Preview

Proportional Representation in the US Government

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
1119 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Proportional Representation in the US Government
Although most would agree that we live in a country whose foundation was based off of the ideals of liberty and democracy, a titanic number of citizens choose not to exercise their suffrage rights. The reason many American’s choose not to vote is because they feel they aren’t being adequately represented. This is likely because there is a lack of representation on many levels, rather it be on a race or gender standpoint. Even though our representatives are chosen through fair and democratic elections, our elections often result in an under-representation of women, ethnic minorities, and poorer social classes. This is due to our winner-take-all philosophy that routinely denies representation to a large number of voters and doesn’t accurately reflect the views of the public. There is a debate as to whether the United States should adopt some form of group representation voting system as opposed to the current winner-take-all system. Although it would require a constitutional change and a change in the minds of American’s, group representation is a certain way to ensure all American citizens are being adequately represented.
Group representation, also known as proportional representation, is designed to remedy electoral injustices. It ensures that any grouping of like-minded people, regardless of them being a minority or majority, get a fair share of power and representation in our legislation. Our current system of winner-take-all can allow someone to be elected with a 50.1% majority, leaving the opinion of 49.9% of the population to be dismissed. Because of this system, minorities have great difficulty amassing a large share of votes and stand little change of voters. If we utilized proportional representation, we would not only give these minorities not only the right to vote, but also an equal chance to be represented. For example, if black voters comprise 20% of the vote in a racially split county, they can elect at least one of the five seats, rather than be

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    As the nation stands, only about 30-50 percent of the United States has voted for a presidential candidate since 2000. A disappointment it is to only have at most about half of the US vote being that it has the third largest population in the world. However, to resolve this dilemma, the idea of mandatory voting could be used to help get the voice of the whole nation out. The need of mandatory is immense for it will better represent the population of America, level the playing field of candidate parties, and it will give the incentive for more informed voting causing the better quality of voters.…

    • 814 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    The disenfranchisement of a person is a heavy topic that you only hear about every four years during the Presidential Election. Why though? The reason: everyone has an opinion on the issue, but only few are willing to say anything about it. Some are afraid of the racial issue our country sees, and some are afraid to sway against their preferred political party.…

    • 984 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Over time, as America promoted greater civil liberties for all of its citizens, voting rights have also undergone change. When the United States was formed, citizens with voting rights were mainly Caucasian males. African American males that were freed could vote also, but slaves however, were considered property and could not vote. States could administer poll taxes, which often left poorer people without the ability to vote if they couldn’t afford the tax. Women didn’t have voting rights and voters in most states had to be 21 before being able to vote. There are many people that are loosely aware of the difficult battle for votes beginning with the history of the United States. Both major political parties have taken numerous steps toward increasing voter turnout so that more people will participate in this right of all citizens.…

    • 299 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Voting is an important civic responsibility. Although it is not required by law, participation is necessary in order for the principle of “rule by the people and for the people” to be successful. Everyone in our country is affected by the outcomes of elections. It is up to American citizens to elect suitable representatives and leaders and this is done through voting.…

    • 313 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    Gerrymandering

    • 1050 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Gerrymandering is defined as the establishment of boundaries of voting districts with the main objective of determining the partial or complete outcome of elections. Gerrymanders are designed with the main objective of insuring the defeat of specific individuals or electing political allies. There are a number of objectives of gerrymandering. Gerrymandering is usually carried out in order to allow for the reelection of incumbents or for the party in power to win more seats in an election than the number to which its percentage of the total vote properly entitles it. This only serves to subvert the will of the people since it denies them the amount of voting power that they are entitled to (Clark 13). Gerrymandering is practiced at all levels of the government where there are electoral districts that have single members including country councils, city councils, legislatures, and many others. The beneficiaries of gerrymandering are usually the incumbent elected officials and their political parties (Weaver 99).…

    • 1050 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    America’s voting system is in dire need of changes. Is this because American voters do not care about who is running? Why is it that when election time comes around the middle and lower class feel like they are nothing? Is this due to the fact that they cannot afford to take off work to vote, or they feel their votes do not count, or rather that they are simply less educated on politics and not very politically active? Only about 68% of African Americans voted in the 2008 election and only about 63% of Caucasians voted. This is the reason that America’s voting system is in dire need of change.…

    • 671 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    The current system under the Westminster elections is first-past-the-post. This is a majoritarial system in that winner-takes-all. Those who are in favour of PR argue that the FPTP system is under-representative towards minor parties and votes are then typically ‘wasted’. However those who are in favour of the FPTP system point out that it leads to a strong government, a clear outcome and keeps extremist at bay. Proportional representation is a institution of different electoral systems that produces a government based on the votes of the electorate and is proportion to the seats that the party receives. This system is different to the current Westminster formula in that the percentage of votes gained is the same as the percentage of seats received.…

    • 681 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As we all know, every vote counts. If we do not remove these voting restraints, at least twenty million people will not have the right to vote for who will…

    • 619 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When the Founding Fathers began designing America’s government in 1787, one of their greatest fears was the possibility of the dumb majority using their power to pass uneducated and disastrous legislature. They feared “the mob”, the everyday citizens that had little schooling and knew almost nothing about politics. To avoid giving the voters too much power, a Representative-Democracy style government was created, a system where citizens would vote for a person or group to represent them in making legislature. Referendum votes bypass the politicians and ask for the people’s opinion directly- they are direct votes where the entire country is invited to vote on an issue, which give the people a chance for their voices to be heard. While a good…

    • 925 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Citizens do not directly vote on specific issues or make ultimate decisions. Rather, the citizens will elect officials they believe represent their views well and, majority willing, that official will win. An example of this would be electing the President or members of Congress in the United States. Within that, states also elect local and state officials to represent them. The elected persons for particular positions should be aware about the problems and the popular opinions about those problems for the people they represent. This system was created as a foundation for representing the citizens of America rather than founding a direct…

    • 292 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Gerrymandering allows for a particular party to get bills passed easily by having a majority of their party in The House of Representatives and Senate. With this increase they will have enough votes to make a bill veto proof. Political and racial gerrymandering are unconstitutional and illegal. As stated in, The voting rights act of 1965 “prohibits spreading minorities across districts”The court’s solution required that states create majority-minority districts — districts in which the majority of the voting-age population belonged to a single minority. With voting that occurred largely along racial lines, these districts allowed minority voters to elect their candidates of choice.…

    • 954 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    However, this notion distorts the one-man one vote principle, which characterizes many democracies across the world. A direct popular vote is a manifestation of true democracy and a fair electoral process but the Electoral College, which characterizes America’s presidential election process, takes this away. In Western counties such as France, when there is no clear winner of a presidential race, a runoff occurs to determine the person who the president becomes. The concepts of fairness, justice and democracy are important in the modern world are should neb manifested in terms of representation, choice, and political systems. The right to vote should upheld in a manner that gives every American citizen the responsibility and chance to vote knowing that his or her vote…

    • 855 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    America has always been a nation of immigrants, and it remains today the most welcoming nation in the world. It is a violation of both state and federal law for immigrants who are not citizens to vote in state and federal elections. These violations effectively exclude legitimate voters whose votes are diluted, and they must be shortened. Voting is a notorious representation in American community life. Besides standing for public office, American citizens don’t have any more civic obligations than those that are derived from their ability and responsibility to help shape the community policy. The privilege to vote is an essential vehicle for exercising civic obligations. That is the reason the augmentation of the vote to all the country’s citizens has truly been…

    • 628 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Every two years on the first Tuesday in November, millions of Americans head to their local polling station for Election Day. Being able to vote in a free and fair democratic election is a is a right that activists in the suffrage and civil rights movements fought for with their blood, sweat, and tears. Those activists and many others saw voting as an agent of change and an important civic duty. However, the mindset that voting is important has changed over the past few decades. According to a study done by the Pew research center, the United States voter turnout trails most developed countries; and the 2016 Presidential election’s voter turnout rate was at a 20-year low (Regan, 2016). One of the leading issues that scholars and politicians alike face when trying to tackle this…

    • 1790 Words
    • 8 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    The government should consider using popular voting instead of electoral voting to give the people a chance to receive the candidate that is chosen. According to Fitrakis and Wasserman, the political system often takes away the rights of minorities during the election (12). In the recent election, the democratic candidate lost due to the thousands of electoral votes that overpowered the popular votes. “Clinton is the sixth presidential candidate to win a legitimate majority but lose the presidency”. In 2013 Americans came together to make a petition to end electoral votes, but the electoral voting system is still the same. The cause of Americans like African American, Hispanics, Asians, etc. losing their right to vote was due to Jim Crow laws…

    • 159 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays