PRICE WARS: THE COST OF A COMPETITIVE BEHAVIOUR
Price wars have racked industry after industry in recent years: from personal computers to mobile phones, from fast-food restaurants to airlines, from grocery retailing to computer software, from beers to frozen diet dinners, from automobile tires to disposable diapers, from detergents to underwear. All too often, there are no winners and few healthy survivors. Price wars indeed represent one of the extreme forms of competitive interplay in the market place, causing great losses. On the one hand, firms take a blow in terms of ability to innovate, consumer equity, and margins; they may forego their competitive advantage, fall victim to substitutes, and even face bankruptcy. On the other hand, consumers, benefit from lower prices in the short run. In the long run, however, they may develop unrealistic reference prices and suffer from lower quality products in the long term. In a broader contest, society may suffer from suboptimal allocation of resources.
Basically, price wars represent competitive behaviour. Price wars are marked by competing firms struggling to undercut each other (Assael, 1990) and may occur if one company lowers its price and competitors match the price (Urban and Star, 1991). It is proposed that such wars can be viewed as "engagement involving two or more vendors seeking to achieve a goal that each is determined to attain and in which the rival vendors
make successive moves and countermoves in an attempt to gain an advantage or to resist any advantage gained by the other" (Cassady, 1963, p. 2). Other researchers (e.g., Urbany and Dickson, 1991) suggest that price wars commonly start with one firm trying to take hold of market share. The result of such a price is downward price pressure that eventually drives other competitors to follow the initial move. Moreover, price wars typify wars of attrition. According to Besanko et al. (1996), "In a war of attrition, two or more parties expend resources battling with each other" (p. 426). Likewise, it is maintained that such warfare is a period in which the firms set prices that are significantly below the prices commonly charged in the industry (Busse, 2000). According to Slade (1989) price wars entail that one competitor cuts price to punish another competitor for violating a rule of competitive conduct. Consequently, the firm to be punished reacts through another price cut, prompting further such cuts by the competitor, and so on. Thomas and Soldow (1988) state that if a price cut violates industry rules, competitive turmoil may result.
Price War as a Competitive Behaviour
As stated in the previous section, price wars are a competitive behaviour. Marketing researchers have provided a number of directional insights into the price war phenomenon. For example, in an empirical work by Putsis and Dhar (1998), it is shown that competitive interaction varies significantly across categories depending on the demand and competitive characteristics of the category. In a later study by Heil and Helsen (2001), early warning signals of price wars are used to explain this competitive behaviour. The authors identify four general factors that influence price wars: (1) market conditions, (2) firm characteristics, (3) product-related factors, and (4) consumer factors. In terms of market conditions, Heil and Helsen (2001) hypothesise that: as market entry occurs and an entrant gains or is expected to gain a sizable market position, a price war becomes more likely; if an industry possesses excess capacity, the emergence of price wars is more likely; price wars are more likely to occur and to be more intense in markets with marginal growth; and the incidence of such war is relatively high in markets where market power is highly concentrated and fragmented markets and low for markets with intermediate levels of concentration. In terms of firm characteristics, the authors propose that: as exit...
References: Assael, H. (1990). Marketing. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Prentice Hall.
BBC News (Sept. 16, 2005). "UK petrol price war breaking out." Retrieved 29 November 2005 from http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/4251964.stm.
Besanko, D., Dranove, D. and Shanley, M. (1996). Economics of Strategy. New York: Wiley.
Bruce, L. (July 4, 1991). Ford Lands Price Blow in U.K. Car War. International Herald Tribune. Retrieved 29 November 2005 from http://www.iht.com/articles/1991/07/04/ford.php.
Busse, M.R. (2000). Firm Financial Conditions and Airline Price Wars. Working Paper, Yale School of Management, New Haven, CT.
Cassady Jr., R. (1963). Price warfare in business competition: A study of abnormal competitive behavior. Paper No. 11, Bureau of Business and Economic Research, Graduate School of Business Administration. Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI.
Daily Times (13 May 2002). "UK tabloids go to war." Retrieved 29 November 2005 from http://www.dailytimes.com.pk/default.asp?page=story_13-5-2002_pg4_6
"Indian detergents price war." (May 2004). Focus on Surfactants, 5, 5.
Putsis, W.P. and Dhar, R. (1998). "The many faces of competition." Marketing Letters, 9, 269–284.
Slade, M.E. (1989). "Price wars in price setting supergames." Economica, 56, 295–310.
Urbany, J. and Dickson, P. (1991). "Competitive price-cutting momentum and pricing reactions." Marketing Letters, 2(4), 393–402.
Please join StudyMode to read the full document