Public Examination Should Not Be Abolished

Topics: Education, Assessment, Psychometrics Pages: 2 (565 words) Published: February 21, 2014
SUMMARY:  DISADVANTAGES
While several states are implementing some form of standards-based reform, there is very little empirical evidence to prove that standards, assessment, and high-stakes accountability programs are effective in improving public schools.  In many states, such as California, attempts to implement standards-based reform are inconsistently or carelessly aligned with quality research. The following are some of the shortcomings of standards-based reform. 1. Recent reports on the standards-based reform movement in New York suggest that in many schools the careless implementation of standards and assessment may have negative consequences for students. 2. Vague and unclear standards in several subject areas in several states complicate matters and do not serve as concrete standards defining what students should know and be able to do. 3. Top-down standards imposed by the federal or state government are also problematic.  They impose content specifications without taking into account the different needs, opportunities to learn, and skills that may be appropriate for specific districts or regions. Table 1: Advantages of SBA compared with external examinations Point

Characteristics of SBA
Characteristics of Exams
Scope
Extends the range and diversity of assessment collection opportunities, task types and assessors Much narrower range of assessment opportunities: less diverse assessment; one exam per year Authenticity

Assessment done by students' own teacher; less possibility of cheating as teacher knows student capabilities; assessments more likely to be realistic Removes assessment entirely from teaching and learning; stressful conditions may lead to students not demonstrating real capacities Validity

Improves validity through assessing factors that cannot be included in public exam settings Limits validity by limiting scope of assessment, e.g. difficult to assess interaction skills in exam environment Reliability

Improves reliability by...
Continue Reading

Please join StudyMode to read the full document

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Should Public Examinations in Malaysia be Abolished Essay
  • Should Examinations Be Abolished Essay
  • Should examinations should be abolished ? Essay
  • Essay about Public Examination Should Not Be Abolished
  • Examinations Should Be Abolished Essay
  • Essay about Examination Should Not Be Abolished
  • Essay about Examinations Should Be Abolished
  • Essay about Why Examination Should Not Be Abolished

Become a StudyMode Member

Sign Up - It's Free