Preview

Primary Source Analysis Example

Good Essays
Open Document
Open Document
991 Words
Grammar
Grammar
Plagiarism
Plagiarism
Writing
Writing
Score
Score
Primary Source Analysis Example
Primary Source Analysis: Woodrow Wilson’s Fourteen Points
The source is a speech delivered by Woodrow Wilson on January 8th 1918; the speech was delivered among Woodrow’s fellow congressmen in the American congress. However, the speech was not written purely by Wilson, During World War I, Walter Lippmann became an adviser to President Woodrow Wilson and assisted in the drafting of the speech. The several points covered in Wilson’s speech aimed to resolve territorial issues in Europe, as well as improving post-war American diplomacy. To achieve this Wilson supported the League of Nations which was set up following the end of war. The speech therefore was not focused purely for American congress, but instead the International stage.
The American congress would be more experienced politically; therefore the direct audience of Wilson’s speech is the congress. However, Wilson was fully aware that his speech would become part of public knowledge; the speech would not only be listened to in America, but also those countries affected by WW1. Wilson’s fourteen points was a reflection of his ideas and was used to input his views within the Big Three, Clemenceau and Lloyd-George. The fourteen points eventually established the League of Nations; therefore this suggests that the audience of the speech was to the international arena. Wilson recognised that there was opposition within congress towards a supranational organisation; therefore he aimed to persuade the congress the advantages of such organisation. This is shown later on when the USA under Harding did not join the League of Nations.
Wilson’s speech was unprecedented in terms of that it was strongly liberal, and it aimed to join nations through liberal ideology. This is different to how countries, including the USA normally ran as they were more interested in their own achievements rather than the world arena collectively. It is also important to put emphasis on the fact that the USA were the ones hoping for a

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Progressive Hall of Fame

    • 1141 Words
    • 5 Pages

    During his Presidency, soon after the Germans signed the Armistice (treaty) in November of 1918, Wilson went to Paris to try to construct an “enduring peace”. President Wilson, against his doctors’ warnings, even made a national tour to persuade the public to support the Versailles Treaty. He was very religious and believed that he was guided by God’s will. Wilson also wanted to personally determine the United States’ foreign policy. He sought after freeing the United States of trusts and restoring the old economy of shops and small businesses. By doing so, he reclaimed the “Anti-Trust Act”. Wilson personally said, “Americans...are meant to carry liberty and justice and the principles of humanity wherever [they] go, [they] go out and sell goods that will make the world more comfortable and more happy, and convert them to the principles of America”. Wilson desired an “orderly change” for not only the United States, but for humanity. That is why he should be…

    • 1141 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    After reading Thomas A. Bailey’s article on “Woodrow Wilson Wouldn’t Yield”, I feel this quote best represents exactly what Woodrow Wilson stood for. He was a man who wanted peace and would not yield for anyone or any country unless it was best for him and our country. In Tomas A. Bailey’s article, his argument that Wilson’s fourteen points and most notably the League of Nations wasn’t passed not just because of the points themselves. But because of Wilson’s failure to see little changes and revisions to his plans, the League would have fallen through, instead of pitfall in the Senate like it did. “On March 4, 1919 - 39 Senators or Senators-Elect, more than enough to defeat the treaty-published a round robin to the effect that they would not approve the League of Nations in its existing form. Bailey also argues that Wilson’s character, in that his huge desire for morality and idealism, we also much to blame for his stubbornness in keeping the League of Nations unrevised or compromised upon.…

    • 541 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    “No one but the President,” he said, “seems to be expected … to look out for the general interests of the country.” He matured a program of progressive reform and asserted international leadership in building a new world order. In 1917 he proclaimed American entrance into World War I a change to make the world “safe for democracy.”…

    • 886 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    1991 Apush Dbq

    • 671 Words
    • 3 Pages

    President Wilson’s unwillingness to compromise is evident in his speech in 1919, which states his position on the League of Nations: “I stand for it absolutely” (Doc. A). He then claims that the slightest impairment would be like betraying the soldiers who fought in the war because they would have fought for nothing (Doc. A). This exaggeration becomes a weakness in his argument, since his Treaty is not the only way for soldiers to receive the peace they fought for. Also, President Wilson’s “Appeal to the Country”, which occurred after his loss in senate, relies on a strong sense of nationalism, and claims that the League of Nations would give the U.S. the opportunity to protect the rights of people and nations, which the opponents of the League are stopping (Doc. G). This bold claim leads to loss of support, since President Wilson leaves no other possible way to realize the dream of the founders of our government.…

    • 671 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Treaty of Versailles. DBQ

    • 790 Words
    • 3 Pages

    On January 8, 1918, Wooldrow Wilson the president at the time, turn U.S. participation in the war into a religious crusade. He wanted to change the nature of international relations and to make the world safe for democracy. This war was merely a struggle among imperialist powers. Wooldrow Wilson announced his plan, which was meant to organize peace. These were Wilson's fourteen paints. It argued for "open covenants of peace openly arrived at" freedom of seas, equality of trade, and self-determination for all peoples. His most important point, which was the last one (14th) called for international origination, a "League of Nations", to preserve peace.…

