Preview

Pros And Cons Of Eugenics

Better Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1521 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Pros And Cons Of Eugenics
Eugenics is referred to as the science of improving the human population by controlled breeding to increase the chances of desired qualities. Eugenics was intended to improve the human characteristics of those with valuable genes while discouraging the reproduction of those who possess hereditary defects. Some of the degenerative traits can be classified as mental illnesses, physical defects, inferior races, and even individuals who commit illegal acts. Certain states have these sterilization laws in place to ensure that the general public who are economically unstable do not procreate. Between the years of 1930 and 1974, the practice of genetic sterilization in North Carolina began to dramatically increase.
The term eugenics, known as in
…show more content…
As stated previously, people believed that positive eugenics would benefit future generations. Parents have the right to do what they feel that will be in the best interest of their children. This means that these parents had the choice of wanting to reproduce a child with desirable traits to prevent negative characteristics. Being able to enhance offspring was seen as a positive reinforcement for the population because it would produce a more gifted generation. In addition, various intellectual influences assumed that eugenics treated diseases (Goering, 2014). Since scientists had the ability to genetically manipulate heritable traits, those same traits that caused diseases were able to be controlled within the population. If a person did not have traces of diseases in their family medical history, they had the capability of reproducing with someone else with positive eugenics. However, if a person was detected of a disease, including mental illnesses, physical defects, and unlawful behavior, they were forcibly sterilized so that those negative eugenic traits would not spread throughout the …show more content…
Even though many apologies were distributed, what else has the state done for the people of this tragedy? Governor Bev Purdue founded the N.C Justice for Sterilization Victims Foundation to provide equity and reimbursement for those affected by these sterilization procedures under the N.C Eugenics Board Program. This foundation serves as a primary resource for individuals who wrongfully sterilized; they are provided guidance when it comes to N.C sterilization laws (N.C Justice for Sterilization Victims Foundation, 2014). Originally, a fiscal amount of $10 million were to be allotted to compensate for the victims and $500,000 would be distributed individually but victims only received $200,000 (Cohen, 1970). According to the article by Eric Mennel, there were discrepancies with the compensation legislation. Only people that had their procedure done under the Eugenics Board of North Carolina were able to receive a pension of the fund (Mennel, 2014). This attempt to reimburse victims of eugenics was a decent one, but it still neglected the thousands of other people who were sterilized before the Eugenics Board was established, leaving them with nothing to compensate for their pain and

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Buck V Bell Case Study

    • 319 Words
    • 2 Pages

    The main person in this case was named Carrie Buck; she was a feebleminded woman who was committed to a state mental institution. She was a resident of the state of Virginia, which in 1924, this same state passed a statute that authorized the superintendants of mental institutions to order the sterilization of people that suffer with hereditary…

    • 319 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The first benefit is to prevent or minimize a decrease in future fertility. By preventing this avoidable decrease, that child is given to the opportunity to make future reproductive choices. Failing to offer fertility preservation deprives the child of a choice that he or she would have otherwise had. The second benefit is the demonstration of concern for the child’s future fertility. Undergoing a fertility preservation procedure is no guarantee that the patient will become a parent to a baby who is genetically related to him or her. However, the attempt to preserve the child’s fertility demonstrates the parents’ and clinicians’ concern for the child’s future reproductive choices. These significant benefits justify a presumption in favor of attempting fertility preservation, assuming that there are effective and established techniques…

    • 982 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    What may start off having even the best of intentions could end up having some serious negative consequences. Theodore “Teddy” Roosevelt seemed to have started his belief in eugenics within a sense of nationalism where it was a woman’s duty to the state to birth and raise a family. He emphasized this view through his conservation programs where white, farming women were the epitome of the ideal type of person that should be procreating. Unlike the weak, feebleminded, retarded, deaf, blind, etc. who should not pass along their unwanted genetics. There are a few other authors in our text book, American Earth: Environmental Writing Since Thoreau, that also followed this program of eugenics masked by a conservationist agenda.…

    • 2674 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Eugenics in Star Trek

    • 563 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Eugenics is the applied science which advocates the use of practices armed at improving the genetic composition of a population, usually a monkey’s population, but in the story Star Trek Space Seed, it is practiced on the human population by a group of eccentric scientists. The humans that were produced from the selective breeding process had “five times the strength of a normal human being and five times the intellect”. This led to the Eugenics War which pitted the scientists and their creations against the human beings who believed this was wrong. Eugenics would be a good idea for many reasons. Four examples are the intellect increase, the strength increase, stabilized living, and less diseases. Eugenics is also a very bad idea. Four examples are the intellect increase, strength increase, increase in ambition, and superiority mindset.…

    • 563 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    North Carolina Eugenics Settlement In 1929 through 1974 the nation participated in an era called the Eugenics Movement. This was a social movement that called to improve the nations population by essentially removing the unfit and mentally unstable from the society or otherwise known as a way to conserve and increase the dominant population. Basically during the Eugenics Movement, the government sterilized those that they believed were undesirable, therefore being unable to reproduce, ultimately in hopes of making a better and stronger society. The decision of whether an individual should be sterilized was based on factors such as if a women was unmarried with children, African Americans, mentally ill, minorities, blind, deformed, victims…

    • 534 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “Well, sweetie, your father and I did not have the money to design our own child like all of our friends were doing at the time.”…

    • 1415 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    * Backers of Eugenics (science of genetic lines and the inheritable traits they pass on from generation to generation) claimed that traits could be traced through blood lines and bred into populations (for positive traits) or taken out of blood lines (for negative traits)…

    • 4161 Words
    • 17 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    Genetic engineering often gets a bad rap with changing the natural evolutionary cycle, but it could, with proper guidance, improve almost every aspect of daily life. Advances in the Biotech Revolution have made many things that we had merely considered to be science fiction or a thing of dreams are now possible.The fact of the matter is that genetic engineering is applicable to everyday life while still being ethical and inline with people’s morals.…

    • 1069 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Selective breeding in dogs. Also known as artificial selection, is the process by which humans use animal breeding and plant breeding to develop particular traits on the animals such as how they look or to produce certain exaggerated traits. There are many different types of traits that make reason for selective breeding, mainly physical, and only some for good emotional and disease blocking purposes. In a lot of ways, this is similar to inbreeding in humans. Selective Breeding a bad thing because of the treacherous things that can happen because of it, the funding of something that produces less good than there ever will be, selective breeding.…

    • 848 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    Race Cleansing

    • 1859 Words
    • 8 Pages

    Poor and powerless people were victimized by the Eugenics movement. Though the movement was trying to do its best for individuals, families, societies and nations, it had its own weakness. Carrie Buck was one of the victims of sterilization. The justice Oliver Wendell Holmes left no doubt about either the overall legality of the procedure of its appropriateness for Miss Buck. None of the judges who decided Buck’s fate ever saw or met her. Justices relied in part on the expert opinion of Dr. Hamilton Laughlin to help them make up their minds and a report has been sent at the Eugenics Record Office, in Cold Spring Harbor, New York. By those false reports made by Dr. Hamilton, Buck was condemned as an epileptic and as a feebleminded person and recommended to have sterilization even though she had refused it. The case finally made its way…

    • 1859 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Eugenics is the belief that selecting, partners, controlling the reproduction of certain groups of women, and controlling the generating of offspring improves the quality of human life. This practice dates back to ancient Greece, but after the Nazis adopted the practice of forced sterilization, it gained much criticism and scrutiny and was disapproved of by many people. Forced sterilization in history has almost always been dictated by people in power.…

    • 938 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As research continues to uncover new disease-causing mutations, the prospect of stopping the transmission of heritable diseases increases. With the use of modern technology, expecting parents can now be prescreened in order to determine their carrier status for certain diseases. Parents who choose to use in vitro fertilization are able to choose embryos that are free of disease due to preimplantation genetic diagnosis. Additionally, parents can be provided with information on their unborn child with the use of prenatal genetic testing. Some individuals view modern genetic technology as eugenic; however, this biggest difference between eugenics now and eugenics during the 1900s is consent. Today individuals pursue genetic testing by choice and policies on ethics and consent prevent reoccurrences of the immoral endeavors within the field of…

    • 585 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Future Eugenics

    • 474 Words
    • 2 Pages

    Consumer driven eugenics practices like designer babies, provide parents with choices, something that the old eugenics never did. However, these choices may inhibit conditions for choice in the future. Screening embryos for diseases and creating children “In our own image” (Galton, David (2001)) can help parents give their children the best quality of life possible. Yet, in the future these techniques could put pressure on parents to create increasingly perfect children and enhance them above the normal species functioning. This may result in parents who choose to continue a pregnancy…

    • 474 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Here, when parents are planning on having a baby, they are faced with having to decide whether they want a genetically engineered baby or whether they want to let nature run its course. However, this decision involves much more than a simple yes or no, as this decision will decide their child’s social location and will assign them a master status. Deciding to genetically engineer their baby, parents are assuring their baby the master label of valid, but parents who decide to let nature run its course, are taking the huge risk of having a no-perfect child who will be labeled with the master status of ‘invalid,’ one which can’t be changed.…

    • 1645 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    At this point in time, which was the early decades of the 1900’s, war made life chaotic. The acceptance of Eugenics promoted a more peaceful, proper future (which we today can obviously see as being severely incorrect!). Scientifically, Eugenics was also receiving praise. It was viewed as being a way to improve humanity. There was a fear that the intelligent people would have fewer kids, and the “less than adequate” would in turn have more kids. It was believed that this would have a negative impact on natural selection, and be harmful to society. To promote such an idea, there were two main “methods”- positive eugenics and negative eugenics. The former involves trying to promote the healthy/regular people to have children. The negative eugenics system involved using medical and sterilization (which I will discuss more later on) processes to prevent the others from having kids. Awkwardly enough, to be deemed “unfit” and to undergo negative eugenics was not a punishment. After all, people viewed the problem as being a defective…

    • 1800 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Good Essays