Psychodynamic vs Psychosocial Theory
Freud vs Erikson
Lewis-Clark State College
3 October 2014
There are many different versions of the Cinderella story; I looked at one of the more traditional ones so as to figure out how Cinderella might have resolved the earlier stages of development by applying Freud’s stages. Oral: Cinderella had to become less dependent on her caretakers after her mother died and her father remarried. Her father was obviously grief stricken when his wife died, because when he remarried his new wife was evil and controlling of him and his daughter. The step mother sent Cinderella to a cold plain room and turned her into a servant, instead of letting her live the life of luxury she was accustomed to. Cinderella never complained about the abuse and her living arrangements to her father. At the age of 25 Cinderella would be less dependent on her family and taking care of herself doing chores and being a servant to her step family. She wouldn’t be complaining about her circumstances but as an adult maybe looking for a way out on her own. Anal: Cinderella obviously felt capable and productive as she was doing the household chores she is assigned from sun up to sun down. In the story she has help and companionship from the animals in the courtyard, you assume she enjoys this perk because she is a young, good, sweet, and beautiful girl. Cinderella had to rise before her step mother and sisters so that she could prepare their food which they always found fault with. To wash and launder their clothes for the day, plus having to clean the castle. At age 25 Cinderella shows she is capable of doing the cooking, cleaning and other household chores. She would have companions but with her advanced age maybe she was friendly with the other servants instead of the animals. As an adult she would have more social skills and engage other people around heer. Phallic: Cinderella identified herself with being like her mother, sweet, good, maintaining her clothes and body in a beautiful way. With her father she acted like a young adult even as child, maybe acting like his wife. The main prop in the story is the glass slippers and whose foot in the kingdom it would fit. So it is all about sexual parts male and female the slipper representing female anatomy and the foot representing male anatomy and the perfect fit of the two. This stage is about sexual fulfillment and individual identity according to the stages of Freud. At age 25 she would still identify herself with her mother, and maybe her step mother who are her examples in life. At this age her hormones should have taken over and her biological clock is ticking, wanting to experience sex, love, and marriage. ID: Cinderella had dreams of being happy and in love when she grew up, marrying her prince and living happily ever after. She was beautiful, well behaved, well dressed, sweet and good in nature. She never complained about her circumstances but did her best to overcome them in the end. With the help of her fairy god mother she got to go to the ball, which was forbidden to her by her step mother, meet her prince, and resume her former life of luxury without being bitter to her step mother and sisters. Letting us know that true love can be yours thru perseverance and overcoming situations we are cast in. At age 25 she would still have dreams but as she was not a young girl anymore it is a possibility that she wouldn’t believe in a fairy god mother but would take matters into her own hands and attended the ball in spite of her step families warnings. Ego: Because she fell in love with the prince and got married, she bowed to her own individual pleasure. This shows the coming of her own importance with her ego because marriage is what all women are taught to want in our society. At age 25 she may have made other decisions in her life like...
Please join StudyMode to read the full document