Presumption Of Guilt Is Wrong

Good Essays
The accidental discovery, by a teacher, of suspected stolen goods in a student’s bag is problematic. Is one entitled to act on a wrongful search, albeit accidental, and further, is the presumption of guilt fair/valid? Firstly, consider what action(s) is directed by principles of obligation/duty (Deontological). Secondly, consider the negative and positive consequences of possible responses to determine which course of action achieves the best possible outcome (Consequentialist).

I Deontological – there are conflicting duties: duties of principle, professional duties, and obligations as a community member. Which duty takes precedence? A) Duty not to act ← Search of bag was violation of privacy, regardless of accidental or not. What
…show more content…
It’s not inconceivable that Rodney purchased or was given items. There may be a reasonable explanation. Recent behaviour suggests a positive change. It is wrong to brand him a thief and not give him the benefit of the doubt. ← Could there be cultural issues? (E.g. Aboriginal view may not view shoplifting in the same way.) ← Respecting Rodney as a moral agent is an obligation so others respect us equally ← (Is doing nothing just a social and professional evasion of responsibility?)

B) Duty to
…show more content…
← Discouraging wrong behaviour encourages honourable behaviour. This will help Rodney grow up to be a better person. Better to stop Rodney now before it escalates into a life of crime. ← Sensitive response to Rodney will validate his trust in authority figures and encourage developing trust. ← Prevent possible parental beating. ← Teaching values will help Rodney learn values. ← If we privately approach Rodney in a caring manner to discuss shoplifting we may be able to preserve the improvement in his studies and behaviour and convince him of the error of his ways and thereby Rodney becomes an asset the community instead of a liability. ( Also holds for II.B)

B) What could be the consequences of informing school/school superiors? ← Receive more help with the situation (input from counsellors, year advisors, principal) a team response more likely to produce better strategy for dealing with Rodney. ← Fulfil contract of employment as teacher, maintained professional integrity which is also good for teaching career. ← Avoids suggestion of favouritism (unfairly protecting Rodney) would erode position of authority and moral

You May Also Find These Documents Helpful

  • Good Essays

    Deontology

    • 857 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Deontology Karen Ward PHI208: Ethics and Moral Reasoning (GSP1408A) Professor Daniel Wagner 03/10/2014 Deontology When people think about ethics, most think in the way of deontology. People who think this way believe in right and wrong, or good and right. Deontologists live by “rules” or “constraints”, these are set by themselves based on the way society views things, for instance; lying, or cheating. Deontologists view lying and cheating are wrong, unless they thought it was their…

    • 857 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Deontology

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages

    Session 3. Deontology and virtue ethics 29/1/2014 Virtue ethics: Text for assignment question 1 and session 3 File Brennan, J. (2012): For-Profit Business as Civic Virtue, Journal of Business Ethics, 106(3): 313-324. The nature of moral value: -You see a boat capsizing; somebody shouts for help -you swim to rescue the person but once you reach the boat the person has already drowned -Does your action have a moral value? Actions aren’t everything -There are important ethical properties…

    • 837 Words
    • 4 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Satisfactory Essays

    Deontology

    • 509 Words
    • 2 Pages

    and good will versus the utilitarian aspect of maximizing happiness. One of the things we did was to begin a networking of friends; family and casual contacts to jump-start the business model in order to get exposure. This is where the ghosts of Deontology rose from the grave. My wife had a moral business contract with her company stating that she would not use her position or influence for personal profit. Some of our business audience was friends and casual contacts from work. The Deontological…

    • 509 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Satisfactory Essays
  • Good Essays

    Essay On Deontology

    • 336 Words
    • 2 Pages

    According to Conway and Gawronski, deontology is more focused on the action itself, rather than the consequence as in utilitarianism (Conway & Gawronski, 2013, p. 216). Deontology originated from Immanual Kant, who believed that outcomes are determined by the morality of the action committed. Law enforcement officers take the oath of ethics to follow the good order and discipline of the law, which is how deontology fits as a decision-making process. Whether officers want to…

    • 336 Words
    • 2 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    UTILITARIANISM AND DEONTOLOGY Action we take must have consequences whether good or bad. Utilitarianism is a theory that focuses on consequences that will bring about the best possible outcome of any situation, in terms of individuality or people, this means some sort of pleasure and happiness must be the result. On the other hand, deontology focus on the doing the right thing, were your intentions will be understood based on the right thing where everyone in your position would do the same, more…

    • 1004 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Deontology Essay

    • 1085 Words
    • 5 Pages

    Deontology is the regulating moral position that judges the ethical quality of an activity considering the activity's adherence to an administer or principles. It is in some cases portrayed as obligation or commitment or govern based morals, since guidelines tie you to your obligation. Deontological morals are normally differentiated to consequentialism, goodness morals, and logical morals. In this phrasing, activity is more essential than the outcomes. The term deontological was initially used to…

    • 1085 Words
    • 5 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Powerful Essays

    Describe the main principles of the two normative ethical theories of deontology and utilitarianism. Compare and contrast the two theories, bringing out any problems or limitations you see in each. INTRODUCTION:- Bioethicists ask these questions in the context of modern medicine and draw on a plurality of traditions, both secular and religious, to help society understand and keep pace with how advances in science and medical technology can change the way we experience the meaning of health…

    • 1333 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Powerful Essays
  • Good Essays

    CRG 520 ASSIGMENT THE MOVIE REVIEW ISTANBUL AKU DATANG PREPARED BY: NAME: NURUL HASIKIN BINTI NGAH MATRIC NO: 2011646112 GROUP: AC2204A Istanbul Aku Datang is a movie about a sweet and naive blogger named Dian who travels to Istanbul in plan to make her boyfriend, Azad, a medical student, to propose to her. She enrols in language course in the same university as Azad and in the period of three months, she hopes that her plan on convincing her boyfriend to propose her will be success…

    • 1321 Words
    • 6 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    Ethics And Deontology

    • 686 Words
    • 3 Pages

    Module 1 - SLP Business Ethics and Deontology Background In the Module 1 SLP, you will be given requirements for structuring the papers you will write throughout your degree program. In this module, we will discuss the required format and and writing requirements of all future papers (Case and SLP). Required Reading To begin, please review pages 1-11 of the Trident University International Student Guide to Writing a High-Quality Academic Paper. Then read page 16 of the Student Guide to Writing a…

    • 686 Words
    • 3 Pages
    Good Essays
  • Good Essays

    A strict deontologist would have no qualms about doing his duty. The Seven Oaks Philosophy website states, “Theories in this category (deontology) address the question of what makes one action right and another one wrong irrespective of the consequences of the action.” That means no matter the result a strict deontologist will do his duty. I, the computer programmer, have sworn an oath to never intervene in any government action. If I were to interrupt the launch, that action would be wrong, because…

    • 364 Words
    • 1 Page
    Good Essays