Preview

Prison Incarceration Vs Rehabilitation

Satisfactory Essays
Open Document
Open Document
634 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Prison Incarceration Vs Rehabilitation
The article in question discusses the concern rather or not the public should be financially responsible for prisoners as far as funding their sex change operations. The article first acknowledges that legally there are certain accommodations that need to be met for human beings. Therefore, a person's religious, ethnic or social status in society does not serve as an excuse for cruel treatment instead of giving respect to their natural born rights. On the other hand, the material expresses that after the Transgender Law Center brought two cases against the state of California and considering recommendations from psychiatrists, these procedures are necessary for the sanity of inmates. Along these lines, the context of the eighth amendment becomes …show more content…
Even though the purpose of incarceration is to remove criminals from society there's a need for rehabilitation. Therefore, funding towards educational programs puts forth the effort to change criminals into law-abiding citizens to restore order. Under those circumstances, there is a gray area between deciding whether or not it is beneficial for the public to pay for the academic advancement of criminal. Convicted felons are viewed upon as second-class citizens as if they are insufficient and incapable of bettering themselves. For the reason, people take the stance that supporting this form of rehabilitation promotes change and offers them the opportunity to develop their way of thinking. It's important for prisoners to comprehend their surroundings and develop a certain mindset when entering an environment outside of …show more content…
One can find it difficult to explain to another person that it is a necessity or cruel and unusual punishment to deprive criminals of a sex change. The public can take into consideration that if jails or prisons were withholding medication from those who were transgender prior to incarceration could be argued as a violation of the eighth amendment. However, seeking the public to pay for the initial process of becoming a different sex and using the law against taxpayers is unjust. Faith in the criminal justice system has weakened since the incarcerated are beginning to have the same casualties as law abiding citizens. Society attempts to instill moral values to the public that good behavior receives rewards while the bad experience consequences for their actions. However, there becomes conflict when "the bad" are getting rewarded for their behavior and others have to suffer the financial consequences for their "good

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Within the article, “Is It Time to Desegregate the Sexes?” by, Judith Shulevitz, there are many different methods used to convey the onion of the author which can be summarized as, in modern America there is a dramatic need for reform in the rights of transgender citizens, particularly for students.…

    • 587 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Given current trends in society today, the next era of corrections will be a hybrid model between the rehabilitation and punitive model. Thousands of studies show the positive and negative components of each of these models. The rehabilitation model was not properly measured years prior due to the lack of technology and society was critiquing the process because they were not able to see the benefits of the program first hand. The punitive model on the other had has had plenty of evidence on its success in increasing incarceration rates and creating issues with overcrowding and lack of funding. Nevertheless, each model has something positive they can bring to the table.…

    • 958 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A masculine woman in a female prison adopts a social role as well as a sexual role as what is termed the “aggressor”. Since the identity of transgender differs across prisons themselves, the authors state that research done on the treatment of transgender individuals in prison can only be conducted when this is understood. The authors argue that not recognizing the different status of the transgender population in women’s prisons will render them invisible instead of the assistance we think we are providing by labeling them transgender. The methods used were qualitative, utilizing focus groups of prisoners to question them about social concepts. This method is used properly for the hypothesis the researchers sought to prove, yet encounters translation issues. The basis of the author’s argument if that transgender people in women’s prisons are seen as aggressors, a separate social standing. However, we only see this through their transcriptions of interviews, as the participants never explicitly state it. This exposes a level of bias in the researchers although the structures of the focus groups were thoughtful and controlled. As this article was written in 2015, the data retrieved is current and relevant to the issues being researched. As we continue to study the treatment of transgender peoples, it is important to recognize these author’s findings that the term we use is different depending on the environment and would thusly affect the research. This study exposes the novel idea that being transgender in a women’s prison can actually be beneficial in many ways, opposite of the treatment seen in men’s prison. This new outlook is vital in analyzing the representation of transgender people in media as well as properly observing and finding…

    • 1154 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    On the basis that they were born a certain gender, even though that gender may have now been corrected to reflect their true, inner gender and personality, the law does not see give them equal treatment. The law's lack of recognition of the transsexuals as human beings has caused discrimination and thus the attitude of the society has reflected this discrimination offered by the law. If even the law cannot recognise them as equal human beings, there is little hope of living their lives with dignity and respect and less chance of changing society's attitude towards…

    • 2701 Words
    • 11 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Rehabilitation ideology seems to focus more on the actual idea that when someone is imprisoned that their time there will actually change who they are as a person. they believe that your time spent in prison will mold your personality to not wanting to commit crimes and make you a more accepted member of society following the social norms that will make you a better person.…

    • 212 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Better Essays

    There are many individuals who do not know about the increasingly common identity known as transgender. Transgender is a term that describes a person who identifies as the sex opposite of what is stated on their birth certificate. Also, a numerous amount of people don 't recognize the growing population of individuals who are gender-nonconforming, which means they identify themselves as neither man nor woman. To a large sum of transgender people life is the equivalent of being trapped in a cage, a cage that is your own body. They struggle daily with being reminded of the identity society labels them as and not the identity they envision themselves to be. Even within the LGBT community, they are in the shadows waiting to be noticed and trying to cry for help, but they are always silenced by the more common LGBT family. The “T” in LGBT has always been there, but it has been pushed aside until now. In 2013, the feuded debates started to arise between the Republican politician consultant behind Prop.8 Frank Schubert, conservative coalition groups, evangelical voters; and the Transgender Law Center, Gender Public Advocacy Coalition, students, and the Williams Institute Manager of Transgender Research, Jody L. Herman. The question has arisen: should it be acceptable for transgender people to use public facilities based on their gender identity? The belief discussed by the Law center, Williams Institute, and the Gender Public Advocacy Coalition and many others within the LGBT community is that Transgender individuals need a safe place to go to the restroom without fear of verbal or physical violence (Davis). All they want is to use the restroom like everyone else, but conservatives have a different opinion. They think that if they allow this to happen, it will open up the door to the possibilities of an increase number of sex crimes due to people falsely representing themselves as transgender or even confusion to those who simply…

    • 1567 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Good Essays

    The correctional system has three main goals: punish, protect the population and rehabilitate the offender. However, it is unclear how well the modern U.S. correctional system achieves these goals and whether the money invested in the correctional system might be better spent. (http://www.ehow.com/about_5087269_role-correctional-system.html)…

    • 1103 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Various things in today’s society undoubtedly attract a great deal of attention; one of those things in the most recent of news is transgender becoming more relevant or popular. With this specific topic comes plenty of controversy on things such as discrimination, laws, and most commonly the public opinion of current days society.…

    • 667 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    My basic understanding of it is, that transsexual people have very specific needs, including legal and medical, which are often overlooked in the LGBT movement and side skirted in many conversations in some transgender spaces. Specifically, I am thinking about certain theoretical conversations that go on in the genderqueer community and people who identify as transgender but do not pursue body modifications.…

    • 1381 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The source is about transgender inmates specifically male to female (FTM) in the prison system and the ways in which to go about protecting them from victimization and housing arrangements while facing this dilemma of difference (Sumner and Sexton 2016). The article compares and contrast using a universal approach or a difference approach which may involve a greater sense of action and fulfillment necessary to rectify the injustices of the transgender minority (Sumner and Sexton 2016). The author demonstrates these dilemmas, and discusses how the prison system and structures based around them, faces a level of inconsistencies on how to face and create and equal solution to this dilemma of difference and how it can overtly effect the arching…

    • 305 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    The Iranian Penal Code

    • 183 Words
    • 1 Page

    Iran is an exceedingly socially stratified society based on wealth, power, ethnicity, and gender, where all people must act according to the traditions and norms corresponding with their biological sex. The Iranian Penal Code reflects these norms and punishes those that act contrarily to them, and is particularly heavy-handed when it comes to striking the gavel on LGBT related crimes. While being LGB is a crime, the state has figured out a way to substantiate the claims made by officials, such as President Ahmadinejad, “that there are no homosexuals in Iran”, and they achieve this by coercing them to undergo sex reassignment surgery (SRS) to become “T”, or transgender.…

    • 183 Words
    • 1 Page
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Best Essays

    In the United States today the incarceration of offenders is not always the right option for rehabilitating criminals. The idea of putting offenders on probation who are supervised, also with a suspended sentence can assist in the decrease of crime (University of Phoenix, 2011). This paper will discuss the origins of rehabilitation in prison and its definition, the definition of parole and how it differs from mandatory release, the definition of probation and how it compares to other forms of sentencing, the definition and options of community corrections, and the critique of the current rehabilitation options. Also this paper will determine if there are better solutions than the current community corrections options that exist today.…

    • 1154 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Best Essays
  • Good Essays

    It has come to my attention that there has been discomfort for transgenders at this school due to the students having to use the bathroom of their biological sex. A transgender is a person whose self-identity does not conform to the sex that they were assigned to at birth. The transgender population is on the rise so it is time to address this issue. Recently the Obama transgender policy got released, there was a large concern about privacy across the United States and the majority of the population objected to this new idea. Another worry that people have is that the public is being used as a social experiment. Some U.S. states went the opposite way of acceptance and decided to create bathrooms that the transgender population would not be able to use; This act is the…

    • 572 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    As society evolves it grows in diversity and acceptance to which regard the legal system must change to better serve societies needs and values. With reference to this the legal system’s approaches to protect and recognise the rights of same sex couples in relation to same-sex marriage has proven to be ineffective. Whilst there has been reform through the Corbett v Corbett 1970 (One of the couple had undergone a sex change operation so the courts reformed the sex requirement from birth certificate to the…

    • 689 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Transgender Discrimination

    • 1615 Words
    • 7 Pages

    For many years, members of the gay, lesbian and transgender communities have been persecuted because of their sexual orientation. The group that will be the focused on in this essay is transsexuals. Transgender is a term that describes transvestites and transsexuals, which is gender identification not sexual orientation. Transgender are individuals whose gender identities or gender expressions contrast with traditional social norms and expectations. Gender identity refers to a person’s sub-conscious sex or their internal sense of being male or female. Gender expression refers to the way a person shows their gender identity to others through their behavior. Transgender individuals should be allowed to have a physical transformation to define their gender as man or woman without having to have their morals and values challenged by others.…

    • 1615 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Good Essays