    • 790 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    When war broke out about Europe on the 28th of July in 1914, Wilson made sure the nation new his stance. 21 days after war was declared he gave a message to Congress (Document A) stating that he favored neutrality as a strategy and everyman loving America would as well. He supported this because many citizens of the United States had heritage leading to a side of the war and America entering the war would splinter America. Wilson was correct in his assumption that most Americans did not want to enter the war at that time. The American people to that point had tried to stick with an isolationist’s attitude. Though the people wanted neutrality there were still some debates about how America was going about it. Document B displays a common thought during this time that while America claimed neutrality they actually favored the Allied powers. Munsterburg who wrote this letter was an extremely well educated man but he did not acknowledge in his letter the effect the blockade had America’s claimed neutrality.…

    • 1169 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    President Wilson came to the conference with what he called his 14 points. His points called for a world that would continue to remain intact.…

    • 467 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Better Essays

    President Wilson was a peaceful man. He didn’t want to be in a war, he wanted things to be fair and equal among all the countries. His slogan in the reelection for was “He kept us out of the war”. And despite this, five months later he asked congress to declare war on Germany. Wilson had tried his best to keep America out of the war and to calm the war down. But the other countries wouldn’t listen to him and so in the end he had no choice.…

    • 1503 Words
    • 7 Pages
    Better Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    because of the war between Great Britain and France had in April 1793. It designed to keep…

    • 411 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Carleton argues Wilson was not responsible for the failure of joining the League because Carleton felt that even if Wilson had agreed to the Lodge Reservation, how sure are we that by Wilson joining in, it would have been enough for America to get in the League? Carleton points out, “Under the Lodge Reservation, every signatory nation had to accept them before the United States could become a member” (194). He uses this proof to support his claim that if Wilson had agreed with the Lodge, but the U.S. still didn’t make it into the League because not all fifteen nations agreed to let us in, would we still be blaming Wilson? Carleton also states that if Wilson was as stubborn as he was made out to be, then he would have been a joke for a president. He was accused of not understanding world politics but in that day, what American statesman understood world politics more than Wilson? Carleton also dismissed the fact that Wilson was accused of not being able to compromise. He stated “If the truth of this accusation must rest on Wilson’s attitude during the Treaty fight, and I think it must, for he showed remarkable adaptability in other phases of his Presidency” (194-195). Given the situations Wilson was in as a president, from the stroke to dealing with the League, Wilson has had no choice but to adapt and compromise with certain situations. Carleton ends his claim with the focus more on Lodge because he procrastinated votes on the treaty for two weeks and made it…

    • 819 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Versaille Treaty Dbq

    • 772 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Wilson states, “[The founders of the Government] thought of America as the light of the world as created to lead the world” (Doc F). This is going against America’s strong tradition of isolationism, which is displayed through Washington’s Proclamation of Neutrality, the Monroe Doctrine, and Washington’s Farewell Address. Wilson was being stubborn because he was unwilling to compromise on the issue of the League of Nations (Doc C). Wilson wanted the Versailles Treaty his way, so when the treaty was amended, Wilson urged his supporters in the Senate to vote against it. Even though some liberals supported Wilson’s idea on the League of Nations, they also criticized his stubbornness. For example, W.E.B Du Bois criticized Wilson’s stubbornness by referring to it as his “idiotic way” (Doc G). Wilson attributed to the Senate’s defeat of the Versailles Treaty, but if he would have compromised, it is possible that the treaty could have been passed. However, Wilson’s stubbornness was not the main issue, the American people's fear of the United States would be drug into another war that they had little say so about. This is shown through the political cartoon “Interrupting the Ceremony” (Doc L). In the cartoon, the League of Nations is marrying the United States getting married to foreign entanglements. However, the Senate came to the rescue by interrupting…

    • 772 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    If the United States joined it, many feared for America’s independence (Document F). However, if the United States did not join, then America would be in constant fear of their safety. President Woodrow Wilson and Senator Henry Cabot Lodge had differing opinions of the League of Nations (Keene, 230). Wilson’s argument gave an emotional appeal to the sacrifices of those who served the war (Keene, 230). This speech was not concerned with the selfish values of independence. It was centered on the safety of Americans who were directly affected by the war. Essentially, this idea should have been the founding principle of the position of the United States in the World. America should put the welfare of its citizens before the…

    • 884 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    The need for Wilson’s speech and the current mindset of the American public were a direct result of a succession of antagonistic events in Europe that were rapidly effecting the United States. As the task of remaining neutral became increasingly unfeasible due to numerous insults by the British and German governments, Wilson was forced to shift his foreign policy into a more internationalist scope, a path which the majority of Americans failed to follow (Boyer 791). The same man who was reelected in 1916 on the platform…

    • 2460 Words
    • 10 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    World War One was the focal point of all foreign affairs during Wilson's presidency. Wilson's foreign policy focused on keeping America neutral and economically strong by trading with nations on both sides of the conflict. This aspect of his policy was a failure, and Germany eventually provoked the United States to enter the war. The fourteen points, written by Wilson, was a set of fourteen ideas to help the world promote democracy and stability. It was extremely idealistic, and most of the ideas presented were not accepted, except the League of Nations. The League of Nations was proposed to keep the world from entering another large scale conflict. The League was created, and many of the major nations joined it, except for the United States. The republicans in congress and the senate did not allow the United States to join. This shows that Wilson's foreign policy can be considered a…

    • 594 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays