Preview

Pros And Cons Of Affirmative Action

Powerful Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1423 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Pros And Cons Of Affirmative Action
Khadija Abdallah

Affirmative Action: Blessing to Minorities or Burden to Society? Over the last forty-seven years, affirmative action has been on the forefront of the issue of race in the United States. Affirmative action is the legal term which was first used by President John F. Kennedy with the purpose to level the gap between blacks and whites within schools and the workplace (Erbe). In 1961, President Kennedy used affirmative action as a method of making up for the one hundred years of legalized discrimination within the states. Affirmative action obligates all universities and places of work to consider minorities during the selection processes of these companies, organizations, and schools (Erbe). Although the policy of affirmative action was an innovative idea for making sure that the disadvantages that were created in American history
…show more content…
It was based on the prestigious University of Michigan’s affirmative action policies which had started to stir trouble with in admission offices. Both of the cases were first brought to federal courts in 2000 and 2001. Both the University of Michigan's undergraduate program and its law school were represented in Grutter v. Bollinger. The Supreme Court maintained the University’s law school policy of affirmative action in a tough five to four ruling (Brunner). The judges ruled that race can be a factor in the selection process of students for college because it promotes "a compelling interest in obtaining the educational benefits that flow from a diverse student body." However, the court ruled six to three for a more mechanical approach to the University of Michigan's undergraduate admissions method. The University of Michigan uses a point system to rates students and used to give bonus points to minorities, after the ruling from the Supreme Court forced the institute to modify this system

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    In the present case, the question is whether Joe Smith parent can file a lawsuit because he was discriminated against due to his race, sex, national origin, religion, and/or financial means. Like in the Yick Wo case, Smith is discriminated due to his national origin. Even though, his origin is white and the admissions policy might appear neutral to some, but it is applied unequally to whites. In DeFunis v Odegaard, this case was ruled moot because Defunis was in his last year of law school, so the courts would have to wait for a later case to set a precedent. In Bakke v. UC Board of Regents, the court would decide that at place of higher education can use race in their admission policy, but it cannot be the lone deciding factor. When the university…

    • 390 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    In 1978 Supreme Court case, Regents of the University of California v. Bakke, 35 year old while male, Allan Bakke applied to the University of California Davis Medical School and was rejected twice while exceeding academic requirements for admission. The university reserved 16 of 100 spots for minorities in part of their affirmative action program. Bakke sued claiming he was denied admission to the Medical school both times based on race. The California Medical School argued that their admissions process is used to guarantee all individuals an equal opportunity while creating a diverse student body. Baker argued that this admissions process violated the Equal Protection Act and the Civil Rights Act. Did the University of California violate…

    • 219 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Barbara Grutter(white) was denied admission at the university of Michigan Law school. The school said that they use race as a factor in admitting students because they are trying to achieve diversity. The District Court decided that the school's interest in achieving diversity among their students was not a compelling…

    • 51 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    OPINION: The special admissions program is unconstitutional, but race may be considered as a factor in the admissions process. Justice Lewis Powell (J. Powell), writing for the court, says that the Supreme Court of the United States (Supreme Court) should not pay attention to past discrimination in reviewing the policies of the University, as this is equivalent to allowing political trends to dictate constitutional principles. J. Powell determines that accepting a minimum number of minorities simply to reduce the traditional deficit of such individuals in the medical profession is unconstitutional, as it gives preference to an individual on the basis of race alone. The major determination of the Supreme Court is whether or not racial preference may be used to promote diversity of the student body. J. Powell argues that setting aside a specified number of minority slots is not congruent to the purported goal – minority students in…

    • 344 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The continuation of the application of affirmative action in the labor market. “Affirmative action is one of the most controversial government interventions in the labor market since the abolition of slavery.”(Jonathan Leonard) Affirmative action pertaining to the labor market takes a very different stance. Under Executive Order 11246 (part of the Civil Rights Act), “ you are not to discriminate against any employee because of race, color, religion and sex, as well as take affirmative action to ensure that there is a diversity of employees”. The contradiction of this statement is astonishing, and to have that nailed in the coffin known as our Constitution, is the ultimate blow on the use of this policy in the workplace. The fact that we must not consider race, but consider it in terms of diversity is overall a confusing concept and forced employers to establish ‘quotas’ to meet racial goals. This is very beneficial for white collar or craft jobs, where employers are hesitant to hire minorities or women because they do not believe they can handle the burden of the job. This maybe one of the only circumstances where federal pressure is advantageous, and statistics show that establishments are growing to give more job openings specially for african americans, hispanics and other minorities, decreasing its 89% white-hiring percentage. The effects of these kinds of policies are significant on a 99% confidence level or better, and have resulted in better representation in establishments(especially minority females) and also benefit companies in their own employment growth. However, these job openings are mainly in unskilled positions reducing the production of specially-skilled members of society, and basically producing only white specialties. Studied by Ashenfelter and Heckman(1976), taking african americans as an…

    • 2122 Words
    • 9 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    Many colleges try to have a racially diversified environment by using affirmative action. Some colleges used the point system which would give an edge to minorities over Caucasians. The supreme court of Texas prohibited colleges to use affirmative action. When affirmative action was prohibited, minority enrollments at colleges decrease. To racially diversify colleges, Legislature passed the top ten percent rule. The top ten percent rule states any high school student that is in the top ten percent of his or her class will be automatically admitted into any Texas public college. Although the rule did diversify colleges, primarily University of Texas at Austin, the rule was unfair to many students. The top ten percent rule should be abolished or altered to be more equal among students.…

    • 755 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Furthermore, the Regents v. Bakke decision upheld the constitutionality of treating race as one consideration among several in admissions procedures, pointing out the value of diversity in learning environments and opposing the application of racial limits. Ultimately, affirmative action is still an important tool for advancing equality of opportunity and diversity, despite recent setbacks. The need to have measurable objectives for affirmative action programs was made clear by the Supreme Court's ruling in SFFA v. Harvard and SFFA v. UNC (2023), which also emphasized the importance of taking race into account as part of an entire admissions process (Professor Stone Class…

    • 436 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Grutter And Diversity

    • 108 Words
    • 1 Page

    In response to the law suite the university of Michigan stated that the admissions office employees are instructed to try and keep an eye on diversity, the university stresses that they are committed to racial diversity in the university. The university’s official policy states that using Affirmative Action to contribute to the character of the university (School, N.D.). The university was more focused on how they looked in the eyes of the public, not so much on opportunity for…

    • 108 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Affirmative action is a policy with a set of criteria’s designed to ensure equality for all groups within a society to provide everyone with an equal opportunity to obtain success. Affirmative action in American society is renowned for allowing minorities and women a chance for equal access to education and a chance to access equal employment. Affirmative action can lead to the adoption of quotas for jobs and colleges in which a certain amount of potential employees or appointments must come from formerly underrepresented groups of people.…

    • 1495 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Best Essays

    “President Kennedy, as a way to fight discrimination, first coined the term Affirmative Action in 1961. Later on President Johnson employed Affirmative Action as a means of “a more profound stage of the battle for civil rights . . . not just equality as a right and a theory, but equality as a fact and result”” (“Background on Affirmative Action.”). Over the past few decades Affirmative Action has grown out of where it originated from and been altered to the extent where it has lost touch with its original intent. A prime example of the misuse of Affirmative Action can be seen in the college admissions process. The arguments against Affirmative Action fall into two categories. First Affirmative Action is immoral and causes individuals to act in an immoral manner, and second, rather than positive consequences Affirmative Action has a net negative consequence on individuals. The removal of Affirmative Action programs in colleges will lead to a colorblind admissions process that is fair to all races. The use of law enforcement could ensure that minorities are not discriminated against in the…

    • 2888 Words
    • 12 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    The Supreme Court was presented with the case of Fischer vs. The University of Texas where Abigail Fisher was suing the University for discrimination in their affirmative action based admissions process. The Supreme Court voted 7-1 and ruled to send the case back to the lower courts for further review and put off making any final decisions to change the U.S. policy on affirmative action, a “longstanding but fragile societal compromise, one that forbids quotas but allows using race as one factor among many in the admissions process” (Laptik). Both articles discussed in length the constitutionality of the race-based admissions process as well as explaining the Supreme Court’s position on the matter. The justices made statements that explained that the admissions programs must be subject to strict scrutiny where the it can be determined that classification based on gender, race and ethnicity occurs for the sole purpose of creating a diverse student population. The programs that use affirmative action in public universities are being scrutinized to ensure that their methods are a means to an end and serve to create diversity only. This issue will come before the Supreme Court again in the future and there will most likely be a more permanent ruling on the matter.…

    • 580 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Should a man be hired for his skills or for the color of his skin? Is racial diversity in the business world more important then the most qualified workers? Affirmative action has become an important topic in today 's society to better diversify the different races in America. Affirmative action is a set of public policies that were designed for the elimination of discrimination toward race, color, sex, etc. These policies are under attack today because of the unfairness toward the more qualified people. Increasing opportunities for a minority that has suffered past discrimination is the cause for affirmative action, and for the reverse discrimination toward the majority. Many people view discrimination toward one race today to compensate for the discrimination of another race in the past as unfair. This reverse discrimination is unfair treatment toward the majority. Affirmative actions are policies created to give preferential treatment to the discriminated, but also discriminate as well.…

    • 726 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The affirmative of action was first introduced by President John F Kennedy, but was later signed by President Johnson in July 2nd, 1964. Affirmative action is an action for institutes to encourage diversity among their pools of people, by hiring people that have historically been kept out. The affirmative action has created many job opportunities for people who were excluded and would probably have never got those jobs if it was not for the affirmative action. Stephen Henderson, who wrote “I am Affirmative Action” in the Detroit Press, and later USA Today, is an example of how the affirmative action can change some one’s life forever. In Henderson’s article, it was mentioned that the current rate of African American students in the University of Michigan is only 5 percent (Henderson) of the total population, and was barley doubled that percentage when the affirmative action was in its peak.…

    • 513 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Diversity In Colleges

    • 968 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Referring to the court case Fisher v. University of Texas, Jason L. Riley—in his article, “Scalia Was Right About Race Preferences”—mentions evidence brought to light by a Justice involved in the case. Riley states, “racial preferences can handicap some black students by placing them in elite schools where they don’t have the same credentials of the average student and struggle academically” (Riley 1). Due to the fact that the aforementioned students were admitted because of their race—rather than their merit and prior education—they find the higher-level academics extremely challenging. The students are wholly unprepared for the work ahead of them, due to their relatively limited primary education, when compared with the education of their more privileged peers. Further evidence of this disparity between the education of students admitted under affirmative action, and students who were not, is displayed in Martin Trow’s paper, “Preferential Admissions in Higher Education”. When speaking about the advantage given to minority students in admissions he states, “The average black student admitted, for example, had SAT scores 250-300 points lower than his or her white and Asian classmates and a substantially weaker high school grade record as well” (Trow 295). Despite the unsatisfactory scores received from African…

    • 968 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Affirmative action refers to the policy being implemented to create equality within racism, religion, sexuality and colour.It is being discussed in South Africa that the policies focus on employment, education and health programs that disadvanted people and women have equal opportunities in the work place. President John Kennedy of United Nations signed it on March 1961 that government employers "not discriminate against, any employee or applicant for employment because of race, colour, creed, or national origin". it was created to make sure that all applicants are employed and employees are treated during employment without regard to their race, creed, colour, or national origin".…

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays