century America, Princeton University Press, Princeton NJ. Ramasubban, Radhika (1989): ‘Imperial Health in British India, 1857-1900’ in Roy MacLeod and Milton Lewis (eds), Disease, Medicine and Empire and the Experience of European Expansion, Routledge, London. Rosen, George (1993): A History of Public Health, Johns Hopkins Press, Baltimore. Schofield, Roger et al (1991): The Decline of Mortality in Europe, Oxford University Press, Oxford. Szreter, Simon (1999): ‘Rapid Economic Growth and the Four Ds of Disruption, Deprivation, Disease and Death: Public Health Lessons from Nineteenth Century Britain for Twentyfirst Century China?’ Tropical Medicine and International Health, 4(2): 146-52. Sung John F et al (2003): ‘Public Health in Taiwan’, Development Research Group, The World Bank, Processed. Tatara, Kozo (1991): ‘The Origins and Development of Public Health in Japan’ in Walter Holland et al (eds), Oxford Textbook of Public Health, 2nd ed, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp 55-72. UN estimates (http://esa.un.org/unpp/ p2k0data.asp). Vögele, Jörg (1998): Urban Mortality Change in England and Germany, 1870-1913, Liverpool University Press, Liverpool. Woods, Robert (2001): ‘The Role of Public Health Initiatives in the Nineteenth Century Mortality Decline’ in John C Caldwell, Salley Findley, Pat Caldwell, Gigi Santow, Wendy Cosford, Jennifer Braid and Daphne BroersFreeman (eds), What We Know about Health Transition: The Cultural, Social and Behavioural Determinants of Health, Australian National University, Canberra,, Vol 1, pp 110-15. – (2003): ‘Public Health Service Delivery: The Historical Experience of the Developed Countries’ (especially the United Kingdom, France and the United States in the Nineteenth and Twentieth Centuries), Development Research Group, The World Bank, Processed.
Economic and Political Weekly
December 3, 2005
Please join StudyMode to read the full document